Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Mon Jun 11, 2012 9:48 am

My thoughts seem to create some feeling of intimacy that kind of feels like myself.
If I don't focus on thinking, I do not sense a self. Yet something is looking out of my eyes. I cannot pinpoint that.

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:12 am

I also would like to say that I have a long history of exposure to non-dual concepts. When replying to your questions/pointers this does seem to hinder. My thoughts trying to assist in 'making the Shift' and at the same time only comfortable with a gradual change ('feeling a bit more free'). I am fed up with that and hence I phrased this topic the way I did. I want to SEE and no longer be able to UNSEE.
I don't mean to break the line of enquiry and by all means ignore this if that is for the best, just had to share this at this point. Thanks for devoting your time to me.

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Mon Jun 11, 2012 4:54 pm

I also would like to say that I have a long history of exposure to non-dual concepts. When replying to your questions/pointers this does seem to hinder. My thoughts trying to assist in 'making the Shift' and at the same time only comfortable with a gradual change ('feeling a bit more free'). I am fed up with that and hence I phrased this topic the way I did. I want to SEE and no longer be able to UNSEE.
I don't mean to break the line of enquiry and by all means ignore this if that is for the best, just had to share this at this point. Thanks for devoting your time to me.
My thoughts seem to create some feeling of intimacy that kind of feels like myself.
If I don't focus on thinking, I do not sense a self. Yet something is looking out of my eyes. I cannot pinpoint that.

Isn't this interesting? The conversation we're having here. I'm asking you about self and you're telling me about sense of self. You have nothing to say about self do you? You don't really know yourself.

I bet you cannot give me one true statement about yourself.

Give it a try
I also would like to say that I have a long history of exposure to non-dual concepts. When replying to your questions/pointers this does seem to hinder.
It can but you know what? Once you are aware of that, you can counter it so it's fine. You're aware of it you'll be fine, just compensate. Find the balance between what you already know and what are trying to discover.
In simple terms don't allow what you already know to prevent you from discovering something new, something that at first may even seem contradictory.
My thoughts trying to assist in 'making the Shift' and at the same time only comfortable with a gradual change ('feeling a bit more free'). I am fed up with that and hence I phrased this topic the way I did. I want to SEE and no longer be able to UNSEE.
I don't mean to break the line of enquiry and by all means ignore this if that is for the best, just had to share this at this point. Thanks for devoting your time to me.
Don't worry. Just go back to the reply I gave you above after reading here and continue from there. We're well on our way you and I.
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Mon Jun 11, 2012 6:00 pm

Isn't this interesting? The conversation we're having here. I'm asking you about self and you're telling me about sense of self. You have nothing to say about self do you? You don't really know yourself.

I bet you cannot give me one true statement about yourself.

Give it a try
Great, you're saying things I'm not expecting.

Here goes, true statements about myself:

I exist.
I am.
I am aware.
The tricky bit here is the 'I' but that is semantics, there is something here that can say 'I' which cannot be doubted at all. I know that I am. What I am is a different matter. I don't know what I am.

Also true statements about myself are:
I see, feel, hear, touch, smell, taste and think. Again, 'I' is the tricky bit.
I could also say 'there is seeing, feeling, etc'. That has the taint of borrowed knowledge but looking at it simply, it cannot be doubted. But it is what I experience, not what I am.

Apart from this I can also make statements about who I am as an individual (I'm a man, etc) which can be verified materially but these are just labels and agreements. Still, as observations, these are true as well.

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Mon Jun 11, 2012 6:34 pm

Are any of those statements true?
Can you really say that you exist when you can't find a self?

Would it be more true to say that "Existence exists"

Seeing feeling hearing touching all of these things are happening for sure. Is the self there before the experience though? Or do you project that onto the experience?
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Mon Jun 11, 2012 7:28 pm

Are any of those statements true?
Can you really say that you exist when you can't find a self?
No. Logically, no. Experientially, though, I find myself resisting that notion. I don't quite feel it. If somebody would ask me: do you exist? I would unequivocally say: yes. But it is true I cannot find anybody located anywhere that would exist. Maybe the trouble is that all sensory experiences seem to refer to a centre (the body, or somewhere inside the body but then I cannot find any centre in there from where I would be experiencing. Except perhaps in my chest but as you pointed out in the beginning I see that sense of being located there so the self would be that which sees that and that I cannot find anywhere. I keep wanting to locate that somewhere though. Like trying to find some imaginary 'space' where I would be (non-dually, of course) located.
But I can simply not deny that I cannot find any self located anywhere, so, no, I cannot really say I exist then.
Would it be more true to say that "Existence exists"
Yes. In spite of the 'borrowed knowledge connotations', that rings true. 'Existence' being just a word but definitely something exists which cannot really be called a thing because it cannot be located anywhere, but it does exist very definitely and inevitably in your face type of thing so 'existence exists' sounds about right.
Seeing feeling hearing touching all of these things are happening for sure. Is the self there before the experience though? Or do you project that onto the experience?
No, the self is projected onto it. There is no self I can find, it definitely does not exist independently of the seeing, feeling, etc. So after the seeing I say: I see. I actually also say: I see this or that. Which is also not there in the seeing. But maybe I'm jumping ahead. I just suddenly saw that. Also I saw that there is no self before the experience but there is Existence before the experience.

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Mon Jun 11, 2012 8:02 pm

What is needed in an experiment like this one we're doing here is attention to detail. That is very important.
Experientially, though, I find myself resisting that notion. I don't quite feel it.
That's not good enough. Children truly believe in Santa Clause and would describe the same feelings relating to him.

What you need to do is test this. Not logically. Use logic to analyse the results of your testing but your testing must be physical/sensory/mechanical.
Is that notion a self? Does this resistance qualify as a self? Is this resistance the thing living your life and having your experiences?
If somebody would ask me: do you exist? I would unequivocally say: yes.
So in that case what are you considering to be yourself? Body? Mind? Experience of Life?
Which? Where is the thing having that experience?
But it is true I cannot find anybody located anywhere that would exist. Maybe the trouble is that all sensory experiences seem to refer to a centre (the body, or somewhere inside the body but then I cannot find any centre in there from where I would be experiencing.
Would it be true to say that you are just attaching the label "me" to anything your attention falls upon?

Except perhaps in my chest but as you pointed out in the beginning I see that sense of being located there so the self would be that which sees that and that I cannot find anywhere.
What do you think though? Could you be a feeling in your chest? Where does the self go when that feeling goes?
I keep wanting to locate that somewhere though. Like trying to find some imaginary 'space' where I would be (non-dually, of course) located.
Here's a question. Is there any self required to find the self? Do you need a self, in order to locate the self?

But I can simply not deny that I cannot find any self located anywhere, so, no, I cannot really say I exist then.
Logically no but an absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. You are looking for evidence that there is no self, evidence of self's absence.

Is there any self required to find the self?

Yes. In spite of the 'borrowed knowledge connotations', that rings true. 'Existence' being just a word but definitely something exists which cannot really be called a thing because it cannot be located anywhere, but it does exist very definitely and inevitably in your face type of thing so 'existence exists' sounds about right.
That isn't actually really about self however. It has nothing to do with self.
That aside what do you know for sure about your self?

Also I saw that there is no self before the experience but there is Existence before the experience.
Of what? What is it that exists prior to the experience?
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Mon Jun 11, 2012 9:08 pm

I am going to take some time replying to this. You made some very good points. I'm too tired now.

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:08 pm

I'll be here.
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Thu Jun 14, 2012 10:16 pm

Back after having to spend time on practicalities.
What is needed in an experiment like this one we're doing here is attention to detail. That is very important.
Point taken. It is this thoroughness I am after.
That's not good enough. Children truly believe in Santa Clause and would describe the same feelings relating to him.
Again, point taken. I can see there is a fuzzy belief quality to my approach to this, almost like working towards a desired result and trying to generate the feelings supposedly belonging to it. I can see it is about looking afresh not knowing what it is I will find.
What you need to do is test this. Not logically. Use logic to analyse the results of your testing but your testing must be physical/sensory/mechanical.
Yes, I see this must be so. I am unsure though how to do this as in response to your questions looking it is hard to only look and not think about them.
Is that notion a self? Does this resistance qualify as a self? Is this resistance the thing living your life and having your experiences?
The notion is an idea and the resistance is a feeling. They are experiences to me, not what is having the experience or living my life. Although there is an IDEA or SENSE that a resistance or I contraction is TRYING to live my life.
This idea or sense do not qualify as a self.


So in that case what are you considering to be yourself? Body? Mind? Experience of Life?
Which? Where is the thing having that experience?
I'd have to say that what is looking out of my eyes now. It is not a thing but it is experiencing.
Would it be true to say that you are just attaching the label "me" to anything your attention falls upon?
I would say yes, but the label: 'I am experiencing this' (e.g. 'I am feeling this headache' possibly followed by 'a thought to get rid of this headache translated as I am thinking that')
What do you think though? Could you be a feeling in your chest? Where does the self go when that feeling goes?
No. Clearly not. When that feeling goes I am still what is looking out of my eyes.

Here's a question. Is there any self required to find the self? Do you need a self, in order to locate the self?
Jezus, such a good question. It seems like a koan to me (i.e. designed to implode my logical thinking).
My answer is I need 'looking' to locate the self. Looking does not need a self. It happens spontaneously.
Locating the self from a self seems an impossibility.

Logically no but an absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. You are looking for evidence that there is no self, evidence of self's absence.

Is there any self required to find the self?
So you are saying to look for positive evidence of self's absence? Is that possible? I've kind of had the concept that there may be a moment of complete giving up of trying to find myself or anything else which would amount to liberation. I.e. liberation can only be achieved by negation. Now you are telling me it is possible to have positive, irrefutable, mechanical, sensory, physical evidence that there is no self? If so, that is what I'm after.
My answer remains, what is required to find the self is looking, not a self.

That isn't actually really about self however. It has nothing to do with self.
That aside what do you know for sure about your self?
I know there is this experience, of looking out of my eyes to this screen seeing the background of the room, etc etc.


Of what? What is it that exists prior to the experience?
Not me, but something exists. Not really something.

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Sat Jun 16, 2012 11:02 am

Hi there, you still there for me? I read elsewhere on the forum that one is expected to post at least once a day which I did not make last week with my 3 day break. I'm still eager to continue. Thanks.

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Sun Jun 17, 2012 3:48 pm

Jesus. Did not know that. Don't worry about the breaks I can't always make it either. I'll have a look at this thread later and get back to you snowed in at the moment. Literally...
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
JoshOz
Posts: 107
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 3:12 pm

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby JoshOz » Sun Jul 01, 2012 10:40 am

Hey, missed this reply entirely, usually I would get an email notification. Anyway, great we can continue this at some point. Practicalities strike again, just moved house and not really on internet until 9 July (except for occasional visits to internet cafes).
Meanwhile, if you wanted to you could reply to my last post about the subject matter (pun intended) of June 14th, 9:16pm, if you have time and the snow has cleared. Until we talk again...

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Wed Jul 04, 2012 2:31 pm

Hey I'm back the simplest thing I can offer you right now is to ask you to take this issue very personally. I'm in transit will write more later.
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/

User avatar
StepVheN
Posts: 67
Joined: Mon Mar 19, 2012 5:00 am

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Postby StepVheN » Wed Jul 04, 2012 2:34 pm

So you are saying to look for positive evidence of self's absence?
Yes
Is that possible?
Yes

I've kind of had the concept that there may be a moment of complete giving up of trying to find myself or anything else which would amount to liberation.
No it's not like that. It's more a thing you realize about reality, than a thing you realise about your self
The Science of Selflessness: http://www.osanalysis.com/


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 14 guests