Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
What brings you to Liberation Unleashed?
I think I've always been seeking a much richer experience of life than what mainstream U.S. culture provides. At the same time, it seems very likely that what's driven this has been my suffering from depression. Early philosophical and cultural studies led to a literary encounter with eastern wisdom, which has since resonated with me. I have started and stopped the associated practices (yoga, meditation, etc.) many times over the years, never practicing for very long at any time. My friend introduced me somewhat recently to some modern thinkers who were publicly challenging and criticizing the many iterations of religious dogmatism. One such thinker's name is Sam Harris. He is a philosopher, a neuroscientist and an experienced meditator. Pretty recently he published a book titled, "Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion". In it, among other things, he discusses the benefits of practicing mindfulness and explains how through philosophical investigation one must conclude that what we think of as our self does not exist. He also briefly though respectfully looks at the spiritual experiences that have been accessed consistently through "psychedelics" or "hallucinogens or "entheogens". This is important for me, as I cannot overestimate how compelling such experiences are to me. This realization that the self does not exist, Sam says, is highly spiritually significant. The philosophical justification came, I believe, long after his experience of Direct Pointing from Tulku Urgyen. Basically, Sam said get a pointer, so I'm here to get a pointer. Finally, the person who most fully explains the world for me is Marshall McLuhan, and he notices that with our new media environment we will find eastern wisdom to be more and more important in navigating our experience. So it's good to have that justification too, as well as the sense that the highly typical eastern wisdom spiritual quest doesn't have a monopoly on truth.
What are you looking for? What do you expect from this?
I am looking for truth, spirituality, peace on earth and in my life, etc. I would have always planned to evaluate an idea and activity like no-self whenever I'd heard of it and pursue it in the spirit of understanding, in the spirit of all the noble or more fundamental aspects of life and the world, exploration of the mind. But I am here because I am devastated by depression. It has generally ruled me completely. I can stay stable and not freaking out and wanting to go to the hospital the past two days by setting myself about the task of finding relief for what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally. The psychiatric aspect of it I've learned to leave to my psychiatrists recently...what a mess! How many variables to consider! And plus, it's far out of my reach in the first place, with all the medical training required to build understanding.
I again started practicing mindfulness about 2 weeks ago, and this was just the latest in the seemingly hundreds of defenses I've tried to protect myself from complete demoralization and psychological torture by the predictable and spontaneous occurrences of overwhelming negativity in thought and emotion that have visited me throughout my every day for the last 17 years. The preceding sentence includes "what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally" and my strategy for "finding relief" from this. After mindfulness lost the battle in a matter of 3-4 days like all the rest, I knew I had to start asking others for their ideas for defenses because, apart from this liberation that has yet to work for me, I couldn't imagine a defense better suited to help me navigate this negativity. So I'm exploring more of my talk therapist's suggestions, I'm searching the net for ideas, and I'm trying this again.
Now you know what I'm looking for, the following is what I expect. I expect to be able to practice mindfulness with rock-solid grounding and confidence that "I" am NOT my thoughts, sensations, emotions, etc., even as my abilities are very modest. I expect that this will eventually put an end to my spending my life overwhelmed despite being apparently free of crisis. To not be all throughout every day overwhelmed by despair, devastation, suicidality, jealousy, bitterness, un-word-able distress, hopelessness/helplessness, etc. I’m not expecting immunity from these to arrive instantly and never go away. I hope that with liberation the cause of the overwhelming will become extinct, even if gradually, and so I will no longer need the unknown impenetrable defense I’m seeking. That said, I, as completely as I can, understand the following quotes from the website and believe that my motivations and expectations are in line with them.
Liberation Unleashed is not…
going to lead you to eternal peace and happiness, it is not about happiness.
about freedom from emotions and intense feelings.
getting rid of self, ego, I.
a way to get free of depression or other diseases.
FAQ’s
I am depressed and anxious. Will liberation help me?
Liberation is not a cure for physical or mental disorders. Seeing through the illusion of self is an important step in seeing through the stories that fuel depression and anxiousness, which both derive from that same self illusion.
Will I never suffer again?
The answer depends on how we define suffering. If you hope to enter a life of unending bliss and only happy feelings, you’re going to be disappointed. Life will go on as before. All sorts of emotions will continue to arise. Yet, without the concept of a central self to stick to, how can there truly be suffering?
What is next?
Seeing self for what it really is – a story – does not mean that your life is suddenly upgraded in every conceivable way. Old habits, beliefs, programming and conditioning will very probably remain in place. Awakening from the story of you allows old patterns to drop away quickly. The foundation upon which these patterns were based is gone.
What is your background in terms of seeking and inquiry?
I'm kind of unclear on what all exactly happened, but I have a thorough enough idea I think. I first heard of this truth by reading Sam Harris’ book “Waking Up”. I probably listened to a youtube video or two after reading that. Then at some point after that I found no-self.com. I read their explanation and I talked with Mike. I read Butterflies are Free to Fly at their instruction (I think). Then I came upon Liberation Unleashed. I registered and got a pointer named Cody J. Dennis. That conversation is on the forum under my then-username blackfoot332. This was in June 2015. The liberation didn’t happen, I got frustrated and stopped replying, but I’ve since kept no-self on my mind, very much, as an eventual priority in my life, a next step in spirituality. I’ve continued to struggle with depression, and after finding even the defense against negativity that mindfulness could offer to be insufficient, I have decided to make this a priority again. I wrote a couple paragraph-long post when I came back and thought Cody might still be around that lays out a few aspects of my current frustrations with this process and his suggestions. But why go into all that? You’ll have your own style and we’ll be working with that one not Cody’s, and any other complaints or questions will come up as need be in our exploration. Also, I dig it conceptually/intellectually, but that’s totally irrelevant as I understand.
How ready are you to question your beliefs about who you are and see the truth no matter what?
11
I think I've always been seeking a much richer experience of life than what mainstream U.S. culture provides. At the same time, it seems very likely that what's driven this has been my suffering from depression. Early philosophical and cultural studies led to a literary encounter with eastern wisdom, which has since resonated with me. I have started and stopped the associated practices (yoga, meditation, etc.) many times over the years, never practicing for very long at any time. My friend introduced me somewhat recently to some modern thinkers who were publicly challenging and criticizing the many iterations of religious dogmatism. One such thinker's name is Sam Harris. He is a philosopher, a neuroscientist and an experienced meditator. Pretty recently he published a book titled, "Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion". In it, among other things, he discusses the benefits of practicing mindfulness and explains how through philosophical investigation one must conclude that what we think of as our self does not exist. He also briefly though respectfully looks at the spiritual experiences that have been accessed consistently through "psychedelics" or "hallucinogens or "entheogens". This is important for me, as I cannot overestimate how compelling such experiences are to me. This realization that the self does not exist, Sam says, is highly spiritually significant. The philosophical justification came, I believe, long after his experience of Direct Pointing from Tulku Urgyen. Basically, Sam said get a pointer, so I'm here to get a pointer. Finally, the person who most fully explains the world for me is Marshall McLuhan, and he notices that with our new media environment we will find eastern wisdom to be more and more important in navigating our experience. So it's good to have that justification too, as well as the sense that the highly typical eastern wisdom spiritual quest doesn't have a monopoly on truth.
What are you looking for? What do you expect from this?
I am looking for truth, spirituality, peace on earth and in my life, etc. I would have always planned to evaluate an idea and activity like no-self whenever I'd heard of it and pursue it in the spirit of understanding, in the spirit of all the noble or more fundamental aspects of life and the world, exploration of the mind. But I am here because I am devastated by depression. It has generally ruled me completely. I can stay stable and not freaking out and wanting to go to the hospital the past two days by setting myself about the task of finding relief for what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally. The psychiatric aspect of it I've learned to leave to my psychiatrists recently...what a mess! How many variables to consider! And plus, it's far out of my reach in the first place, with all the medical training required to build understanding.
I again started practicing mindfulness about 2 weeks ago, and this was just the latest in the seemingly hundreds of defenses I've tried to protect myself from complete demoralization and psychological torture by the predictable and spontaneous occurrences of overwhelming negativity in thought and emotion that have visited me throughout my every day for the last 17 years. The preceding sentence includes "what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally" and my strategy for "finding relief" from this. After mindfulness lost the battle in a matter of 3-4 days like all the rest, I knew I had to start asking others for their ideas for defenses because, apart from this liberation that has yet to work for me, I couldn't imagine a defense better suited to help me navigate this negativity. So I'm exploring more of my talk therapist's suggestions, I'm searching the net for ideas, and I'm trying this again.
Now you know what I'm looking for, the following is what I expect. I expect to be able to practice mindfulness with rock-solid grounding and confidence that "I" am NOT my thoughts, sensations, emotions, etc., even as my abilities are very modest. I expect that this will eventually put an end to my spending my life overwhelmed despite being apparently free of crisis. To not be all throughout every day overwhelmed by despair, devastation, suicidality, jealousy, bitterness, un-word-able distress, hopelessness/helplessness, etc. I’m not expecting immunity from these to arrive instantly and never go away. I hope that with liberation the cause of the overwhelming will become extinct, even if gradually, and so I will no longer need the unknown impenetrable defense I’m seeking. That said, I, as completely as I can, understand the following quotes from the website and believe that my motivations and expectations are in line with them.
Liberation Unleashed is not…
going to lead you to eternal peace and happiness, it is not about happiness.
about freedom from emotions and intense feelings.
getting rid of self, ego, I.
a way to get free of depression or other diseases.
FAQ’s
I am depressed and anxious. Will liberation help me?
Liberation is not a cure for physical or mental disorders. Seeing through the illusion of self is an important step in seeing through the stories that fuel depression and anxiousness, which both derive from that same self illusion.
Will I never suffer again?
The answer depends on how we define suffering. If you hope to enter a life of unending bliss and only happy feelings, you’re going to be disappointed. Life will go on as before. All sorts of emotions will continue to arise. Yet, without the concept of a central self to stick to, how can there truly be suffering?
What is next?
Seeing self for what it really is – a story – does not mean that your life is suddenly upgraded in every conceivable way. Old habits, beliefs, programming and conditioning will very probably remain in place. Awakening from the story of you allows old patterns to drop away quickly. The foundation upon which these patterns were based is gone.
What is your background in terms of seeking and inquiry?
I'm kind of unclear on what all exactly happened, but I have a thorough enough idea I think. I first heard of this truth by reading Sam Harris’ book “Waking Up”. I probably listened to a youtube video or two after reading that. Then at some point after that I found no-self.com. I read their explanation and I talked with Mike. I read Butterflies are Free to Fly at their instruction (I think). Then I came upon Liberation Unleashed. I registered and got a pointer named Cody J. Dennis. That conversation is on the forum under my then-username blackfoot332. This was in June 2015. The liberation didn’t happen, I got frustrated and stopped replying, but I’ve since kept no-self on my mind, very much, as an eventual priority in my life, a next step in spirituality. I’ve continued to struggle with depression, and after finding even the defense against negativity that mindfulness could offer to be insufficient, I have decided to make this a priority again. I wrote a couple paragraph-long post when I came back and thought Cody might still be around that lays out a few aspects of my current frustrations with this process and his suggestions. But why go into all that? You’ll have your own style and we’ll be working with that one not Cody’s, and any other complaints or questions will come up as need be in our exploration. Also, I dig it conceptually/intellectually, but that’s totally irrelevant as I understand.
How ready are you to question your beliefs about who you are and see the truth no matter what?
11
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
G'day Whitey, tell from your experience (no theory or 2nd hand information) what is real ?
vince
vince
- blackfoot332
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Fri May 15, 2015 4:49 pm
- Location: Broomall, PA
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Hi Vince you can call me Dan
what is real...
I don't know. I guess I don't know what real means. I can tune into one or another senses or try to observe my thoughts or my emotions, y'kno mindfulness or meditation, but that doesn't give me any answer to the question what is real.
what is real...
I don't know. I guess I don't know what real means. I can tune into one or another senses or try to observe my thoughts or my emotions, y'kno mindfulness or meditation, but that doesn't give me any answer to the question what is real.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
'morning Dan,
In our language we have nouns. These are things that can be handled, like rock or water. ..but then we have abstract nouns. These are not actual things, but are spoken of like they are. University is an example. If you go to a university, what do you find ? There are buildings, students, lecturers, professors, etc, but no actual university thing. It is a concept that encompasses all of the mentioned components.
Can you see that 'Self' is an abstract noun ?
Are you familiar with the Buddhist term 'emptiness' ?
Would you say that, when you are aware of a sensation, that the sensation is actual (real) ?
vince
Yes, it is a tricky one, as in our cult(ure) we falsely assume much to be real when it is actually a concept. When we focus in on the word 'real', it becomes a bit unreal. Perhaps 'actual' might be a better word for this.I don't know what real means.
In our language we have nouns. These are things that can be handled, like rock or water. ..but then we have abstract nouns. These are not actual things, but are spoken of like they are. University is an example. If you go to a university, what do you find ? There are buildings, students, lecturers, professors, etc, but no actual university thing. It is a concept that encompasses all of the mentioned components.
Can you see that 'Self' is an abstract noun ?
Are you familiar with the Buddhist term 'emptiness' ?
Would you say that, when you are aware of a sensation, that the sensation is actual (real) ?
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
I feel very clear-headed and confident these days, which is very good, I think it will get us on the same page very quickly.
For full disclosure, I had an experience when I was last being pointed about a year ago. I know that we are not looking for an experience. But while I was trying to tune in totally to my audial senses, I actually lost myself and was just in a very full-feeling, complete-feeling experience of the sound, like it was JUST sound in my consciousness. I haven’t been able to repeat the experience since. Maybe I’d say THAT felt real. I don’t know, I don’t remember well enough.
More about emptiness
Recently I was forcing the concept on my brain that the self was just a belief, and that I could try to find it and deconstruct it in my thoughts. I understand that this is not what liberation is like. I did get a couple of moments where I had the sense of being a voyeur in a robot, essentially, that was living in a robotic world. That the whole thing was going automatically and so it was very suspenseful entertainment because there are so many possibilities and I didn’t know what would happen next and yet I could watch from a safe “distance”. That sounds like emptiness or no self. But I know that wasn’t it because of the technique I used but more importantly because it was just an experience, it didn’t convince me that this was actually the way things were for sure.
I also saw a definition of emptiness that negates the philosophy of essence, thing-ness, function, form, abstract concept, etc. Another one that I particularly enjoyed named ‘Pratītyasamutpāda’, which was linked as “dependent origination”, and it turned out to be just what I expected. Purely for conversation, the following ideas are very fascinating to me and unfortunately obscure for their potential insight. Marshall Mcluhan talked about the visual bias of civilized man convincing him that his reality was full of figures without ground (individual identity). I suppose that this dependent origination asserts that the world is “all ground”. In any case, I recognize that this, the ‘everything’s inextricably linked and there is no objectivity only subjectivity’, is a more accurate model of reality than the “all figures” one.
Marshall Mcluhan believes (I think) that the self illusion took hold as a result of the visual bias and its illusion of “point of view” that was caused by the adoption of the phonetic alphabet of Ancient Greece. All “Western” technology since that time intensified this illusion until the effect was reversed with the advent of electric technology. Since then we have been falling back into a more tribal than literate state of mind, and that explains the sudden usefulness of Eastern (non-visually biased) Wisdom. It’s not that the illusion of the self was a mistake, necessarily. It’s just that the self, along with Euclidean Geometry, Newtonian Physics, and Cartesian Philosophy primarily exist in the mind. They don’t exist as a matter of the Direct Experience we’re now using. The idea is that unless we start recognizing the effects our technologies have on our social and psychic organization and manipulate them to effect our preferred design, we are on a course for a complete wipeout of literacy/civilization/visual-bias in favor of tribalism- a global village. Our technologies are conditioning us to think this couldn’t be better, but surely there are many benefits to be preserved from our time in history.
No. I can see that self COULD be an abstract noun by entertaining the model that there is no locus of control (I could just imagine this is a reasonable conclusion from learning that different types of experience are processed in different areas of the brain, or I could believe the neuroscience or philosophy that points to the same conclusion), there is just the chaotic competition of stimuli for attention. But I have no more reason to believe it is an abstract noun than I do to believe that it isn’t and that there actually is a locus of control. Just don’t know. Haven’t looked into it enough.Can you see that self is an abstract noun?
I am not. So I looked at the Wikipedia page for it named, ‘Śūnyatā‘. I see that there is not consensus on its meaning. I saw some definitions pretty much just asserting that it means that this world is empty of self and anything related to self. Below I found another definition that takes me on a tangent that could be of some interest to you but is not strictly relevant to this liberation.Are you familiar with the Buddhist term ‘emptiness’?
No. When I put my attention to sounds, it feels like there’s mental distance, and disinterest. They’re just totally value-free stimuli. And I feel like no matter how long I might practice mindfulness of them (and all sensations, I think) there’s still that distance. So they don’t feel especially real at all. They’re just more meaningless mundane forms, like leaf designs on wallpaper. Maybe I’m confusing “real” for “significant”, but maybe I don’t understand the difference.Would you say that, when you are aware of a sensation, that the sensation is actual (real)?
For full disclosure, I had an experience when I was last being pointed about a year ago. I know that we are not looking for an experience. But while I was trying to tune in totally to my audial senses, I actually lost myself and was just in a very full-feeling, complete-feeling experience of the sound, like it was JUST sound in my consciousness. I haven’t been able to repeat the experience since. Maybe I’d say THAT felt real. I don’t know, I don’t remember well enough.
More about emptiness
Recently I was forcing the concept on my brain that the self was just a belief, and that I could try to find it and deconstruct it in my thoughts. I understand that this is not what liberation is like. I did get a couple of moments where I had the sense of being a voyeur in a robot, essentially, that was living in a robotic world. That the whole thing was going automatically and so it was very suspenseful entertainment because there are so many possibilities and I didn’t know what would happen next and yet I could watch from a safe “distance”. That sounds like emptiness or no self. But I know that wasn’t it because of the technique I used but more importantly because it was just an experience, it didn’t convince me that this was actually the way things were for sure.
I also saw a definition of emptiness that negates the philosophy of essence, thing-ness, function, form, abstract concept, etc. Another one that I particularly enjoyed named ‘Pratītyasamutpāda’, which was linked as “dependent origination”, and it turned out to be just what I expected. Purely for conversation, the following ideas are very fascinating to me and unfortunately obscure for their potential insight. Marshall Mcluhan talked about the visual bias of civilized man convincing him that his reality was full of figures without ground (individual identity). I suppose that this dependent origination asserts that the world is “all ground”. In any case, I recognize that this, the ‘everything’s inextricably linked and there is no objectivity only subjectivity’, is a more accurate model of reality than the “all figures” one.
Marshall Mcluhan believes (I think) that the self illusion took hold as a result of the visual bias and its illusion of “point of view” that was caused by the adoption of the phonetic alphabet of Ancient Greece. All “Western” technology since that time intensified this illusion until the effect was reversed with the advent of electric technology. Since then we have been falling back into a more tribal than literate state of mind, and that explains the sudden usefulness of Eastern (non-visually biased) Wisdom. It’s not that the illusion of the self was a mistake, necessarily. It’s just that the self, along with Euclidean Geometry, Newtonian Physics, and Cartesian Philosophy primarily exist in the mind. They don’t exist as a matter of the Direct Experience we’re now using. The idea is that unless we start recognizing the effects our technologies have on our social and psychic organization and manipulate them to effect our preferred design, we are on a course for a complete wipeout of literacy/civilization/visual-bias in favor of tribalism- a global village. Our technologies are conditioning us to think this couldn’t be better, but surely there are many benefits to be preserved from our time in history.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good morning Dan,
Of course, not being able to find one, doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
What does exist, that we could call a Self ? (from experience, not theory or 2nd hand information)
The way i see it, it that there is no 'essence' of anything (or anybody). eg. if you disassemble a car completely, with all of the pieces displayed on the floor, is there anything we could call essence of car.
Dependent conditions is a useful concept. If we start to reassemble the parts of the car, at what point does the concept 'car', become valid ?
vince
Ok, a simple look now will suffice. If you can't identify a locus of control, by looking now, then no amount of searching will.I have no more reason to believe it is an abstract noun than I do to believe that it isn’t and that there actually is a locus of control. Just don’t know. Haven’t looked into it enough.
Of course, not being able to find one, doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
What does exist, that we could call a Self ? (from experience, not theory or 2nd hand information)
Ha, i didn't realize that there were so many interpretations of it.I am not.Are you familiar with the Buddhist term 'emptiness' ?
The way i see it, it that there is no 'essence' of anything (or anybody). eg. if you disassemble a car completely, with all of the pieces displayed on the floor, is there anything we could call essence of car.
Dependent conditions is a useful concept. If we start to reassemble the parts of the car, at what point does the concept 'car', become valid ?
..but you did actually hear the sound. Would you say that the mental distance and disinterest happened after the sound was registered ?No. When I put my attention to sounds, it feels like there’s mental distance, and disinterest.Would you say that, when you are aware of a sensation, that the sensation is actual (real) ?
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Thanks Vince :)
I am somewhat confident in this, though, because during that time where I was forcing the “self is a thought” concept on my mind and had that “robot voyeur” experience, I believe I was pretty thorough there too and I came up with this same story.
I think I can tell what you're getting at, though, and it makes sense. That once I've decided that I'm going to pay attention to a particular sound that I hear (though not in a focused manner), the next step is to find the sound- bring my attention onto that sound to the exclusion of all other experience, because one can't "pay attention" to more than one thing at a time. And the moment I locate the sound in my consciousness to achieve my decision to pay attention to it, I must have only that sound in my awareness/attention, because that's what it means to find that sound. So there must be a moment where it's just that sound without any distance. If this is all true then as I said, it just passes so quickly. And then I repeat it again and again, but it keeps passing too quickly, and I guess I don't know how to pay attention to one thing long enough to believe that it's real.
:)
Why? How do you know this? Maybe I don't need to know right now.If you can't identify a locus of control, by looking now, then no amount of searching will.
I’m glad that you agree with and clarified this, this has been an objection of mine to many pointing instructions.Of course, not being able to find one, doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
At no distinguishable point, we eventually learn, I think. I agree with this but in a purely logical conceptual/intellectual way, which is supposedly unable to be used in this Direct Experience examination.Ha, i didn't realize that there were so many interpretations of it.
The way i see it, it that there is no 'essence' of anything (or anybody). eg. if you disassemble a car completely, with all of the pieces displayed on the floor, is there anything we could call essence of car.
Dependent conditions is a useful concept. If we start to reassemble the parts of the car, at what point does the concept 'car', become valid ?
Thoughts and beliefs (which are just somehow stronger thoughts, maybe a representation of a collection of thoughts, which would make ‘belief’ just another concept I guess, just like ‘university’ or ‘car’). I answered this after a pretty brief mental search for where that feeling/sense of agency/self resides. It seems that emotions and the 5 senses are things that the self HAS, and the self tries to arrange a story about why these things are occurring, and the belief in that story becomes another channel to reinforce the belief in a self.What does exist, that we could call a Self ? (from experience, not theory or 2nd hand information)
I am somewhat confident in this, though, because during that time where I was forcing the “self is a thought” concept on my mind and had that “robot voyeur” experience, I believe I was pretty thorough there too and I came up with this same story.
Maybe. I may hear the sound without judgment for just a split-second. It’s too brief to even remember an experience of it that’s different from the mildly disinterested one. I’m not very sure on this. Then the distance, which I guess we can call a judgmental thought, enters, though the distance happens without any particular words coming into mind. As far as I can tell...but you did actually hear the sound. Would you say that the mental distance and disinterest happened after the sound was registered ?
I think I can tell what you're getting at, though, and it makes sense. That once I've decided that I'm going to pay attention to a particular sound that I hear (though not in a focused manner), the next step is to find the sound- bring my attention onto that sound to the exclusion of all other experience, because one can't "pay attention" to more than one thing at a time. And the moment I locate the sound in my consciousness to achieve my decision to pay attention to it, I must have only that sound in my awareness/attention, because that's what it means to find that sound. So there must be a moment where it's just that sound without any distance. If this is all true then as I said, it just passes so quickly. And then I repeat it again and again, but it keeps passing too quickly, and I guess I don't know how to pay attention to one thing long enough to believe that it's real.
:)
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good day Dan,
If you don't need to know this right now, then you won't search at all.
What do you find that you could call a Self ? (from looking)
Now, the point that you make that it is a purely conceptual way, is excellent (although you might not have realized it)
Concept is great. Very useful in navigating daily life.
Problems arises (often as suffering) when we take concept for reality. So, let's be really clear what is concept and what isn't.
Is car concept ?
Is Truth concept ?
Are sensations concept ?
Is a description of a sensation concept ?
What can you think of, that is not concept ?
Logic may lead us to this conclusion, but from experience, is anything (like a locus of control) noticed beside these happenings ?
Try this exercise; Focus on the sensation where your buttocks meet the chair. (unlike sound, it is (probably) persistent)
Whilst putting attention on the sensation, observe the nature of the thoughts that arise. By 'nature', i mean the labeling and describing, and what ever else occurs.
When thought slow and there are instants of just sensation, notice how impossible it would be to accurately communicate the qualities of the sensation.
Report that experiencing.
vince
Where will you search later, that you won't now ?Why? How do you know this? Maybe I don't need to know right now.
If you don't need to know this right now, then you won't search at all.
So let's focus on what you do find.I’m glad that you agree with and clarified this, this has been an objection of mine to many pointing instructions.
What do you find that you could call a Self ? (from looking)
Hmm, please don't bring "supposed" stuff to this examination. i come at this from a different angle that most of the other guides.I agree with this but in a purely logical conceptual/intellectual way, which is supposedly unable to be used in this Direct Experience examination.
Now, the point that you make that it is a purely conceptual way, is excellent (although you might not have realized it)
Concept is great. Very useful in navigating daily life.
Problems arises (often as suffering) when we take concept for reality. So, let's be really clear what is concept and what isn't.
Is car concept ?
Is Truth concept ?
Are sensations concept ?
Is a description of a sensation concept ?
What can you think of, that is not concept ?
A possible implication here is that there is something that is doing these things ?and the self tries to arrange a story about why these things are occurring, and the belief in that story becomes another channel to reinforce the belief in a self.
Logic may lead us to this conclusion, but from experience, is anything (like a locus of control) noticed beside these happenings ?
Yes, absolutely. The mind arrives with it's offerings in what seems to be no time.I may hear the sound without judgment for just a split-second. It’s too brief to even remember an experience of it
Try this exercise; Focus on the sensation where your buttocks meet the chair. (unlike sound, it is (probably) persistent)
Whilst putting attention on the sensation, observe the nature of the thoughts that arise. By 'nature', i mean the labeling and describing, and what ever else occurs.
When thought slow and there are instants of just sensation, notice how impossible it would be to accurately communicate the qualities of the sensation.
Report that experiencing.
i am simply trying to establish a distinction between what is actual and what is concept.I think I can tell what you're getting at,
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
I don’t know how to look. Paying attention to sensations is one thing. But then to ask a question…I guess I’m having some experience of the difference between actual and concept because I’d say it’s apples and oranges, it’s like two people trying to speak in different languages…not applicable, there’s no ability for the question to interact with the paying attention to the sensation.a simple look now will suffice. If you can't identify a locus of control, by looking now, then no amount of searching will.
I “looked” maybe. Not sure I can tell the difference between that and thinking, I think if you could differentiate looking clearly from “critical thinking”/“logical analysis” that may help. I guess that’s what you’re trying to do with the actual v. concept thing. Here’s what I found that I could call a Self.So let's focus on what you do find.
What do you find that you could call a Self ? (from looking)
1) A certain type of thought- Thoughts/beliefs/(concepts?) that I believe to be strategies to replicate experiences, emotions.
2) Stories about emotions
3) Emotions
And we tackled pretty much this same question above.
The fact that I’m finding it difficult to distinguish experience from theory is not surprising, clearly I’m an “up in my head” kinda guy.What does exist, that we could call a Self ? (from experience, not theory or 2nd hand information)
Thoughts and beliefs (which are just somehow stronger thoughts, maybe a representation of a collection of thoughts, which would make ‘belief’ just another concept I guess, just like ‘university’ or ‘car’). I answered this after a pretty brief mental search for where that feeling/sense of agency/self resides. It seems that emotions and the 5 senses are things that the self HAS, and the self tries to arrange a story about why these things are occurring, and the belief in that story becomes another channel to reinforce the belief in a self.
I am somewhat confident in this, though, because during that time where I was forcing the “self is a thought” concept on my mind and had that “robot voyeur” experience, I believe I was pretty thorough there too and I came up with this same story.
Car, Truth, and descriptions of sensations are concepts. Sensations are not concepts. (I have no idea if this is true, I just know you believe it and it makes sense to me). I’m not going to try to think of something that isn’t a concept, because I still don’t know how to tell the difference. There’s that distance from, disinterest in sensations when I tune into them. I think it’s clear that you know sensations to be actual/real and not concepts, but with sensations’ lack of immediacy to me they could be concepts for all I know.Problems arises (often as suffering) when we take concept for reality. So, let's be really clear what is concept and what isn't.
Is car concept ?
Is Truth concept ?
Are sensations concept ?
Is a description of a sensation concept ?
What can you think of, that is not concept ?
I close my eyes. I listen to a sound for a few seconds, try to ask if there’s a self, not applicable as I said above, not a valid question. I acknowledge my present thought as a thought…I ask “is there a self?”…I don’t know how I’d begin to answer that question. I have no idea what a locus of control would look like or if I’d even be able to see it, and as you said, “not being able to find one doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist”. There’s tons of happenings that I don’t notice but that you’d consider real/actual. I just don’t know how to “look”, “where” to “look”. I can’t survey all of my experience in a given moment, and I can’t survey any one area of my experience to the point where I believe I’ve looked there exhaustively. When asked to “look” I just engage in the simplest form of meditation. And that does not leave me with a feeling that I’ve “looked” as you’d say.A possible implication here is that there is something that is doing these things ?
Logic may lead us to this conclusion, but from experience, is anything (like a locus of control) noticed beside these happenings ?
This was very easy to understand. It is impossible to accurately communicate the qualities of that sensation. I understood this after a few seconds of attention on the sensation. I returned my attention there and noticed thoughts for about thirty more seconds, just to see if there would be a deeper understanding of it, but was left with the same conclusion.Try this exercise; Focus on the sensation where your buttocks meet the chair. (unlike sound, it is (probably) persistent)
Whilst putting attention on the sensation, observe the nature of the thoughts that arise. By 'nature', i mean the labeling and describing, and what ever else occurs.
When thought slow and there are instants of just sensation, notice how impossible it would be to accurately communicate the qualities of the sensation.
Report that experiencing.
Is the difference between actual and concept that actual can’t be accurately communicated and concept can (in terms of function, perhaps, if not in terms of essence)?i am simply trying to establish a distinction between what is actual and what is concept.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good evening Dan,
Obviously to 'look' or to 'see' are metaphors. It refers literally to the visual sense.
If we said 'search for' instead of 'look', would it refer to more than the visual sense organ ?
If we broaden it to include any of the senses, it starts to get hard to find the words to point accurately.
We could ask, "do any of your sense organs get activated by something that could be called a 'self' ?
It would still be 'Existence remains unconfirmed.'
..but then a story unfolds that talks about the mind being the sixth sense.
This makes sense to me. With the other senses, when the primary receptors are triggered, then a sequence of events is facilitated. A sequence that culminates in the brain seeing or hearing or feeling, etc, something.
When thoughts arrive, exactly the same things happen. Usually with the mind, the brain generates and locates an intense emotion. Also, the habitual nature of the mind is to focus on everything that confirms the existence of a self. Mind is 100% narcissistic.
So now, what does our search reveal ?
So would it be accurate to say that the self exists as a thought narrative that gets confirmed by the emotional response to those stories ?
Now the big question. What is your relationship to that complex and detailed narrative with the title of DAN ?
Can you find anywhere a feeling of identification with that storybook character in the stories ?
It was the best experience that your brain could conjure, to describe to you the current conditions from a physical perspective. ..and it happened without the interference of the sixth sense (the mind) swamping the organism with strong emotions, just to reinforce the existence of an individual.
love
vince
Ah, yes, it's so that our language doesn't have words for the concepts needed to describe this stuff.I don’t know how to look.
Obviously to 'look' or to 'see' are metaphors. It refers literally to the visual sense.
If we said 'search for' instead of 'look', would it refer to more than the visual sense organ ?
If we broaden it to include any of the senses, it starts to get hard to find the words to point accurately.
We could ask, "do any of your sense organs get activated by something that could be called a 'self' ?
It would still be 'Existence remains unconfirmed.'
..but then a story unfolds that talks about the mind being the sixth sense.
This makes sense to me. With the other senses, when the primary receptors are triggered, then a sequence of events is facilitated. A sequence that culminates in the brain seeing or hearing or feeling, etc, something.
When thoughts arrive, exactly the same things happen. Usually with the mind, the brain generates and locates an intense emotion. Also, the habitual nature of the mind is to focus on everything that confirms the existence of a self. Mind is 100% narcissistic.
So now, what does our search reveal ?
Hmm, so every point is about emotions. The self is represented by the thought stories that are about emotions.Here’s what I found that I could call a Self.
1) A certain type of thought- Thoughts/beliefs/(concepts?) that I believe to be strategies to replicate experiences, emotions.
2) Stories about emotions
3) Emotions
So would it be accurate to say that the self exists as a thought narrative that gets confirmed by the emotional response to those stories ?
Now the big question. What is your relationship to that complex and detailed narrative with the title of DAN ?
Can you find anywhere a feeling of identification with that storybook character in the stories ?
Yes! This is looking. You didn't arrive at any conclusion as you appreciated the qualities of that sensation. You observed it.It is impossible to accurately communicate the qualities of that sensation. I understood this after a few seconds of attention on the sensation. I returned my attention there and noticed thoughts for about thirty more seconds, just to see if there would be a deeper understanding of it, but was left with the same conclusion.
It was the best experience that your brain could conjure, to describe to you the current conditions from a physical perspective. ..and it happened without the interference of the sixth sense (the mind) swamping the organism with strong emotions, just to reinforce the existence of an individual.
A good test to see if something is a concept, is to ask if it is about (anything..)they could be concepts for all I know.
Ah, good segway (segue) Yes, under normal daily life this will continue to be the case. ..but if you 'examine' this a little bit closer, we soon conclude that this is a belief. There is no way of you actually knowing that they are real. There is just a story that says based on experience this is very likely (i'd be gobsmacked if it didn't). It's a concept.There’s tons of happenings that I don’t notice but that you’d consider real/actual.
Concept is the attempt to describe or communicate the (apparent) actual. Is it about something ?Is the difference between actual and concept that actual can’t be accurately communicated and concept can
love
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Hey there, presence who is called "Vince" :)
Accurate? I don’t know. I don’t know if that search for a self was thorough enough. It doesn’t match the results of the earlier search for a self, and I didn’t “search” for very long. If it was searching and not thinking. BUT. That sounds reasonable, and I’m pretty comfortable with the answers I gave. Luckily I had some more clarity in answering the rest of your questions.Hmm, so every point is about emotions. The self is represented by the thought stories that are about emotions.
So would it be accurate to say that the self exists as a thought narrative that gets confirmed by the emotional response to those stories ?
Happily I have a right big answer for u! Dan is everything that I’d say to describe my personality- thoughts, feelings, sensations (I guess), and behaviors (I don’t know if this is all that makes up the personality story) from my birth up to and including now (But there’s a distance that I’m about to describe, like anything I could describe about myself has to refer to the past, even if it’s just from one second ago). The personality gives that “I exist”, “alive”-ness, I-don’t-truly-know-what-will-happen-next-feeling context, it attempts to synthesize all my experience into a coherent story for stability’s sake. So I can definitely say that “I” am not my personality. I was thinking, what about when I’m irritable and so I act irritated with someone around me and then I say “Sorry, I’m feeling irritable, it doesn’t have anything to do with you.” I was thinking well that’s a knowing what’s happening in the moment- I feel irritable and I can tell others that I do. But I think there’s still a part of me that doesn’t feel that it IS the irritability, and it’s not sure whether or not in the very next moment I will not be irritable, which could happen and would be a total mystery because I wouldn’t understand what made me suddenly not irritable. Even clearer, I’d say that this feeling of “I exist” is totally mysterious- it’s completely in the realm of the unknown, and again, it’s an I-don’t-truly-know-what-will-happen-next-feeling.Now the big question. What is your relationship to that complex and detailed narrative with the title of DAN ?
Can you find anywhere a feeling of identification with that storybook character in the stories ?
I’m very happy to hear that I’ve looked, successfully, and it wasn’t even painful at all!Yes! This is looking. You didn't arrive at any conclusion as you appreciated the qualities of that sensation. You observed it.
So I see that we’re moving away from the scientific and into the tribal mode of experience (collectively in the world and interpersonally in this exchange). Truth, the “known”, in order to be considered “known” has to be presently “known” by some consciousness knowing it. Knowing is a present-moment experience of a phenomenon, and it requires two things- consciousness and the phenomenon or the “content” of consciousness. The knower and the known. I was getting a little excited about having clarity on this, getting away from my scientific skepticism of, “Well how do you know that you KNOW something?” You experience it, and that is knowing it for that moment of experience. But I see it’s still stuck in duality.Ah, good segway (segue) Yes, under normal daily life this will continue to be the case. ..but if you 'examine' this a little bit closer, we soon conclude that this is a belief. There is no way of you actually knowing that they are real. There is just a story that says based on experience this is very likely (i'd be gobsmacked if it didn't). It's a concept.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good morning Dan-ness,
So, forget everything else.
THIS IS IT.
Direct experience (of sensation) does exist. You experienced it for an instant.
..but it is so elusive, so quickly obscured by the instant invasion of thought stories, either that, or it goes by without being noticed.
So, for practical purposes, it too can be moved into the mysterious camp.
That leaves us with the whole world, everything and everybody and everyone, happening inside concept.
It's all mental.
Nothing actual.
What is the (potential) practical outcome of 'knowing' that your brain produces ALL THAT IS ?
love
vince
https://www.dropbox.com/s/l5l95ekxxmaog ... lusion.mp4
Yes, this is clear. If you look at it as a description of (a memory of) experiencing, call it an experience, it is a (concept about) statement, a definition of what is known. (what the concept of known tries to describe)Even clearer, I’d say that this feeling of “I exist” is totally mysterious- it’s completely in the realm of the unknown, and again, it’s an I-don’t-truly-know-what-will-happen-next-feeling.
So, forget everything else.
THIS IS IT.
Direct experience (of sensation) does exist. You experienced it for an instant.
..but it is so elusive, so quickly obscured by the instant invasion of thought stories, either that, or it goes by without being noticed.
So, for practical purposes, it too can be moved into the mysterious camp.
That leaves us with the whole world, everything and everybody and everyone, happening inside concept.
It's all mental.
Nothing actual.
What is the (potential) practical outcome of 'knowing' that your brain produces ALL THAT IS ?
love
vince
Watch this video and tell me if this is still so ?“Well how do you know that you KNOW something?” You experience it,
https://www.dropbox.com/s/l5l95ekxxmaog ... lusion.mp4
As non duality includes duality, what does this matter ?it’s still stuck in duality.
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
I get less attached to the beliefs and thoughts I have about the whole world etc., because I understand that the beliefs and thoughts are all a construct, a model, and since many of these constructs are flawed I understand that the brain is not an ultimate perfect source of truth. I can take the beliefs and thoughts less seriously. It doesn’t matter whether or not I or anyone else can figure everything out using concepts, because that will still only be the product of an evolutionarily configured organ. Any conceptual conclusion will say more about the function and capacity of this organ than it will about a deeper immutable truth, and, again, we know that organs are not totally flawless, in the evolutionary context or any other, in their operations. An example that comes to mind is how in any ailment it’s possible that one or another organs is overreacting in its defense activity and doing more harm than good for the organism.What is the (potential) practical outcome of 'knowing' that your brain produces ALL THAT IS ?
Now, you say “knowing”, but you put that in quotes. From the context of your preceding statements I guessed that you meant to indicate here a conceptual knowing in contrast to the DE knowing that we employ elsewhere.
Yes. What you KNOW is the direct experience of your hand feeling brushed. The illusory BELIEF that people have about the sensation being felt through the rubber hand is a STORY about the direct experience, so it is CONCEPT. If one was having direct experience using the visual sense, there would be no awareness within that sense of the tactile experience of the brush on the hand. So the conceptual mind gathered sensory input from those two direct experiences, the tactile and visual, combined them with thought, and arrived at an explanation/story/belief/“concept/statement about” that "the sensations are coming from the rubber hand". This concept is not direct experience, therefore it is not KNOWN.“Well how do you know that you KNOW something?” You experience it,
Watch this video and tell me if this is still so ?
https://www.dropbox.com/s/l5l95ekxxmaog ... lusion.mp4
Now when subjects, with eyes closed, identify the rubber hand as the location in space of the tactile sensations…it wasn’t clear whether that always happened AFTER the simultaneous visual/tactile experiment. So maybe that was just the belief still talking and remembering where the rubber hand was. Not sure.
The "it" that is still stuck in duality refers to an explanation/story/concept etc. that I was offering. It is natural that this explanation, as such, would be dualistic. What is non-dualistic is direct experience.it’s still stuck in duality.
As non duality includes duality, what does this matter ?
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good morning Dan,
Can you give me an example of each of these ?
Now, is there any point in pursuing this ?
i find great freedom in accepting the scope of the mystery. Are you consumed by the need to know any of it ?
i take it that nothing can be known.
Let me tell you a story.
When I was a kid, I use to read into the early hours of the morning, and it was always a chore to get out of bed and dressed for school. My mother use to have to wake me several times before it happened.
Anyway, one day she woke me in the usual fashion, and after dragging myself out of be and getting dressed, i was heading out of the bedroom door, when my mother woke me for school.
If you don't know that you're dreaming until you wake up, how do you know that this isn't a dream.
Is it possible to actually know anything ?
...or is knowing purely a concept ?
For that matter, is truth more than a concept ?
The point of this example is that concept is really all we have to work with. Nothing is certain. ..and although there is direct experiencing it is so fleeting that for daily existence, it isn't of much value.
love
vince
Yes, excellent. i have arrived at three categories for thoughts. 1/ Useful thoughts 2/ Rubbish thoughts 3/ entertaining thoughts (these are rubbish thoughts that, on examination, are so ridiculous that i can only laugh at them)I can take the beliefs and thoughts less seriously.
Can you give me an example of each of these ?
Yes, and as we've seen from your investigation, this stuff is as mystery.Any conceptual conclusion will say more about the function and capacity of this organ than it will about a deeper immutable truth,
Now, is there any point in pursuing this ?
i find great freedom in accepting the scope of the mystery. Are you consumed by the need to know any of it ?
Yes. i use quotes to indicate that the word can't be taken literally. It can only be used metaphorically.Now, you say “knowing”, but you put that in quotes. From the context of your preceding statements I guessed that you meant to indicate here a conceptual knowing in contrast to the DE knowing that we employ elsewhere.
i take it that nothing can be known.
Let me tell you a story.
When I was a kid, I use to read into the early hours of the morning, and it was always a chore to get out of bed and dressed for school. My mother use to have to wake me several times before it happened.
Anyway, one day she woke me in the usual fashion, and after dragging myself out of be and getting dressed, i was heading out of the bedroom door, when my mother woke me for school.
If you don't know that you're dreaming until you wake up, how do you know that this isn't a dream.
Is it possible to actually know anything ?
...or is knowing purely a concept ?
For that matter, is truth more than a concept ?
There is no doubt that the subjects were feeling sensation. The fact that their tactile brain center was stimulated by their visual center is less obvious, but it doesn't matter. As you say; "Any conceptual conclusion will say more about the function and capacity of this organ than it will about a deeper immutable truth, and, again, we know that organs are not totally flawless,"If one was having direct experience using the visual sense, there would be no awareness within that sense of the tactile experience of the brush on the hand.
The point of this example is that concept is really all we have to work with. Nothing is certain. ..and although there is direct experiencing it is so fleeting that for daily existence, it isn't of much value.
How is it useful to label something dual or non-dual ?What is non-dualistic is direct experience.
love
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
I have great difficulty in being mindful these days for any length of time, because of my depression it seems. I remember having had satisfying meditation experiences in recent months, and I know exactly what you mean by these categories. 2/ Rubbish thoughts are pure chatter, they may be just uselessly repeating old thoughts or beliefs, going nowhere seemingly, but doing it with determination. 3/ entertaining thoughts are pretty good, as you said, when you’re noticing them as thoughts, they are good for a laugh or a smile, some genuine amusement. 1/ Useful thoughts are the kind that would often end my meditation, because when they’d come around usually it’d be 20 or so minutes in and it would be an idea to go do this or another thing, and I’d have noticed so many thoughts by that point that it was pretty clear that this one was, in contrast, possibly useful.i have arrived at three categories for thoughts. 1/ Useful thoughts 2/ Rubbish thoughts 3/ entertaining thoughts (these are rubbish thoughts that, on examination, are so ridiculous that i can only laugh at them)
Can you give me an example of each of these?
Ok, so I know what you’re talking about.
2/ I can give you lots and lots of examples of rubbish thoughts. Today there was my remembering Sam Harris’ “To think and know that you’re thinking is to be mindful.” Or something like that or its inverse or something. So it was me tasking myself with doing that, when I’ve done that a million times in the past and I’m not at a place where that will help right now. Then I was thinking about how if I tried to observe my thoughts I’d have to do so from the perspective of still believing in the thought that commands me to do that, and then I thought about the concept of selflessness, about how it could be true that all the thoughts I was having, all the things that I would say I was deciding to do, that made up who I was and what I struggle with and my history and my desires and my skills, that all that, that I wasn’t inventing any of that out of originality. But thinking about that concept was just another example of old thoughts, being repeated for no good reason, to no worthwhile end.
1/ Useful thoughts & 3/ entertaining thoughts. As I said, the useful thoughts would come around after at least 15 minutes of meditation/mindfulness usually, and I can’t put near that much time together at the moment. Entertaining thoughts? My depression keeps pretty much any of these from coming in, or rather keeps me from having a safe enough distance from the chitter chatter of rubbish thoughts to be amused.
No, it’s just pure mystery, doesn’t seem accessible by words or thoughts, logic doesn’t apply to it. Definitely don’t need to know it. I feel perfectly comfortable just acknowledging this limit of my thoughts.this stuff is as mystery.
Now, is there any point in pursuing this ?
Are you consumed by the need to know any of it ?
Epistemology, “brain in a vat”, solipsismIs it possible to actually know anything?
...or is knowing purely a concept?
For that matter, is truth more than a concept?
I don’t know if it’s possible to actually know anything, but I’ve long given up believing that I do or likely can “know” anything for sure- that some immutable truth is accessible to me.
Knowing is purely a concept for me, just another degree of relative confirmation/certainty/confidence.
Truth is not more than a concept for me, again just another degree of relative confidence.
So in all these I’m not speaking with confidence in an objective knowledge. I wouldn’t say that this objective knowledge is impossible, I just haven’t worked out the logic- word mathematics- to confirm or disconfirm these definitions (Is “knowing anything” a member of the set “what is possible”? Is “knowing” ONLY a member of the set “concepts”? Is truth ONLY a member of the set “concepts”?)
This is where I am with things in principle. In practice, to be without some sense of clarity, of consistent competent discriminatory ability, is totally agonizing (this is surely due in part to my depression, and perhaps it is due completely to it). So I grasp this inability to know in principle, but I think not intuitively in practice.
I figure now I experience life as duality, and my experience will be different when I see that the self is an illusion because it will be non-dual, like my one-time experience that I tuned into hearing a sound and it became my entire field of experience. Because I label "now" as dual and "liberation" as non-dual, that's just a further way of clarifying here v. there. How is THAT useful? I don't know.How is it useful to label something dual or non-dual ?
Peace
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Daniel39 and 50 guests

