Liberation vs neuroscience.

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Wed Oct 26, 2011 7:29 am

If I can not exist, then I must also be able to exist. Therefore I must conclude that I do exist.
??? I try to break it down.
If I can not exist, then I must also be able to exist
If a flying horse cannot exist, then it must also be able to exist? It sounds like you are using the god-is-almighty argument, which doesn't apply here.
Therefore I must conclude that I do exist.
If the first half is wrong, the conclusion must be wrong, too. (It is)

But let's not do logic here. The question is not if you think you can exist, and what you deduce from that statement. The question is: Do you exist in your own direct experience?
Although we are changing the standard definition of "I" into something different. Not the personalized ownership of I. But something that cannot be held or owned.
I don't suggest changing the concept of I to something more impersonal. No concepts needed.
Therefore, no attachment can be had. In that sense, I do not exist. But that's a rhetorical question. There is no other answer. But one must redefine the meaning of the question.
In what sense DO you exist?

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Fri Oct 28, 2011 12:06 am


In what sense DO you exist?
I'm here, sitting, typing, thinking, breathing, experiencing. Whether it has a name such as "I" or left unlabeled, it is existing.

Where ever I put my attention, I notice existence. Even when my attention is not there, existence happens.

I exist, in that, I experience existence, or should I say, the existence experiences more existence. There is no end and no beginning to the existence. But there are quantum leaps in existence, by that I mean, large perceptual discontinuities. Where "I" begin and where "I" end - There seems to be some physical finiteness, and mental finiteness. There is a perceptual limit to self, where self begins and ends. I would not label You as Me.

I'm spining off into tangents. Bare with me.

What I'm saying is, I think therefore I am. =) or I experience my existence, therefore I exist.

what say you?

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Fri Oct 28, 2011 10:13 am

I'm here, sitting, typing, thinking, breathing, experiencing. Whether it has a name such as "I" or left unlabeled, it is existing.
It is life and only life sitting, typing, thinking. As you say, the "I" is a label, a believe. It is not real. As I have heard saying: like Santa Claus.
Where ever I put my attention, I notice existence.
Do you have control over where your attention is going? Really? Always? Often? Sometimes?
Where "I" begin and where "I" end - There seems to be some physical finiteness, and mental finiteness. There is a perceptual limit to self, where self begins and ends. I would not label You as Me.
Where does your "I" begin and where does it end? Do you find it, is it REAL? Or is it NOTHING ELSE BUT a label?
What I'm saying is, I think therefore I am. =)
I think I have heard that one before :)
It should say: Thinking, therefore being. No I needed.
or I experience my existence, therefore I exist.
Look again. Watch your perceptions, watch your thoughts. One thought is coming in after the other, there is not one "comprising thought" which is experiencing other thoughts and perceptions.
There is not one I-thought which is thinking. The "I exist" thought is on the same hierarchy level as the other thoughts.

This is not just semantics!!!

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Sat Oct 29, 2011 3:40 am


Do you have control over where your attention is going? Really? Always? Often? Sometimes?
the source of the thought that directs attention is just another thought. How much control? From my understanding, none at all. I can't think of any thing that could be the source that isn't just another thought. But this i what I'm trying to disprove to myself.
There is not one I-thought which is thinking. The "I exist" thought is on the same hierarchy level as the other thoughts.
This is where I get stuck. I know this. I know there is no real "I". that it's no more or less than a bundle of thoughts, however through it's complexity something else exists.

For example, just because we are made of atoms, which is 99.99999% empty space does not make us empty space. We are solid due to the combination of strong and weak atomic forces. Just because our building blocks are thoughts, and "I" is nothing but thoughts, who and what we are is more than that.

The problem remains, there is no method of enlightenment that is truly long lasting. And Enlightenment is nothing more than rhetoric.

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Sat Oct 29, 2011 6:48 am

This is where I get stuck. I know this. I know there is no real "I". that it's no more or less than a bundle of thoughts, however through it's complexity something else exists.
Yeah, that is the illusion. A self-reflexive thought loop which is taken for something real.
Just because our building blocks are thoughts, and "I" is nothing but thoughts, who and what we are is more than that.
If you really look, you will find there is NOT more than that. Real thoughts, really interacting with each other. Real bodys. Not more.

How is it in your experience? Not in your theory! Do you "know" there is no real "I" or do you *see* that?

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Sat Oct 29, 2011 8:44 pm

Okay, just going through and re-reading the origin of this thread. I think we are going way off on a tangent. I see that it has become another one-on-one, which this is not. If the discussion is about my own liberation, we can start another thread about that. But the original discussion is about the semantic game of liberation to generate a short lived spiritual experience vs neuroscience's nomenclature.

Again, the game that is played here on this site is that "you're not liberated until you can clearly see that there is no 'I'."

If we take the scientific perspective, explaining nature with only what is observable, then we see that the "I" is indeed a label, like "apple" is a label for the fruit which is part of the tree, which built of atoms, which is really nearly completely empty, and the parts that exist is a complete mystery despite the large amounts of measured data and research.

This is the analogy I'm asking. Why not work with the labels with the understanding that they are that, labels.

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Sat Oct 29, 2011 9:06 pm

Again, the game that is played here on this site is that "you're not liberated until you can clearly see that there is no 'I'."
Right, that's the game here on this site!
If we take the scientific perspective, explaining nature with only what is observable, then we see that the "I" is indeed a label, like "apple" is a label for the fruit which is part of the tree, which built of atoms, which is really nearly completely empty, and the parts that exist is a complete mystery despite the large amounts of measured data and research. This is the analogy I'm asking.
If you want a theoretical discussion about physics and philosophy, there are plenty of other forums do do that.

If you want to experience no self "yourself", I'll be more than happy to help as much as I can, and also answer scientific oriented questions to the best of my abilities. But you have to commit 100% to this, and really want it.

What is it you want, buddhawarrior?

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Sun Oct 30, 2011 9:02 am

There is no need for opening a new thread for confirmations. You just have to answer a set of questions, the first one being:

Is there a you, at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form?

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Sun Oct 30, 2011 3:42 pm


Is there a you, at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form?
There is no one identifiable entity that drives it all, just life happening. The "you" you refer to is just a label. It dresses itself, feeds itself, pays bills by itself, no "me" is needed.

"I" only exist in the sense that the label makes it easy to communicate, but nothing real, nothing physical exists that is the driver of this train.

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Sun Oct 30, 2011 3:54 pm

Earlier you have written:
If I can not exist, then I must also be able to exist. Therefore I must conclude that I do exist.

Although we are changing the standard definition of "I" into something different. Not the personalized ownership of I. But something that cannot be held or owned.
In my ears this "change the standard definition of I into something different" doesn't really fit together with "just life happening".

Would you explain how you experience "just life happening?"

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Sun Oct 30, 2011 10:31 pm

In my ears this "change the standard definition of I into something different" doesn't really fit together with "just life happening".
On a day to day basis, when I say to my wife, "I'm going to the store." I mean that my physical self, the "I" contained in my skin, is going some where. If I say, "I am feeling hurt" I mean that my emotional self is in pain. In general, this definition of "I" works very well to communicate between each other. If I went to a psychologist, they might ask me about my family history, and I will search through my personal experience and draw upon a neurological memory storage system. If "I" were to commit a crime and be convicted, they will put my physical body in Jail.

This is the standard Definition of "I". An individuated being that is responsible for all the actions and reactions happening to it. Something even beyond the physical body barrier, something like a soul.

Taking this standard definition and asking the questions, who is this "I"? or where is this "I" leads to an unraveling of attachments to false identification, false ownership.

A new definition of "I" begin to appear.

"I'm going to the store" becomes "going to the store is happening to this body."

Although, I will not be talking like that to my wife. =)

The original definition of I, now understood as nothing more than a useful label, will still be used. But an additional understanding now comes with each use.
Would you explain how you experience "just life happening?"
I'm sitting here typing, reading, responding, formulating thoughts, seeing other thoughts, all of this is like a chain of falling dominos, action-reaction, kharma, no beginning can be found, no choice. When snow flakes form, some general rules govern the crystallization of water vapors, but the result is complete diversity, with no two flakes alike. Neither the vapors nor the budding flake had to make any decisions to create the individuality of the flake.

It's so funny, cause we all call ourselves human "beings." Why do we say we are a being. Because it's a happening. as a being, we are in a constant state of change. So many things should have the suffix -ing. A flame is not a flame, but a flaming. The sun is not a sun, but a sunning. The tree is treeing. Just like I am being. It's all just life happening.

User avatar
Pratityasamutpada
Posts: 95
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Pratityasamutpada » Sun Oct 30, 2011 11:45 pm

Time to put the philosophizing aside for the time being. What's being asked about and tested here is not your knowledge or analysis, but your direct experience. So, the question was, how do you experience "just life happening?" Who is sitting there typing, reading, responding, seeing thoughts, etc? Don't think about it, look at it right now this moment, who is doing these things?

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Mon Oct 31, 2011 5:35 am

No one is doing. Doing is happening.

User avatar
Ingen
Posts: 1643
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 8:39 pm
Location: Denmark

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby Ingen » Mon Oct 31, 2011 8:30 am

Oh please, that was lame. You can copy this sentence out of any vaguely spiritual book or website.

How do you experience not being a self? How do you experience
"going to the store is happening to this body."
Explain it to us as we have never heard of non-self before, in detail.

Yes, this is a lot of work.

User avatar
buddhawarrior
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Oct 07, 2011 3:27 pm
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Liberation vs neuroscience.

Postby buddhawarrior » Mon Oct 31, 2011 8:53 pm

Time to put the philosophizing aside for the time being. What's being asked about and tested here is not your knowledge or analysis, but your direct experience. So, the question was, how do you experience "just life happening?" Who is sitting there typing, reading, responding, seeing thoughts, etc? Don't think about it, look at it right now this moment, who is doing these things?
I tried writing responses to this, and all I could think about was the philosophizing bit. Everything I write sounds like more philosophy. so after writing and deleting several attempts, this was all I was left with.
No one is doing. Doing is happening.
There are so many threads of thoughts that are going through my head, to catch one and write it down would be inauthentic since I don't really identify with any of them. There is the subconscious part of me which operates on autopilot, like all of my internal organs. Like driving from point A to point B and arriving at point B without any memories of the drive. (it's all sounding like more bullshit) But this is actually how I experience it. I DON'T experience it. That's how it is. I can put my conscious mind to rest and let nature take over. Of course there are times, like now, that I have to use my conscious mind, like I would a hammer if I'm pounding nails. A tool, the conscious mind helps me formulate thoughts, responses, check for typos, etc. (again, more philosophical sounding shit.)

There is a part of me that's getting fraustrated. There's a part of me that wants to quite, give-up. There's parts of me that's calm, at ease, there's part of me that's in pain. my shoulder has a sharp pain, my back is aching, i'm ready to do chores. Etc.

Before my awakenings, I would be very conscious of my ego. I wanted to shape my future, to be someone, something, fame, money, girls, something big. I put heavy burden's on myself. If I made a mistake, I would talk harshly to myself. If I failed I'd take it to heart. If I did something great, I felt on top of the world. I liked to take credit for things I did well, and hated to take blame for things that failed. These same thoughts are still there, but I don't spend much time on them now. Just another passing thought. no need to fixate on them.

The experience of the non-self is not any different than the experience of self. Moment to moment, it's the same. I'm operating less from a "have-to" perspective, less from a "I'm doing it" but rather, a simply "doing". But the physical experience of living has not changed. There are still desires, aversions, ego, clinging, attachment, suffering. Most of the time I snap out of it, and realize what's happening. But sometimes I'll get stuck in a loop and need reminding.

I would say the best part of the whole thing is that it does change my response to the world. I have no other point of view other than my own, so can not accurately say whether it has made my life better or worst, and on top of which I'm not even sure if one can make a better or worst life for oneself. But for the sake of full disclosure, I do feel that my reactions to the world creates a personal reality that is more better. =)

I am a visual person and a visual artist by trade, so I often wax poetic and use metaphores and similies (hopefullly not to be construed as philosophizing.) But I see my experience of no-self as, "the buck stops here." A wave of bad energy comes and hits me, like getting cut off on the freeway, or someone cutting in line at the grocery store. But that negativity stops with me, I will not pass it on. What is there to be mad about? Why would the way someone else behaves anger me? who are they and who am I, but life just unfolding. I have witnessed many times the change in the offending party when they see they failed to offend me, and their whole being changes.

Particularly to this forum thread, I find the question difficult to answer. When I sit and think about an answer, the mind blows up, literally, the gears grind to a halt. There is no answer. Mind goes blank. A million thoughts rush by and can not get one down.

At my job, I'm simply there to help. However hard or frustrating the circumstance, I'm just there moving and helping. Helping others, helping myself. Before Awakenings, I had a big ego I walked around with at work. I'm this, I'm that, I should be this and that, and you should be this and that. I would get offended if things didn't go smoothly. I pretended to be better and more mature and enlightened than others. I wanted to have all the answers. I wanted to be right. Not so much anymore. All those desires are still there, and I see them as thoughts flying through my mind. But I just chuckle to myself. Whether this is the experience of no-self or just becoming more mature, or just getting older, I can not be sure. But it is the experience of just being me.

There are still lot's of areas of my life which gets under my skin. And as time goes on, some sharp edges soften and more edges keep appearing. Sometimes it takes just minutes before I am reminded of no-self, sometimes it takes days or weeks.

Maybe the most layman way to say it is, less things get to me.


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 13 guests