Another guide please

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Sun Oct 26, 2014 11:31 am

If you read, "your right hand" you can point to it.
If you read, "your left hand" you can point to it.
If you read "your head" you can point to it.
Where does "I" in "I'm trying to locate..." point to?
It doesn't point anywhere. There is no 'thing' to point to.
At best (because the belief is that the words are in my head, I hear them in my head) in can point to somewhere in mind, but somewhere that cannot be located as a specific thing or place.

So that is why the conclusion is 'it doesn't point anywhere' .

Here are the instructions again, broken out. Please follow them:

Just take some words that you think of as yours - those ones you posted - and see:
1) if you know where the came from
2) if they are true
3) say what "I" refers to in them.
1 - as above.
2 - (taking the same words - 'I would not like to stop, even though I might be busy with this ridiculous job.')
Hmm. It's true in that the stated intention is there (not like to) but not true in that there is no 'I' (at least not that I can locate) to 'not stop'.
3 - 'I', therefore, must refer to something/someone imaginary.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Sun Oct 26, 2014 3:00 pm

I would not like to stop, even though I might be busy with this ridiculous job.
Doesn't this seem a bit odd? You reflect on your busy schedule and you think that thought, "I would not like to stop..." - it just appears in your mind.

According to the contents of the thought, there is an "I".
But when you look for it you can't find it.
This non-findable subject "I", according to the thought, has likes and dislikes.
This "I", which you can't find, is doing somehing, and it wants to keep going.
At the moment you have th thought, what does it mean to "keep going"? Keeping going is a concept.
This "I", which you can't find is also busy.
And there's a thing called a "job" (again, try to find that), and that thing is "ridiculous".

So there's a thought about a few concepts. You can't find "I", "job" or "keeping going". Nor "wanting"

The second question, is it true, is meant in the sense, without referring to thought - without using anoher thought to justify the statement - is it true?

We agree you had a thought that popped in to your mind in response to you contemplating a question (do you want to keep going or not). That is true - you had a thought.

So you got an answer, in the form of a thought that popped into your mind.
A bunch of the words in the thought don't point to anything you can find in the world.
One of the words, "I", is points to something very important, but you can't find it at all.

How do you know the thought is true? In the sense of not using more thoughts to prove it is correct? And in the sense that you might be demented, or might have been demented when you had that thought?

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Sun Oct 26, 2014 3:29 pm

A little more to consider - so your thought was emotionally charged. It is about and "I" that wants something, but is constrained. Maybe it won't/can't get what it wants to be happy.

Depending on how crucial it is, and depending on how much truth you invest in the thought, you'll feel more or less stressed in your body.

Imagine the thought was "I'm dying" or "I'm going to get my nose cut off" - depending on how much yiu helieve the thought, you'll be more or less stressed in your body.

But the only reason you're having the thought - the first one -is that some guy on the internet asked you something.

If the thought had never crossed your mind, you couldn't have believed it. No stress.
If it crossed your mind and you saw it as nonsense, no stress.
If it crosses your mind and you believe it relates to you, the thing reading these words right now - even though you agree the thought doesn't make sense, your heart might skip a beat.

Doesn't that seem a bit arbitrary?

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Sun Oct 26, 2014 5:28 pm

How do you know the thought is true? In the sense of not using more thoughts to prove it is correct? And in the sense that you might be demented, or might have been demented when you had that thought?
the thought 'I would not like to stop'.

In the moment, possibly have no way of knowing it is true or not.
Over time can note if it is still happening and then deduce it is likely to be true.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Sun Oct 26, 2014 5:34 pm

The thing I'd like you to look at again and again - as you go through your busy week - is that if you have a thought, "that's ABC doing XYZ" - that other than you "assenting" to the thought and investing it with belief, there's no truth to it. Just because you have the thought "ABC is doing XYZ" it doesn't mean that that is true.

I'm not asking you to derail your life. Please continue acting like your thoughts are true.

But in the next day, it would really help if you pay attention to this phenomenon; it is important that you see your thoughts as thoughts and not as truths.
I think I still need to focus on this.

Also, thanks for the little more to consider. It does seem a bit arbitrary, yes.
I would like to catch some real life examples of this as they actually happen, to fully understand it.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Sun Oct 26, 2014 10:16 pm

I think I still need to focus on this.

Also, thanks for the little more to consider. It does seem a bit arbitrary, yes. I would like to catch some real life examples of this as they actually happen, to fully understand it.
I would encourage you to apply the same 3 steps to those thoughts.

Whatever thoughts are happening now, try the 3 out.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Mon Oct 27, 2014 7:48 pm

You might benefit from watching and experimenting with this video: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XB2Itt5KQU8

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Tue Oct 28, 2014 12:04 am

Thank you.
I am doing what I can and will speak more when have something to report.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Tue Oct 28, 2014 10:59 pm

Today I have noticed thought and asked the three questions.
Again, I don't know where they come from, I can't say that any of them are true and there does not appear to be any 'I' that the thoughts refer to.

At one time today I was quite detached and simply noticing this experience.

How come, then, there are other times (happened today also) where 'I' am completely consumed by thought - so much so that there is no questioning of their truth, just some automatic, preconditioned set of assumptions.

I don't think there is anything wrong with either occurrence but do notice the stark contrast.

The video helped clarify, will watch it again the next day or so.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Tue Oct 28, 2014 11:20 pm

Did you notice anything about these things you wrote and your sense of self?
...At one time today I was quite detached and simply noticing this experience.
How come, then, there are other times (happened today also) where 'I' am completely consumed by thought - so much so that there is no questioning of their truth, just some automatic, preconditioned set of assumptions.
Nice looking.

As you explained, for some of the day you noticed your thoughts, that they came out of nowhere, that there was no way to say if they are true (other than referring to more thoughts) and that there doesn't appear to be an "I" that they refer to.

And then for the rest of the day, you're "consumed by thought", no questioning - just some automatic assuming that the thoughts are true.

Which feels better? Which is more enjoyable?

Reading your report and question, I have the following thought: at this point it might be helpful for you to investigate if you control what you pay attention to, if you control what you notice, if you control where your attention goes, if you control whether you get lost in thought or not, etc -- and if you think you do any of that, can you point to that thing that controls that stuff? That is similar to asking what "I" points to.

Does that make sense? Feel free to ask for clarification.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Wed Oct 29, 2014 10:51 pm

Which feels better? Which is more enjoyable?
Noticing definitely is better. The automatic isn't really enjoyable as such. It just happens, sometimes pleasant and sometimes, when caught in dramas, not so pleasant. Hmm. I'm trying to say that the automatic seems robot like, where as the noticing seems alive.
investigate if you control what you pay attention to, if you control what you notice, if you control where your attention goes, if you control whether you get lost in thought or not, etc
Initially I would say no to all of these, although there may be an element of control with what we pay attention to - that is focus, I would suggest.

However, I will spend some time actually looking specifically at these questions.

It makes sense, yes.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Thu Oct 30, 2014 11:27 pm

I wrote out the new suggestions then forgot to take them with me today. Found it impossible to remember the instruction.
I found myself lost in thought a lot today but even then managed the odd moment of seeing thoughts.

Notes in bag now, ready for tomorrow.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Thu Oct 30, 2014 11:31 pm

OK. But do you really need to notice this stuff tomorrow? Can't you do it now?

Eg did you choose to read the last sentence and then this one? Or did it just happen? Can you find anything in your awareness that controls what you pay attention to?

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Fri Oct 31, 2014 9:46 pm

if you control what you pay attention to,
No. Quite definitely not. It's most odd (as in, surely something must control it? Or does it really just happen?)
if you control what you notice,
There doesn't seem to be any control. Except, see below.
if you control where your attention goes,
Well, sometimes .... if there is a thought directing attention. If there is a task to perform.
For example, today I had to find an address - the thought 'I need an address' seemed to direct attention.

This is quite a 'sticky' point for me:
depending on how far I want to trace things back, depends on where I look for an 'I'.
That is, the thought 'I need an address' is just a thought, no 'I' creating or directing it. However, the reason that thought is there is because 'I' had to take a job ...... if not an 'I' then 'something' took on a set of bahaviours, actions, that are performed daily (in short language form this could be termed a job).

So, something decided to do something, which sometimes involves controlling the attention.
In that sense, it could also be suggested that this something also at times controls what is payed attention to and what is noticed.
if you control whether you get lost in thought or not
No. This just happens, or not.
and if you think you do any of that, can you point to that thing that controls that stuff?
Now this is the one. No. I can suggest a 'something'. But where it is, to actually point to it? No, I can't do that.
OK. But do you really need to notice this stuff tomorrow? Can't you do it now?
I could have. I was quite simply tired and wanted some time to relax. I'm not sure who/what wanted that time though.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Fri Oct 31, 2014 10:51 pm

Have you noticed that sometimes when you move you do it without thinking, and other times there's a thought - and that that is how we decide if "I" did it? You did this exercise, right? Please forgive me, but our exchange has gone on for 12 pages and I can't recall it all.

If you haven't done that exercise, or even if you have, please pay attention and notice how thinking, motion and volition work.

And then I'd ask you if the shifting of attention isn't just part of that whole phenomenon of moving, thinking, etc.

You might try paying attention to the feelings you get when you do something volitional, like a yoga move or a dance move. Eg thrill or pride or positive self-regard, and ask if you control those feelings, make them happen, etc.


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 41 guests