Another guide please

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Sun Oct 19, 2014 1:00 pm

I don't know that thoughts are true. I assume them to be. That is, they go un-questioned.
Can you describe that a bit more? E.g. suppose you have a thought like, "I'm too busy to do this" or "I'm making a mess of this".

When you say they go unquestioned, are you noticing that you're thinking? Or noticing and having more thoughts in agreement with the original thought? Or noticing the thought and then acting as if it is true?

Have you tried paying attention when you aren't thinking? That is, suppose a thought goes. There's some time before the next thought, so there's a gap. Have you noticed what things are like in that gap?

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Sun Oct 19, 2014 6:19 pm

When you say they go unquestioned, are you noticing that you're thinking?
Well, undoubtedly some thinking is not consciously noticed so they go unquestioned.

Thinking on this some more I realise that once they are questioned, they are sometimes found to be not true. For example, if i had a thought that said 'I'm a stupid person' and noticed the thought I might then think 'that's not the case', I have shown intelligence here, here and here'.

However, and back to the original context (How do you know that thoughts are true? Can you prove that any of them are true, without using a thought to do it?), some you can prove without using a thought - thought of 'the sun is shining', simply look outside, no thought involved there.
Or thought of 'I've got this problem, xyz can help', simply phone/speak to xyz and ask them if they can help. No thought involved there.
Or noticing and having more thoughts in agreement with the original thought? Or noticing the thought and then acting as if it is true?
Sometimes either of these can happen.

This next bit has intrigued me:
Have you tried paying attention when you aren't thinking? That is, suppose a thought goes. There's some time before the next thought, so there's a gap. Have you noticed what things are like in that gap?
Because I can't say I have noticed.
Now I'm trying it I notice that there is an intense focus in the area of my brain (as if that is where all thought occurs, inside my head) and then there is the attempt for more thought to fill the gap.
I notice its difficult to notice the gap once you are trying and I notice I am trying to find a 'location' of this gap.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Mon Oct 20, 2014 7:57 am

However, and back to the original context (How do you know that thoughts are true? Can you prove that any of them are true, without using a thought to do it?), some you can prove without using a thought - thought of 'the sun is shining', simply look outside, no thought involved there.
Or thought of 'I've got this problem, xyz can help', simply phone/speak to xyz and ask them if they can help. No thought involved there.
So when you see a certain visual pattern in what you think of as the sky and you think "sun is shining", how do you know it is true? How can you prove it is true, without saying, "because I think so and so and it feels correct"?

How can you know that you aren't demented or confused, as in the example of a guy who sees a car in his driveway and thinks someone else has parked it there, when it is actually his own car?
Because I can't say I have noticed.
Now I'm trying it I notice that there is an intense focus in the area of my brain (as if that is where all thought occurs, inside my head) and then there is the attempt for more thought to fill the gap.
I notice its difficult to notice the gap once you are trying and I notice I am trying to find a 'location' of this gap.
I'm not sure I communicated this properly.

If you stare at a point - say a doorknob - for a while, you might have a thought like, "hmm that doorknob is dusty I should clean it". If you keep staring, after a while you may not have a thought. That's the gap I'm talking about - there are times when you aren't absorbed in thought. There's a gap between thoughts.

Staring at something will probably make it easier. Eg if I move around my living space, as my eyes move I'll think things like, "I should move that", "time to throw that away", "trash is looking full", etc. That is, there's all sorts of thoughts triggered by what I see. So staring at something leads to fewer thoughts.

If you observe your mind between thoughts, what is it like? You are aware of things - you see, hear, etc - but you aren't thinking. What is that like?

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Mon Oct 20, 2014 10:30 pm

So when you see a certain visual pattern in what you think of as the sky and you think "sun is shining", how do you know it is true? How can you prove it is true, without saying, "because I think so and so and it feels correct"?
Because, through learnt behaviour and association, I know that the thing humans call the sun gives warmth. I can prove it is the sun shining by standing outside and noticing if I start to feel warmth on my skin.
Or, at the very least, having ruled out other possible sources for the warmth, I can say that the sun is highly likely to be the source of the heat, and as I can feel that warmth and connect it to the visual image in the sky, I can say quite confidently that the sun is shining. There is not a necessity of thought to be involved for that process to occur (although thought may comment on the process.)
If you keep staring, after a while you may not have a thought. That's the gap I'm talking about - there are times when you aren't absorbed in thought. There's a gap between thoughts.
Sure, I'll do this. I'm really keen to discover this gap, thanks for the extra explanation.

Please note I am on that working schedule again. I am committed and engaged, even if it seems that I'm not. I will definitely find some time tomorrow to do the above work.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Mon Oct 20, 2014 11:42 pm

You gave a big long example of thinking about the sun. The question was, "how can you prove it is true, without saying..."


Consider the dementia sufferer who thinks, "that car doesn't belong there" - if asked to prove it true, without reference to thought, how can he?

About "the gap" - you write you're keen to discover the gap. It isn't so much about some gap, but your mind.

If you are alert and you relax, how is your mind?

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Tue Oct 21, 2014 2:08 am

I reread my previous post and I thought I should be clear.

When talking aboutthen sun, the question was, "How can you prove it is true, without saying, 'because I think so and so and it feels correct'?"

That is, if I say, "how can your prove you're named Marcus"?
You might say, "no, my name is Mark"
And I ask, "how do you know that your name isn't Marcus or even Mohammed? Prove it without reference to thought . Memory counts as thought.

If this seems stupid, silly or just frustrating, it relates to the task at hand - the belief that you have a self is roughly equivalent to you having a name or you knowing that white dot surrounded by grey is a sun.

If you strip away all the stuff that thought tells you.... then what?

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Tue Oct 21, 2014 10:14 pm

When talking about the sun, the question was, "How can you prove it is true, without saying, 'because I think so and so and it feels correct'?"
You can't prove it is true. I was thinking abouth this after all that writing about the sun last night and came to the same conclusion - it is a lot of thought.
And I ask, "how do you know that your name isn't Marcus or even Mohammed? Prove it without reference to thought . Memory counts as thought.
Hmm. I'm realising that it isn't possible.

But, what does this prove then?! That the self only exists in thought?

Although I have to say, from my point of view, this is still an intellectual understanding of this.
If you strip away all the stuff that thought tells you.... then what?
This is a really big question! It's like my brain is struggling to comprehend the ramifications of this.
Maybe all that is left is direct experience in this moment.

But ... but .... I want to argue it, it doesn't seem that clear in my everyday life, not sure what to say to illustrate this.
If you are alert and you relax, how is your mind?
Generally, not so active. Quiet.

At the moment I am finding this difficult. Tried to focus on the gap between thoughts and just seem to be noticing every tiny influence and that mind itself is not quiet or calm.
Not that it can't be quiet, just difficult during the 'wired' week of work.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Tue Oct 21, 2014 11:03 pm

But, what does this prove then?! That the self only exists in thought?
I think you might have skipped ahead a bit. Did you get excited and race ahead? Let's take this slowly.

The thing I'd like you to look at again and again - as you go through your busy week - is that if you have a thought, "that's ABC doing XYZ" - that other than you "assenting" to the thought and investing it with belief, there's no truth to it. Just because you have the thought "ABC is doing XYZ" it doesn't mean that that is true.

I'm not asking you to derail your life. Please continue acting like your thoughts are true.

But in the next day, it would really help if you pay attention to this phenomenon; it is important that you see your thoughts as thoughts and not as truths.

Of course, there's "logic" to the thoughts. You'll notice they help you to run your life.

And just as if you feel cold it is true that you feel cold, if you just had the thought "ABC is doing XYZ", it is true that you just had the thought, "ABC is doing XYZ". But, as mentioned above, without investing that thought with belief, there's nothing about the thought that makes it necessarily true.

So I'm asking you to pay attention to your direct experience of thinking in the next few days. Please try to notice what thoughts you have, and in what situations. And please try to see if the thoughts are absolutely true or just useful things that occur to you as you move through your life.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Wed Oct 22, 2014 11:38 pm

is that if you have a thought, "that's ABC doing XYZ"
please give some examples.
that other than you "assenting" to the thought
assenting = agreeing?
and investing it with belief
an example of how this might look would help here also

In the mean time I will do as you've suggested with my current best understanding of what you mean. Thanks. I really appreciate you adapting this to suit my situation.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Wed Oct 22, 2014 11:48 pm

This is really simple stuff. I can relate it to our previous exchange.

Suppose you see a bright white circle on a grey background and think "that's the sun shining in the sky".

If you assent to it, you say, "of course that's the sun shining in the sky."

If you don't, you say, "You can't prove it is true. I was thinking about this after all that writing about the sun last night and came to the same conclusion - it is a lot of thought."

I'll repeat the relevant stuff from yesterday:

The thing I'd like you to look at again and again - as you go through your busy week - is that if you have a thought, "that's ABC doing XYZ" - that other than you "assenting" to the thought and investing it with belief, there's no truth to it.

... I'm not asking you to derail your life. Please continue acting like your thoughts are true.

Also, if you are too busy and would like to stop, that's OK. The nature of this stuff is that it has to be very important or you aren't likely to figure it out. No point in you wasting time.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Thu Oct 23, 2014 11:03 pm

Also, if you are too busy and would like to stop, that's OK. The nature of this stuff is that it has to be very important or you aren't likely to figure it out. No point in you wasting time.
I would not like to stop, even though I might be busy with this ridiculous job. Actually I'm thinking about quitting the job rather than quit this. It will have to wait a week or so - I have to make sure I get paid for all the hours I've put in.
May be I'll find something else, these hours are crazy. I'm tired and exhausted and have to do it all again in a few hours time!

Things may change next week, the work may get easier as our hours will be reduced slightly, we'll see.

I am committed still - I don't want a job to take over my life, even though it is at the moment.

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Fri Oct 24, 2014 2:24 am

So you want to see through the illusion of self? Just take some words that you think of as yours - those ones you posted - and see if you know where the came from, if they are true and say what "I" refers to in them. That's it.

If you want to continue, please do that.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Fri Oct 24, 2014 10:32 pm

Just take some words that you think of as yours - those ones you posted - and see if you know where they came from
ok, start with just a few - like these:
'I would not like to stop, even though I might be busy with this ridiculous job.'
Now that is curious. Trying to work out where they came from and it seems to have drawn a blank. It seemed to have come from somewhere but now I'm trying to locate where, exactly, there just seems to be a blank.

I mean, I can hear the voice speaking in my head as I go over the words, the emphasis on the 'not' .... but I don't know where they came from, or where they are coming from now.

It's crazy. It's like I've assumed that voice that speaks inside is 'mine', but where is that 'me'? Looking for it this way, auditory, is very powerful! What is this voice? Who is this voice? I don't know the answer to that!
if they are true and say what "I" refers to in them.
I don't know where they originate from. I don't know that there is any 'owner' of that voice, those words.
I can pretend it is 'me', imagine it to be 'me'.
And the assumptions start almost immediately there is ever a voice in my head, speaking to 'myself' .... I say assumptions, they are technically, but its like the thought to question where the words come from, if there is an 'I', just does not occur.
So this whole illusion of self is veiled about ... I'm not sure what either. I mean, on the face of it, there is nothing there. It's veiled about something I've assumed to be true all along. And it's not. At all.

I don't know why the words have had such a powerful effect. I know I have translated that into speaking to myself (it's nothing you actually stated) but it is really bringing the 'illusion' to life for me, if that sentence even makes sense!

User avatar
Armstrong
Posts: 728
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 9:01 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby Armstrong » Fri Oct 24, 2014 10:47 pm

OK, where did these words come from?
Now that is curious. Trying to work out where they came from and it seems to have drawn a blank. It seemed to have come from somewhere but now I'm trying to locate where, exactly, there just seems to be a blank.
And when you write, " I'm trying to locate ..." there is an "I" in there. As in "I am trying to locate".

If you read, "your right hand" you can point to it.
If you read, "your left hand" you can point to it.
If you read "your head" you can point to it.
Where does "I" in "I'm trying to locate..." point to?

Finally, you didn't follow the instructions. You didn't ask if the thoughts were true.

Here are the instructions again, broken out. Please follow them:

Just take some words that you think of as yours - those ones you posted - and see:
1) if you know where the came from
2) if they are true
3) say what "I" refers to in them.

User avatar
marka
Posts: 280
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2014 6:17 pm

Re: guide please :)

Postby marka » Sat Oct 25, 2014 11:05 pm

I am still here. Will speak with you tomorrow.


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 44 guests