Thread for CatBells

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
CatBells
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby CatBells » Thu Oct 02, 2014 2:04 pm

Apologies for the slightly longer than anticipated delay in getting back to you but now lets crack on.
I hope you are keeping well.

Many thanks for your responses of which as you would have had expected I have a number of questions for you plus an exercise.
Mainly there are expectations that I will see the ultimate truth, be liberated and won't have to worry about the mind-body issue and more importantly the thought game/battle. Fear is that what if I don't succeed. Difference would be in the perception, I would live moment to moment. Hope is that the attachment to 'I', 'body' and 'mind' will vanish and I will live in pure awareness or just experience life as is without analyzing and getting sucked into it. I have read that similar sort of things have happened to other people, there would be no subject-object difference and only pure awareness.
I would like to be clear by what you mean by the terms "ultimate truth"," liberated", "mind-body", "thought game/battle"
Since, my very first post, where I mentioned that feeling of 'I', 'self' and 'Naresh' has vanished, things have changed. I don't know what exactly has happened, but I find a slight difference in my previous experience (time of my first post) and now. There is more fear, that I may have gained the feeling of 'I'. I wander into thoughts for few seconds and then recognize that I have been carried away by thoughts. The statement I made earlier - "I don't feel one with everything" still stays. There is a sense of body and eyes and ears, through which sensations, seeing and hearing is happening.
Slightly confused here Naresh as in the first sentence you say that the feeling of I, self and Naresh have vanished but then you go on to say that you have more fear that you have gained the feeling of I. Please elaborate.

What is meant by "everything" in your statement "I don't feel one with everything"

Who or what is doing the seeing or hearing?
I haven't seen anything, except the fact that I recognize that what I call 'I', 'me', 'self' is a thought. I recognize and observe this as a thought. But as mentioned before, sometimes I forget and at times it is clear. When I look I find that 'self' is a thought claiming to take ownership of this body and experience. I would dare to say that its qualities, attributes, location and dimension is defined by my body. When I write 'I', 'me' or 'self', I again mean this physical body which is termed as 'Naresh'.
Many times there is an expectation that after seeing through the illusion of a separate self that one will constantly be noticing no self. But in reality it's more like when you first learned there was no actual Santa, no actual Tooth Fairy, no actual Batman. You did not need to stay focused on no-Batman in order to know or remember there is none in reality. So, too, with seeing no self! No self is not a State, not a way of being or feeling or thinking; it's merely a Fact, like no Santa. And it doesn't mean there are never thoughts of self any more than no Santa or no Batman means there are never thoughts of Santa or Batman. We simply know that when we say or write Santa or Batman, we are referring to a fiction.
Came across this Bahiya Sutta:
Please put aside all other teachings, philosophies and such for the remainder of this journey and really just commit to begin looking for this separate self, this "I"; look for what is the experience throughout the day as this looking happens. If you have a daily and essential meditation practice, it's fine to continue that.

However having said that, lets do an exercise to do with sensations. Start with hearing. Listen to sounds. In DE, is there a "hearer" and "what's being heard", or is there just a sound?

Try with sight, too. That can be trickier. Focus on the visual appearance itself, not thoughts identifying which objects you're seeing. Other than those thoughts, is there a distinction between "seer" and "seen", or just a sight?

Now look the other way. There is no name of person, but there is a story about a character. Experience is happening now, the story about experience makes it seem that there is an experiencer. Take a look how the language is structured, there is an assumed subject. This subject is a concept, an idea.

Take a look, is there a gap between experiencer, experienced and experiencing? Try with each sense, is there a feeler of sensation separate from the sensed?
With closed eyes, find out if there is a line between here and there, inside and outside, me and the world. What comes up when you examine that?

User avatar
Experience
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:03 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby Experience » Thu Oct 02, 2014 4:24 pm

Apologies for the slightly longer than anticipated delay in getting back to you but now lets crack on. I hope you are keeping well.
No worries Bill, hope you had a good time. I am doing well :-)
I would like to be clear by what you mean by the terms "ultimate truth"," liberated", "mind-body", "thought game/battle"
By "ultimate truth" and "liberation", I mean that I will see through the facade of 'self' and 'I' and directly experience the no-self 24/7. "Mind-body issue" and "thought game/battle" is my way of saying that liberated people don't have to worry about how they look and be caught up in conflicting thoughts of what is right or wrong.
Slightly confused here Naresh as in the first sentence you say that the feeling of I, self and Naresh have vanished but then you go on to say that you have more fear that you have gained the feeling of I. Please elaborate.
By above statement I mean the following - When I first realized that there is no "I", "self" or "Naresh", the experience was amazing, like an 'aha' moment. For e.g., When I went for long walks, I didn't care how I looked, what I wore or what people thought about me, I was just walking and enjoying the scenery. After 5-7 days that feeling subsided. Meaning I still recognize "I", "self" or "Naresh" as a thought, but it is like the old me is back, I am conscious about how I look, what others are thinking about me....In short I find myself body conscious, which is the same feeling I have had for years. It is like I gained something and now I have lost it. I know it sounds silly, because intellectually I recognize that there is no difference.
What is meant by "everything" in your statement "I don't feel one with everything"
Hmmm, this one is purely based on what I have read and heard about/from "enlightened" people. That feeling of non-duality, where you only experience life/energy flowing through everything - animate or inanimate subject/object.
Who or what is doing the seeing or hearing?
This one is very clear, I have had long hard look and I find that there is just seeing and hearing, no one doing it.
Every time I question/feel/contemplate/think about this, I recognize it is a thought appearing and posing as a
question/statement - "who is seeing or hearing this, is it you, Naresh...no it is the eyes and ears doing this, which is then processed by brain..blah blah blah" I observe or recognize the thoughts and after that (numerous times), I look and find that seeing and hearing is just happening. No explanation and no need for one!
...No self is not a State, not a way of being or feeling or thinking; it's merely a Fact...
Thanks Bill, this helps a lot and clears many doubts. My understanding was that no-self is a way of being - like the state I was in for the first few days. I still have that feeling/understanding/deep knowing that there is no "I" or "self", but JUST experience. But as mentioned before, the special experience has faded a bit. Since past few days, I have been looking and I find, that the fear of gaining "I" is just a thought. There is no gaining "I" as there was never any "I" and the "special experience" was just something I had to experience and it is now a memory or thought. In the present moment, I can have thoughts about losing that experience, but they are just that - thoughts. Please correct me if my understanding is wrong.
Please put aside all other teachings, philosophies and such for the remainder of this journey and really just commit to begin looking.
Sorry, no more side business - only looking and experiencing
Start with hearing. Listen to sounds. In DE, is there a "hearer" and "what's being heard", or is there just a sound?
I am listening to the fan noise - and there is just sound. I have started tapping the table and wall and there is just sound and hearing, though they are happening at the exact same time. I can't tell the difference when sound started and when hearing started.
...is there a distinction between "seer" and "seen", or just a sight?
I am rotating my head around and seeing, just seeing. But when I my eyes focus on something, I recognize a thought appearing - "water bottle", "cup", "phone", etc. As soon as this thought appears, there is a simultaneous experience (or maybe thought, hard to tell) that there is seeing and there is this "water bottle", "cup", "phone". Like a subject-object thing. But if I go on looking, I don't find the subject, however object remains.
...Experience is happening now, the story about experience makes it seem that there is an experiencer.
Very well written Bill, I realize or sense the exact same thing. Whenever I look for "Naresh", all I find is a huge flood of thoughts ranging from my childhood to adulthood. Whenever I look for "I", I just find a repeated echo of thought saying "I". It is quite liberating to sit back and feel this - again and again.
...Try with each sense, is there a feeler of sensation separate from the sensed?
I am touching my face and I just feel pressure, slapped myself - just an uncomfortable sensation. Knocking on the table and wall - just sound or hearing (think its the same thing). I am looking around my room - just seeing of objects. A very interesting exercise!
With closed eyes, find out if there is a line between here and there, inside and outside, me and the world. What comes up when you examine that?
When I close my eyes and just look - I see darkness/blackness and space all around, hard to distinguish between inside and outside, it just doesn't make sense. But when I focus my attention or when I think about my arm or leg or head - get an instantaneous feeling of this body and the rest of the world. This is an interesting exercise and I feel the need to do it numerous times to get a more proper understanding.

Cheers
Naresh
The ‘I” casts off the illusion of ‘I’ and yet remains as ‘I’. Such is the paradox of self-realization. The realized do not see any contradiction in it. - Jed McKenna

User avatar
CatBells
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby CatBells » Fri Oct 03, 2014 9:13 pm

Good Evening Naresh

It is like I gained something and now I have lost it. I know it sounds silly, because intellectually I recognize that there is no difference.
A couple how points here Naresh. The first one is that you will never see through this illusion by intellectually working through things. Just use your direct experience.
There was nothing there to be gained in the first place and as such it cannot be lost. It was there all of the time, and still is, and it isn't something that you have to cultivate.

What I would like you to do is to ask yourself how is it specifically that you are putting yourself back into the illusion?
but it is like the old me is back, I am conscious about how I look, what others are thinking about me....In short I find myself body conscious, which is the same feeling I have had for years.
We all get to be as we are. Part of awakening is to realise that that everybody is free to be as they are. Until you have given this freedom to everyone to like or not like you, to love you or hate you, to see things as as you see them or to see things differently, to agree with you or disagree with you - you will never have your freedom and not be fully awake.

Who or what is getting conscious about how you look - where are these thoughts/feelings and what is behind them?

User avatar
Experience
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:03 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby Experience » Sun Oct 05, 2014 3:09 am

What I would like you to do is to ask yourself how is it specifically that you are putting yourself back into the illusion?
When I look for the answer to above question, I find that there are times, when I get lost in a train of thought and after few seconds I realize it is just one thought arguing with the other. I don't understand why. At times I have just sat down, looking at the wall and let the thought amok, accepting or acknowledging whatever comes. Then I find that the train of thought slows down, I feel good. Other times, when I am working, say cooking, cleaning, studying, etc. the thoughts start and after few seconds I realize I had boarded the thought train a few stations ago, now disembarking and wondering why that happens. I take this process as falling back into the illusion. My understanding is once you have realized the truth, you just observe thoughts run across your mind or wherever they come and go from.
We all get to be as we are. Part of awakening is to realize that that everybody is free to be as they are. Until you have given this freedom to everyone to like or not like you, to love you or hate you, to see things as as you see them or to see things differently, to agree with you or disagree with you - you will never have your freedom and not be fully awake.
I like what you wrote, I am going to look into these statements more.
Who or what is getting conscious about how you look - where are these thoughts/feelings and what is behind them?
When I contemplate on the above statement - I find that it is just a thought, which comes up again and again and again in numerous situations. Now when I am looking, I find this clearly and wondering why am I getting caught up in a thought rather then realizing that it is a thought and acknowledging it as such? I need to work on this practically when I go out to Uni and shopping and stuff.

Thanks for your help Bill :-)
The ‘I” casts off the illusion of ‘I’ and yet remains as ‘I’. Such is the paradox of self-realization. The realized do not see any contradiction in it. - Jed McKenna

User avatar
CatBells
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby CatBells » Sun Oct 05, 2014 8:43 pm

Good Evening Naresh

I will await your reply re your experiences on the last couple of points before moving on as they are very important to our path.

Metta
Bill

User avatar
Experience
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:03 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby Experience » Tue Oct 07, 2014 8:54 am

Hi Bill

Few observations:

When I am in a social situation and I get conscious about the body, I understand it is thought which is appearing and over time I get so sucked into it that I don't recognize that a thought has taken ownership of this body and "I" have become that thought so to speak. In other words I start subtly identifying with the thought "how do I look...blah blah", without realizing it is a thought. This is what I found when I looked. That underlying frustration or anxiety is either the thought itself or maybe a feeling arising due to resistance to the thoughts of body image i.e. avoiding these thoughts or justifying them with other thoughts. Few times, I have let these 'body image' thoughts run amok, accept them and observe them and they just pass away!

Also, my final year exams are approaching soon (in 4 weeks) and I find that I am spending a lot of time contemplating about the ultimate truth. Hence, I need to take a break from this, finish my exams and come back during my summer holidays. This means I wouldn't be able to post on LU for 6-7 weeks. I hope that is okay and we can resume the conversation again towards end of November.

Thanks heaps for your help and patience.

Fond Regards
Naresh
The ‘I” casts off the illusion of ‘I’ and yet remains as ‘I’. Such is the paradox of self-realization. The realized do not see any contradiction in it. - Jed McKenna

User avatar
CatBells
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby CatBells » Tue Oct 07, 2014 8:37 pm

Hi Naresh

Of course it is ok to park this for a few weeks and good luck in your exams - I am away for one week end of November/start of December. Please PM me to let me know how you get on with those exams.

Something to look at in that week that I am away was how much identification there was with "I" in your first paragraph on your last post.

With Metta and Best Wishes
Bill

User avatar
Experience
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:03 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby Experience » Wed Oct 08, 2014 10:02 am

Thanks Bill, I will PM you after the exams and look into the "I" identification then.
The ‘I” casts off the illusion of ‘I’ and yet remains as ‘I’. Such is the paradox of self-realization. The realized do not see any contradiction in it. - Jed McKenna

User avatar
CatBells
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Apr 01, 2014 1:25 pm

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby CatBells » Tue Dec 09, 2014 12:24 pm

Good Morning Naresh

Thought I would just check in with you to see how you are and how your exams went plus to see if you wish to pick up on our exploration.

Regards
Bill

User avatar
Experience
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:03 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia

Re: Thread for CatBells

Postby Experience » Wed Dec 10, 2014 12:27 am

Hi Bill

Thanks for the message. I have PMd you regarding certain developments.

Kind Regards
Naresh
The ‘I” casts off the illusion of ‘I’ and yet remains as ‘I’. Such is the paradox of self-realization. The realized do not see any contradiction in it. - Jed McKenna


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Jeffelan and 24 guests