Blindsided
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Ok, then I think we share the same perspective. Although it leaves me a bit puzzled why both websites each claim to have found the key to liberation, and each claim to be the only one doing this.
Anyway the thing is, I've been paying attention to experience that would otherwise be mostly subconscious for well over a year in the form of various types of meditation, and it certainly has affected my life for the better. But no liberation (which I wasn't really expecting so soon until I found out about RT). So then I've been working with RT pretty much full time for two weeks, more looking at experience that would otherwise be mostly subconscious, with the added focus on seeing if/how it fits together without the assumed I.
Now I'm convinced that your (and their) approach can work, but so far it hasn't worked for me. I take this to mean that I haven't been looking where I needed to look, or not in the right way, or whatever. But like I said, both myself and the people at RT appear to be running out of suggestions quickly, and repeating the same thing over and over again has not changed anything. I'm hoping to skip to the part where we find out what has been lacking so far, because if I have to do the same (wrong) thing for another two weeks I'll go nuts.
Anyway the thing is, I've been paying attention to experience that would otherwise be mostly subconscious for well over a year in the form of various types of meditation, and it certainly has affected my life for the better. But no liberation (which I wasn't really expecting so soon until I found out about RT). So then I've been working with RT pretty much full time for two weeks, more looking at experience that would otherwise be mostly subconscious, with the added focus on seeing if/how it fits together without the assumed I.
Now I'm convinced that your (and their) approach can work, but so far it hasn't worked for me. I take this to mean that I haven't been looking where I needed to look, or not in the right way, or whatever. But like I said, both myself and the people at RT appear to be running out of suggestions quickly, and repeating the same thing over and over again has not changed anything. I'm hoping to skip to the part where we find out what has been lacking so far, because if I have to do the same (wrong) thing for another two weeks I'll go nuts.
- Garsius Tyla
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:48 pm
Re: Blindsided
Frustration. Good. Take it closer and be with that feeling.
Is that feeling YOU?
What is behind it? Any entity, which sprout that feeling? Look.
Is that feeling YOU?
What is behind it? Any entity, which sprout that feeling? Look.
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Right so that's exactly what phi told me to look at in his first post to this thread. Well I've felt frustrated on and off about this for the last two weeks. I'm not sure what I'm looking at other than the aforementioned physical and mental phenomena, but somehow it can become very gripping. And no there's no entity somewhere getting gripped, it's just this body and mind doing the gripping. Sometimes looking at it makes it subside a bit, but it comes back at some point. And sometimes it doesn't subside at all. Of course the point is not to make it go away by looking, I'm aware of that. And I'm also aware that there is no entity doing the looking. But none of this has made any difference so far.
- Garsius Tyla
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:48 pm
Re: Blindsided
Lets cut that to pieces, ok?
There is frustration.
There is frustration about frustration, right?
There is no you, who can be frustrated?
There is no choice to be frustrated, or not be?
Now:
There is seeking for liberation
Who and from what there can be liberation?
Can you gain anything?
Or can you lose anything?
Investigate yourself on every question.
There is frustration.
There is frustration about frustration, right?
There is no you, who can be frustrated?
There is no choice to be frustrated, or not be?
Now:
There is seeking for liberation
Who and from what there can be liberation?
Can you gain anything?
Or can you lose anything?
Investigate yourself on every question.
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Yes.Lets cut that to pieces, ok?
There is frustration.
There is frustration about frustration, right?
Not me, only this human.There is no you, who can be frustrated?
No choice.There is no choice to be frustrated, or not be?
Not me, only this human.Now:
There is seeking for liberation
Who and from what there can be liberation?
Not me, only this human.Can you gain anything?
Not me, only this human.Or can you lose anything?
I don't know how.Investigate yourself on every question.
- Garsius Tyla
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:48 pm
Re: Blindsided
By saying:
Look:
what THIS "human" is?
body
thoughts
moods
emotions
feelings
awareness
sense of self
what else?
So when saying:
you are not honest with yourself. Let' say you are "closing your eyes" and not looking.Not me, only this human.
Look:
what THIS "human" is?
body
thoughts
moods
emotions
feelings
awareness
sense of self
what else?
So when saying:
to which part in that bunch of things, with label "human", you are relating your answers?Not me, only this human.
Re: Blindsided
Garsius Tyla is doing an excellent job helping you break down the experience, so I'm not going to interfere with that part of the conversation.
What I want to tell you, though, is that the process of becoming free is ALWAYS full of frustration, being fed up, feeling like you can't do it anymore (in two ways: you feel you are somehow incompetent and are never going to crack this; and you also feel you just can't take any more of whatever investigative method it is you are using). These are all signs of progress. I'm not BSing you here. They are genuine indicators that you are progressing toward insight into non-self. The most important piece of advice for this stage, regardless of which method you are using, is to keep doing what you have been doing. Your method has gotten you this far, which means it works. Now you just need to stick with it, against your instincts telling you to quit. I know whatever method you are practicing, it is not nearly as pleasant as it used to be. I know it feels like you are not making any progress. I know this because it was exactly the same way for me, in the weeks leading up to the insight.
What I want to tell you, though, is that the process of becoming free is ALWAYS full of frustration, being fed up, feeling like you can't do it anymore (in two ways: you feel you are somehow incompetent and are never going to crack this; and you also feel you just can't take any more of whatever investigative method it is you are using). These are all signs of progress. I'm not BSing you here. They are genuine indicators that you are progressing toward insight into non-self. The most important piece of advice for this stage, regardless of which method you are using, is to keep doing what you have been doing. Your method has gotten you this far, which means it works. Now you just need to stick with it, against your instincts telling you to quit. I know whatever method you are practicing, it is not nearly as pleasant as it used to be. I know it feels like you are not making any progress. I know this because it was exactly the same way for me, in the weeks leading up to the insight.
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Yeah, I understand this as part of pretty much any worthwhile meditation practice. But what those guys over at RT keep saying (and which makes sense to me, and I've also seen the conversation between Elena and that Theravada monk for example, as well as other threads on this forum here and at RT) - is that all it takes is just one honest look. That it can be over in 10 minutes or 10 seconds in principle, the only delay is in getting to the point where you're actually looking. Now maybe that's mostly an ideal situation, although again all the examples I've seen so far (and I mean all of them) are more or less like that.Garsius Tyla is doing an excellent job helping you break down the experience, so I'm not going to interfere with that part of the conversation.
What I want to tell you, though, is that the process of becoming free is ALWAYS full of frustration, being fed up, feeling like you can't do it anymore (in two ways: you feel you are somehow incompetent and are never going to crack this; and you also feel you just can't take any more of whatever investigative method it is you are using). These are all signs of progress. I'm not BSing you here. They are genuine indicators that you are progressing toward insight into non-self. The most important piece of advice for this stage, regardless of which method you are using, is to keep doing what you have been doing. Your method has gotten you this far, which means it works. Now you just need to stick with it, against your instincts telling you to quit. I know whatever method you are practicing, it is not nearly as pleasant as it used to be. I know it feels like you are not making any progress. I know this because it was exactly the same way for me, in the weeks leading up to the insight.
And over at RT where I'm trying to tell them something isn't working as it's supposed to in my case, I'm being told that I'm full of crap and that I'm just not engaging honestly. And he's right, I'm not engaging in the same thing over and over again anymore, after two weeks of it having produced absolutely nothing, and all the while having him throwing the same old assumptions at me about why he thinks it's not working. Now I don't care if I'm told that I'm full of crap or that I should take responsibility and stop behaving like a child, I can take that fine and I know my flaws well enough. But when there's only a one-way communication going on and my feedback isn't taken seriously then yeah that's what pisses me off.
So anyway I apologize for my mood here, and I thank you for your efforts (and also the guys at RT, don't get me wrong). It hasn't been like this for all these two weeks, but right now I just seem to be coming back down like a brick.
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
To your question: "There is no you, who can be frustrated?" - My answer referred to the fact that frustration is a human emotion, it occurs as part of those processes that make up a human, deluded or not.you are not honest with yourself. Let' say you are "closing your eyes" and not looking.
Look:
what THIS "human" is?
body
thoughts
moods
emotions
feelings
awareness
sense of self
what else?
So when saying:to which part in that bunch of things, with label "human", you are relating your answers?Not me, only this human.
To your question: "Who and from what there can be liberation?" - My answer referred to the fact that the mind/brain of this human can be shown that the self it believes in does not exist.
To your question: "Can you gain anything?" - My answer referred to the fact that this human mind can gain freedom from that false belief.
To your question: "Or can you lose anything?" - My answer referred to the fact that this human mind can lose attachment to that false belief.
The fact that "human" is only a concept which in reality refers only to a bunch of conditioned phenomena that operate as part of, and integral to, the larger whole of the universe, does not take away from those answers. If we're taking the viewpoint that there is nothing to gain here, then I should leave.
Re: Blindsided
I agree that communication can't always just be one-way. However, and this is a big one, going around in circles is what it often feels like, even if you are making progress, and that is normal. So if someone keeps bombarding you with the same ideas over and over again, this can actually work just like a good meditation practice, in which your instructions don't really change all that much. You think you have been doing the same thing for weeks, and you have, but you're still making progress, and eventually, it all comes together.
Add to that the fact that on RT they are very fond of "engaging" seekers (i.e. getting them worked up so they don't lose interest), and you have a recipe for a person honestly trying to help you by badgering you with the same words over and over again. This works better for some people than others, but it is definitely a worthwhile approach, so don't dismiss it just because it has not produced any noticeable results yet.
Regarding the question whether all it takes is a few seconds of looking at reality the right way or you need to work at it for months, I like to liken this to the needle in a haystack. If you have already heard me say this, you can skip the rest of this post.
Anyway, seeing reality as it is is very much like finding a needle in a haystack. All you need is to look through that one little bit of hay that contains the needle. You don't need any preparation; you don't need practice; there is no special technique you need to master. You can walk up to the haystack, pick out the needle, and you're done. However, does that mean you can expect to just walk up to they haystack and pick out the needle? Of course not. Depending on circumstances beyond your control, it may take minutes or weeks.
The method I was taught is a little bit like just taking a handful of hay, looking through it, then throwing it out and taking the next handful. It usually takes months, just like it would with a real haystack, but it's unlikely to take more than a couple of years. Think about it, though: What gets you the result is not changing your technique or becoming a more competent investigator. It's really just persistence.
The method on this website is more like using a metal detector, albeit a crude one: We still can't just point out the needle for you and present it to you on a silver pladder, but we can use words (which are not an excellent, but a fair means of communicating the necessary information) to tell you in which general direction to go to find the needle. It will be faster, but it still won't usually happen right away.
Add to that the fact that on RT they are very fond of "engaging" seekers (i.e. getting them worked up so they don't lose interest), and you have a recipe for a person honestly trying to help you by badgering you with the same words over and over again. This works better for some people than others, but it is definitely a worthwhile approach, so don't dismiss it just because it has not produced any noticeable results yet.
Regarding the question whether all it takes is a few seconds of looking at reality the right way or you need to work at it for months, I like to liken this to the needle in a haystack. If you have already heard me say this, you can skip the rest of this post.
Anyway, seeing reality as it is is very much like finding a needle in a haystack. All you need is to look through that one little bit of hay that contains the needle. You don't need any preparation; you don't need practice; there is no special technique you need to master. You can walk up to the haystack, pick out the needle, and you're done. However, does that mean you can expect to just walk up to they haystack and pick out the needle? Of course not. Depending on circumstances beyond your control, it may take minutes or weeks.
The method I was taught is a little bit like just taking a handful of hay, looking through it, then throwing it out and taking the next handful. It usually takes months, just like it would with a real haystack, but it's unlikely to take more than a couple of years. Think about it, though: What gets you the result is not changing your technique or becoming a more competent investigator. It's really just persistence.
The method on this website is more like using a metal detector, albeit a crude one: We still can't just point out the needle for you and present it to you on a silver pladder, but we can use words (which are not an excellent, but a fair means of communicating the necessary information) to tell you in which general direction to go to find the needle. It will be faster, but it still won't usually happen right away.
- Garsius Tyla
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:48 pm
Re: Blindsided
There is no mind. "Mind" is the same label as "human", as "I". Look and write down for what this label are used?
To your question: "Can you gain anything?" - My answer referred to the fact that this human mind can gain freedom from that false belief.
To your question: "Or can you lose anything?" - My answer referred to the fact that this human mind can lose attachment to that false belief.
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Garsius, I know there is no mind, it's also just a bunch of impersonal natural processes coming together just like the rest of human and everything else. So what. You asked, I answered, and all the distinguishing between name and form doesn't make one damn bit of difference. If you're going to expect an answer from me on a textual medium, you're going to expect them in dualistic terms. Don't beat me over the head with them, I don't need any more education in that.
Phi, I get that, I get the various views on enlightenment developing over time or being instantaneous and either you have it or you don't, and even the view that everyone is already enlightened or there's no such thing as enlightenment. I get that, and I get how that's all referring to the same reality. And I'm not dismissing the approach of RT and this place, like I said before I'm convinced it can work.
But anyway for me this is turning out to be just more meditation, and I can do that fine on my own without getting worked up on some forum about it. I'm glad to have learned about these sites and what you've discovered to be central to the whole thing, insofar as it wasn't old news. I'll take that with me in my practice as best I can, on and off the cushion.
Bye guys, all the best.
Sincerely,
Mark
Phi, I get that, I get the various views on enlightenment developing over time or being instantaneous and either you have it or you don't, and even the view that everyone is already enlightened or there's no such thing as enlightenment. I get that, and I get how that's all referring to the same reality. And I'm not dismissing the approach of RT and this place, like I said before I'm convinced it can work.
But anyway for me this is turning out to be just more meditation, and I can do that fine on my own without getting worked up on some forum about it. I'm glad to have learned about these sites and what you've discovered to be central to the whole thing, insofar as it wasn't old news. I'll take that with me in my practice as best I can, on and off the cushion.
Bye guys, all the best.
Sincerely,
Mark
Re: Blindsided
before you go..
this is not about meditation, but honest look. once. tha's all.
all you need to do is want it. more than anything and no matter what.
If you reach for truth, the truth will find you and set "you" free. then you can go back to meditation and stop seeking for whatever you are trying to find. so it's your call.
you can leave, or you can stand here, open a thread on one-on-one section, call somebody up an finish it.
it really is simple.
and nothing required.
this is not about meditation, but honest look. once. tha's all.
all you need to do is want it. more than anything and no matter what.
If you reach for truth, the truth will find you and set "you" free. then you can go back to meditation and stop seeking for whatever you are trying to find. so it's your call.
you can leave, or you can stand here, open a thread on one-on-one section, call somebody up an finish it.
it really is simple.
and nothing required.
See for yourself.
8-week guided self-inquiry experience → https://ilonaciunaite.com/8-week-program/
8-week guided self-inquiry experience → https://ilonaciunaite.com/8-week-program/
- Pratityasamutpada
- Posts: 95
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:40 pm
Re: Blindsided
Ilona, I just don't seem to know how to do it. On RT I've had a general thread, I've had a public one-on-one, and I've had a private one-on-one. I'm unemployed at the moment so I've been able to spend almost all my time on this for two weeks, observing experience from the moment I wake up to the moment I fall asleep. I'm sure it's really simple, like whistling or flaring your nostrils, but some people just seem to be stumbling in the darkness and miss the obvious, like me as it turns out. How do you convey to them what they have to do, over the internet, if the verbal pointing somehow doesn't catch on? Also how do I pull through those moments when everything suddenly seems just utterly pointless and I don't even know what to do with myself anymore.
Re: Blindsided
of course it feels hopeless. it's ok, and it's pointles too. yes. but for now allow that to be here.
i can show you the way..
we can do it here. i'll ask some questions, you look for answers and then you pop. i mean popping happens. The looking-seeing is happening already. that's how you are still here.
firstly, what do you notice when you hold this thought:
there is no separate entities at all in real life. as in zero.
can you just watch what is going on inside: thoughs-feelings, write it all here.
i can show you the way..
we can do it here. i'll ask some questions, you look for answers and then you pop. i mean popping happens. The looking-seeing is happening already. that's how you are still here.
firstly, what do you notice when you hold this thought:
there is no separate entities at all in real life. as in zero.
can you just watch what is going on inside: thoughs-feelings, write it all here.
See for yourself.
8-week guided self-inquiry experience → https://ilonaciunaite.com/8-week-program/
8-week guided self-inquiry experience → https://ilonaciunaite.com/8-week-program/
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests

