New to This -help needed
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
I suppose by the ego I mean the sense of self-the little man/woman in the head.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Ok, that's clear. Good.
Now let's find out.
Is a human being born with a sense of self?
Now let's find out.
Is a human being born with a sense of self?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Well my understanding is they are not. A baby thinks you have come into its world. Is that a sense of self? Then the "mine " mentality evolves. Thats my understanding of child psychology. A baby sees everything as part of its world until a sense of separateness develops and from there the "I" evolves.
But while I think the above is important I'm concentrating on just working out whether this sense of self is false. Just focusing as you advised on the experience rather than the intellect. Its scary but liberating.
But while I think the above is important I'm concentrating on just working out whether this sense of self is false. Just focusing as you advised on the experience rather than the intellect. Its scary but liberating.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Yes, it's not going to do much good at this point speculating on the exact details of the formation of the self-sense, yet this simple observation alone should be sufficient to make it clear that this sense of self is a construct- that doesn't necessarily make it "false" (it is, after all a REAL sense), but it makes it clear that it doesn't necessarily refer to an actual separate self.But while I think the above is important I'm concentrating on just working out whether this sense of self is false. Just focusing as you advised on the experience rather than the intellect. Its scary but liberating.
Now the idea is emphatically NOT to get back to this infantile state where there is no sense of self yet, nor is it to get rid of this sense of self (it is, in fact, quite practical in certain situations), but to thoroughly and completely see how there is never an actual separation in life, despite the sense that suggests that there is. This is not about becoming selfless or dropping the ego. There never was a self to begin with.
So, this notion of the ego or self taking root. Examine that.
Has a self actually ever taken root?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
"So, this notion of the ego or self taking root. Examine that.
Has a self actually ever taken root?"
Can you run through how to show a quote. This is driving me nuts!
A self which does not really exist cant take root. Thats my understanding. Perhaps its a trick of perception?
You mentioned a sense of self can be useful in certain situations. What did you mean by that ? How can a sense of something that is false be useful?
Am I right in thinking that many negative and indeed positive feelings we have about ourselves are all creations of the ego?
Has a self actually ever taken root?"
Can you run through how to show a quote. This is driving me nuts!
A self which does not really exist cant take root. Thats my understanding. Perhaps its a trick of perception?
You mentioned a sense of self can be useful in certain situations. What did you mean by that ? How can a sense of something that is false be useful?
Am I right in thinking that many negative and indeed positive feelings we have about ourselves are all creations of the ego?
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Sure.Can you run through how to show a quote. This is driving me nuts!
Step one: select the text to quote:

Step two: press the "Quote" button above the text edit field:

That's it.
--------------------
Yes!!! So what then does a feeling or thought of "being in the ego" or something similar really mean? What state-of-affairs does it point to?A self which does not really exist cant take root. Thats my understanding. Perhaps its a trick of perception?
When I'm chopping onions for dinner for example, the illusory separation between "me" and the onion is quite useful... but there are more, less trivial examples, I'm sure you see how the sense of self has its purpose in the way our lives have been constructed.You mentioned a sense of self can be useful in certain situations. What did you mean by that ? How can a sense of something that is false be useful?
Like I mentioned several times already- this process is not about dropping the sense of self, "getting rid of the evil ego" or any such thing- it's about finally, deeply recognizing what is true and what isn't.
Not sure what you mean by that exactly. What's being asked here?Am I right in thinking that many negative and indeed positive feelings we have about ourselves are all creations of the ego?
If there is in fact no self, how can that self create anything?
How does this question relate to your experience- look for yourself. These many negative and positive feelings about yourself. What is the self to which these feelings refer? Does that self have any actual existence?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
There is no self that it refers to. At least I feel strongly it doesnt! It make sense on a very very practical level-a random set of memories,narratives and interpretation is not a thing. A reality. Yet we carry on as if it is If I can step outside myself see the patterns and observe me while speaking then I can surely see there are only words coming out of a body not out of a little man up there.How does this question relate to your experience- look for yourself. These many negative and positive feelings about yourself. What is the self to which these feelings refer? Does that self have any actual existence?
I tend to give myself very negative self talk but in reality there is no self to talk to. There is just actions/moments. "I" can judge a situation without the fear of how this will make me look-because there is no self to be affected but I have to keep in mind those around me still see themselves as separate.
I just need to practice this. The doubts are just the shock of the realisation.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Spot on, well-put!There is no self that it refers to. At least I feel strongly it doesnt! It make sense on a very very practical level-a random set of memories,narratives and interpretation is not a thing. A reality. Yet we carry on as if it is
Seems you have really seen the emptiness of the character-self, the imagined person.
That's step one.
Are you ready for step two?
If I can step outside myself see the patterns and observe me while speaking then I can surely see there are only words coming out of a body not out of a little man up there.
I" can judge a situation without the fear of how this will make me look-because there is no self to be affected but I have to keep in mind those around me still see themselves as separate.
Now the character-self has been seen to have always been illusory- a story, let's take a look at that other, subtler, self that has suddenly entered the story. The self that can apparently step outside, judge, observe, see, practice non-separation.I just need to practice this.
That notion of self I usually refer to as the Observer and it is in many cases, the final illusion to be seen through.
Can you see how "stepping out of yourself", "judging situations" etc. is simply a more subtle form of the same story of me? From a concrete person the you has now changed into an ephemeral, detached observer.
Still considered to be somehow separate from what is happening.
In reality- there never was any separation, just the mistaken idea that there ever was.
There is no self to practice no self.
No self to practise non-separation.
See?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
I do see but Anthony De Mello whom I have read quite a bit talks about this observer but must read that bit again. If there is no observer then how do we judge what is right or wrong or any judgement? Whats our point of reference?
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Who cares what Anthony De Mello thinks about the observer? Seriously. How about relying on your own experience instead of borrowed book-knowledge?I do see but Anthony De Mello whom I have read quite a bit talks about this observer but must read that bit again.
Does the occurence of the thought "this is wrong" require an observer to exist?If there is no observer then how do we judge what is right or wrong or any judgement? Whats our point of reference?
Does the occurence of the thought "this is right" require an observer to exist?
Point of reference? How do you see morality functions?
Right now, in your experience- if the jugdgment "this is wrong" occurs- how does this work, where does the judgement come from, really? Where does ANY judgement come from, for that matter?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Could you explain what you mean by morality functions?Point of reference? How do you see morality functions?
Morality would still exist but in fairness that is based on societal influences and experience. Now both these things are still present in experience even if they are not personally attached ie because there is no self I cant really say 'in my experience' but I can use experiences.
Does that make sense?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
There still is judgement . We still must make moral decisions and decisions can still be moral-even when one accepts no self. Otherwise as noted earlier in the thread I could rob a bank and claim nobody did it!
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Sorry, that was awkwardly formulated- what I meant to ask is simply: how does morality operate? How do judgements form? I think you already found the answer though:Could you explain what you mean by morality functions?
Yes, that makes sense, although I'm getting the feeling you're trying to convince yourself here.Morality would still exist but in fairness that is based on societal influences and experience. Now both these things are still present in experience even if they are not personally attached ie because there is no self I cant really say 'in my experience' but I can use experiences.
Does that make sense?
Remember: this is not about taking a specific perspective or attitude, it is simply a constant invitation to look at what is actually already the case right now.
Yes, judgement happens, obviously. Yet where is the judge?There still is judgement .
We?We still must make moral decisions and decisions can still be moral-even when one accepts no self.
Here it seems like you're trying to match an idea of some kind of 'no-self theory' with a belief in the necessity of morality. Stop doing that. Stop theorizing and look at what is right in front of you at this very moment, man!
There is no self.
None at all.
Nothing separate from this- this- THIS!!!
What is happening right now- this is it- nothing separate from that at all.
Utterly impossible.
You see? No separation possible at all. Just this.
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Thanks for that back in a few days. Struggling with a bit of the blues which I know are false as they are a tale told my no one but just need a break. Need to cocentrate on the experience
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Sure, take care.
;-)
Nope, these blues are real blues, they're just not yours. Just happening, as everything else.struggling with a bit of the blues which I know are false as they are a tale told my no one
;-)
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Elad, Majestic-12 [Bot], Semrush [Bot] and 17 guests

