Page 1 of 3

Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 9:35 pm
by JoshOz
Experienced seeker (and finder) of conceptual liberation seeks the end of conceptual seeing.
Direct seeing without the concept of direct seeing. Freedom.
It seems that the 'I' that tries to look, wants to achieve that liberation is a concept itself and cannot lift itself out of the swamp.
Still the experience of 'I' and being bound goes on. Or does it really?
Josh

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 9:49 pm
by StepVheN
It sounds like you know exactly what you want. Exactly what it looks and feels like. Exactly how liberation works.

Which is strange, because you're not liberated.

Better question than the one you ended on.

Is it right now? This very second?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 10:07 pm
by JoshOz
Thanks for replying to my post!
This very second is too quick for anything to 'go on'. Actually when I read the question, the immediate answer is wordless, like a flash of nothing.
I phrased the question the way I did because conceptually I seem to 'know how liberation works' but that does not quite cut the mustard. I'm quite happy to follow your line of inquiry as if nothing has ever come before.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 10:47 pm
by StepVheN
Well we'll give that a go then.

How do you know that there is a self?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:12 pm
by JoshOz
I don't really know there is a self. I know I exist. I know there are experiences that seem to refer to some type of individuality. Like I experience my body, not yours. I know that I exist but what that I is, I do not know.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:29 pm
by StepVheN
I don't really know there is a self. I know I exist. I know there are experiences that seem to refer to some type of individuality. Like I experience my body, not yours. I know that I exist but what that I is, I do not know.
Individuality. Perfect. There is definitely individuality. We can observe that. There's good evidence for it. In that I'm interacting with something (you) that I am not able to will into action as it seems I can of myself.

You experience your own individual life, not mine. But, where is the you experiencing that life? Is there one? Where is the evidence for one?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2012 11:52 pm
by JoshOz
The immediate answer to your question is: No. I can't find any me. There is no evidence for a continuous me. There seems to be a sense of me, an almost physical sense of me, trying to understand, looking for pleasure and avoiding pain, looking for an advantage for itself. This is not there all the time but there is a sense that it is potentially there all the time.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 6:00 pm
by StepVheN
What is it that has that physical sense. It must belong to you, if you exist. You're obviously not that fleeting sense. You don't experience what it is to be that fleeting sense, you have a looking in view of it. Where is the self that has that looking in view?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2012 11:10 pm
by JoshOz
When I try to look for that self, I get glimpses of seeing that it is not there at all, and my thinking starts to freak out, like it is afraid to die, resisting that. I've been sticking with this for a while now, it comes in waves, looking for that self, touching what seems to be a void, feeling of being pulled in, thoughts, resisting, looking again.
I see the tendency to dramatise this 'process' as well. Also a way to hang on to identity.
Back to the question. Where is the self that has that looking in view? Darkness. Nothingness. But also peaceful, even joyful.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 1:35 am
by StepVheN
When I try to look for that self, I get glimpses of seeing that it is not there at all, and my thinking starts to freak out, like it is afraid to die, resisting that. I've been sticking with this for a while now,
It isn't working for you then, look at this on a simpler level. Don't try and look specifically for a self this time just look and see what is actually there.
it comes in waves, looking for that self, touching what seems to be a void, feeling of being pulled in, thoughts, resisting, looking again.
Drop it. Look at what is there.
I see the tendency to dramatise this 'process' as well. Also a way to hang on to identity.
Back to the question. Where is the self that has that looking in view? Darkness. Nothingness. But also peaceful, even joyful.
It doesn't matter. Dramatize it all you like there's still no you regardless, the drama is inconsequential. The peaceful/joyful thing is a matter of opinion

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 12:03 pm
by JoshOz
what is actually there (here) is being aware, of an ever changing array of impressions, body sensations, thoughts.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 5:02 pm
by StepVheN
No. You are not being honest here. You are giving me some kind of per learned, one size fits all story. Maybe you think hat is the same as paying attention to your reality. It's not. It's not good enough it won't get you anywhere. I want you to describe in as simple and natural everyday terms as you can just what you are experiencing. No mysticism. No joyful surrender. No excess just simple everyday down to earth language to describe reality as you experience. Do you see a self? Do you smell feel or hear a self? Do you see the absence where self should be?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Sat Jun 09, 2012 8:46 pm
by JoshOz
I'm sitting in front of this screen, I feel the warmth of my body, I hear my fingers typing, I am thinking about what I'm writing, I am seeing these words, I see the rest of the room and outside in the background, I hear vague sounds in the distance, I feel my breath, I feel my body tingling, I taste my mouth, that's it. I do not see, feel or hear a self, all I feel are sensations and thoughts. I do not see a self. I see thinking about a self, looking to see if I see the absence you talk about. If I look I don't see anything.

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2012 12:24 am
by StepVheN
So where does the self come into this? Where do you sense the self if at all?

Re: Seeking the end of conceptual liberation and bondage

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2012 12:24 am
by StepVheN
What about the self?