Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Posted: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:13 am
What brings you to Liberation Unleashed?
I think I've always been seeking a much richer experience of life than what mainstream U.S. culture provides. At the same time, it seems very likely that what's driven this has been my suffering from depression. Early philosophical and cultural studies led to a literary encounter with eastern wisdom, which has since resonated with me. I have started and stopped the associated practices (yoga, meditation, etc.) many times over the years, never practicing for very long at any time. My friend introduced me somewhat recently to some modern thinkers who were publicly challenging and criticizing the many iterations of religious dogmatism. One such thinker's name is Sam Harris. He is a philosopher, a neuroscientist and an experienced meditator. Pretty recently he published a book titled, "Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion". In it, among other things, he discusses the benefits of practicing mindfulness and explains how through philosophical investigation one must conclude that what we think of as our self does not exist. He also briefly though respectfully looks at the spiritual experiences that have been accessed consistently through "psychedelics" or "hallucinogens or "entheogens". This is important for me, as I cannot overestimate how compelling such experiences are to me. This realization that the self does not exist, Sam says, is highly spiritually significant. The philosophical justification came, I believe, long after his experience of Direct Pointing from Tulku Urgyen. Basically, Sam said get a pointer, so I'm here to get a pointer. Finally, the person who most fully explains the world for me is Marshall McLuhan, and he notices that with our new media environment we will find eastern wisdom to be more and more important in navigating our experience. So it's good to have that justification too, as well as the sense that the highly typical eastern wisdom spiritual quest doesn't have a monopoly on truth.
What are you looking for? What do you expect from this?
I am looking for truth, spirituality, peace on earth and in my life, etc. I would have always planned to evaluate an idea and activity like no-self whenever I'd heard of it and pursue it in the spirit of understanding, in the spirit of all the noble or more fundamental aspects of life and the world, exploration of the mind. But I am here because I am devastated by depression. It has generally ruled me completely. I can stay stable and not freaking out and wanting to go to the hospital the past two days by setting myself about the task of finding relief for what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally. The psychiatric aspect of it I've learned to leave to my psychiatrists recently...what a mess! How many variables to consider! And plus, it's far out of my reach in the first place, with all the medical training required to build understanding.
I again started practicing mindfulness about 2 weeks ago, and this was just the latest in the seemingly hundreds of defenses I've tried to protect myself from complete demoralization and psychological torture by the predictable and spontaneous occurrences of overwhelming negativity in thought and emotion that have visited me throughout my every day for the last 17 years. The preceding sentence includes "what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally" and my strategy for "finding relief" from this. After mindfulness lost the battle in a matter of 3-4 days like all the rest, I knew I had to start asking others for their ideas for defenses because, apart from this liberation that has yet to work for me, I couldn't imagine a defense better suited to help me navigate this negativity. So I'm exploring more of my talk therapist's suggestions, I'm searching the net for ideas, and I'm trying this again.
Now you know what I'm looking for, the following is what I expect. I expect to be able to practice mindfulness with rock-solid grounding and confidence that "I" am NOT my thoughts, sensations, emotions, etc., even as my abilities are very modest. I expect that this will eventually put an end to my spending my life overwhelmed despite being apparently free of crisis. To not be all throughout every day overwhelmed by despair, devastation, suicidality, jealousy, bitterness, un-word-able distress, hopelessness/helplessness, etc. I’m not expecting immunity from these to arrive instantly and never go away. I hope that with liberation the cause of the overwhelming will become extinct, even if gradually, and so I will no longer need the unknown impenetrable defense I’m seeking. That said, I, as completely as I can, understand the following quotes from the website and believe that my motivations and expectations are in line with them.
Liberation Unleashed is not…
going to lead you to eternal peace and happiness, it is not about happiness.
about freedom from emotions and intense feelings.
getting rid of self, ego, I.
a way to get free of depression or other diseases.
FAQ’s
I am depressed and anxious. Will liberation help me?
Liberation is not a cure for physical or mental disorders. Seeing through the illusion of self is an important step in seeing through the stories that fuel depression and anxiousness, which both derive from that same self illusion.
Will I never suffer again?
The answer depends on how we define suffering. If you hope to enter a life of unending bliss and only happy feelings, you’re going to be disappointed. Life will go on as before. All sorts of emotions will continue to arise. Yet, without the concept of a central self to stick to, how can there truly be suffering?
What is next?
Seeing self for what it really is – a story – does not mean that your life is suddenly upgraded in every conceivable way. Old habits, beliefs, programming and conditioning will very probably remain in place. Awakening from the story of you allows old patterns to drop away quickly. The foundation upon which these patterns were based is gone.
What is your background in terms of seeking and inquiry?
I'm kind of unclear on what all exactly happened, but I have a thorough enough idea I think. I first heard of this truth by reading Sam Harris’ book “Waking Up”. I probably listened to a youtube video or two after reading that. Then at some point after that I found no-self.com. I read their explanation and I talked with Mike. I read Butterflies are Free to Fly at their instruction (I think). Then I came upon Liberation Unleashed. I registered and got a pointer named Cody J. Dennis. That conversation is on the forum under my then-username blackfoot332. This was in June 2015. The liberation didn’t happen, I got frustrated and stopped replying, but I’ve since kept no-self on my mind, very much, as an eventual priority in my life, a next step in spirituality. I’ve continued to struggle with depression, and after finding even the defense against negativity that mindfulness could offer to be insufficient, I have decided to make this a priority again. I wrote a couple paragraph-long post when I came back and thought Cody might still be around that lays out a few aspects of my current frustrations with this process and his suggestions. But why go into all that? You’ll have your own style and we’ll be working with that one not Cody’s, and any other complaints or questions will come up as need be in our exploration. Also, I dig it conceptually/intellectually, but that’s totally irrelevant as I understand.
How ready are you to question your beliefs about who you are and see the truth no matter what?
11
I think I've always been seeking a much richer experience of life than what mainstream U.S. culture provides. At the same time, it seems very likely that what's driven this has been my suffering from depression. Early philosophical and cultural studies led to a literary encounter with eastern wisdom, which has since resonated with me. I have started and stopped the associated practices (yoga, meditation, etc.) many times over the years, never practicing for very long at any time. My friend introduced me somewhat recently to some modern thinkers who were publicly challenging and criticizing the many iterations of religious dogmatism. One such thinker's name is Sam Harris. He is a philosopher, a neuroscientist and an experienced meditator. Pretty recently he published a book titled, "Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion". In it, among other things, he discusses the benefits of practicing mindfulness and explains how through philosophical investigation one must conclude that what we think of as our self does not exist. He also briefly though respectfully looks at the spiritual experiences that have been accessed consistently through "psychedelics" or "hallucinogens or "entheogens". This is important for me, as I cannot overestimate how compelling such experiences are to me. This realization that the self does not exist, Sam says, is highly spiritually significant. The philosophical justification came, I believe, long after his experience of Direct Pointing from Tulku Urgyen. Basically, Sam said get a pointer, so I'm here to get a pointer. Finally, the person who most fully explains the world for me is Marshall McLuhan, and he notices that with our new media environment we will find eastern wisdom to be more and more important in navigating our experience. So it's good to have that justification too, as well as the sense that the highly typical eastern wisdom spiritual quest doesn't have a monopoly on truth.
What are you looking for? What do you expect from this?
I am looking for truth, spirituality, peace on earth and in my life, etc. I would have always planned to evaluate an idea and activity like no-self whenever I'd heard of it and pursue it in the spirit of understanding, in the spirit of all the noble or more fundamental aspects of life and the world, exploration of the mind. But I am here because I am devastated by depression. It has generally ruled me completely. I can stay stable and not freaking out and wanting to go to the hospital the past two days by setting myself about the task of finding relief for what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally. The psychiatric aspect of it I've learned to leave to my psychiatrists recently...what a mess! How many variables to consider! And plus, it's far out of my reach in the first place, with all the medical training required to build understanding.
I again started practicing mindfulness about 2 weeks ago, and this was just the latest in the seemingly hundreds of defenses I've tried to protect myself from complete demoralization and psychological torture by the predictable and spontaneous occurrences of overwhelming negativity in thought and emotion that have visited me throughout my every day for the last 17 years. The preceding sentence includes "what I think troubles/disables me behaviorally" and my strategy for "finding relief" from this. After mindfulness lost the battle in a matter of 3-4 days like all the rest, I knew I had to start asking others for their ideas for defenses because, apart from this liberation that has yet to work for me, I couldn't imagine a defense better suited to help me navigate this negativity. So I'm exploring more of my talk therapist's suggestions, I'm searching the net for ideas, and I'm trying this again.
Now you know what I'm looking for, the following is what I expect. I expect to be able to practice mindfulness with rock-solid grounding and confidence that "I" am NOT my thoughts, sensations, emotions, etc., even as my abilities are very modest. I expect that this will eventually put an end to my spending my life overwhelmed despite being apparently free of crisis. To not be all throughout every day overwhelmed by despair, devastation, suicidality, jealousy, bitterness, un-word-able distress, hopelessness/helplessness, etc. I’m not expecting immunity from these to arrive instantly and never go away. I hope that with liberation the cause of the overwhelming will become extinct, even if gradually, and so I will no longer need the unknown impenetrable defense I’m seeking. That said, I, as completely as I can, understand the following quotes from the website and believe that my motivations and expectations are in line with them.
Liberation Unleashed is not…
going to lead you to eternal peace and happiness, it is not about happiness.
about freedom from emotions and intense feelings.
getting rid of self, ego, I.
a way to get free of depression or other diseases.
FAQ’s
I am depressed and anxious. Will liberation help me?
Liberation is not a cure for physical or mental disorders. Seeing through the illusion of self is an important step in seeing through the stories that fuel depression and anxiousness, which both derive from that same self illusion.
Will I never suffer again?
The answer depends on how we define suffering. If you hope to enter a life of unending bliss and only happy feelings, you’re going to be disappointed. Life will go on as before. All sorts of emotions will continue to arise. Yet, without the concept of a central self to stick to, how can there truly be suffering?
What is next?
Seeing self for what it really is – a story – does not mean that your life is suddenly upgraded in every conceivable way. Old habits, beliefs, programming and conditioning will very probably remain in place. Awakening from the story of you allows old patterns to drop away quickly. The foundation upon which these patterns were based is gone.
What is your background in terms of seeking and inquiry?
I'm kind of unclear on what all exactly happened, but I have a thorough enough idea I think. I first heard of this truth by reading Sam Harris’ book “Waking Up”. I probably listened to a youtube video or two after reading that. Then at some point after that I found no-self.com. I read their explanation and I talked with Mike. I read Butterflies are Free to Fly at their instruction (I think). Then I came upon Liberation Unleashed. I registered and got a pointer named Cody J. Dennis. That conversation is on the forum under my then-username blackfoot332. This was in June 2015. The liberation didn’t happen, I got frustrated and stopped replying, but I’ve since kept no-self on my mind, very much, as an eventual priority in my life, a next step in spirituality. I’ve continued to struggle with depression, and after finding even the defense against negativity that mindfulness could offer to be insufficient, I have decided to make this a priority again. I wrote a couple paragraph-long post when I came back and thought Cody might still be around that lays out a few aspects of my current frustrations with this process and his suggestions. But why go into all that? You’ll have your own style and we’ll be working with that one not Cody’s, and any other complaints or questions will come up as need be in our exploration. Also, I dig it conceptually/intellectually, but that’s totally irrelevant as I understand.
How ready are you to question your beliefs about who you are and see the truth no matter what?
11