Hi Sayah,
Sorry I cant somehow use the quote, so i answer without it..
If you post not by pressing the ‘Quick Reply’ but with ‘Post Reply” (purple-orange button in the left corner of the bottom of the page) then under the text box all the previous posts will appear. Select the lines you’d like to quote, press the quote button, and it’ll be automatically put into the text box.
I saw wonderful dream last night. I saw very clearly this whole thing. How thoughts were just thoughts and how there no "I" just thoughts of "I".
Beautiful. Sometimes seeing continues into dreams.
No thoughts can have no attributes. Like strong or weak or positive or negative. They are thoughts too! It kinda feels they have, but they dont.
Exactly. What makes feel that thoughts may have any attributes? Is it possible that this is also just a thought?
Memories can never be real, because they are just thoughts too. I was thinking that maybe if someone had a traumatic experience in the past, like near drowning in the lake and then he when he sees lake, is very frightnend, so maybe that memory comes from subconscious level to remind the present moment.. ? Well, okey maybe I got it now: the memory at that moment isn't real, the feeling of fear is. Yes okey, memories can never be real!
Very good. A memory is a thought appearing now, in the present moment. There might be simultaneously arising emotions (like fear) with it. And yes, in direct experience there is (1) an arising thought labelled as ‘memory’ and (2) a sensation in the body labelled as ‘fear’.
Can we say that a memory is the content of a thought?
A memory is not real. But does it real as an arising thought in direct experience?
Is there a feeling of fear in direct experience, or there are only sensations in the body, with a simultaneously arising thought-label “this is fear”?
Nothing is outside of this moment. The mental narrative belongs this moment too. I think you your mind can travel to the past or future, speculate all kinda stuff..but your body is always at tjis moment. Breathing, smelling, seeing.. actually thereCAN'T be anything out side of this moment. This is it, life is happening only moment by moment. Our mind just travels easily dreaming or worrying or whatever...
Can the mind travel to the past or future?
What is past and future in direct experience?
Where is the mind in direct experience?
So thoughts effect your emotions and that way, can ruin your day, if you blindely listen to that as a truth. But on the other hand I get it..like thought can never ruin anything, that's a thought too! It's ALL just thoughts! !!
When a thought is believed and not seen only as an arising thought, then the associated or conditioned emotion can arise.
What is this ‘you’ or ‘I’ that can blindly listen to thoughts?
Where is it?
Check it in direct experience.
thought cant do anything. If it think it can, that's another thought too.
Exactly.
Mental narrative is also part of the current experience. I think every moment is as it is, DESPITE of the mental narrative. Life happens as it happens, moment by moment and whether you worry or dream your whole life, current experience still fully happens ALL the time.
Don’t just think whether “every moment is as it is, despite of the mental narrative”, but check it in direct experience.
Is worrying or dreaming also part of the current experience?
This last question was very good and opened "the door" a bit more! That current thought is real but it's content not. So true!! Thoughts are full of ridiciously stupid stuff, hah! That has nothing to do with REALITY. Its so hard sometimes to be aware of this and then "you" just listen to that crap.. OR actually that "you"is a thought too! Damn, that dream was good last night! I'm starting to ser..wow..it's ALL just thoughts! !!! This is wild..
Yes, very good looking.
What is it that can be aware of this?
Is there an ‘awarer’?
But have to ask you something: i did this test in my mind; singing certain song, or shout in my mind or curse...and did it. So who is it, who makes these decisions? "I" made this decision and did it. Mind and thoughts did what "I" wanted. Who or what is that, who wants to drink the tea or go out or draw.. am I just a automatic thing that does what ever LIFE wants "me" to do? The mind just thinks this "I" is in controll of everything? This is so hard to understand. .
Very good questions, but I leave these to you to find out for yourself. And yes, this is hard to understand because it cannot be understood. The illusion of self cannot be seen through with the same thinking that created it in the first place.
Here is an interesting exercise.
Choose one of your arms - It doesn't matter which.
When you have done that, rest for a moment and then when you want to, raise that arm into the air.
Do this as many times as you like, and each time inquire . . .
What is this 'I' that is controlling the arm?
Don't go to thoughts - examine the actual experience - Can a controlling 'I' be located?
Also . . . what is this 'I' that is choosing that particular arm?
Again, don't go to thoughts - examine the actual experience - Can you find an 'I' that is doing the choosing?
Can you find an 'I' that chooses here right now?
Well, thank you again Vivien!!!!
It's my pleasure.
Love,
Vivien