Hi Coll,
will you go back and answer them here and below, so important, as your answers show u this (hrt) and then i can go with u to see where u/we are?
Yes, sorry about that. Yesterday there was a bit of frustration and distraction on my part. Here are my answers:
who can stop mind shatter?
Can you make thoughts stop?
If I is a thought, who is doing thoughts?
- I cannot stop mind chatter. It appears on its own, but goes away temporarily when there is attention to the present moment. The chatter comes back when attention goes away.
- No, I cannot make thoughts stop.
- No one is doing the thoughts. Thoughts appear by themselves, seemingly out of nowhere.
in Direct experience, can u locate a "body"? isn't that a thought also?....
Can you know it is "tention"? Meet this label "tension" and what does it say?
Do u have something u love doing...art, hobby, outdoors, while driving....go there today, do u notice "u" disappear while doing that?
- Yes, the identification of a body is thought.
- When I try to meet the label "tension" it is not there. The identification of tension is also thought.
- It's true. There are such times when "I" am not there. But right as it happens, I don't notice the fact of "my" disappearance. It's only after the fact, as a thought process, that I can label one moment as "I am present" and the other as "I was not present."
yes it is what is happening all along and can just be "unnoticed"...u writing this, thoughts arising about looking for this "i", who is doing this?
can you locate a separate person there a "Bill", inside of u?
- No one (in the sense of a continuous self) is writing this. These fingers, which are part of a body, type on the keyboard. They type in reaction to thoughts. The body is not a continuous self. The thoughts are not a self.
- No, I cannot locate a separate continuity of self inside of "me." There is a body, which changes. There are thoughts, which are momentary.
Yes, thoughts can come in to protect "someone" as that is what they are in a habit of doing.
In Direct Experience, without thought labels, experience is there really a separate self,
"I", "me" to protect, was there ever or was that all created by thought?
There is no separate, continuous self discernible through thought, whether present or past.
You are here already and many teachings possibly pointed you here, now u can "lay them down" so to speak to see and look for this separate self as your answer is key. Do you find one outside of thought?
Just sit quietly to look and be with the answer of a simple "yes" or "no" that arises.
What is experienced?
No, I don't find a self outside of thought. There is an experience of a "heavy" sensation in the head right now, along with much heavy breathing in the body. "I" hope this isn't hyperventilation. Literally LOL.
So who is thinking it?
Who is doing your thoughts?
Who needs to perceive it?
- No "one" in the sense of a continuous self.
- No one. They just appear.
- No one. There just is a perceiving.