Stuck in the mud

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Sat Oct 21, 2017 6:59 pm

Hi Perry
The ‘self’ is something I create out of experience as a way to explain to myself what is happening, in the belief that that will gives me some control. I have yet to see that it doesn’t give me any control.
What is it, in terms of direct experience, that you "create out of experience"?
How does this give control?
The feeling of irritation, anger and upset are so unpleasant that I want to stop them, to control them. I try to do nothing but then I feel overwhelmed by sadness and cry. I felt like a child and embarrassed that I cried, because now I have lost ground and the person who has made the horrible comment seems the stronger one. I wanted to be the stronger one in control, so I could tell them off properly and shame them into admitting what they said was unkind.

So my thoughts were attempting to control the emotion but it didn’t work. Even when the person apologised it didn’t feel like they meant it. And the anger and hurt carried on.
it still felt that a ‘self’ was trying to protect itself. Even when I tried letting all this just be, with a belief that the ‘self’ was a just a belief, something was still doggedly holding on.
What goes on in direct experience during this ‘protection’
Thoughts that I couldn’t follow were racing, which got in the way of concentrating on ordering food at the counter. I kept having to check what I was doing because I felt exposed and that others would see how upset I was and close to crying. The lady behind the counter was so friendly and warm and I felt I had force my mind to concentrate so I could respond to her warmth. I am trying to protect myself from more hurt and to change how I am feeling in order to be able to cope with crying in public. But the more I squash down the emotion the more it seems to support it. I have to protect the hurt from escalating and prevent it happening again because it is so unbearable. So this is all in an attempt to cope with someone being hurtful to me and me not wanting to have hurtful feeling that seem unbearable and need to be squashed. But this doesn’t protect me it just goes round and round.

It did seem to take longer than usual for me to recover and calm down.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Sun Oct 22, 2017 11:27 am

Hi Diane,

Since we are looking at how protection mechanisms work, it's worth emphasising before we go any further that this is not about taking away protective strategies and leaving you more vulnerable. If something feels like an effective defence, it will always remain available.
The feeling of irritation, anger and upset are so unpleasant that I want to stop them, to control them. [...] my thoughts were attempting to control the emotion

That's a totally understandable response. We are not here to try to 'solve' or prevent situations like this, but to understand them, so let's look into what is going on ....

This appears as a situation of opposition between the feelings of irritation, anger and upset, and the sense that "I want to stop them, to control them".

So where is "I" in all this? Is "I" on both sides of the apparent opposition, or just one? Or on neither side, nowhere at all?

Is there really an "I" that is feeling irritated, angry and upset? Or are these feelings simply occurring in experience?

Is there really an "I" that is feeling the urge to control, or is this something just arising in experience?

Perhaps there is some sense of identification that switches rapidly back and forth between the two poles? One moment illuminating the feeling of hurt, the next moment the desire for control? If so, is this really controlled by "I", or do these reactions just drive each other?
I am trying to protect myself from more hurt and to change how I am feeling [...] But this doesn’t protect me it just goes round and round.

OK, this is a good start to look into the question "what is being protected?" ... I think there are enough questions above for now, so I won't add more, we will need to come back to this later.

best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Sun Oct 22, 2017 7:13 pm

Hi Perry
Is there really an "I" that is feeling irritated, angry and upset? Or are these feelings simply occurring in experience?
Is there really an "I" that is feeling the urge to control, or is this something just arising in experience?

There is no ‘I’ that is feeling irritated, angry and upset. They were feelings occurring in response to a painful experience. I went looking for the ‘I’ and interpreted the experience as being an ‘I’. Also the ‘urge to control’ I again mistook this for something arising in experience. I wanted to explain it all by recognising an ‘I’ but it was no more than a belief and thoughts mingled with experience. Because my feelings were so strong it was a need in me to explain it all away with this ‘I’ and I was not seeing what was really going on.

Perhaps there is some sense of identification that switches rapidly back and forth between the two poles? One moment illuminating the feeling of hurt, the next moment the desire for control? If so, is this really controlled by "I", or do these reactions just drive each other?
The going backwards and forwards between hurt and wanting control did feel like an ‘I’ but it couldn’t have been. Again I mistook this drive for the ‘I’ when it was just one experience switching and driving another.

I am trying to protect myself from more hurt and to change how I am feeling [...] But this doesn’t protect me it just goes round and round.
The ‘I’ is still very slippery.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Mon Oct 23, 2017 4:55 pm

Hi Diane,
There is no ‘I’ that is feeling irritated, angry and upset. They were feelings occurring in response to a painful experience.

Great stuff!
I wanted to explain it all by recognising an ‘I’ but it was no more than a belief and thoughts mingled with experience. Because my feelings were so strong it was a need in me to explain it all away with this ‘I’ and I was not seeing what was really going on.

Likewise, really good observation.

This 'need to explain' touches on something we have not looked at closely yet - stories!

Does a "me, Diane" character appear as a character in stories that arise in thought? What sort of stories?

How real is this character? Is it self?

Do you ever mistake the character for being a real 'self'?


Best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Mon Oct 23, 2017 8:05 pm

Hi Perry
Does a "me, Diane" character appear as a character in stories that arise in thought? What sort of stories?


There is the ‘me’ character that is not very bright who won’t be able to understand complex concepts particularly Buddhist ones. This is proven by not being able to remember Sanskrit and Pali words. The ‘me’ who wasn’t as clever as her brother and whose father didn’t think should be educated. The ‘me’ that won’t see though ‘self’ however persistent she is, because she is not bright enough. The ‘me’ that isn’t clever enough so you will get bored with how long I am talking and maybe you will give up on me.
How real is this character? Is it self?


This character is mostly real, constructed from thoughts, feeelings and family stories from the past. It does feel like a ‘self’ because it is different views clumped together. But these views are beliefs and fears that I believe to be true.
Do you ever mistake the character for being a real 'self'?


I do mistake the character for being a real ‘self’ because the default setting is on automatic and it all happens so fast in my head. But I also no that the ‘self’ isn’t my thoughts, nor does the ‘self’ reside in my mind.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Tue Oct 24, 2017 10:07 pm

Hi Diane,

Think of the Eiffel Tower!

You did it, right?

Was that Eiffel Tower real?

.... take a moment to consider this ....

For all you know, the actual monument in Paris might have ceased to exist ten minutes ago, vaporised by aliens, yet the Eiffel Tower appeared as a thought, yes?

So the Eiffel Tower was only real as a thought, as a character in a story you might hold about Paris and all things French.

.... take a moment to get comfortable with this before we go further......

Now:

Think of "me, Diane"!

Was that Diane real?
This character is mostly real

As real as what?

As real as a thought? Or as real as the floor beneath your feet?

Remember, the question is not "are the stories involving this character are true?" but "is this character real?"

Best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Wed Oct 25, 2017 2:38 pm

Hi Perry

The ‘me Diane’ is a character and is not real, she is a character that I have made up and believe to be real. She is a story but as I write this it still feels hard to really grasp this. Diane isn’t real she can’t be found as a ‘me’ yet something hangs on. “Is that I haven’t quite got it?”

What I think is ‘me’ is not ‘me’ but different experiences, different thoughts, different emotions which I form into a character which plays out in stories. I can’t quite believe this yet I write it - it’s puzzling.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Thu Oct 26, 2017 5:36 pm

Hi Diane,

Whoops, I thought I sent this last night, but it had not gone, sorry....
The ‘me Diane’ is a character and is not real, she is a character that I have made up and believe to be real. She is a story but as I write this it still feels hard to really grasp this. Diane isn’t real she can’t be found as a ‘me’ yet something hangs on. “Is that I haven’t quite got it?”

What I think is ‘me’ is not ‘me’ but different experiences, different thoughts, different emotions which I form into a character which plays out in stories. I can’t quite believe this yet I write it - it’s puzzling.

Yes! Very good!

So is there any fundamental difference between the 'me Diane' character, and any other character in thought?

Best wishes

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Thu Oct 26, 2017 7:48 pm

Hi Perry
So is there any fundamental difference between the 'me Diane' character, and any other character in thought
No there is no difference between the ‘me Diane’ character and any other character they are just thoughts that I believed to be real.

So where to now?

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Thu Oct 26, 2017 9:37 pm

Hi Diane,

You seem very sure about it this time, very good!

Let's go back to something very important that we parked temporarily:

What is fear protecting?

If there is no fear in current experience to investigate, maybe you still find, as you reported before, that
The fear arises when I ask myself “is this self”?

If not, you may be able to reconnect with an experience of fear from memory?


Best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Fri Oct 27, 2017 5:04 pm

Hi Perry
What is fear protecting?
I do bear in mind what you said about expectations being unhelpful and remind myself of this when they come up. In answering the question ‘what is fear protecting’ I fear I am back in this territory once again. It’s not easy to explain and although I have a bad cold, sore throat and a fog in my head, I do want to have a go.

As I have looked into my direct experience with your help, I am not as afraid about there being ‘no me’ as I was. But the fear has shifted to a belief that I won’t be able to see this, really see it. I do feel that I know that sense experience is not performed by a me, that thoughts are thoughts and that I am a character in my own story that is no more real than Father Christmas. I am more able to experience feelings and nightmares like the weather often stormy and that I am no more in control of them than the movements of my limbs, which no what to do themselves. So the fear is protecting a belief that I will not be able to really see through this illusion, that I will only ever no it as a group of thoughts. But I also no a belief is no more than a belief. I am not sure what is preventing me seeing something that was never there. Or is it fear that I will never be the same again? I would rather take the chance of never being the same again.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:32 am

Hi Diane,
I am not as afraid about there being ‘no me’ as I was

That's good to hear!
So the fear is protecting a belief that I will not be able to really see through this illusion, that I will only ever no it as a group of thoughts. But I also no a belief is no more than a belief. I am not sure what is preventing me seeing something that was never there. Or is it fear that I will never be the same again?

OK, so although you're starting to see what is going on here, it is not quite clear yet exactly what is going on - that's OK, we just carry on looking....

Let's start with what is most clearly and directly available to experience:
  • what physical sensations are involved in the experience labelled 'fear'?
  • what thoughts and stories arise?
  • is there a 'me, Diane' character involved?
Best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Sat Oct 28, 2017 6:17 pm

Hi Perry
what physical sensations are involved in the experience labelled 'fear'?
There are burning sensations around both knees. My chest is tight with the breath sometimes shallow and then a deep in breath. The skin on my face feels very hot and flushed.
what thoughts and stories arise?
“You won’t be able to do this”. “You were so sure you could”. “See your just making a fool of yourself”. “You will never be free”. “It’s too late”. ”Panic attacks have a life of their own you can’t control them, they always win out”. “You have no control over your thoughts so how can you see there is no ‘me’ “. “Here ‘I’ am in control making you feel bad”.
is there a 'me, Diane' character involved?
There is a ‘me’ character made up of all the thoughts that pop in an out telling me I won’t be able to do this, even though I was so sure I would be able to.

Best wishes
Diane

User avatar
perrym
Posts: 557
Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2012 7:55 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby perrym » Mon Oct 30, 2017 12:26 am

Hi Diane,

OK, that's really clearly described, thank you!

So thoughts arise featuring a 'me, Diane' character failing to achieve various things, and this is accompanied by various uncomfortable feelings and sensations.

Is there any real danger here?

Can the 'me, Diane' character, this idea, actually be hurt?

Does this idea of 'me, Diane' actually need protection?


Best wishes,

Perry

User avatar
DianeSt
Posts: 92
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:46 pm

Re: Stuck in the mud

Postby DianeSt » Mon Oct 30, 2017 8:45 pm

Hi Perry

So thoughts arise featuring a 'me, Diane' character failing to achieve various things, and this is accompanied by various uncomfortable feelings and sensations. Is there any real danger here?
No there is no real danger here.
Can the 'me, Diane' character, this idea, actually be hurt?
Feelings of hurt are felt but the ‘me, Diane’ character is an idea so cannot acutually be hurt.
Does this idea of 'me, Diane' actually need protection?
The idea of ‘me, Diane’ is only an idea and so doesn’t need protection.

Best wishes
Diane


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 41 guests