YES! How on earth could you tell? It's complete bafflegap. People don't use language, they live as language. Everybody talks, talks and talks about things that are complete bullshit and often don't even exist. And me too, when I try to express some wonder, feeling or have a talk with someone, what comes out is complete crap.
I also went through the same and still think many times that almost everything I say or write is bafflegap (this is a funny word, that I didn't know!).
But we need to communicate and if you don't share what's going on with you, how can I guide you?? Please write without censuring what pops up. Thinking is always changing anyway, what seems a fact today is discarded tomorrow. And that's okay :)
Yes, I notice it's comforting just noticing this, but it's easier for me to notice with eyes closed.
Why are you saying it is easier with eyes closed? When you look with eyes open, do you see an I?
Well yes, but I just notice the difference in how much I'm identified with an I, after contact with a human identification increases.
It seems to me that you are under the assumption that identification with an I shouldn't be happening? Why not?
What is identification exactly? Isn't identification a label you place in a experience?
There is a experience going on, yes? In that experience self-thoughts can take a front stage role, sure. Sometimes they are very compelling and you start thinking that they shouldn't be happening, that they have a meaning, that they are happening to YOU, that you are identifying with them. You start believing that you are entering and leaving identification with an I (are you??) and that it is possible to stop identification or something similar. Yada, yada, yada, thought loop feeding itself. Check in your own experience if this is what is going on.
Is any of this happening to a you? Can it be controlled by a you? Does it have a personal meaning?