Whitley Blaine
I feel really bad about not replying for a long time, I guess I need to get motivated to keep "looking" more. It's hard because I'm a pretty happy person, I almost wish I was less happy so figuring this all out would seem more urgent!
9:44pm
Lisa Hamilton
You can't 'figure it out'. You can't think your way into it. It can only be experienced, SEEN.
What looks out of the eyes, hears with the ears, lifts the arm, breathes the lungs? LOOK.
January 9
6:29am
Whitley Blaine
If there's no self how could anything "look" out of the eyes or do anything? The whole thing seems contradictory.
8:47am
Lisa Hamilton
That's thinking. There is a thought saying 'it's contradictory'. Just because there is no 'me' does not rule out that sight happens, hearing happens, arm raises, etc. Try that again, Whitney.... just sit quietly, raise one arm, lower it, raise and lower the other one. How does it happen? Is there a 'me' making them move? Watch closely.
Thinking about this is a circular unending puzzle. Such fun! And the root of all turmoil, as things simply are as they are, thoughts merely adding ideas on top of them all, coloring them and seeming even to change them from what they are into whatever thought says about them.
Check this. Go through your day seeing, hearing, tasting, smelling, feeling.... watch tree leaves blow around and notice how you think 'that's the wind', taste your dinner and notice how you think 'that's good'; hear music and and watch critiquing or praising thoughts come in, and that YOU GIVE THEM CREDENCE. They are believed. The music BECOMES what is thought. Yet they are simply ideas pasted on experiencing after it shows up.
January 14
9:27pm
Whitley Blaine
I get hung up when you ask me "WHO or WHAT is moving the arm?"
It doesn't seem like ANYTHING is moving the arm! If i'm honest with myself, I think about the arm moving and then it does, but although I've heard about the "law of attraction" and the idea that thoughts can change the world around us...I don't think the thought is LITERALLY lifting up my arm. And perhaps I could say electrical signals in the brain are doing it, but that's not something I know in my direct experience.
9:45pm
Lisa Hamilton
I don't ask how it is moving... I ask is there a 'you' moving it? Look. Is there a you moving that arm????
9:45pm
Whitley Blaine
No
haha
To be blunt
9:48pm
Lisa Hamilton
Great. Is there a you that typed that?
Is there a you that reads this? LOOK. Both times here.. is there a you doing either of these?
Was there ever a you?
9:57pm
Whitley Blaine
Not a me that typed this, per say....where I get confused is...couldn't you say that whatever "sees" is a sort of "you"?
In fact, sooo many "spiritual" types tend to do that..or so it seems
(I'm really sorry but it's super late and I have to go to bed but I will check my inbox in the morning!)
10:02pm
Lisa Hamilton
You're thinking about it... you want to solve this by logic and thoughts. STOP.
Watch what happens when you think about it... you are once removed... from ANYTHING you think 'about'..
Your beliefs tell you there is a 'you', a 'me'... look at them, see them for what they are: believes about something. Are they true? Is there a you? Look at the beliefs and look at the experience... is there a you breathing the lungs, driving the car, eating the dinner? Where the heck is this you that thoughts keep saying is so real??
Really ponder all this.. really look some more at both thoughts and direct experience, all day long...
Night, Whitley....
January 21
7:15am
Whitley Blaine
Timeline Photos
Good Nite
By: A Life Balanced
8:28am
Lisa Hamilton
And what's the status? Believing thoughts about a self? Is there a self believing those thoughts? Or thoughts simply showing up, embraced or allowed to flow through.... ? Look.
January 26
5:06am
Whitley Blaine
I find that awareness sort of...."drifts" between the feeling of not being a 'self' and just sort of "being your experience" or "being awareness," and being all caught up in thought and self-image. Sorry if I did a bad job of explaining that lol but I think that's what confuses me. It's natural to FEEL like we are a self, and so, I assume this is not a bad thing?
January 28
4:15pm
Lisa Hamilton
Hi... was not here for a few days..
It's natural for there to be some back and forth between realizing there is no personal self and feeling like there is one; there's a mechanism, a structure in place that gets things done, and it's all to easy to equate that with 'me', an entity, when it's merely the human's built-in abilities to act like a human.
Tell me: Have you experienced the reality of no self... did you see it? Even if it went away.... You are the only one who knows if you did....
Is there a you?? Anywhere to be found??
4:16pm
Whitley Blaine
I certainly did. The "me" is not there.
4:23pm
Lisa Hamilton
Hahahaha! LOVE IT!
Tell me more.... Is there a 'you' in any way shape or form?
And to what do you refer when you use the word 'I'??
5:47pm
Whitley Blaine
Well when I realized that there's no entity behind the thoughts in my head, the voice that speaks about anything and everything lol, it created a pretty big space. LIke..there was a "space" between that which experiences and that which was previously seen to be a "me". I think that was one of the moments where this became less of an intellectual understanding and more of just an obvious fact of life..lol
5:49pm
Lisa Hamilton
Is there an experiencer, and the experienced?
5:54pm
Whitley Blaine
there is just experience
that's what's so crazy
way back, probably months ago, i realized that we've never seen our head except in the mirror lol
and by that i mean...what we think of as "the experienced" is really ALL there is as far as sight is concerned
that caused a bit of a shift in me
then much more recently i learned that there's actually a "nonduality"-type teacher who literally bases his teachings around that
it's called headlessness...haha
http://www.headless.org/
pretty funny how universal many of our "realizations" are
6:00pm
Lisa Hamilton
You say 'there is just experience' and then say 'what we think of as the experienced is really ALL as far as sight is concerned'... do these 2 statements conflict? more about experiencing please...
Yes, Douglas Harding...
6:03pm
Whitley Blaine
well the second statement was just a bad way of putting it lol
but experience...
6:04pm
Lisa Hamilton
Yes?
6:07pm
Whitley Blaine
it really does feel like we're part of the big sea of experience
like..
the thoughts about self, the "sense of self", the erik satie piece i'm listening to right now, my computer..it's all the same "stuff", all experience. there's no separate thing that experiences it, and none of it is created from something "else"
which is paradoxical, especially for us
let's say i sit down to meditate
and thoughts keep coming into my head and distracting me from the present moment
what we typically do is blame "ourselves" for this, as if we are somehow creating the thoughts
or like..this is gonna sound really bad lol
but if I kill someone
i would of course feel bad
and all of society would look at it as a bad thing that "i" did
but all of this is just happening
we just thing that "I' did it or "he" did it
and that's kind of hard for me to wrap my head around, especially with all my facebook judging of politicians and their actions lol
6:11pm
Lisa Hamilton
This sounds very clear... more please about 'it really does FEEL like we're part of the big sea of experience'... is that an idea or is it true?
You FEEL that.. can you tighten it up?
From your direct experience, only, please....
6:23pm
Whitley Blaine
I can try..haha
ahh it's hard lol
6:28pm
Lisa Hamilton
I find it's really truly easiest to say direct experiencing... so, when it is feeling like we are part of the big sea of experience what IS that experiencing for you? Is there you and experience, experiencing only, something having experiences?? Just describe what comes .....
6:34pm
Whitley Blaine
i will do that it's 11:34 here and i've been trying to go to bed earlier, but i'll talk to you in the morning!
there's one thing i'm confused about, but I don't know if i'm ready to answer it lol
a lot of people who talk about there being "no personal self" or say there is "just experience" also seem to think that "we are consciousness" or that we are all little bits of consciousness..these two ideas seem to contradict each other
i'm doing ok with seeing through the illusion of "I' and all that, but the "bigger picture" that everyone seems to want to figure out is pretty overwhelming..lol
6:41pm
Lisa Hamilton
No need to worry about that bigger pic right now. Once you are comfortable with seeing thru the self illusion other things stabilize over time. I've seen it happen time and time again. And it did for me. OK... in the morning say some more about your direct experience of ..... experiencing! Night....
6:43pm
Whitley Blaine
goodnight! thank you!
6:46pm
Lisa Hamilton
You are more than welcome. Always...
7:10pm
Whitley Blaine
i was in bed when i thought of something that i just HAD to ask you! have you ever seen the movie i heart huckabees? i feel like you would love it!
so funny
February 2
11:02am
Whitley Blaine
When I stop holding onto the "self image," I become a point of awareness in the environment I'm in. And my experience becomes only what is around me (like the people and things), not so much the thoughts or images in my head. And then when/if I slip back into "self image mode," my awareness is only partially in the present, and partially in the head, being "filtered" by my thoughts
February 2
3:37pm
Lisa Hamilton
I never saw it but you are about the 4th or 5th person to tell me they think I'd like it so I'll watch it!
So.... have you seen through the illusion of a separate self... of the 'me'???
February 2
7:15pm
Whitley Blaine
Yes!
8:12pm
Lisa Hamilton
How is that for you... how do you feel?
What do you mean when you use the word 'I' or 'me'.... ?
Is there something in control; how do things happen?
What are you?
AND: what is it like, living with no Whitley? Was there ever a Whitley?
February 4
4:02am
Whitley Blaine
I feel pretty normal. When I use the word "I" or "me" it could refer to 'awareness' or it could refer to the body and mind that "sees" this experience. I don't know if something's in control, I guess it's a mystery, but it's certainly not a little "me" that's controlling me and only me! I am awareness; it's pretty much the same living with no Whitley because there never was a Whitley.
4:29am
Whitley Blaine
I don't see why this was ever that big of a deal, or how i could see "through the illusion of a separate me" any "deeper". But I've seen it. I just feel like anyone who's read Eckhart Tolle or meditated for a bit has seen it too..haha
February 4
8:55am
Lisa Hamilton
What is awareness, and how can anyone 'be' it???
March 25
11:01am
Whitley Blaine
I'm stuck
I've been seeing clearer than ever, I find it hard to get stuck in negative thought loops because I recognize that that is not "me" and so they just pass by. My emotional health has improved soo much since we started talking, probably because I don't identify with the emotions nearly as much.
But I don't feel as though I've completely "passed through the gate," because a recurring pattern for most people seems to be passing through a point where they "know" that there is no self, they realize it fully.
I don't mean to seem like I have too many expectations..I just dont know how else to deepen this understanding further. Or is there even a need to? I don't know
March 25
3:01pm
Lisa Hamilton
Here's the ticket:
Is there a "me" in any way, shape, or form?
Was there ever?
Could there ever be?
Your truest answers to these will tell you exactly what is what. If the answers point to "Yes. There is something....." then continue looking. Where the heck is it???? If not, you are Whitney Gated.
Hugs.
Tuesday
7:21pm
Whitley Blaine
No. There is no "me"
Wednesday
10:56am
Lisa Hamilton
Was there ever a me?
Could there ever be one?
Does anyone else have one?
11:19am
Whitley Blaine
No, no, and no.
As for some other questions..
"how do you feel?"
When I really "look" at this and see that there is no self, only this experience, and "settle into" "being" the experience and not "being" a "person", i feel very calm and happy.
But that's not what this is about. I still feel the same emotions a lot of the time, just with more "space". I'm less emotionally reactive, but again, there is no specific "feeling" that comes with this seeing. it's more of an unfolding, a falling away of old self-related beliefs that i no longer need to hold onto because their premise is untrue: there is no self, so i do not need to worry about "developing" myself, becoming more "disciplined" and whatnot. The human may have a drive to improve himself, become kinder, more compassionate, more driven, more focused....and it is fine to let that unfold, but you need to let go of the idea that it really is "you" being improved. (sorry i went off on a tangent lol)
What do you mean when you use the word 'I' or 'me'.... ?
It refers to the false "i" supposedly controlling the body and mind. The human still has thoughts relating to an "i" and there's nothing "I" can do to change "the human" because the human is all there is in this equation--there is no seperate entity to change things! I feel as though the "i" thoughts will either become less frequent or gradually I will believe them less and less over time.
Is there something in control; how do things happen?
Nothing is in control. Life is kind of a series of chain reactions lol. If I'm hungry, but also have a lot of work to do, there is no "I" that decides if I'll eat or work. Inevitably there will be a thought process going on--"well, I haven't eaten much today...but I am really busy...hmm maybe I should go eat quickly" whether the end conclusion of this process affects the action, or if the action was "decided" before the thought process, i have no idea lol. it doesn't really matter much...
What are you?
The question doesn't even make sense. WHO? What is WHO? Are you talking to the human? Well yes there's a human perceiving this but there is no seperate self to call "you", so the question itself doesn't work. One could say I am EVERYTHING, one could say there is no me...the first one seems to point to the sense of oneness that comes when you see that there is no seperation, the second one seems more true but they're both true in a sense. Sorry if I'm ranting...
AND: what is it like, living with no Whitley? Was there ever a Whitley?
Living--events, thoughts, and emotions still come up, 'negative' and 'positive.' what changes is that I believe them for less time, you know? They appear and when the thought first appears I feel as though "I" am thinking it but I "know" i'm not, and i feel as though that space will increase over time.
2:12pm
Lisa Hamilton
This all sounds very good, Whitley!
Are you interested in formally answering the LU confirming questions in order to get into FB LU groups? If so, I'll line them up and we'll go from there...
Lots of love! Great work...
2:13pm
Whitley Blaine
ok i would like to do that, not only to get into the group but to see if i actually got it this time lol
Wednesday
8:42pm
Lisa Hamilton
First is a starter question: Have you seen through the illusion of the self?
(Your own feeling about this is important... )
8:48pm
Whitley Blaine
Yes, I'm quite certain I have
Thursday
8:18am
Lisa Hamilton
Great! I'll post the questions.
8:44am
Lisa Hamilton
Take your time, give detail.
1) Is there a 'me', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works.
3) How does it feel to see this?
4) How would you describe the illusion of 'self' to somebody who has never heard about it before but is curious?
5) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look? Was there a specific moment when seeing happened or was it gradual? What exactly happened?
6) When you say "I", to what are you referring?
7) During experience, is there an experiencer? Is it body that experiences or is the body the experienced?
9) Describe experience right now, what it's like.
Thursday
7:26pm
Whitley Blaine
1) No. There is no "me". There is only the thought of a me. It feels like a "filter" through which life is perceived; that is, ego-identification still occurs, and when it does, life is perceived "through" a thought, the self thought. Then once the thought is seen for what it is, one sees life without the filter.
2) The illusion of seperate self starts when babies start to think of themselves as a seperate entity, or create an "ego". It is the phenomenon that occurs when a human believes there is an operator controlling it, a seperate entity called "me" that is somehow seperate from the body. It works by creating a self image, which everything is seen through. For example, you try to play an instrument, and you have all these beliefs that "I" am not good enough, so you give up. It's a set of thoughts that together become a belief, which guides the human's actions and other thoughts.
3) I feel relieved--I finally have less "seeking" to do. The fear of never waking up is gone which is wonderful. I feel like I have a lot to learn so to speak but I feel like the "seeking" is over in a sense. But seeing this does not bring about a specific "feeling" of enlightenment. There can be a feeling of unity, or joy, or a feeling of "space" between perception and "you", but none of these things ARE "enlightenment" (enlightenment in this case just means waking up and seeing this). It has no specific feeling.
That said, it's a lot harder to get caught up in negative thoought patterns and 'negative' feelings because once I see that they aren't happening "to" anybody i don't get caught up in them.
4) I would tell the person that we think of ourselves as a seperate entity that lives up in our head somewhere and controls our thoughts, emotions, and actions. She would probably nod in agreement and I would ask her to find that "I". When she looks for it and inevitably can't find it, she'll probably rationalize that "she" is an entity that can't be found, a soul or spirit or something in the heavens. I will explain that this "I" is nothing more than a collection of thoughts and beliefs that all form a complicated belief-web, and thus, ego-conditioning. When you see the world through this belief in a "self", you identify with your thoughts and emotions, so that's why you get caught up in emotional spirals and suffering, and fear.
5) Seeing was very very gradual, I started almost a year ago. I logically understood it almost immediately, which began the awakening process. it all made so much sense, but my mind had to go through a LOT of confusion to figure it out clearly. once i truly SAW it i was very scared, and i was actually scared to carry on with awakening because the thought of not being a self was terrifying (at least to the ego). When I truly woke up (when I messaged you) was when I was so sick of searching that i thought "what am i doing? I KNOW there's no self, i know it 100%, i'm just in denial/holding on to ego". When I realized that I already knew, I realized that the only thing keeping me from "getting through the gate" was my acceptance of me seeing through it. So i basically accepted what happened and at that point truly felt like i had "seen through" it. But it was a long, gradual process where I had tons of gradual realizations.
6) I am referring to an imaginary "I" that is really just a thought, a belief.
7) No, there is no experiencer. There just IS experience, which doesn't make any sense but after "awakening" I just accepted that that really is how things seem to be. The body is being experienced, the body does not experience per say. It helps me to think that the world is like a virtual reality--makes me realize that things are less "important" and in that smallness I feel big! hahaha
9) "i'm" at my desk working late for the last time before "I" leave college to do something more worthwhile. So what it's like: well, the "outside" world is seen the same way, except there is no self image quietly running as the underlying belief. to clarify...perception is experienced but when "I' thoughts come up claiming to own that experience, they are quickly disbelieved by the human, because the human realized that they don't make sense and then began his way down a path of questioning other beliefs and figuring things in the world out.
Ps. You skipped number 8!
Cheers
8:44pm
Lisa Hamilton
Well done, Whitley!
Number 8 was skipped, yup... It seemed redundant.
I have a question about your number 9 answer: What is the 'human' that has realization, etc? Not sure what you mean there.
Everything else sounds good, so let's just clear up this single thing and then I'll submit for confirmation...
Really, really glad for you, Whitley. You worked a long time here...
8:59pm
Whitley Blaine
I mean that experience is perceived without the preconceived notion of "self"...it's hard to explain, basically i don't feel like i'm looking "through" self at reality so much. And when there is identification with the "I" it is seen for what it is pretty quickly
9:33pm
Lisa Hamilton
Not sure if I get it yet; do you mean that the 'human' is what is left when identification with the "I" collapses? If so, is it an entity, or... ??
9:38pm
Whitley Blaine
When identification with the "I" collapses, I perceive the world without looking through the "filter" of "I". I don't know how else to describe it other than it feels like I'm perceiving the world...directly, in a way.
I really don't know
what to say lol I guess I could re-answer the question differently.
Today
8:35am
Lisa Hamilton
I think I get it, Whitley... and I'm fine with it. If the guides who take a look at this have any further questions I'll pass them along. I'll get all this over to them and we'll go from there.