Hi Nic,
1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
No there is not. There is no separate entity , me or I . It is a shadow, a claim, an illusion. Something that it is claimed is real but cannot be found or located in direct experience. There was never an I. Any interaction with such an I requires thought to kick in to keep the grand illusion in place.
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
The illusion of a separate self is a mistaken belief. It is like adding 2+2 and believe it creates 5 because you are unaware your whole premise and foundation of maths is incorrect. The illusion of a separate self is like walking into your kitchen and seeing a milk bottle spilt on the floor and a cat standing over it covered in milk. The thinking mind concludes that it knows for sure that the cat must have spilt the milk.
So it creates a whole narrative (and identity) around this idea. Yet the thinking mind doesn’t know that the cat could have been planted there by someone else who wanted it to look like the cat did it.
That is the illusion of the separate self. All the evidence seems to point to an I. ‘I’ seems to have a name a form a body an identity etc etc clothes a house a car a job. However when I itself is to be found and not the things pertaining to I, it cannot be seen. Only “reactions” of “I” or “effects of I” but not this so called I itself
It has no physical shape, no colour, no tone, no specific location , and can only be engage with my conjuring up thoughts about it, which are not it but again something pertaining to it.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
It feels such a relief to see this , as it’s something I’ve always known but not been able to clearly articulate in my head’. I’ve always kinda got this but now I see how the illusion works how it is out together , and I can see how suffering has kept it in place for me. Suffering has reinforced this I and kept me in a search for an end to it. Now I see that the idea of an entity suffering who needs to figure out how to make it stop , has just kept me in a kind of loop of suffering and strengthened the feels of a separate I.
Now I see that the illusion of separation is the suffering. This idea there is someone for whom things have some how gone wrong has perpetuated this belief of not being able to get it right. Now I feel that no matter how much the thinking mind insists there is and never will be evidence of an I entity.
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over; made you look?
Recent events of mass panic in the media. I could see so clearly how people were filling in gaps in stories and getting 5! I hadn’t seen clearly so far that that’s what I was doing in relation to the very idea of a self. I could see how implying something was true would automatically prompt the thinking mind into filling in the gaps and creating a reality. I recently saw that that’s what I have been doing with my very self! Seeing the ‘iconography’ apparently connected to ‘my life’ and creating a whole entity that ‘must’ exist- irrespective of the evidence.
5) Describe decision, intention, free will, choice and control. What makes things happen? How does it work? What are you responsible for? Give examples from experience.
Decision is an illusion. A thought that comes after and says “I did that”. It is an after thought of a false identity attempting to assert its realness by pleading guilty to the action! Decision however always comes after the event (a realisation of it does). A memory of us deciding.
Intention is a thought projected into the future attached to the natural flow of life. Life flows and thoughts arise and mind says “that’s my intention”- (simile to decision). It’s mind or illusory thoughts way of claiming identity. However the thought of intention and the eventual
Outcome arise spontaneously with no input from anyone.
Free will- the ‘me’ thoughts’ best attempt to claim it is real. It is a kind of agreement that we all assume must be (for whatever reason, religious , moral etc) and so the idea of free will is assigned to a me. However as I clearly saw with the hand lifting exercise - there is no I choosing. There is no I interacting with a choice there is just action. Free will is an after story copied and pasted onto life to attempt to validate the existence of a me.
Control. This is the me thoughts’ best weapon against anxiety. By suggesting before or after an event that ‘I’ chose to do it ‘me’ thought can hold onto the illusion of itself a while longer, and strengthen the illusion by asserti by asserting it was ‘me’ who actually made that choice and controlled things, so ‘me’ must be real.
Control is a projected thought into a completely boundless free life stream in order to attempt to validate the existence of an I.
6)
Anything to add?
Thank you ‘Nic’ so much ! Can’t wait for our next cosmic interactions!