Hi Samu,
LU guides must have been instructed to point out some things and leave some questions uncommented - am I right? I’ll bet there are good reasons for it too. e.g. answering some questions may not be beneficial to the one being guided.
It depends on the style you choose to take, but yes it's something like that ;). I do read all of your posts, every post of course, but sometimes a little focus and probing one particular issue or area helps. And many times the other questions fall away.
There is a body and a bunch of thoughts and beliefs that seem to be connected in some way. I don’t know how but they seem to go as a ‘package’. Or am I not seeing something there?
Okay so there is a body, there are thoughts and beliefs also as thoughts. Can you give an example of why they seem to be a package? For example, there is physical pain in the back and then a thought arises about that physical pain.
I hear you about forgetting how to define what 'I' is ;).
Separate vs. individual - I can’t define the difference between those either. What is it?
Perhaps because neither exist, other than as thoughts? What else could they be? For example, some cultures may not even 'think' of themselves as an individual such as in a collectivist society. A different way of
thinking.
So let’s say there is no “I” but there is an individual body and experience - can’t we call that combo an “I”
Do you mean for the sake of communicating and convenience? Or that the body and experience make up a real thing called 'I'?
The body is the single individual. And the mess of thoughts/beliefs seem to be individual as well. I can’t tell that anyone has access to experience, that would suggest that there’s someone who is experiencing and something that is experienced and only the experience can be found, not the one who is experiencing. This sounds like an inner conflict, I know :) I’m messed up it seems…
Take a minute and look go through your senses. What do you see, hear, smell, taste, touch? Do you see a body? Do you hear thoughts? Do you see an individual? Do you hear/smell/taste/touch, an individual?
Where does 'Individual' live, where in experience does it reside exactly?
No separate self but still control over just a single body - that would suggest there is some sort of separate unit driving just one body (or each body) instead of all bodies or all life. So that’s what’s causing conflict here, limitation to a single body and the experience attached to it while there shouldn’t be any separation.
It shouldn't be like this according to who or to what? It seems there is an assumption that no separation = no individuality? What's really happening?
-Can you lift 'your' arm up?
-Can you lift up the arm of someone else (with a decision)?
-Can you find two separate 'things'?
If you say your 'body' is separate, consider what will eventually happen if your body was buried...It is a lump of earth, no? Was it really separate?
so this is where the ‘point’ out of which experience is experienced (does that make sense?):
tactile = within assumed borders of the body (I can’t directly shut this sense off or hinder it really upon will)
visual = there seems to be a place somewhere behind the eyes where the recording of experience is happening
auditive = somewhere behind the ears, otherwise same as above
smelling = somewhere behind the nostrils, otherwise same as above
tasting = somewhere inside the mouth, otherwise same as above
Does this come from thought/assumption, or from a direct experience of the senses?
-Do you see something in the eyes, or do you just see?
-Do you hear something in the ears, or do you just hear sounds?
-Do you smell something in the nose or is there just smell?
-Do you taste something in the mouth, or is there just taste?
All that is necessary is to notice whether something comes from a thought, or from the senses. Remember the back side of the cup exercise? Put an object in front of you. How do you know the back side of that object exists? Is it directly from your senses, i.e. you see the back side, or is it being assumed by thought?
So can you see where I’m lost?
Yes. Try and notice just like the cup exercise where information is coming from. "I see things behind the eyes", is this actually experienced or is it that you see things and you feel a sensation behind the eyes and have thoughts that suggest sight happens behind the eyes?
Hug,
Wesley