Re: Help me see the absence of separate self
Posted: Sun Jul 12, 2026 7:41 am
Hi Thomas,
I haven't been active here but I just got an email notifying me of your post.
I'm going to cut to the chase: Every time you look for 'I', you find something within experience (either a thought or a sensation). If you can find 'I' within experience, then what makes it so different from all other experience? If it's a thought/sensation, what makes it so different from other thoughts and sensations?
Is it always there? When immersed in an activity, isn't there no sense of 'I' at all, but you still have your other sensations obviously in experience? So if it's not required to experience anything else, and it's not permanent, and it's noticeable/observable just like all other experience, do you think that it could really be 'you' or anything special? Or maybe it's just a thought/sensation you've learned to label as 'I'?
Anyway, it doesn't matter what you label it as. But now that you've noticed the seer/observer/I is just another thought/sensation, my question is: Who's noticing that thought?
Who notices that "it always points back either to a thought or to a sensation"?
Who notices that "it's circular again"?
Does anyone notice? Does anyone generate those thoughts? Or do they appear spontaneously and then disappear again? Is there anyone here who is "observing" the sense of I? Or is the sense of I simply there independently? Is the sensation in your head felt by anyone, or is it just there, by itself?
It would help to be in a clear, quiet headspace when exploring these questions.
I haven't been active here but I just got an email notifying me of your post.
I'm going to cut to the chase: Every time you look for 'I', you find something within experience (either a thought or a sensation). If you can find 'I' within experience, then what makes it so different from all other experience? If it's a thought/sensation, what makes it so different from other thoughts and sensations?
Is it always there? When immersed in an activity, isn't there no sense of 'I' at all, but you still have your other sensations obviously in experience? So if it's not required to experience anything else, and it's not permanent, and it's noticeable/observable just like all other experience, do you think that it could really be 'you' or anything special? Or maybe it's just a thought/sensation you've learned to label as 'I'?
Anyway, it doesn't matter what you label it as. But now that you've noticed the seer/observer/I is just another thought/sensation, my question is: Who's noticing that thought?
Who notices that "it always points back either to a thought or to a sensation"?
Who notices that "it's circular again"?
Does anyone notice? Does anyone generate those thoughts? Or do they appear spontaneously and then disappear again? Is there anyone here who is "observing" the sense of I? Or is the sense of I simply there independently? Is the sensation in your head felt by anyone, or is it just there, by itself?
It would help to be in a clear, quiet headspace when exploring these questions.