Re: Guess it's time
Posted: Sun Oct 14, 2018 12:37 pm
Thank you. I did the exercise, let’s see.
Of course, these triggers are themselves thoughts. Seeing a plant is just colors, and thoughts label the sensation and come up with ‘plant’ and related thoughts and memories surrounding this concept.
So it is not necessarily surprising what kind of thoughts come up. But it is impossible to tell which exact thoughts will come up and also which ‘triggers’ are going to be activated. And I can see that - if you have no direct say in what thoughts come up, then there is no free will. Since a lot of actions are based on thoughts.
I’ve been staring at my hand a lot too. Just moving it like you instructed, and finding a ‘mover’ that moves the hand. It’s still not there. But still, I just can’t seem to get rid of the feeling that there is control over the body. So the hand is not moving because of thoughts, because thought is not needed for movement. But still it feels like the impulse to move comes from me and I have direct control over this.
So this is what I’m not seeing clearly. I can’t find a ‘me’ doing the moving, but somewhere I’m not convinced. Not sure how to explain this.
💛
I cannot determine what the next thought is going to be. But the thoughts that come are not really surprising, since they usually have something to do with recent thoughts. Or the thoughts are triggered by something in the environment.Can you do this? Isn’t a thought only known as it appears? In that case, can you possibly clam to be in control of the thinking process, the thoughts, choices or impulses that arise, unless you can somehow investigate them beforehand?
Of course, these triggers are themselves thoughts. Seeing a plant is just colors, and thoughts label the sensation and come up with ‘plant’ and related thoughts and memories surrounding this concept.
So it is not necessarily surprising what kind of thoughts come up. But it is impossible to tell which exact thoughts will come up and also which ‘triggers’ are going to be activated. And I can see that - if you have no direct say in what thoughts come up, then there is no free will. Since a lot of actions are based on thoughts.
This is true. If ‘I’ had a say in this, I would only think happy thoughts.Do you have unpleasant thoughts? Do you want to have them? If you had any control over thoughts, don’t you think you would choose not to think such thoughts at all?
Wouldn’t you be able to choose never to have thoughts that seem to make you unhappy?
No. I can’t find a me in the ‘me’ thoughts. It is only thoughts built upon thoughts. And this creates an sense of me.Can you ever find a ‘me’ within the “me” thoughts and feelings, or just a sense of me?
They just arise. There used to be the idea that they arise in the head, but the head is just a concept. There’s just arising. It’s a sensation that’s experienced and it leaves no trace.Where are they arising?
Are they inside something?
Are they central to you, or are they peripheral?
Do they leave any trace when they have gone?
I’ve been staring at my hand a lot too. Just moving it like you instructed, and finding a ‘mover’ that moves the hand. It’s still not there. But still, I just can’t seem to get rid of the feeling that there is control over the body. So the hand is not moving because of thoughts, because thought is not needed for movement. But still it feels like the impulse to move comes from me and I have direct control over this.
So this is what I’m not seeing clearly. I can’t find a ‘me’ doing the moving, but somewhere I’m not convinced. Not sure how to explain this.
💛