Re: Skeptical but Open
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2014 5:02 pm
They say the role of the teacher is not to answer the questions but instead to question the answers. Thanks for the teaching.
Liberation Unleashed Forum The Gate
https://liberationunleashed.com:443/nation/
https://liberationunleashed.com:443/nation/viewtopic.php?t=2920
From your present perspective, was there ever a separate self that was able to create anything? Is there anything now that has intrinsic needs and wants?.My personality/ego/separate self created the coping strategies (thoughts) necessary to hide my vulnerabilities and still meet as many of my basic and intrinsic needs as well as my wants, as possible.
Please look at the question again. I do need you to answer the questions in detail from your current experience. Let me know if the question is not clear to you.besupax wrote:
In regard to question 5 please provide more details from your current experience. E.g. what happens between being hungry, having 3 food options, and finally cook or buy one of them? Is there a chooser there? Also, what goes on when you are falling asleep? Is there at any time a `me` needed or involved in deciding/controlling?In the 2 days since this experienced occurred there have been many experiences. None of them have been anything different than the days prior. What has changed is the perspective from which I see them. The squirrel is still the squirrel but yet now I see it as an expression of life. In the same vein, my reactions to seeing the squirrel are also an expression of life. These 2 days have been amazing. Seeing from this perspective (I can almost hear your question already, what is seeing...this expression of life is seeing) is like seeing through new eyes.
No, there has never been a separate self able to create anything. Life creates. Even intrinsic needs and wants are life expressions.From your present perspective, was there ever a separate self that was able to create anything? Is there anything now that has intrinsic needs and wants?.
The options are there as a result of life happening, choosing happens as a result of life happening. There is no chooser nor is there a need for a chooser. Nothing and everything goes on when falling asleep. There is no true me, there has never been a true me, and there never will be. What there is is an expression of life that has a label of me.In regard to question 5 please provide more details from your current experience. E.g. what happens between being hungry, having 3 food options, and finally cook or buy one of them? Is there a chooser there? Also, what goes on when you are falling asleep? Is there at any time a `me` needed or involved in deciding/controlling?
Does the review team what any further clarification of these questions?Here are your final questions:
1. Is there a separate entity "self", "me", "I" at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
2. Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
3. How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
4. What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
5. Do you decide, intend, choose, control events in Life? Do you make anything happen? Give examples from your
current experience.
6. Anything to add?
Now, please find the person who crossed the threshold. Also, could you please describe the threshold? Can the threshold be found in direct experience? What is the continued growth you are talking about here?the point was for me to cross over a threshold. Perhaps the threshold I crossed is of a different perspective of others but it is sufficient for me (the life expression of me). It has truly helped me see and be from a new place. It is a new stepping stone for continued growth.
My word, this is getting old. When is it ok to use the word me without having to change the terminology to 'expression of life'?Now, please find the person who crossed the threshold.
Threshold is the terminology used by Liberation Unleashed. For me, please save the who is the person question again, was the realization that both internal and external formations were expressions of life. Additionally, beliefs, ideologies, personalities, ego's, etc were also expressions of life. Even the thoughts that are recognizing that the thoughts are expression of life are being recognized as expressions of life.Also, could you please describe the threshold?
I (the expression of life with a label) does not understand the point of the query. What is there to experience anything directly? What is experience? Is experience something that exists outside Life?Can the threshold be found in direct experience?
This observation (see my last answer) (observation - another expression of life) is in of itself a opportunity for further introspection (continued growth). Believing that gaining insight into the concept of no-self is the end of the search for truth is a self-imposed (expression of life) limitation of capabilities. Life itself constantly reveals itself to be limitless and as expressions of life we have the same potential.What is the continued growth you are talking about here?
What is an I?Once seen through the illusion it is not possible to forget. Am I right?
More 'you' and 'me'. It seems 'you' can use the term but 'I' cannot.Can you tolerate a little more discomfort and stick with me?
Using the terms I, me, my, etc.. carry a different perspective but apparently only others are allowed to use the term to communicate.Sometimes it is hard to communicate the "new experience" of not being seperate.
Seeing there is no-self was the gate. Passing through the gate was the understanding and seeing and bringing that understanding/perspective and integrating it back into daily life. This is not a concept, it is.Let's make 100% sure that you are all the way through and didn't get stuck in a concept of no-self.
This contradicts the statement above regarding being stuck in the concept of no-self. That said, nothing differently happens. Life is as it always is.What we are looking for is acknowledgement of how Life Happens when there is simply no self at all.
That is why I'd like a direct answer from your direct experience to the following question (without conceptualizing please):
There is no intention, decision, free will, choice, or control. The best example to share is the 5 minute no I exercise.Can you talk about decision, intention, free will, choice and control?
Yes! Absolutely!!!There is no intention, decision, free will, choice, or control.
Does life want or do you want? None of the responses are from two weeks ago.I want a clear answer from your direct experience (right now and not from 2 weeks ago).
The truth is the truth and requires no 'proving'. If that is what Liberation Unleashed is looking for then the purpose of the organization is flawed and I want no part of it. Knowing is knowing and requires no proof to anyone or anything. How can you prove life is life? If you know, Prove it. To my knowledge the human race has been trying to do just that for thousands of years and has yet to succeed.fuzz1961 wrote:There is no intention, decision, free will, choice, or control.
Yes! Absolutely!!!
But - imagine I was your best friend or your teenage daughter. How would you `prove` to me from your experience, so that I, who has never before heard anything like that, that this is true? I, as your best friend won`t just take for granted a statement `there is no intention...`. I want to know, how do you know?
Thanks for the trust...nothing I wrote was copied or rewritten from another source. I wrote as the directions requested, open and honest.You could have copied the statement above, that`s why I am looking for your words to describe your experience. And I know it is hard to describe a `no` something. So please give it your best shot.
I wish this exercise had not turned out this way but it is life being itself just as my wishing it wasn't so is also life just being. Similarly any character traits are all just life expressions. Neither good or bad, they just are. As for finding another guide, what do you think would be the benefit? Based on this experience it would be difficult for me to use this process to help others so why should I go on? As you said my experience is all I need and I have that. For reasons that only life can comprehend I cannot communicate it you in a manner that is satisfactory. I'm ok with that.Would you feel more comfortable if another guide does the last bit of the final question(s) with you?