Dear Sunil,
Are you having a tantrum fit? Are you just sulking, little Daria?
Yes, I think I have been having a tantrum AND feeling sulky! I have hit a huge wall of resistance and feel like a bratty, angry child. It is painful to acknowledge, but doesn't make it any less true. So much resistance, pain, anger, frustration, grief, despair has come up for me (drawn from the collection of labels for some of the feelings) and it is hard to distinguish whether it is a reaction to this physical illness I am experiencing (numerous physical discomforts) and/or feeling stuck here. I feel completely fed up with living this way, yet here I am. I feel so stuck in such a dark place these past few days, it seems to be filtering everything making it very difficult to move forward in any positive way. I am going to make an effort here to see beyond this darkness ... I guess the positive here is that I don't care a bit about the "nice girl" and it seems easier to drop it and just "spill it" like it is without trying to uphold that image. One less piece of mental baggage. Thank you.
Of course it feels such as just an understanding will not do. It HAS to be direct experience, not understanding, belief or any of the mind things. Thoughts can not tell you anything true. Touch your hair again, what makes it hair, what makes it yours? This is not understanding, there is no mind needed here.
Thank you, this is exactly what I feel ... mental understanding won't cut it.
Nothing makes the hair to be hair in DE, it could be anything (before labeling) and nothing makes the hair mine. This is the experience.
We have to start from the top. Perhaps it would be easier this time.
What experiences a " me" in DE?
Assuming we are still okay with DE being the only determinant. If not, we can't proceed.
What is this you that is real? Are you the body? Are you the thoughts?
Why are you trying to force and what are you trying to force?
That illusion, which you say all evidence points to, means something other than false? Come on 4.0 girl.
ILLUSION is seeing something that is not there. And all evidence according to you points to you being an illusion.
Yes, ready to start again; I will not "censor" things that seem irrational or confused (that push my "I must be stupid/not smart enough" button), or do not make sense (the "nice, perfect 4.0 girl" needed to do that), but will just "spill it" straight up this time so perhaps it will be clearer where I am getting hung up:
In DE there is no me experienced ... just sensory data, impersonal (not attached to any-thing or anyone). There are sounds, sights, sensations, etc. just occurring.
I understand that DE can be the only determinant, or else we are dealing with labels/thoughts/mind/beliefs; still OK here.
This "me" that is real seems to be the one experiencing everything; this sensory data is received (somewhere, no idea where, can't find a place) and then interpreted to mean something happening within a context of a "me"; e.g., sensation in the head experienced, somehow labeled/interpreted as "throbbing pain in MY head, I am in pain." This me "knows" the experience of head pain from past experience of similar sensory data that has happened. This "real me" has a history of experiences/memories that feel "personal" and familiar that can be drawn upon "at will"; in other words, if "I" want to remember other experiences of head pain, I can draw them from memory banks and this occurs when "I" decide to do so (seemingly controlled by the will of an "I"). This seems to be where I get stuck; the interpretation/labeling part that creates a "familiar/personal I" is outside of DE so must be discarded as any evidence of an "I" if DE is the only determinant. If DE is the only determinant there is no evidence of any I ... so I see all the familiar personalized experience (described) happens after the DE. How can I accept that this personalized experience is NOT a me?
Am I the body? It sure feels that it is "my" body experiencing so many sensations right now; I don't feel the sensations happening in other bodies. Now I feel really stuck here too. I "know" I am not the body (because I have experienced continuing awareness when I have been outside my body) and that in DE there are only sensations that occur but without labeling/identifying them, they are only sensations, not "my headache" etc. Again this feels like a mental understanding, I don't know how to let go of accepting the personalized labels as real. On the Sounds True link that you sent, it was said that the body identification (my body, not my body) is neurologically embedded/programmed in the brain ... is this part of the problem here??!
Am I the thoughts? As they just arise, DE shows that "I" am not in control of them arising (or subsiding). However, "I" can bring up a particular thought or memory seemingly at will (this is tricky for me); however, this does not make ME the thoughts. I can see that thoughts create a "me". Without thoughts there are no constructs of a "me" "my body" "my thoughts." DE points to the fact that I am not the thoughts, and logic says that it takes thoughts to construct a me. This still seems to be a mental understanding as it still FEELS like there are "my thoughts" and I seem to be affected by them. Can't seem to shake this. I see that if I can fully accept that the thoughts are not "mine" the whole house of cards could fall without the labels to make it all a me.
Are we fighting here, sitaji? Read this again. "Not been able to fully accept no me" what does that mean. Are you going to ask an illusion to accept that she is not an illusion? Or not ask her to accept no she? What is this?
Oh, I am feel so stuck here! This is what I have just described ... DE shows me there is no me, just sensory experiences... and as soon as the labels get added, there is a me. I understand this, that thoughts can never tell me anything true, so I must be an illusion because I am (essentially) created by thought ... so I see your point - that it is absurd to ask an illusion to accept that she is not an illusion. I am ashamed to say, I still feel stuck here - logic (all evidence points to my being an illusion) doesn't seem to bring me to acceptance.
Look at the evidence, counsellor. Is Daria an illusion or not? If not, show me where she is and what she is? We define real those things we can directly experience.Redo the touch experience to find you in the body. The thought experiment to find the thinker.
I am going around and around in the same circles (4.0 and all) here. Defining real things as those we can directly experience by definition means Daria is an illusion as I cannot experience her by DE. 100% logical, totally points there and yet the rope still seems like a snake. HELP! Am I totally hopeless? I want to be fully honest here, that I still experience a snake ...
Another big word, the mind likes to throw out, a belief. What does belief mean to you? Do you believe in god, in santi clause, tooth fairy, superman? If the evidence isn't strong enough. Lets start there. Reiterate what makes you say " you have seen the evidence of no self?"
Belief means that I am absolutely convinced of the truth of something, that there is no doubt. And I am not absolutely convinced of no self as much as I would love to be. Here is the evidence I have seen of no self:
1) I have looked within and do not directly see any thing that is a self there
2) I see that sensory information comes (without my control) and is automatically labeled (from memory) without any conscious control of a self
3) I have seen that all thoughts and emotions arise without the control of a self and that "I" act as puppet in response (cause-effect)
4) With DE as the determinant, by definition there cannot be any evidence of a self because this requires a label which by definition cannot be DE
Do you actually experience that there is a you or is that just another thought?
Are all of these doubts just thoughts or direct experience? I need details on what's going on here.
I feel like we are going around in circles again, and that I just can't get this!! I do not experience a "me" in DE so it the experience of me has to be just another thought!!!!! YES, all of these doubts are (by definition) just thoughts too, as a doubt cannot be a DE because a doubt is a label/thought/identification, not a DE. I SEE THIS BUT I STILL FEEL STUCK. DE cannot be put into words or described or it is no longer DE. By definition, DE cannot be described and "doubts" and a "me" require description so they must be coming from thoughts/mind, not DE. HOW CAN I JUST ACCEPT I AM NOT A SELF???!!!! I see the logic and all I feel is frustrated and blind ...
And what makes you think that the superimposed belief is not just another thought from which you agree all doubts are coming?!
Logic tells me that the superimposed belief is just another thought and that doubts are just thoughts. DE wipes all that out. Is it that I have lived my life from thought and am not at all accustomed to accepting DE as the truth ...? Is this where I am stuck??
Just because some one thinks about a heinous crime doesn't make him a criminal. Just by thinking, one doesn't become as super model or a Nobel laureate. There is no qualitative difference between truth and a lie in thoughts. The only thing we can rely on is direct experience using your senses. You can smell the pizza, touch the table, see the lamp. They are there. You can think of Eiffel Tower and fly to Paris, verify that it is there. What will you see when you go to verify Daria? The body. Is that you?
Same issue here. DE will never verify Daria or the body as being me.
Are you by any chance, so used to the suffering that you find a life without such crutches threatening? Would you be able to face the acupuncturist if you don't bring flowers? What would happen if she doesn't like you? What if she tells you off? Gives you a cold shoulder. Is that the end of your life as you know it?
I just don't know if this is the case. I am absolutely sick and tired of suffering and do not believe that I would consciously choose it. Yes, without it, this would be the end of my life as I know it, and I cannot imagine that I would not welcome this even if fear (of unknown) arises.
Or do you want the 60's peace and love for all? Are there expectations you can never fulfill and hoping seeing the truth will make them all come true? I know all of this, for I too am a child of the same era, conditioned the same way with heart breaks even happening today. Only difference is dear that it is just happening because of Big Bang. There is no me to change this now nor was there ever although I too was under the illusion that I could make it happen. Or are you afraid you will become too nihilistic and give up doing anything?
Yes, I do like the 60's peace and love for all. And yes, I do hold some hope that seeing the truth will bring more love and peace but I am not sure how this holds me back from accepting a no self. I have never been on any bandwagon to change the world, my only real desire is to change my understanding to reflect what is true, even if it is not peace and love for all.
One more thought for you. If you were in control of your life, made all the decisions and present all the way through would you bring all these suffering to your body and mind? Would you really need to be here, doing this? Would anyone suffer?
Great point. I cannot imagine consciously bringing all of this suffering to my body (and it is suffering greatly at present) and mind!! It makes absolutely no sense at all. If I were in control of my life, I would surely not purposefully bring this suffering to anyone.
BTW, Thank you for the link from Sounds True; I found it very interesting, especially the part about how the brain is programmed to be hypervigilant throughout the night looking for predators (based on 1000's of years of human existence). That is precisely what I experience, and explains it perfectly!! I awaken with a panicky feeling, deep seated fear of being harmed in some way. As he explained, most people just forget it and go back to sleep, but I am really sensitive and aware of it happening. This makes perfect sense, and is another perfect example of programming ...
As I finish this, I notice an anxiety about your disapproval arising ("she is hopeless, can't accept what is in front of her nose" etc.), of not fulfilling my "nice girl, sugar-coating people-pleaser" image. And I realize that all of that just places obstacles in my getting closer to the truth. So be it, I've just "spilled it."
Love, Sita/Daria