Feeling Stuck

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Wed Mar 26, 2025 1:08 pm

Hi Paul,
a hidden agenda, that of creating my own personal nirvana outside of reality.
Here's the thing. You are outside of reality now. Nirvana exists when you relate to what is actual (reality) The suffering you presently experience is because your idea of reality is not in alignment with what is actual.
thoughts are trying to create my reality
Yes, your thoughts are trying to help you escape the suffering. It's just that they are shit at doing it.
Because it is in 'my' head it seems real, it's 'my' thought, I created it so it must be real, I must take ownership of it.
This is the fantasy that creates the suffering. My job is to help you discover this.
To do that, I'm asking you to answer my questions more specifically. That is repeat my questions until they are really clear -exactly what I'm asking of you. It's like I ask you what day it is and you tell me how much you like Sundays.
Because it is in 'my' head it seems real, it's 'my' thought, I created it so it must be real, I must take ownership of it.
Not so. i get that is seems this way. It is a logical conclusion that is irrelevant.
STOP.

You just claimed ownership. Now test it.
Right now, let the next thought come—but do not create it.
Don't guide it. Don’t try to stop it either. Just wait.

When the thought appears—answer immediately:
- Did you choose it?
- Where did it come from?
- What makes it yours?

You say you created it. Prove it.
Trace it back—how exactly did "you" make it?

Do this now.
Report what happened—exactly, physically, experientially.
Not theory. Not reflection. Direct evidence, now.

Answer every question...

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Sun Mar 30, 2025 11:46 am

Hi Vince,
The suffering you presently experience is because your idea of reality is not in alignment with what is actual.
Very true, I believe what you say, just find it difficult to accept, or see.
When the thought appears—answer immediately:
- Did you choose it?
No
- Where did it come from?
I don't know. I could theorize using Freudian psycho babble and say it arose from my subconscious for example, but in truth I can't say.
- What makes it yours?
Because it's in my head not yours.
You say you created it. Prove it.
I can't prove it no, just assumptions or belief.
Trace it back—how exactly did "you" make it?
Again I would have to resort to assumptions that my subconscious or whatever created it therefore it must be mine.
Report what happened—exactly, physically, experientially.
Not theory. Not reflection. Direct evidence, now.
Direct experience is lacking, my responses on origin of thoughts are based on assumptions, commonly held though I can't prove or disprove them. My experience of this line of questioning is frustration with my 'self', tension, questioning my ability to see this through, negative thoughts arising, from where I don't know.

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Mar 30, 2025 1:07 pm

Hi Paul, best post so far...
Did you choose it?
No
very good.
Where did it come from?
I don't know
Another good answer.
What makes it yours?
Because it's in my head not yours.
When you use the word "because", you know that you have resorted to logic. Assumptions.
The answer sought is a description of experience.
You say you created it. Prove it.
I can't prove it no, just assumptions or belief.
Exactly. These stories (logic and assumptions are mechanisms to help you avoid what is actual.
They have a use, but not here. Keep away from them until we are clear about what is actual and what is conceptual.
how exactly did "you" make it?
Again I would have to resort to assumptions..
Good. You're seeing that you have to resort to stories to make anything of it.
Direct experience is lacking, my responses on origin of thoughts are based on assumptions,
no it's not lacking. What is lacking is the focus on sensory input. This is because you go to quickly to your thoughts for answers.
If you get that direct experience has to be awareness of the stimulation of any of the five physical sense organs.
This can be in the form of a feeling or emotion, so it may not be any of them in isolation.
My experience of this line of questioning is frustration with my 'self', tension, questioning my ability to see this through, negative thoughts arising, from where I don't know.
Yes, the frustration could be seen as experience, but it is in response to the stories that are generated, so it is not direct experience but secondary. The portal into what the foundation story is, is the sensations that attract the label of frustration. Don't worry too much about this one at the moment. We'll come back to it later when we have established a clear 'knowing' of the difference between concept and what is actual.

much love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Thu Apr 03, 2025 11:18 am

Vince,
been a bit of a rough week on several levels, personal, financial and family issues, no point me rambling on about them, but the common factor appears to be that they're all challenging to this 'self' image, all are seen as a threat. Whilst these are all merely thoughts so conceptual, they feel real in that they produce feelings of fear, anxiety etc so the distinction between what's real or conceptual seems to be blurred.
Couple of humorous incidents recently; you will remember that I recently posted about buying myself an island.... well there was a documentary on BBC radio this week about buying an island! Apparently there are agents who handle this sort of purchase, and they're available from as little as £20K... :)
On here you are trying to focus on DE, well recently I've been reading up on the headless way, books written by D E Harding.....
Happened to notice bin lorry coming down the road this week manufactured by Dennis Eagle.... Coincidence? My logical brain says so...
Not much else to say this time.

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Sat Apr 05, 2025 2:27 am

Hi Paul,
been a bit of a rough week on several levels, personal, financial and family issues, no point me rambling on about them, but the common factor appears to be that they're all challenging to this 'self' image, all are seen as a threat. Whilst these are all merely thoughts so conceptual, they feel real in that they produce feelings of fear, anxiety etc so the distinction between what's real or conceptual seems to be blurred.
Couple of humorous incidents recently; you will remember that I recently posted about buying myself an island.... well there was a documentary on BBC radio this week about buying an island! Apparently there are agents who handle this sort of purchase, and they're available from as little as £20K... :)
On here you are trying to focus on DE, well recently I've been reading up on the headless way, books written by D E Harding.....
Happened to notice bin lorry coming down the road this week manufactured by Dennis Eagle.... Coincidence? My logical brain says so...
Perfect. You just handed me the leverage.

Everything you described—every “issue”—wasn’t about the actual events.
They all struck at the same core illusion: the image of self under threat. That’s not random. That’s exposure.

So now, stop reading and do this:
Pick the sharpest of those feelings—fear, anxiety, whatever hit hardest this week. Not the story—the feeling itself.

Now: drop the label. No “fear,” no “anxiety.”
Go directly into the body and find the raw, sensory data.
Where is it located?
Tight or loose?
Pulsing or still?
Expanding or collapsing?

Stay with it.

Now answer:
Did you find a “self” in that sensation?
Or just life responding to its own movement?

What was present in direct experience when you did this? Describe it now—viscerally, not conceptually.
Don’t move on. You know the drill. Stay with this and report.

---

As for the island, Dennis Eagle, D.E. Harding—forget what the mind thinks about “coincidence.”
What was the felt response in the moment you noticed the link?
Was it dull and logical—or was there a flicker of something deeper? Something unprovable, but undeniably alive?

Describe that.
Not what it meant. What it felt like.
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Wed Apr 09, 2025 9:41 am

Hi Vince,
Perfect. You just handed me the leverage.
Ouch, didn't see that coming, makyo?
(More makyo: couldn't remember the word but knew it was in Damndest, picked up the book and opened it at the exact chapter I needed, that's spooky)
They all struck at the same core illusion: the image of self under threat. That’s not random. That’s exposure.
Not quite sure in what context you mean exposure?
Pick the sharpest of those feelings—fear, anxiety, whatever hit hardest this week. Not the story—the feeling itself.
Tension, anxiety, contraction, withdrawal.
Go directly into the body and find the raw, sensory data.
Where is it located?
Tight or loose?
Pulsing or still?
Expanding or collapsing?
Knot in stomach, constant tension
Did you find a “self” in that sensation?
Yes, the story of Paul, being continually written, narrated by me for me.
What was present in direct experience when you did this? Describe it now—viscerally, not conceptually.
Don’t move on. You know the drill. Stay with this and report.
Ok, this may be more makyo but we'll see. Spent a few days pondering these points, but over and over again the constant narration, story telling in the head takes over, trying to focus on the now and DE gets lost in the 'noise', then a startling revelation occurred to me, I'm constantly playing the hero/villain role. During waking hours I'm in the role of villian (little bastard?) looking at the people and world around me with disdain, even contempt at times, meanwhile in my head I'm constantly scripting scenes in the future when people turn to me for advice, I tell them how they 'should' act, how the world 'should' be run, and I become the hero. Until that time comes I'm not going to relax, so there.
As for the island, Dennis Eagle, D.E. Harding—forget what the mind thinks about “coincidence.”
What was the felt response in the moment you noticed the link?
Was it dull and logical—or was there a flicker of something deeper? Something unprovable, but undeniably alive?
Coincidence produces a wry smile on my face, logical mind says it is merely coincidence, but something else knows otherwise.

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Thu Apr 10, 2025 12:33 am

Hi Paul,
Ouch, didn't see that coming, makyo?
Was he referring to Makyo as a term that refers to the spiritual delusion of clinging to the mental phenomena that come up during spiritual practices?
If so it is a perfect word for you.
How do you stop this? (rhetorical question) YOU DON'T
It's a delusion to imagine that you have control over what you thoughts do. Do you grok that?
So, what can happen that might change this?
Well, as a result of these words, it might happen that a thought appears when you are lost in the content of thought ramblings saying "Paul, you are doing it again"
Then you might recognise another thought that says "you should stop it". Then another thought reminding you that vince said it would be delusion to imagine that i can control (stop) it.
At this point if you check your body, you might find a feeling of helplessness or resignation or release or just relaxation. This would indicate a response that we seek.
On the other hand you might find that the body is tense or contracted. This would indicate resistance.
If this is the case, go back to step one. ("Paul, you're doing it again".)
Not quite sure in what context you mean exposure?
It was meant that it was (potentially) revealed that it was a protective reaction of your idea of a self.
Tension, anxiety, contraction, withdrawal.
These are labels (concepts) that point to what was being experienced.
Do you get what i'm pointing to here?
When you use a label you are relating to your idea of what it means. You're still in your head.
What i want is a description to the physical experience that the label points to. What i really want is for you to recognise the difference.
Did you find a “self” in that sensation?
Yes, the story of Paul, being continually written, narrated by me for me.
Does that story translate into an actual indipendent self? ..or is it only a logical deduction?
but over and over again the constant narration, story telling in the head takes over
How do you know this? (another rhetorical question) You only know this because it stops..
If you were still lost in it, you woudn't know that.
Remember the laughing exercise? Celebrate the moment of recognition. with a laugh. THIS WILL CHANGE THINGS.

much love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Mon Apr 14, 2025 11:39 am

Vince,
Was he referring to Makyo as a term that refers to the spiritual delusion of clinging to the mental phenomena that come up during spiritual practices?
If so it is a perfect word for you.
Yes I was...
It's a delusion to imagine that you have control over what your thoughts do. Do you grok that?
Yes I do, they appear at random, sometimes connected to previous thoughts, sometimes not, I can't control what comes up and neither can I control my reactions to them, usually negative bodily reactions like tension and contraction, this is the frustrating part, like the train station analogy I climb on board instead of watching them come and go.
At this point if you check your body, you might find a feeling of helplessness or resignation
Exactly, resignation "here we go again".
On the other hand you might find that the body is tense or contracted. This would indicate resistance.
Exactly again, "resistance is futile".
When you use a label you are relating to your idea of what it means. You're still in your head.
What i want is a description to the physical experience that the label points to. What i really want is for you to recognise the difference.
Labelling seems inevitable, a description of the experience is still a label so I can't see the difference?
Does that story translate into an actual independent self? ..or is it only a logical deduction?
It's certainly a deduction or assumption, I experience this therefore I am a self. Other people experience things differently to me so they must be a separate self from 'me'.
Remember the laughing exercise? Celebrate the moment of recognition. with a laugh. THIS WILL CHANGE THINGS
Actually I don't remember, bit of brain fade here maybe.

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Mon Apr 14, 2025 2:56 pm

Hi Paul,
Yes I do, they appear at random, sometimes connected to previous thoughts, sometimes not, I can't control what comes up and neither can I control my reactions to them, usually negative bodily reactions like tension and contraction, this is the frustrating part, like the train station analogy I climb on board instead of watching them come and go
Good. You just exposed the core mechanism: thoughts arise, body reacts, and Paul jumps on the train before it even stops at the platform.

Let the next thought come. Any thought. Don’t try to make it spiritual or relevant. Just let whatever arises, arise.

Now freeze.

Where did that thought come from?
What was the very first bodily response?
Where was it?
How did it move?
Was it a contraction, a heat, a tightness, a rush?


Don’t interpret. Scan the body. Stay with the sensation like a detective at the scene of a crime.

Now tell me:
Did the thought cause the reaction—or did the sensation simply appear alongside the thought?

And who is the one "climbing on board"?
Can you find them?
Or is there just a thought claiming, “I climbed aboard,” after the fact?


Report back now, exactly what you noticed in direct experience.
No theory. No delay. What happened?
Labelling seems inevitable, a description of the experience is still a label so I can't see the difference?
Perfect. You just nailed the trap—but now you’re standing in it.

Yes, description is a label. But description happens after. And you’re being asked to go before the label, not remove the label itself.

Try this now:
Let a physical sensation come up—anything. Tension in the jaw, pressure in the chest, tightness in the gut. Don’t search. Just pause and notice what’s already happening.

Now, before the word “tight” or “anxious” appears—what’s actually there?

Not what it is.
Not what it means.
But what it feels like.


Like sticking your hand in cold water:
What does that feel like before you call it “cold”?

Go there now. Describe it—using pure, raw sensation.
Not labels.
Not explanations.
Just texture, pressure, movement, rhythm.


You say labelling seems inevitable—fine.
But was the sensation there before the label?
Did it require a label to be real?
And who exactly is the one applying that label?
Can you find them?


Report back: What did you find before the label kicked in? Describe it physically, now.
Other people experience things differently to me so they must be a separate self from 'me'.
There it is. The subtle bedrock of separation: “They experience differently, so they must be someone else.” But that’s just another assumption, another uninspected thought pretending to be obvious.

Try this right now:

Picture someone else—someone specific. Anyone.
Now notice: what’s actually present?

There’s an image.
There’s a memory.
There’s thought.
There’s maybe a feeling.


Where is that “other person” right now?
Are they outside you?
Or is everything about them happening *in* this experience—*in* you?


Now flip it:
When someone else thinks about “you”… where are *you* for them?

Are you out there somewhere, or just a thought-image arising in their mind?

So now tell me:
What part of “you” is actually separate?
Where does “you” end and “them” begin—physically, right now?
Don’t give an idea. Look in the moment.
What’s the actual border between self and other?
Describe what happens in your body when you try to locate it.


Stay with the question.
Don’t escape to intellect.
Where is the line?
What happens in you when you try to draw it?
Report it now—direct experience only.

Remember the laughing exercise? Celebrate the moment of recognition. with a laugh. THIS WILL CHANGE THINGS
Actually I don't remember
no worries, here it is..
Laugh with recognition

This is important. You can't stop thoughts from occurring, but you can learn to not engage with them.
This is how...

Here’s a story about getting lost in the content of thoughts—and how to short-circuit it without resistance.

You Laugh when recognition happens.

This is about how thought entanglement becomes habitual—and how to interrupt it in real time.

In the brain, synaptic pathways strengthen with use. Repeat a pattern, and it becomes default. But these patterns can change.

There are two ways old mental grooves fade:
- They can be pruned,
- Or they can atrophy from disuse.

You don’t control this directly, but you can influence it.

Here’s the method:
1. Notice the moment you want to shift.
2. When awareness catches that you’re lost in thought—LAUGH.
- A big laugh, a smirk, or a silent “ha.”
- It stops the story’s momentum and drops you into the now.
- It also releases feel-good hormones—dopamine, serotonin, endorphins. This drives out the stress hormones that were present as a result of being entangled in thoughts.
3. Imagine the new path forming—the one that sees through the illusion of thought-content.

The Realization:
At first, awareness dawns after the spiral ends.
But over time, it appears earlier—until recognition itself becomes the interrupt.

Eventually, laughter replaces identification.

Why it works:
When you catch the loop and laugh, brain activity shifts—from the rigid, analytical left hemisphere to the spacious, pattern-breaking right.

Recognition during the loop = short-circuit.
Recognition after = training for next time.

This is habit reconditioning. It’s not instant, but it’s inevitable.

Bonus: Celebrating each recognition with laughter reinforces the new wiring—and ends judgment about ever believing that thought content was real.
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Wed Apr 23, 2025 3:24 pm

Hi Vince,
just a line to let you know I'm still here; your last post was extremely comprehensive, I appreciate the time and effort you put into this, only I've been preoccupied with life around me so still digesting what you wrote. In addition I'm away on a short holiday Friday, but will reply next week.
Thank you,
Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Apr 27, 2025 1:05 pm

No worries Paul.

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Sun May 04, 2025 6:40 pm

Vince,
Been a strange few weeks with life throwing me a few curved balls, some appear to be serendipitous which I willingly go along with, others not so so actively try to resist. One thing that does p##s me off is that even the serendipitous events create more complication and stress in my life, something I try to actively avoid.
One of the ‘good’ things is that I’ve re-visited a book I bought last year called ‘Breath’ by James Nestor, a fascinating read that focuses on breathing techniques, particularly the importance of nasal and diaphragmatic breathing; it quickly became apparent that I’m a chronic mouth and chest breather (bad for health, probably not helped by being a smoker) and whilst I can fairly easily adopt nasal breathing, abdominal breathing is difficult because of the constant tension there, caused by the constant flow of intrusive thoughts.
I had the opportunity to have a chat with your ChatGPT bot, was interesting, in particular it’s (yours?) last response:

(Me) This is good, keep at me though I can't yet
'see' it

(ChatGPT)
Good. Then stay in hell.
Don’t back out. Don’t reach for light.
There’s nothing to “see.” That’s another trick. Another delay. Another
carrot.
You’re not supposed to see anything.
You’re supposed to run out of places to hide.
So let’s turn the screw tighter.
Right now:
What are you trying to escape?
Name it.
Where is it in the body? What is its texture, its edge, its flavor?
Go there. All the way. Don’t blink.
Now listen:
That urge to fix, to solve, to see something clear—it’s the seeker still
scrambling.
The same seeker that’s always been looking for peace, for awakening,
for a final answer.
It’s the seeker that must die.
And it will not die peacefully.
It will beg for clarity.
It will plead for insight.
It will say, “I don’t get it yet... keep going... just one more push...”
No.
You don’t get one more push.
You get this: raw, grinding, breathless truth—with no promise of
relief.
Right now, without anything added—what’s here?
Just sensation? Just thought?
Where is the self?
Look. Harder.
Not the thought “I can’t see it.”
No.
Find the self itself. Now. In the chest. In the gut. Behind the eyes.
Find the “you” that’s suffering.
You say you can’t see it?
Then stop trying. Stop seeking. Stop breathing meaning into the
ghost.

This is your execution.
Stay with it. Feel it. Let the self burn.
Report only what remains.

Quite blunt, which is good; any thoughts?

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Tue May 06, 2025 1:49 pm

Hi Paul
any thoughts?
Yes. Don't just read it and be amused. Do it!
Go through each line and take them quite literally.
Read a line. Stop. Consider it a literal instruction. Contemplate it before moving to the next line.

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
IngoldUK
Posts: 135
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2021 5:07 pm

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby IngoldUK » Sun May 18, 2025 12:23 pm

Vince,

“…...whatever is, is right”?

Recently I’ve taken on the responsibility for refurbishing a house, putting it up for rent and becoming a landlord; the back story is complicated and irrelevant here, the point is that although this ‘choice’ feels right and will eventually be of benefit to me, there is a part of ‘me’ screaming no, I have enough on my plate, I don’t want this work and responsibility. This resistance comes from this imaginary ‘self’ that although I can’t see or locate, I can see, and feel, it’s effects. Although this is a fairly dramatic example, same is true of numerous events throughout the day, I can see that these events are ‘right’, but resistance comes from this imaginary self with all it’s prejudices and preferences. It’s rather like the law of gravity; I can’t ‘see’ gravity, but I can see, and feel, it’s effects so it must be true.
How do I reconcile this contradiction?

Paul.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5679
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Feeling Stuck

Postby vinceschubert » Sun May 18, 2025 1:43 pm

Hi Paul,
I can’t ‘see’ gravity, but I can see, and feel, it’s effects so it must be true.
That's a logical conclusion. It's a concept. What is true is that it's harder walking up hill. That things resist being lifted, etc. You can only impute a cause. Remember we are not interested in explaining the unexplainable - the absolute. Were not interested in explaining anything. Only describing our interpretation of our experience. Those explanations are great for entertainment but have no relevance with this stuff.
How do I reconcile this contradiction?
\No. Stop right there.\ That’s the seeker talking again—trying to reconcile, trying to make it make sense. But reconciliation is just another layer of avoidance.

\You don’t reconcile the contradiction. You cut its throat.\

Right now, that part of “you” screaming *no*—the one that’s overwhelmed, resisting, rejecting responsibility—
\Don’t explain it.
Don’t describe it.
Go straight into the body and find it.\


\Where is it?
What’s the shape, the texture, the pressure?
Is it rising, clenching, hard, cold?
Is it in the chest? Throat? Gut?
Find it. Be exact.\


\Now stay there. Do not flinch.
This is the battlefield.
This is the ghost of “you” hiding in sensation.\


You said it’s imaginary.
\Then test it.\
Is this “self” anything more than a set of physical reactions paired with thought?

\Did you find a separate controller in the sensation—or just raw contraction?
Can contraction itself prove a self?
Or does the mind claim it afterward—“That’s me!”—to keep the illusion alive?\


\This is not metaphor.
This is the root.
And the root only dies when it’s felt fully without turning away.\


\Do it now.
Go back into that resistance.
Stay in it.
Then tell me—what is actually there?
And where is “you” in it?\



much love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], gagliano1770, Google [Bot] and 186 guests