No sound!"What is the sound of one hand clapping?"?
How would you respond to that question Nicholas?
(I accidently found a joke related to this, I wasn’t looking for the answer… just browsing streamentry subreddit cause I had a doubt (related to other thing) and found something that said…
Master asked to disciple: "What is the sound of one hand clapping?"
And the disciple slapped the Master in the face making a loud sound, thus automatically obtaining enlightment
)
so I’m not awareness neither? I’m nothing because I don’t exist. But why “I’m awareness is closer”?What reactions arise to hear that what you truly are is this that is called awareness?
ok… yeah because awareness is another label! But this awareness is clearly contained to each entity, right? That’s what makes them seem like separate…In the light of this truth, how could there ever actually be separate entities that claim they are in control and independent of life?
…
I started to think about this yesterday… but the truth is that I only got more questions.
Let’s say I’m… some kind of a soul/awareness/thing (which… I guess would be wrong? Maybe because I’m not separate from the rest?)
Anyways… then I don’t understand why I feel/see/hear from this body and not from the rest. If we are all connected why everyone just feels “its” stuff?
If I’m some kind of an “awareness”… then why do I experience things? How an awareness has the power of feeling/seeing? Shouldn’t be just there observing?
….
I think I.. get why I can’t use the mind to answer… if I consider myself some kind of awareness (although it would be wrong to say that… right? But then I still have no idea what I am if I am something or just don’t exist altogether)What is this that is experiencing your experience right now?
Then listening to the mind would be pointless. Simply because… I’m not the mind! So it’s going to generate noise and noise and thoughts and blahblah…
But then how do I answer? Do I have a mind of my own?
What is experiencing this right now? I can’t describe it. Some kind of a presence. Of a… something
I could say “inside my head”… but… maybe I could say “everywhere” ?Where is the experience of YOU now - even if you don't have a thought?
It can’t be boiled down to one place… because in that case… where exactly it is?
Maybe, again… it is everywhere.
No, thoughts are just another door of perception. Like there are sounds and feelings.If thoughts are there does the experience of you change?
the same! Never changeYou were perceiving thoughts 5 minutes ago. In this moment now you are experiencing different thoughts to those a few minutes ago.
While thoughts change have YOU changed or are YOU still the same unchanged YOU?
noHas anything about YOU or where you are located changed in the last 5 minutes?
noIn the last hour?
noSince you were a child?
everywhereYou see your form in a mirror but where is the YOU that is perceiving the form?
It has no root! One would say “the heart” or “the brain” or “the body” but it’s not true.Where's the sense of you emanating from - that sense of you that seems like the root of your attention?
if something is everywhere, can it really go inward? It is already there. There’s no inward.Where does your attention go?
can the mind sense awareness? If I’m awareness (but not really because I don’t exist) then can the mind detect it? Or the mind has its own awareness?Where does it go when you turn around and come back to YOU - to the most simple sense of YOU?
Who’s turning around? Me or the mind?
But I don’t exist (in theory, just haven’t seen it yet)
These questions just invoke more questions sorry!!
Well… I don’t know what I am (but… this is the mind speaking….)
I don’t know If I can sense the most simple sense of me, because that’s still body sensations.
Although there seems to be something here… but… how do I describe it? It’s beyond senses. It something else. Something different.
yesGo to the most simple sense of what you feel like you are. Right now. Where it feels like you are right now
Can you go there?
it’s always thereOr are you already there?
yes, it’s veeery different from the other 5 senses or mind.If you're already there then can you know it in the same way you can know what you read in a book?
YesCan you know it in the same way that you know 4 + 4 equal 8?
can’t find anyBut now the question is does it have a boundary? Does it have a limitation?
Because it’s beyond dimensions or characteristics… those come from the senses. This is something else. Am I that thing? But then… I thought I didn’t exist. Help me clarify please.Just because you can’t define yourself as an object with dimensions and specific characteristics does that mean you can't know where you are?
love is an emotionCan love actually be found?
we tend to say “I love you a lot” or to a new person “I think I love you a little”. So it changes sizes!Does love have quantifiable dimensions and characteristics?
It does have quantifiable dimensions and characteristics, but they are subjective.
not without the bodyCan the mind know love?
Only the body and mind can do that. What I am, I don’t know. I don’t know if I can know things.But can YOU know love?
something that cannot be describedLook behind these questions - what is there?
Maybe without analysisIn what way are you expecting an answer to appear?
How about we change the rhythm? Less questions, maybe 1 or 2. And much more time staying with those questions until it’s crystal clear. Will that help?
Also, how exactly do I answer, how do I look?
“don’t go to the mind”
However, the mind is the one that wants to look.
Maybe don’t listen to any thoughts until there is silence and the answer just appears and it’s obvious?

