Hi Allyn
Very good!
What is the previously perceived distance made of?
Well the first simple answer that comes up is "space" or "air".
But then I realize that the sky is made out of exactly the same thing as space or air. It isn't different at all.
So the sky is actually all around us all the time!
Now look!
What are “sky” and “air”? Think of the “apple” example. What are these labels pointing to?
Without all the physiological components that make up the eyes and how they see, there are no color distinctions.
So isn't even "color" a labjel or description of "seeing" and not an actual direct experience?
Yes!! Without all the story, there is only seeing :)
Well experientially I can "sense" the gap not just through color/seeing but also through sensation, smell, etc.
The experiment was just about the picture, where there is only seeing. But yeah in reality you can explore this gap in all senses. Different colours in seeing create the illusion of things but all that is there is seeing. Different levels of sounds create the illusion of a song but all that is there is hearing.
Can you see that? What is the pause between the song lines made of? What is silence? Silence is still hearing, right? It’s part of how thought describes reality – in absence and presence. This is from Alan Watts in that respect:
“This wave phenomenon is happening on ever so many scales—the fast wave of light, the slower waves of sound—and there are all sorts of other wave processes, such as the beat of the heart; the rhythm of breath, waking, sleeping; the movement of human life from birth to maturity to death. And the slower the wave goes, the more difficult it is to see that the crest and trough are inseparable, and this is how we become persuaded in the game of hide-and-seek. So we see the trough go down, down, down and think it keeps going forever—that it will never rise back up again into a crest. We forget that trough implies crest, and crest implies trough. There is no such thing as pure sound—sound is sound/silence. Light is light/darkness. Light is pulsation—between every light pulse there is the dark pulse.”― Alan W. Watts, Out of Your Mind: Tricksters, Interdependence, and the Cosmic Game of Hide and Seek
Hmm. So "color" is a mental construct however there is a distinction in the appearance of one color vs another color that can be seen. But perhaps this is only so in the physiological components of how the eyes see?
Yes, colour is a concept. Even neuroscientist agree to that.
But does the eye see? Do you see the eyes seeing or you deduct that? If you see them seeing then what is actually doing the seeing? How is this actually experienced? Close your eyes. Even with your eyes closed you can still see stuff. At first there is only darkness, but see what happens in a minute...
Yep it definitely is. I recognize this. But I also recognize that this thought interpretation is a very deeply rooted and lifetime one and that the underlying beliefs or the root cause is very unconscious.
It is noticed that there is a very strong resistance and very low acceptance tolerance to any situation where the mind says, "I cannot get away" or "I am being restricted".
It's not wanting to get away from pain or unpleasant sensations, it's more of an unconscious story running in the background about feeling trapped by them.
Well, this is all conditioning that needs to be checked. We are all conditioned to avoid “unpleasant” experiences and look for “pleasant” ones. But what happens when you examine the actual label “pleasant/unpleasant”. Allow yourself to sit with the “unpleasant” ones even for a second and acceptance starts unfolding. Right now it may be impossible to believe that resistance and fear are your friends, but if you start noticing them, you will see where they lead. Resistance itself is not meant to be resisted, otherwise it locks into self-strengthening, repeating loops. Some say there is a path of least resistance, and when resistance melts, all that is left is surrender. This is the path of saying yes to whatever feeling, emotion, or sensation shows up. Surrendering is what is left when resistance to what is ends. Listening closely and noticing sensations in the body are key to releasing stuckness.
There actually is something in the sensation that suggests danger. The painful sensation suggests there is something physiologically harmful to the health of the body.
However I can't know that because I don't have direct evidence that there is anything wrong like an illness or disease.
So although there COULD be danger, I can't KNOW that there is.
So "danger" is only a thought.
Yes!! It’s only thought that gives the story of danger. Sensation on its own is just sensing without the “explanation”. Some stories come closer to reality than others but still very much an approximation. I suppose the analogy with the icons on your computer desktop comes handy. They are used as a visual representation of what is actually a binary code – zeros and ones - so you can make use of them.
But is the icon of email really a box with mail in it?
It's the thoughts and the sensations that combined form this sense of I.
The thoughts I can see through, but the body seems to solidify this experience and cause me to doubt my doubt in my thoughts. It's like the body rebels very strongly when there is a disidentification with thoughts.
The abdomen mostly.
Yes you are correct that is a sensations + thoughts.
How do sensations solidify the experience without the interpretation? Sensations are just sensing, vibrating or whatever words you want to use to describe them. They are just happening.
Where is “abdomen”? Again do sensations have a location or the location is their label? So yes sensations are happening but is there something in them that suggest a “me” without the thought?
It's like the nervous system is stuck in fight or flight mode.
Perfect example of a story – scientific or spiritual, doesn’t matter – still a story.
Does the sense of self have any characteristics or attributes?
Afraid, mistrusting, and frustrated.
Emotion = thought + sensation
These are thoughts that you are reporting. Attributes here are in terms of seeing, hearing, …. (DE)
So that would mean sensations?
Sensation and thoughts.
It is either thoughts then sensations that confirm the thoughts or sensations then thoughts that come in to try to manage the sensations.
Very good observation!!
How does that make you feel?
Yes. It's the story of a child who grew up with a mother who made her feel trapped and controlled. Then the story of an adult who kept that story alive by making poor choices that put herself in situations where she felt trapped and controlled, such as psych hospitals and jail. And now the story of the even older adult who perpetuates the story by feeling trapped and controlled by her own body and was told that accepting it and riding it out will free you from it so she's trying that now.
What identifies with it is not an entity. It is beliefs. The belief that it is intolerable and completely unacceptable to feel trapped, and the belief that being trapped is possible.
This feeling has been so bad at times that I wanted to die rather than experience it.
Well trauma is also a story,
right? It's one of these self-strengthening, repeating loops.
Is there anyone that does the believing or is there just thinking about believing? Is there anyone that is stuck in believing or just stories about someone who is stuck into believing, into memories of traumatic experiences?
Just thoughts that have been thought for a very long time and the body's conditioned responses to them.
Ok, so “body” is just a label describing sensations as we’ve already seen. But can thoughts do anything but describing what is already happening? Do senses depend on each other to happen? How is this observed without a story?
1. Sit comfortably on a chair. Close your eyes. Lift your leg and pay attention to the sensation of “leg lifted”
2. Open your eyes and now pay attention to the sight of the leg only.
3. While looking at the leg, pay attention to the sensation of the leg.
Do sight and sensation appear simultaneously? Do they appear separately? Do they depend on each other? Is there a link between them? What does the link look like?
Love
Rali
“Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in.”
― Alan Alda
"The moment I am aware that I am aware I am not aware. Awareness means the observer is not"
― Jiddu Krishnamurti