Hi Vince, with the time difference I am probably not going to get this to you before you sleep, because this reply has taken me quite a long time.
Have you considered that right and wrong are cult(urally) imposed concepts ?
Yes , I have considered it a lot , right and wrong ARE FOR SURE culturally imposed concepts. They definitely are.
I like how you wrote it like cult (urally). So much of what culture believes in is like a cult, brainwashing, and propaganda mould these beliefs of right and wrong and we worship them. Would you say though that there is anything at all fundamentally right or wrong , like ANYTHING at all? In your opinion. Sorry, I shouldn’t be asking you questions should I? Or is that ok with you that I sometimes do if it helps me clear things up?
Ok, before I read further you asked me to give you a rant on Truth so here goes........
Well, the same way you asked me to consider that right and wrong are no doubt culturally imposed concepts, for the most part I would say so is 'truth '. Truth in terms of what one believes to be right and wrong and such. What we feel is 'our' truth, like what I was telling you was 'my' truth in thinking there is some order and goodness to Totality and such. Truth used in this way is simply another belief, another story, no different. And most of our so called human truths are definitely just more stories. I am not sure if some stories are better than others lol but I guess we can say some stories, or beliefs , or truths lead to consequences that may be more 'gentler' than others, for ourselves and others. More life affirming somehow , less destructive . Though these two words are stories too. So there's this way of looking at truth.
However, I think 'truth' is also just what it is in its most obvious sense, not a "lie", meaning what just IS. What’s ACTUALLY happening at any moment. Thats the truth .What I mean by this is that in daily life, there are so so many ways that we are not in truth to ourselves and others, we lie all the time, whether it be small lies and exaggerations or big lies and hurts, or denials, not showing our true self for fear of what others think, the list goes on and on. The constant acting out, and fortification of psychological armour. Masks and defenses we put on, roles we play, none of it is truth at all. So in my opinion, this definition of truth , which is 'reality', (reality right be the better word), and not my previous one which was really 'values' or 'beliefs' is the more correct definition. Truth just meaning what is, this is the one I want to emphasize as my rant for you on truth , it's the one I think is the TRUTH, pun intended lol!! True means "real". Before concepts etc. , stripped down and naked. Ok, hope this rant made sense to you.
Moving on to the fact we know so little......
I once saw a guy with a T-shirt that said 'I’ don’t know' , thought it very wise. indeed lol. Yes .... all of what we think we know are in fact beliefs, when I wrote you earlier Email I had wanted to add that there is actually NOTHING I can know for sure, nothing at all! And thats the truth ha ha!
Back to speaking of beliefs, I know everything i told you on my 'meaning of life ' rant is a story and yet somehow I feel that is not that I 'should' believe in as you say. but more that it’s a gut feeling that feels right, like intuition, not the kind of belief one would have from fear say, like in organized religion for example. But you’re right, it’s still a story I choose to believe. But then again do I choose it? Do you believe in intuition? is it true? Or just another story and belief?
Beliefs have consequences
Yes i realise that beliefs have consequences. A recent example would be the person yesterday who ran a truck through a bike lane and killed others in New York. This ties in to truth and beliefs and cultural conditioning of right and wrong. He 'believes ' his 'truth' is that Allah would want him to kill infidels and his actions are 'right' and he will get into heaven (maybe 50 virgins too if he really pleased Allah ) all as a consequence of his actions. He 'believes' his story of truth and consequences. In turn , his beliefs and conditionings resulted in a lot of consequences, in that people died, and lives have forever been affected. So we get back to our first point on right or wrong depending on cultural conditioning, to us here in the West we feel what he did was wrong, to others like ISIS, it was 'right'. Its really neither right nor wrong when looked at this way is it Vince?
But..... That’s why I asked you earlier though if there is anything YOU think is fundamentally wrong? Was this act a product of wrong thinking, (I believe it was ) , is there such a thing as right and wrong thinking? Was this an 'apparent self ' causing awful consequences. And could he have chosen to do it differently? Probably not ....Not unless his conditioning was totally different .
On a side note, Just so you know I am literally writing this to you alongside your message in LU, in real time lol, reading and writing on the fly, with my screens split on iPad so I write in my notes app as I read your email and comment before I continue to read on because I think thats the best way and I don’t jump ahead. Of course if you gave me an exercise to do that would be different, but for this discussion I feel it best, sooooo.... moving along... (well i am not getting any work done this morning Vince, lol, was that my choice to take all morning to write to you, am I procrastinating, can i even control this) Wow...
OK, I just read your point when you said in reply to my take on the flow of life etc., that it was another 'good' story. You’re right, I know it’s a story, I really do. Then, when I read that you said that I exhibit characteristics of wisdom, I got a couple of tears in my eyes. A strange reaction for me . But it touched me deeply and immediately. In a pure way, not a proud of myself way lol.
And now you say there is one thing that tells you that I am not liberated and not awake and can I guess what that one thing is?
....... Well in all likelihood I can’t guess correctly because it probably is what i am blind to and is what’s holding me back I suspect , but .....if I had to say something , right now, (and I do promise to always take a try to answer every one of your questions which I know you ask with total purpose and to guide me and not frivolously at all), it’s that the thing that tells you I am not awake is because YOU can see or tell that I believe somehow I am not free, or have something to figure out, or believe with this little self that I have to get over this imaginary self? That the seeking is perpetuating the search? That really there is no quest. That the fact I am trying to figure it all out means I believe in separation and haven’t seen through the imaginary self?..... that I am trapped ....
I don’t know. That’s my guess for now before I continue.
The best story that i have been able to come up with says that all of the wrong in the world can be equated to a healing crisis in the human organism.
For example when we pick up a stomach bug, in order to eliminate the body will get temperature and vomiting and diarrhea......
Ha ha, well Vince, I think we may be kindred spirits you know, because your 'story' you describe here pretty much could sum up mine too almost verbatim. I resonate deeply with what you say. And you are right too in that it’s is not all getting worse, statistically speaking. But times are intense indeed. The other day, I listened to a very recent interview with Eckhart Tolle by Oprah , (that Oprah lady is pretty wise lol ), and she was asking Eckhart about if he still believes that there is a waking up of humans that he mentioned in his book the New Earth in light of the fact that it certainly doesn't seem so with all that is going on now, the craziness and polarization and hatred etc. , anyway, he kind of said basically what you just said.... and that sometimes things do get worse before they get better and again it’s the ego and belief in self and being asleep that is causing all the ills.
Then you comment on the part I wrote from Rupert and say that even though you superficially agree...
I do however see the sense of separation and the delusion of a separate self as symptoms rather than the root cause.
I have to think more deeply on this line, I cannot completely understand it yet. I think you are stepping back deeper here, asking why do we have this belief in a separate self which is an illusion or delusion, what’s the cause of that ?
Hee hee , by the way, I like your little soapbox. But seriously, I am earnestly trying to get what you are saying here.
I am paraphrasing and you can tell me if I am on track.
You are saying, I think , that by not realizing that all these concepts (which come from our thoughts ) are just stories , we conclude that there is a separate self. So the end result of these concepts is the illusion and belief in a separate self (which really is a symptom which then leads to consequences). And prior to this belief we simply don’t recognize that everything is thought and concepts and then erroneously believe in this illusionary self , we are asleep ...
You’re saying, I think, that the 'apparent separation' isn’t the root cause. It’s the symptom that leads to the consequences. It’s an extra step so to speak. Eg, New York killer. Deep belief in separate self. Does what he thinks is right and there are terrible consequences but the self which did this was not the cause but the effect or symptom actually of the concepts and ideas and conditioning which led to this separate self belief. Is that what you were saying?
As a by the way, I am in complete agreement with you about the education system (and the medical system for that matter, we have so many systems backwards and messed up at this point in human development it seems ) . Oh I could go on and on a soapbox about this too lol, told you we were kindred spirits! Just as a small example, I almost have to laugh when I see how right now in the US, they are literally manipulating people with the whole patriotic idea and the kneeling and flag,(Donald manipulated them beautifully) it’s bizarre to see them all fall into the trap. Their allegiance pledge they make the children recite each day in school which my children just found weird. Ok I’m on a soapbox now, so better get off! You’re so right though , these taught ideas do have such an undeserved elevated status and it 'causes or conditions' so much damage. We completely ignore what is and try to mould the world in to what we think it should be with these ideas, and it’s all complete BS! Trying to control everything.
We might have to delve more into cause and effect being illusions, you didn’t ask me a direct question on this and since this is getting very long, i will not comment.
But I think i am getting where you are coming from that what these consequences and causes are are just really conditions that line up. Everything is connected somehow, the whole butterfly on your side of the world could cause a hurricane here analogy.
Literally forever. i could go back to if one of my ancestors was sterile, that i wouldn't even be here.
OMG, that’s the line of the day. I want to tweet this ha ha because I wish one of Donald trumps ancestors were sterile .... This made me laugh so much but it’s so damn true. You are right. (And I know, another story could be that Trump is part of the whole diarrhea healing thing of the human organism in a perverse way )
It is not a long shot to say that if any one condition hadn’t happened in the world and was different, that everything , EVERYTHING would be different. Wow, really mind boggling when you take it all in isn’t it? And your story with your laptop and all those conditions remind me of mine with my Chicago trip story and my iPhone story (which by the way i had to pay yesterday 130 to fix aarrgh). This condition of my fall in Chicago causing this store in Lake Mary Florida to get a sale, crazy right? and we could go on and on ad infinitum couldn’t we?
Yes, as you say, it’s the beliefs in concepts that setup conditions which lead to the consequences. But now we have come full circle and are back to beliefs and truth and right and wrong and conditioning again, haven't we Vince? Beliefs are a product of our conditioning and culture that we think are 'right' and 'true' (empty concepts ) which then set up conditions which have consequences. But the beliefs are just really empty concepts , so that first domino that flips all the others in sequence isn't even real?! What a notion! And then in between somewhere along the domino chain, but really early on, the belief of a separate self comes in and becomes a domino. And also, following your line of reasoning and this domino analogy , different beliefs would lead to a different world then wouldn't they?
You also ask 'how can separation be anything more than another concept', I think we are going to have to explore more of this in another email because it requires more pondering and I am kind of brain fired at this point and won't do it justice But with all we have contemplated here in our emails, it seems clear that separation must indeed be just another though and concept, I think I am glimpsing that.
I thank you Vince from the bottom of my heart for the time you taking with me, and you come totally from the heart and with love, you have so brightened my day today with this. As I break for lunch, I hope you are having sweet dreams in the land down under.
I very much look forward to more of our discourse
Love
Diana
PS I have family in Sydney and Adelaide and there are a lot of people from Trinidad (Trinis we call them) in Perth What part of Australia are you in?