I really appreciate the feedback, everyone. I have to admit that things have been getting more challenging lately--unresolved material and habitual patterns have been coming up that still need to be worked through. Thoughts and desires arise to push certain things away or get rid of them, to get the clean-up project over with and cross some kind of finish line...but where would this finish line be, and who would cross it? I want to be careful not to rush this, to take my time and make sure this is seen as clearly as possible.
No. There’s no way. If I am honest with myself, I can only conclude that there is no one living this life, only life living itself through this body-mind. The experience of being an individual remains, and identification with aspects of this experience still happens at times, but looking at this reveals nothing but a conglomeration of thoughts and sensations--no self to be found.
Who is honest here? This is not about analysing, it's about seeing the truth. So a conclusion is not what we need. You need to see this in real life.
When I mentioned being honest with myself, I meant facing the I-thoughts and seeing them as thoughts, instead of pretending that I exist. There are times when a conditioned pattern is being witnessed as it is happening, and there is a feeling that something false is being held on to--yet the pattern continues. Looking at it, this thing that was being protected is seen to be nothing but another thought, another belief...until the pattern pops up again.
It feels dishonest to keep defending something that I know cannot be true. No evidence of an I has been found in reality. There is no way to prove that it exists. Every thought or feeling of I points to nothing. Yet there is a conflict between this knowing and the thought/behavioral patterns that keep playing themselves out--it feels painful, like being split apart. This can be helpful as a kind of alarm that calls the attention to look closely at what is going on, but lately the tension seems to be hanging around longer. The stories appearing around this (Something is wrong, I screwed up, what should I do, etc.) have created fear and confusion that can be murky and difficult to see through. Writing this out now seems to be helping somewhat, although it can be hard to focus on the writing with so many internal distractions. It can take several hours just to write something like this post.
So what is the self. How does the illusion of self happen in practice / in real life? Explain this like to a 5 yo. What are the facts, what are the assumptions ...
Example: Right now, what is happening in reality is that thoughts, memories, and experiences are being organized and put into words and sentences. Even this is a description constructed after the fact: in the moment, in direct experience, there is simply the flow of whatever is happening--thinking, feeling, typing. In the midst of this flow, a thought may appear that says, “I am doing this.” There may also be a feeling that seems to confirm this, maybe a contracted feeling, that feels like it belongs to “me”. Suddenly, it feels like “I” am now separate from this flow (even though all this “I” stuff is actually part of the flow). This triggers all kinds of thoughts and feelings about how this “I” relates to its experience: Am I doing this right? Should I be doing something else? I’m not good at this. What will they think of me? And so on.
This is the self in action. Or rather, this is the thought/feeling pattern that creates the illusion of a self. The pattern itself is real--the self is not. It was not there before the pattern arose, and it did not show up afterward. There have only been thoughts, sensations, movements, etc., and they have always been happening on their own. The self-pattern happens in the same way--the only difference is that even though the self it points to does not exist, it is believed to be real...and it is believed to be
me.
As an aside: There is a fear that I may not have been completely honest or open about my experience earlier. This was not my intention, and I apologize if I misled anyone. Clarity and confusion seem to come and go, and I do not want to avoid the unfamiliarity and uneasiness around real-life issues. I do not want to pretend to be liberated if I am not, nor to attempt to guide others if I have my own blind spots. I intend to work through this until it is done.