I'm sitting here at my desk with my eyes closed. I'm in my home office, and it's pretty quiet apart from the occasional passing car and the clock ticking. Then my mind was suddenly attracted to a quiet chirpy sound outside. It was probably a bird, but I'm not sure. It might've been some squeaky bits of metal scraping each other in the wind. It went for a few seconds and then stopped.
So the thought I zoomed in on was this. "What is it?" My mind doesn't like not having a label for what I'm hearing. That question seemed to flutter around somewhere within the space of my head and my chest. It felt like a butterfly restlessly fluttering around. What is it? What is it? What is it?
It's interesting that my analytical mind wasn't taking over. I was more feeling the energy of this restless questioning fluttering around in my body.
The sound stopped. I still don't really know what it was. It was probably a bird or a cricket-like insect, and it must've flown away.
Requesting a guide
Re: Requesting a guide
OK great. I will be back tomorrow. Meanwhile; give your attention to how the mind does stuff like that. Just 'who' is doing that questioning exactly?
(I am not asking you to do this all day long, just to regularly revisit the material from time to time, till our next exchange here.)
(I am not asking you to do this all day long, just to regularly revisit the material from time to time, till our next exchange here.)
Re: Requesting a guide
I need to be in a very still place in both body and mind to be able to observe such subtle stuff. So I mostly paid attention this morning while I was doing my morning yoga and meditation routine.
All I can say is – when I'm focusing entirely on my direct experience, there is only sensation. And awareness that there is thinking going on. And no matter where I look, I can't locate any particular sensation that points to a 'who' that's doing or experiencing any of the above. There's really nothing there but sensation -- physical sensations like feeling this body against the floor and the movement of muscles, as well as an awareness of thoughts and emotions arising.
All I can say is – when I'm focusing entirely on my direct experience, there is only sensation. And awareness that there is thinking going on. And no matter where I look, I can't locate any particular sensation that points to a 'who' that's doing or experiencing any of the above. There's really nothing there but sensation -- physical sensations like feeling this body against the floor and the movement of muscles, as well as an awareness of thoughts and emotions arising.
Re: Requesting a guide
OK, that is a particularly promising opener this evening!All I can say is – when I'm focusing entirely on my direct experience, there is only sensation. And awareness that there is thinking going on. And no matter where I look, I can't locate any particular sensation that points to a 'who' that's doing or experiencing any of the above. There's really nothing there but sensation -- physical sensations like feeling this body against the floor and the movement of muscles, as well as an awareness of thoughts and emotions arising.
Just take those few breaths first, just be in that seat
I want to look at sound again:
There is probably some sound available in your room there. Perhaps you are on a swivel-chair with a creak? Perhaps there is that mild hum of the monitor or computer fan? Or perhaps it is you just deciding to give your attention to that next decently salient piece from the general traffic orchestra? Maybe it's the sound of a bike bike with open pipes? An ambulance siren? A heavy Mach Truck? A plane overhead? Y'know how some sounds can stand out a little? So just making a decision now about which sound to attend to.
Is there a hearer? A sense of a 'you' 'doing' the hearing?
Or is there just sound?
Is there an experiencer?
Or just the experience?
Sit with this a bit...breathe.
Re: Requesting a guide
It takes some effort to get my mind away from my 'everyday mind' so I can do this exercise. Otherwise I'm too locked into my habitual way of perceiving which is very ME-centric.
So I'm turning to the sound of my clock ticking. When I really zoom into that sound, there's just sound that is passing through this awareness. It takes a lot of work to stay in that place. But like I said this morning, I can't point to any experience so okay yeah 15 that is a hearer. There's no direct sensation that tells me there is a hearer present. There is certainly awareness of a body, and my overall physical presence. But I recognize that my rupa isn't the same thing as a hearer. It's just the body, not the awareness. It's too easy to conflate the two. So as far as this experience of the clock ticking, there is sound vibrating my rupa's ear drums. But as for what or who is doing the actual perceiving, there doesn't seem to be anything.
So I'm turning to the sound of my clock ticking. When I really zoom into that sound, there's just sound that is passing through this awareness. It takes a lot of work to stay in that place. But like I said this morning, I can't point to any experience so okay yeah 15 that is a hearer. There's no direct sensation that tells me there is a hearer present. There is certainly awareness of a body, and my overall physical presence. But I recognize that my rupa isn't the same thing as a hearer. It's just the body, not the awareness. It's too easy to conflate the two. So as far as this experience of the clock ticking, there is sound vibrating my rupa's ear drums. But as for what or who is doing the actual perceiving, there doesn't seem to be anything.
Re: Requesting a guide
Oh oops. Ha ha. I'm using voice dictation software and when I answered the phone it inserted "so okay yeah 15" in the middle of the paragraph! You can ignore that part.
Re: Requesting a guide
Mmm, OK, Let's return to that later perhaps.But I recognize that my rupa isn't the same thing as a hearer. It's just the body, not the awareness. It's too easy to conflate the two.
Let's just settle into your breathing:
Just sitting there now, in your room, aware of the actual feeling of how your body is planted into your chair giving up its weight to the nurturing support of Earths gravity. Noticing now, how this mammal, this bi-ped is just sitting here, Just being. Notice how you partake of Earth's bounty, how those breaths arise and depart again, all by themselves. Allowing yourself to just savour their arising and falling as you continue to arrive and orientate towards opening to your direct experience of this moment.
I want to now ask you to notice a sight object, anything in your current line of vision. It might be something in the room beyond your computer monitor, or it might be the cross symbol X, in the top right hand corner of your screen. Just give your attention to that seen object right now, in a spirit of kindly awareness, forcing nothing, just giving it a relatively measured attention:
Is there a 'seer', 'seeing' and 'seen' as three separate items? (that middle one; 'seeing' being a process of course rather than an 'item' strictly speaking) or is there just the 'seen'?
What happens hear when you really 'look' in this way?
Please return to this exercise regularly over the ensuing hours, forcing nothing, just being with what happens. Is there really an actual seer?
Re: Requesting a guide
I'm finding it more difficult to work with my sense of sight as opposed to hearing. When I look at something, I get the distinct experience of there being me and a separate object. I am here, it is there. And therefore it's hard to avoid the feeling that "I" am looking at "the object". I'm still working on this one.
I'm also puzzling through why it's so different from hearing things. Maybe it's because I experience sound within me, so it feels easier to feel like it's all one experience.
Any pointers?
I'm also puzzling through why it's so different from hearing things. Maybe it's because I experience sound within me, so it feels easier to feel like it's all one experience.
Any pointers?
Re: Requesting a guide
Yes we are sometimes surprisingly specific with our acuities. The big three of course are sight, hearing and sound. Many people major in one and can be a bit soft with the others. There can be some odd surprises too: I had never even noticed having much of a sense of taste then, on evening sitting there in Direct Experience, all nicely cued up with a spot of breathing I noticed that there was no 'me' tasting, instead there was just the experience of taste itself BANG! I was suddenly through! But let's not rush things:
Take up your breathing.
I had begun writing my reply when I realised that it so much resembled something already written on the same topic by Lex that I dug up a copy of that for you:
'There are no words to adequately describe how to see, no maps of how to get there; all I can do is Point to where you should look. This is not a mental exercise; all the thinking you can ever do will never get you there. I will give you clue, because I was also a Thinker. Just before I saw it, I suddenly realised that my guide was telling me to LOOK, not to Think. When I looked, I saw it.What is Looking? It is focusing on your Direct Experience. Seeing with the eyes, hearing with the ears, feeling with the skin, smelling with the nose, tasting with the tongue. Sensation, before it is judged and labeled, is direct experience.'
It sounds to me as though you are being hood-winked by that 'mine-maker' which immediately arrives pretty quickly and appropriates the experience to a 'self' which then tells itself that it must be 'having' the experience.
Try this: With eyes closed, take one or two breaths then decide to just open you eyes suddenly and look with naked awareness at any familiar object which you already know to be in your field of vision (an unfamiliar object is even better) Just fully take it in without naming it.
This exercise can help people to notice that there is always just a few milliseconds of Direct Experience of seeing, maybe longer, before standard labeling starts up.
Give this a go now and tell me what happens.
Take up your breathing.
I had begun writing my reply when I realised that it so much resembled something already written on the same topic by Lex that I dug up a copy of that for you:
'There are no words to adequately describe how to see, no maps of how to get there; all I can do is Point to where you should look. This is not a mental exercise; all the thinking you can ever do will never get you there. I will give you clue, because I was also a Thinker. Just before I saw it, I suddenly realised that my guide was telling me to LOOK, not to Think. When I looked, I saw it.What is Looking? It is focusing on your Direct Experience. Seeing with the eyes, hearing with the ears, feeling with the skin, smelling with the nose, tasting with the tongue. Sensation, before it is judged and labeled, is direct experience.'
It sounds to me as though you are being hood-winked by that 'mine-maker' which immediately arrives pretty quickly and appropriates the experience to a 'self' which then tells itself that it must be 'having' the experience.
Try this: With eyes closed, take one or two breaths then decide to just open you eyes suddenly and look with naked awareness at any familiar object which you already know to be in your field of vision (an unfamiliar object is even better) Just fully take it in without naming it.
This exercise can help people to notice that there is always just a few milliseconds of Direct Experience of seeing, maybe longer, before standard labeling starts up.
Give this a go now and tell me what happens.
Re: Requesting a guide
I'm just checking in to let you know I'm alive and still working on it. Nothing new to report. And not much change in the "seeing" front either.
Re: Requesting a guide
OK, more from me tomorrow.
Re: Requesting a guide
Even more Happy Wesak! (As we are celebrating it in the Buddhist Centre today)
Regarding your;
"...not much change on the seeing front either"
I am just sending you, by private message an expansion about Direct Experience for one of the senior guys on here
Regarding your;
"...not much change on the seeing front either"
I am just sending you, by private message an expansion about Direct Experience for one of the senior guys on here
Re: Requesting a guide
Did you send me the PM? If you did, I'm not seeing how to pick it up.
I should also let you know that I may not post much over the next day or so. My father-in-law passed away last night so we are hopping in the car to drive some 4-5 hours to New York tonight, so we can attend the funeral tomorrow morning. I will be back tomorrow night.
In the meantime, I thought I'd say a few more things about what I've observed. I've been sitting with my visual experience, looking at things as if I just landed here from Mars and had no idea what anything I was looking at actually was. So I was observing swaths of color and shapes, luminosity, etc. in other words seeing the qualities of what the eyes were taking in. I'm also noticing how my mind has the tendency to label everything, and can get glimpses of what the experience of seeing without labels might be like.
But doing all this takes a huge amount of effort, and feels like a struggling effort of banging my head against a wall. I know that can't be right.
I'm also noticing that doing this exercise with seeing is so much harder than with hearing. You mentioned how many people major in one, and clearly mine is hearing. I think I've been more attuned to hearing from very early on in childhood. I also pursued that interest by studying music my whole life. Sounds, and music in particular, generally have a way of moving me more than visual things.
I wonder if it's related that I have never connected to any kind of visualization practice in meditation. During my ordination training process I struggled for years with the prostration practice, never making a shred of connection to any part of it. It just felt like an overwhelmingly busy mental exercise for me. After three years of struggling, I was excused from doing the practice. And though I was given the White Tara practice at my ordination (hence my username here) I've never been able to do the practice on my own. As I mentioned before, I relate much more to Anapanasati and Satipatthana.
So is this a case where I should go with my strengths, or try to shore up my weaknesses to get things to balance out. My instinct tells me it's the former, but I'll go with your guidance.
I should also let you know that I may not post much over the next day or so. My father-in-law passed away last night so we are hopping in the car to drive some 4-5 hours to New York tonight, so we can attend the funeral tomorrow morning. I will be back tomorrow night.
In the meantime, I thought I'd say a few more things about what I've observed. I've been sitting with my visual experience, looking at things as if I just landed here from Mars and had no idea what anything I was looking at actually was. So I was observing swaths of color and shapes, luminosity, etc. in other words seeing the qualities of what the eyes were taking in. I'm also noticing how my mind has the tendency to label everything, and can get glimpses of what the experience of seeing without labels might be like.
But doing all this takes a huge amount of effort, and feels like a struggling effort of banging my head against a wall. I know that can't be right.
I'm also noticing that doing this exercise with seeing is so much harder than with hearing. You mentioned how many people major in one, and clearly mine is hearing. I think I've been more attuned to hearing from very early on in childhood. I also pursued that interest by studying music my whole life. Sounds, and music in particular, generally have a way of moving me more than visual things.
I wonder if it's related that I have never connected to any kind of visualization practice in meditation. During my ordination training process I struggled for years with the prostration practice, never making a shred of connection to any part of it. It just felt like an overwhelmingly busy mental exercise for me. After three years of struggling, I was excused from doing the practice. And though I was given the White Tara practice at my ordination (hence my username here) I've never been able to do the practice on my own. As I mentioned before, I relate much more to Anapanasati and Satipatthana.
So is this a case where I should go with my strengths, or try to shore up my weaknesses to get things to balance out. My instinct tells me it's the former, but I'll go with your guidance.
Re: Requesting a guide
Tough as it is, do allow this recent bereavement to be a source of reflection, so I am saying nothing new in that Impermanence department because I know that you know the territory.
I sent that expansion, (which was written by one of the guys on here as a general guiding thing for Guides in general) straight to your gmail.
As regards your pertinent question: Definitely the former! Forget the visual in your case. All of this is about getting one to perceive. That's all it needs, otherwise we would have to tell Stevie Wonder; "Forget it mate!" No, it is very much more straightforward than to have to see 'no self' in each and every of the six sense spheres. We just use those for their access potential, that's all.
Just take a good look at that expansion I sent about the process of Direct Experience OK?
You are doing just fine. It all still looks very much on course from my end and it is absolutely plain to me that you are going to 'get it' but in the meantime what might be intruding is that I think you are pushing yourself too hard. I sense that there is too much 'trying' going on.
I want to ask you to think more in terms of relaxing and letting go. Yes, ambition is good and I will not withdraw that remark, but you have sufficient ambition to succeed, I could tell that from your opening post so I am very happy with that side of this equation. But let us remember that here, we are talking about the goal of allowing yourself to JUST BE!
So leave aside the striving.
Take a look at those other skandhas. thought, sensations, hearing, smelling, tasting.
Perhaps it is best not to do this in New York at such a fraught time?
Perhaps it is best instead, to do this back home, in front of your home screen, with a wee bit of breathing beforehand in a spirit of kindly concern for mind and body.
With much warm metta for you and yours, at what cannot be an easy time.
I sent that expansion, (which was written by one of the guys on here as a general guiding thing for Guides in general) straight to your gmail.
As regards your pertinent question: Definitely the former! Forget the visual in your case. All of this is about getting one to perceive. That's all it needs, otherwise we would have to tell Stevie Wonder; "Forget it mate!" No, it is very much more straightforward than to have to see 'no self' in each and every of the six sense spheres. We just use those for their access potential, that's all.
Just take a good look at that expansion I sent about the process of Direct Experience OK?
You are doing just fine. It all still looks very much on course from my end and it is absolutely plain to me that you are going to 'get it' but in the meantime what might be intruding is that I think you are pushing yourself too hard. I sense that there is too much 'trying' going on.
I want to ask you to think more in terms of relaxing and letting go. Yes, ambition is good and I will not withdraw that remark, but you have sufficient ambition to succeed, I could tell that from your opening post so I am very happy with that side of this equation. But let us remember that here, we are talking about the goal of allowing yourself to JUST BE!
So leave aside the striving.
Take a look at those other skandhas. thought, sensations, hearing, smelling, tasting.
Perhaps it is best not to do this in New York at such a fraught time?
Perhaps it is best instead, to do this back home, in front of your home screen, with a wee bit of breathing beforehand in a spirit of kindly concern for mind and body.
With much warm metta for you and yours, at what cannot be an easy time.
Re: Requesting a guide
Hi MB,
Just got back. I hear you about my trying too hard. That's typical of me. A very strong samskara! I will just BE tonight, in front of the telly.
And honestly, this is not a fraught time for me or my husband. He was not close to his dad at all, and hence neither was I. So our lives are just continuing on as usual. No real impact on us.
You said you sent the Direct Experience thing to my gmail, but I haven't gotten it. I'm going to DM you my email address via Facebook, just to make sure you sent it to the right place.
Thanks!
Just got back. I hear you about my trying too hard. That's typical of me. A very strong samskara! I will just BE tonight, in front of the telly.
And honestly, this is not a fraught time for me or my husband. He was not close to his dad at all, and hence neither was I. So our lives are just continuing on as usual. No real impact on us.
You said you sent the Direct Experience thing to my gmail, but I haven't gotten it. I'm going to DM you my email address via Facebook, just to make sure you sent it to the right place.
Thanks!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests

