The difference is subtle perhaps, but I hope you can see that there can be autopilot and a belief in self, and there can be autopilot and seeing reality. Please let me know if this is your understanding of autopilot, so that we’re using the same terms of reference.
Thanks, i see the distinction you are drawing. I believe i'm going through this exercise to move from autopilot/self to autopilot/no-self-seeing-reality.
Look at your piece above – when the theory and observation seem to be at odds, do you reject the theory or the observed phenomenon?
yes, that's one conclusion. you have to throw out the faulty theory. Or you have bad data, or a bad experiment design, or fault measurements. The loophole that always trips me up here is that Im not confident enough to believe that I can know everything. Do Unicorns exist? I've never seen one. But by that same logic (which i feel like it some sort of logical falacy name), anything i havent seen directly doesn't exist, which is just silly. There have to be constraints on that chain of logic or it just sounds foolish.
Proving a negative is a b*tch, the best you can do is amass piles of evidence and satisfy yourself that you (and everyone else) have done your best with the tools you have available.
Which I think is this process. The part where I amass evidence that counters a belief in self goes quite well until I can't find any evidence of self. Then I start straying into matters of philosophy and religion and quickly get very confused.
But I stray. (again)
Take two objects/possibilities, where you might ordinarily choose either, e.g. coffee or tea,
blue pen or black pen, salt and pepper. Then look and see if you can find the ‘choice-point’ where
you could go either way. Describe how choosing happens.
Ok, for this exercise i picked raising either my left hand or my right hand as a conscious choice.
Describing how choosing happens: At first my experiment happens entirely in my thoughts w/o ever actually raising my hand, but i think that's not really the direct experience we're after here, so I moved to actually moving my arm/hand.
phase 1 - I think: "im going to raise my right hand". I observe the thought and the choice. I sit a moment, then move my right hand up.
sounds simple. but i originally focused on which hand actually moved, so i messed around trying to trick myself. However, we're focused on the CHOICE point. So, i see that the first choice happened even before i thought "i'm going to raise my right hand", because i feel like i made a decision to consciously make a mental choice with mental words.
So the choice moves back to some sort of non-verbal decision *before* i form the word-thoughts.
Im comfortable with this, as after all, if you had to mentally think in words, all your decisions would be slow.
So it's before even the formation of word-thoughts. Perhaps a feeling? I tried not to jump too far down the chain, but inevitably led to "word-thought-decision preceded by 'feeling-decision', maybe preceded by some sort of networked interaction of beliefs, preceded by an 'optimized neural pathway' neurology mismash. All of which winds me up with the simple case of:
I dunno where that decision came from
So that doesnt make sense. My choices at this point in the experiment are:
a) decide to reject the theory that there is a decider
b) reject the experiment as flawed -- maybe we dont know how to measure the origin of choice, and this experiment of using my mind and body to observe a choice point is as flawed as using a bathroom to measure the weight of the planet.
c) decide that my understanding of decider/choice is inadequate internal thoughts: I'm stupid, im not educated enough, I have no background to understand, i should have studied philosophy
d) decide our current ability to measure/observe choice is inadequate -- internal thought: i'm a flat-lander commoner being told the world is round 100 years before there is an understanding of how to measure this
Help, I think im stuck in thinking thoughts.
Somehow I always land at: When I look and can't see a self/decider, but of course it's there (I have a belief, it seems), and I have to accept this belief 'on faith' or risk being ridiculous / ignorant / unbeliever. (hurm).
Ive tried to look at the consequence of rejecting this belief, but im think im so far off topic now that I should just stop.
This is supposed to be simple, direct and unquestionably seen/felt, right? well my current state is confused and frustrated, so at least i know im in the wrong neighborhood. heh.
Should you not have been happy, rather than disappointed, when you saw through an illusion you were holding?
This reminds me of the scene in 'the matrix' where the guy betrays his companions because he doesnt like the illusions he can no longer believe, he just wants to go back to believing the confortable illusions. (the 'i know this isnt a steak' scene)
I didn't like that guy and don't want to be that way. Your remarks make we wonder if I'm not peevishly holding on to an illusions because it's more comfortable than the reality I'm being shown.