Requesting a guide

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Tue Jun 11, 2013 3:20 am

No no! Absolutely not outside of conditioned co-production! I just hadn't been able to get my head wrapped around it.

I know I haven't been checking in as often lately. I don't feel like I have anything to say, really. I'm still just sitting with my experience. Not really sure where it's going, or IF it's going, but I'm sitting with it.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 8:15 am

OK, just get back to checking in with me anyway. It could all flow once you start typing. I want to ask you to allow the following from page four to inform your reflections:
"...stunningly simple..."
"...not very complicated!"
"...pretty obvious..."
"...surprisingly ordinary"
"...are you fu*king serious? Is THIS all it is!?"
"...an eerily ordinary, almost stupidly simple recognition..."
"...Christ, it's a drop-jaw no brainer!"
"...surely this can't be all there is to it?!"

Does this help to throw light on what that 'thing' might be?
I want you to see this as a real question in a spirit of genuine enquiry rather than any questioning of your intelligence. This is just not an intelligence 'thing' at all. So please do give it a bit of breathing space and reflection. The Buddha did not teach that there was 'no fixed unchanging self' instead he taught that there was 'no self' at all. Here is a quote from a recent seer through, who 'got it' a few weeks ago; might the answer to my above question be as simple as this?:

"I know I saw it to some degree very early on in this process (as it is really not very complicated!) Conditions are it. The Buddha didn’t say; "Everything is pratitya samutpada, plus a little chap with a clipboard, twiddling knobs in a control box" - he said, dependent arising is the whole thing in total...FULL STOP! I had never realised this before. I had always found a way to import the ‘I’.... albeit in the guise of an ever changing self, into the Dharma."


Nor did the buddha say everything is pratitya samutpada plus: "...an energy field in the upper half of your skull..." (Tara33 above)
Yes, there are sensations but where is the 'self' in direct experience?
The Buddha simply taught that there was no self. He did not teach that there was no delusion of self. He knew all about that delusion as he had once taken refuge in it too.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 8:37 am

Our big mistake is that we privately take ourselves out of Conditioned Coproduction as though it applied to everything else in the universe, but, somehow, not to this imagined 'self', this commentator!
We call this commentator ourself when it is simply mental proliferation (papancha) However consciousness is always endlessly generating content because that is what consciousness does!
In some ways it is remarkable that we conclude that the papancha is our 'self' when the evidence seems so insubstantial. Contrast the type of papancha we experience on a lovely weekend summer evening on a beach by the ocean with the papancha we experience in a mid-week Boston traffic snarl-up. It seems nuts to call this papancha a 'self', but that is what folk do! Insight into 'no self' consists in waking up the the realisation that papancha, mere mental proliferation, is not a self, nor is there a 'self' to be found in the other skandhas either...just relax, let go and LOOK.

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Tue Jun 11, 2013 1:02 pm

Well ... um.. I'm not finding that terribly helpful.

Yes, I understand that this is simple and obvious. I'm not trying to analyze this to death. I know it's not an intellect thing. I don't think of it as a questioning of my intelligence. I understand that it's about seeing something very simple. As I said before, I see it's like those brain teaser puzzles where the answer is just to turn my perceptions on its head and just see it differently. But I can't seem to find my way around this wall in front of me. I just keep staring at the wall. At least I'm not banging my head against it, but I have to admit the impatience is starting to come up again.

Yes, my impatience is just more prapanca. Yup.

I've been reflecting on pratitya samutpada. I see that too. Everything that happens is a result of something else being in place before it. I get it. I get it. I don't questions that either.

I don't have any doubts about any of this.

The Buddha taught that there is no self. There is no part of me that's exempt from that universal law. I get it! I get it!

You keep saying to relax, let go and look. That's what I'm doing. Just last night, I was having my typical bout of insomnia, so I was "meditating" in bed. What I mean by that is I was lying there with completely relaxed body, let go, and completely relaxed mind, let go. Allowing the sensations and thought to arise as they will, and observing the flow of it all. At times I was imagining what it might be like to really have no clinging to self. To allow each moment to arise and flow with it. I must have been doing that off and on for a good hour or two, because that's how long I was lying awake.

I do this sort of thing many many times throughout my day. While driving, while at my desk working, while out walking, etc.

So what am I not seeing? Where do I look? How do I look? I just don't get it. It's not helping me to tell me to just look, because that's what I'm doing! As best I understand how, at least.

By the way, you should know that as of the Friday after next (June 21), I head off to a full immersion meditation retreat for a month. With Viveka and Tejananda as the two retreat leaders, out in California. Part of my reason for doing this work now was to put myself in the right frame of mind for the retreat. If I don't pass through the gate before then (which is looking likely to me at this point), I'm hoping something might happen during the retreat. Well, something definitely WILL happen on retreat, no doubt. I don't know what it'll be though!

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 3:25 pm

Whoa now! Steady up and just hold those horses there! That retreat is ages away. You just keep yourself closer to our work here on this screen combined with your day to day observations OK? Things are still looking fine to me at this stage, but at this particular stage I need to see less side-stepping, OK frankly, I need to see less evasion really. Look, I know you are a conscientious wee scout so I do sympathise too. I know that you know the theory and you know meditation paractise etc and I really know what a pain in the neck it is to have to read my repeated injunctions to 'just look' but remember our 'looking in a new way' of a few days back? ie looking with a relaxed sense of metta? If you just do the same old same old, then you are bound to just get the same old results. But things changed for you then when you did things differently. Stay with that attitude plus Beginners Mind. Beginners Mind means having an outlook of; 'I know nothing, I know absolutely nothing'.

I will just level with you here and say that what looks to me is happening is that part of you already knows you are very close to 'getting it' and because of that, another part is running away in fear, it's putting up a strong rearguard defense to maintain the old fishbasket of self hood, because of its comforting familiarity. Sounds daft, but we all do it, so that's not a criticism. However I am asking you to just stay close here. You have nothing to lose but your Dukkha. You side stepped those seven questions of mine from page six. I let the matter go at the time in case it meant that you were taking stock and steadying up for your final run at the Gate, but I am now asking you to address those questions in the above spirit.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 4:37 pm

PS I forgot to say that a bit of frustration is fine by the way, but your metaphor of the brain teaser puzzle is more applicable to the lay man and not so applicable to you. For you, with all your Dharma training, it is a lot more straightforward than that and a lot more accessible via the rational faculty than one might have thought given the huge song and dance which is traditionally created around the topic (although yes, what you finally see when you 'get it' is such a surprise that it causes a huge emotional shift)

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Tue Jun 11, 2013 5:03 pm

For you, with all your Dharma training, it is a lot more straightforward than that and a lot more accessible via the rational faculty than one might have thought given the huge song and dance which is traditionally created around the topic
Can you say a little more about that? It makes intuitive sense, but I'm not sure I completely understand.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 8:03 pm

Sure I would be glad to say more: The man in the street usually does not know that the Buddha in one of the earliest examples of Direct Pointing said:


Bahiya sutta:
In the seen, there is only the seen,
in the heard, there is only the heard,
in the sensed, there is only the sensed,
in the cognized, there is only the cognized.
Thus you should see that
indeed there is no [self] here;
this, Bahiya, is how you should train yourself.
Since, Bahiya, there is for you
in the seen, only the seen,
in the heard, only the heard,
in the sensed, only the sensed,
in the cognized, only the cognized,
and you see that there is no [self] here,
you will therefore see that
indeed there is no [self] there.
As you see that there is no [self] there,
you will see that
you are therefore located neither in the world of this,
nor in the world of that,
nor in any place
betwixt the two.
This alone is the end of suffering.” (ud. 1.10)

(The original translator had used the word 'thing' which I replaced with [self] which is more immediate to our current enquiry purposes. Presumably he had originally used the word 'thing' to cover every kind of self-construction that the self takes refuge in; ie 'me', 'self', 'I', soul, atta, Ground of Being, etc. Dh.Jnanavira)

For you it is different Tara. You have this udana, this Verse of Uplift which instantly resulted in Bahiya 'seeing though' with no training. I would ask you to read it again closely as Jnanavira has made a more comprehensible job of it. Don't make the mistake of instantly recognising it and saying; 'Oh yeah I know that one!'

More to follow from me later.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 9:00 pm

The man in the street would at best just shrug his shoulders, at worst get angry at the concepts of Right View and Wrong View. You on the other hand will not even get angry when I now admonish you that you are flagrantly denying the teaching of the Buddha, that you are neurotically clutching onto cherished wrong view of 'self' in your deluded greed and hatred. This does not bug you because you know I am just being a well-meaning brother in the Dharma who knows that this is what we all do anyway, and that I am not much better, having only broken the first fetters and therefor still having all the others myself!!!


Now look, what's coming next is very important. It is crucial:
Just take a few kindly breaths and be still.
I really, really did mean 'relaxing' and 'letting go'
You are NOT being asked to cultivate a higher STATE of consciousness in which you then realise; 'Oh, hey, there IS no self!' that is the Samatha approach and that is fine. This approach is very different. It is the Vipassana approach in which, through being Directly Pointed to ones own Direct Experience, one becomes aware that there is indeed no self to be found, quite simply because there never HAS been any self, at ANY time in the first place.

This is not a STATE that is achieved it is simply a seeing, simply a realisation. It is not metaphysical. Just look at the evidence. That is all that is meant by; 'JUST LOOK'.

You have looked and not found any meaningful concrete self in your bald, unadorned sensations of seeing, of hearing, or of thinking. Nor have you found anything that could be meaningfully called a 'self' in the changing patterns of bodily sensations either. Most people think there is a self in these before they look, but that is mere uncorroborated speculation, (those same people are capable of 'experienceing their 'self' in a rubber hand. But is that really their 'self' in that rubber hand?!) You, on the other hand, have found that that is not the case in your direct experience of just looking. Your empirical analysis has revealed that there is in fact, no self to be found in the five skandhas, as the Heart Sutra steadily points out, skandha by skandha.

It is not Rocket Science which explains people's general exclamations of astonishment when they notice this for the first time! Frankly there never WAS any self in the first place! I am not speaking figuratively here nor am I speaking metaphoricaly, instead I am speaking in simple plain English with neither twist, nor spin, nor embroidery. That is why it is called 'recognition' when people wake up. This entails relaxing and letting go the cherished illusion of there being a 'self' and now awakening to a new dawn of truly living free from the suffering caused by a belief in a self. This simple recognition which emerges at that moment of relaxing and letting go the limiting notion of a 'self' is what gives rise to those cries of how simple it all is when you actually look. It is not about trying hard to see this 'no self'. You will not see it because it was never there in the first place.

It would not be so easy for me to ask this of the man in the street, but again, I am asking you leave aside that limiting garment just for the sake of argument for a few seconds, and instead try this coat on for size in the privacy of your own room there. You are only trying out a view a bit like someone notionally trying out the idea that their hated politcally opposite party might be right, in the privacy of his own mind. This is not something needing a higher state of consciousness AT ALL. It is like the difference between a kid believing in Santa and not believing in Santa anymore. It is black and white. Just relax into giving up that old limiting view.

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Tue Jun 11, 2013 10:13 pm

Thought you'd appreciate this:
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid ... =1&theater

More from me later. Probably tomorrow morning.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 10:44 pm

A smashing cartoon Tara!
Just a wee bit more Direct Pointing to your own Direct Experience as you sit there now, from the Buddha. This is stuff that the man in the street would not always have had immediate access to, nor would he likely be able to take on board, if he were not already a Buddhist in the first place, like you are.

The Buddha is refreshingly unambiguous here with his declaration of Right View and leaves no grounds whatsoever for slavishly persisting in any belief in the existence of any kind of any tiny wee self, being detectable in Direct Experience anywhere, ever:


AN 10.60 Girimānanda Sutta:

"Now what, Ānanda, is the recognition of selflessness? Here, Ānanda, a monk, gone to the wilderness, to the root of a tree, or to an empty place, discriminates thus: ‘The eye is not-self, forms are not-self; the ear is not-self, sounds are not-self; the nose is not-self, odors are not-self; the tongue is not-self, flavors are not-self; the body is not-self, tactual objects are not-self; the mind is not-self, phenomena are not-self.’ Thus he abides contemplating selflessness with regard to the six internal and external sensory spheres. This, Ānanda, is called the recognition of selflessness."

Just breathe, relax, let go.

Will you now take a look at the Heart Sutra in this light?

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Tue Jun 11, 2013 10:51 pm

But of course I am insisting that you need to be looking into your own direct experience here. If you just stay in the head ie if you just stay at the level of Views, then that old wrong veiw could cloud wisdom out through sheer weight of habit. This needs giving up, relaxing, letting go!

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:57 pm

Today is one of those days when I'm mostly in back-to-back appointments. I have 30 minutes right now so I'll report in quickly.

I confess to having an "ugly mood day" yesterday. I have gotten into this unfortunate pattern where every time I get a deep-tissue muscular therapy, it sends my whole system into haywire, in particular a brain fog that results in a pretty deep depression and irritability. So I apologize if I came across negative. I also confess that I felt very angry and frustrated at you yesterday. But I also was aware that I was in that ugly mood (not a real self), and so restrained myself from responding while under its very powerful spell. It has passed. I am not angry at you today.

So I think these are the questions you said I was avoiding:
This time turn to thoughts:
Can a thought think itself?
Can a thought decide to think?
Notice the arisal and departure of thoughts?
Have you ever clearly decided to do a Metta meditation practise only to find that 'your' thoughts sometimes wanders off to do something else? How could that possibly happen if your thoughts are 'you' and that you had decided to do the Metta?
Might it just be that thoughts come and go by themselves? That we just call them 'ours' through sheer habit? That we think that our thinking is 'me' that it is 'self', but in actual fact. when you look at it, you get to see that it just happens?
I don't think I was avoiding responding so much as I felt like it wasn't getting me anywhere to respond. I can give my "right answer" to all of them. And it's not just a view. I really do see that it is that way. But something inside still wasn't letting go of this notion that there is a self in the middle of it all. I can write out my replies if you wish. But I think you know how I'm going to answer, right?

You suggested that I "try on" the idea that I have no self. One of the reasons I was frustrated with you yesterday is because I still was unable to figure out HOW to try it on. I had mentioned a couple times that I could figure out HOW but didn't feel you had responded. Well, this morning I think I got a vague sense of how I might do it. Not that I actually was able to, but I just sat and asked myself, "what might it feel like right now if there really was no self here?" I just sat deeply with that, with metta. Some progress in that direction, I think. Nothing much, but something.

I had a serious bout of insomnia last night. The worst in a very long time. That isn't part of my usual post-massage symptoms. I'm wondering if this is Mara again. It fits his pattern with me. He's very disruptive, usually in a bodily way.

by the way, this is my Vedic horoscope for this week:
Scorpio: Dig into death and dance in the charnel grounds. Shovel your compost and sift through the soil. Hear of the haunts and listen to their whispers. Transformations are here to forever change you. Gather your sacred Kali mala and count your blessings.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Wed Jun 12, 2013 10:47 pm

OK no probs. I was just giving a bit of Dharmic background with the Buddha's Direct Pointing to the observable fact that there is no self to be found in Direct Experience. You are not going to lose a 'self'. You never at any point have had any self in the first place. 'Self' is just a thought, not a reality that can be found anywhere in direct experience. Take another look at the definition of Direct Experience which I sent you in that document earlier.

The HOW, is simply to look in a spirit of CELT, (curiosity, exploration, learning and keeping it tangible) with that kindly warmth of metta. Just looking, that's all. Do you find a 'self' anywhere in your actual, by which I mean YOUR ACTUAL direct experience? Just relax and let go into your own tangible direct experience right now in this moment.

Take another look at this right now because it was these six questions from page six that I was referring to, not the ones you thought:

[[Firstly just a little bit more on those limiting, doubt filled thoughts of yours from earlier on:

Are your thoughts the real you? Are thoughts your 'self'?

Do you really want to be identified as your thoughts?

Especially when they are sometimes as unhelpful as those ones were?

Can a thought really be 'your' 'self' if it just arrives unchosen and takes up unwanted residence?

Can a thought actually DO anything?

Thought was not even capable of reminding you that metta is the way forward here. You already knew that but 'thought' did not even bother to wheel that one out for you, an item that you tell students about all the time.

Can we seriously rely on thought since we don't know where it comes from, and don't know where it goes to when it goes, and we don't know when the next one will arrive!?

There is never more than one thought experienced at any given time. Thought is just so limited! It's like a one note instrument compared to the symphonic possibilities of that fuller awareness which becomes available when we leave thought aside for a bit, de-emphasise its centrality in our lives, and instead just 'be'. Just savouring our direct experience of the Universe.]]

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Wed Jun 12, 2013 10:51 pm

Great to see that your Vedic Horoscope is telling you that you are nearly there already!!!


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], Majestic-12 [Bot] and 8 guests