Requesting a guide

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Thu May 30, 2013 2:00 pm

It's good that you spelled out the driving scenario because, to be honest, you probably never would've gotten it out of me otherwise. I'm familiar with the phenomenon because I used to do it, of course, like everybody else. But I rarely if ever actually do it now.

Part of the reason might be because I live in the middle of a city and I can't imagine zoning out like that while driving. It would be downright dangerous. Not only for me, but for others too – especially pedestrians that leap out in front of my car at intersections without looking (because they're busy watching their iPhones instead -- I guess THEY are doing this exercise, aren't they?).

But as I think about it now, I realize that I rarely drive like that even if I'm on a boring open stretch of highway and I'm the only car on the road (as I did on my trip to New York last weekend). I've come to enjoy mindful driving, and often do so without the radio or any other distractions. Even if I'm in a conversation with someone with me, I still stay mindful.

I was thinking last night whether there might be other things I do that could substitute for this "mind off elsewhere" experience. The only thing I could come up with was playing the piano. There are some extremely fast and complicated passages that one cannot possibly play by consciously manipulating each finger movement. It can only be played on physical autopilot. I do recall times when I watched my arms and hands in amazement at what they were doing, because "I" was not really controlling them.

But I have not played the piano now for 18 years, and probably never will again. I got injured and had to give that up long ago.

Yes, of course, there are times when I am absent. For example, like everyone else I sometimes put down my reading glasses somewhere and then five minutes later have no idea where I put them. The classic move of people hitting middle age. But apart from these sort of fleeting scenarios, I think I rarely go into that kind of absent autopilot.

I suppose you could be talking about those driving moments when my foot seems to automatically go to the brake when an unexpected car or pedestrian leaps in front of me. It happens before I make the conscious choice to do it. So yes, I'm definitely familiar with the phenomenon, in fleeting moments.

Remember the description I gave you a while back about steering a canoe down a river? To me, THATS more what the experience feels like. There are many times when my body becomes that river (say, when walking), in the sense that it's flowing with its own momentum, and there's really no conscious choice/self-involved in moving it. But I'm still mindfully present, steering the canoe in a bigger directional way. Does that make sense?

I will try walking today and get back to you. I may or may not make it before your bedtime because I have a pretty full day today.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Thu May 30, 2013 6:01 pm

OK no probs! The wandering mind thing I mentioned was not a neccessary part of that exercise in Just Looking (besides I would not have asked you to be mindful of unmindfulness when it was in the process of occuring anyway!) so I should not have mentioned it.
My central point was simply that the mind/body organism simply performs all of that stuff quite seem-lessly without conscious commands or coaxing.

This is a wee bit more remarkable in Europe where we have shift stick autos; so in town traffic, there is all this really complex stuff going on with the left hand (the engine reaches the right note for a gear change. This engine note comes in through the ears, is interpreted by the brain and becomes a hand movement which shifts the gear stick etc) But I thought I would just try it with an American driver anyway as there is still a lot going on with really important visual stuff being transmitted via the brain to the legs.

So it is all about just noticing that all that complexity happens by itself whether we are mindful of it or not.
Give it another look sometime at your convenience.

Still on 'seeing'; I'd like to return to something you said half way down our second page:

[[Postby tara33 » May 23rd, 2013, 3:59 pm
I'm finding it more difficult to work with my sense of sight as opposed to hearing. When I look at something, I get the distinct experience of there being me and a separate object. I am here, it is there. And therefore it's hard to avoid the feeling that "I" am looking at "the object". I'm still working on this one.]]

I want you to tell me more in detail about the actual content of the; "...experience of there being me..."
Just take a look at that 'me' right now.
What is its size?
What is its shape?
What is its colour?
What is its texture?
How would you describe this thing, this so called 'me' in words that a twelve year old would understand?
Does it in fact really exist at all?

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Thu May 30, 2013 7:00 pm

I want you to tell me more in detail about the actual content of the; "...experience of there being me..."
Just take a look at that 'me' right now.
What is its size?
What is its shape?
What is its colour?
What is its texture?
How would you describe this thing, this so called 'me' in words that a twelve year old would understand?
Does it in fact really exist at all?
I know that there really is no "me" there, but that's my intellect speaking. If you ask my direct experience what's there here are my answers:

Size and shape: it roughly corresponds with the upper half of my skull. So the upper hemisphere down to maybe around my nose or upper lip-level. It fills that entire space.

Color and texture: Once again, I'm showing that I am a somatic experiencer, not a visual one. So in my experience, it has no color or texture. It's just an energy field that I sense, an "aliveness" that gets activated when it sees an object out there. This is what I sense when there is visual stimulation in front of me.

As an experiment, I'm closing my eyes right now and seeing if anything changes. But even with my eyes closed, I still have the sense of looking ahead at this darkness ahead of me. So it's still there. I don't have time to do it now but I think if I sit and meditate for a long time with my eyes closed, that "aliveness" would dissipate. But I'm not sure. I'll have to check when I sit tomorrow morning.

Does it in fact really exist at all? If I had to answer only from my direct experience, I would have to say yes. There's definitely something there. But my head knows that's the wrong answer.

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Thu May 30, 2013 7:44 pm

So it is all about just noticing that all that complexity happens by itself whether we are mindful of it or not.
Give it another look sometime at your convenience.
An addendum here.

Yes, I did get the point of this exercise after your response. I do know from brain research that there are many ways the brain can coordinate our physical and mental actions without our conscious control. The amygdala and the "fight or flight" response is another good example. So I do understand that there is no single central conductor who is in charge of everything. But that still doesn't prove to me that there is no self anywhere at all. My direct experience is still trying to convince me that it is there somewhere behind SOME of my actions.

Also, a little more on my previous response. I realize that this energy field in my head that I was describing is again just a physical sensation. Not really any proof that there is a conscious "self"/conductor present. But somehow deep down inside I still want to believe that it's there.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Thu May 30, 2013 11:33 pm

Very good stuff in both posts! We are really closing in on it now thanks to your honest, openness.
More form me tomorrow on those great entries from you this evening.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Fri May 31, 2013 1:03 pm

I know that there really is no "me" there, but that's my intellect speaking.
Great straddling of this diachotomy
As an experiment, I'm closing my eyes right now and seeing if anything changes. But even with my eyes closed, I still have the sense of looking ahead at this darkness ahead of me. So it's still there. I don't have time to do it now but I think if I sit and meditate for a long time with my eyes closed, that "aliveness" would dissipate. But I'm not sure. I'll have to check when I sit tomorrow morning.

Does it in fact really exist at all? If I had to answer only from my direct experience, I would have to say yes. There's definitely something there. But my head knows that's the wrong answer.
Again nice crisp stuff (but your middle piece above is not Direct Experience it is just reported thoughts BTW)
Does it in fact really exist at all? If I had to answer only from my direct experience, I would have to say yes. There's definitely something there. But my head knows that's the wrong answer.
Mmm!
Also, a little more on my previous response. I realize that this energy field in my head that I was describing is again just a physical sensation. Not really any proof that there is a conscious "self"/conductor present. But somehow deep down inside I still want to believe that it's there.
'Course we'd still want to believe it, otherwise we'd go nuts, right?!
(office interruptions now. Back with you again shortly. NB don't do this on an iphone I want you sitting at a full screen having taken a few breaths first. If that means you leaving it till later that's OK)

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Fri May 31, 2013 3:06 pm

Excuse my delay. Don't come you back in yet.
I just want to follow on directly from my post directly above and will do so in a few hours.
Just let things simmer.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Fri May 31, 2013 5:59 pm

(Just continuing straight on from above, now please just re read down again, starting from my post at 12.03)


Of course you want to, otherwise you'd go nuts right?

OK you have a clear, even seemingly quite rational, fixed view in place. So far, so good, that is not a problem. It is however a view about how 'things' are; ie it is a view about The Nature Of Existance. However your current view is absolutely counter to that taught by the Buddha which as you know was that the Nature of Existence is; Impermanence, Unsatisfactoriness and No Self. Your view currently occupies the place in your consciousness which is ideally meant to be occupeid by his RIGHT VIEW instead. Frankly the two are mutually exclusive! OK?

Now don't laugh here, you are doing just fine, ideals can wait! However in the meantime we just have to open up to Possibility Land a little bit more to invite the insight to arise, set the scene, make it nice and accomodating right?

OK try this: I want to ask you to acknowledge that that view of having a 'self', that garment, so to speak, has got you this far and that is fine, that coat has done its job. But look, I now want to ask you to just try on a different coat to see how that one feels OK? No one can see you, you have nothing to lose, you are only going to try the thing on for heaven's sake!
However, before pulling out this coat/view for you to try on, I must caution you in advance that on first seeing it people often exclaim something like "You can't be serious! That's not a coat!"

Let's just look at this Insight 'thing' another way:
If everyone (and I do mean everyone without exception; everyone for millenia as well as everyone who has seen it via this forum in recent days) if everyone variously describes it as being:

"...stunningly simple..."
"...not very complicated!"
"...pretty obvious..."
"...surprisingly ordinary"
"...are you fu*king serious? Is THIS all it is!?"
"...an eerily ordinary, almost stupidly simple recognition..."
"...Christ, it's a drop-jaw no brainer!"
"...surely this can't be all there is to it?!"

Does this help to throw light on what that 'thing' might be?
I want you to see this as a real question in a spirit of genuine enquiry rather than any questioning of your intelligence. This is just not an intelligence 'thing' at all. So please do give it a bit of breathing space and reflection. The Buddha did not teach that there was 'no fixed unchanging self' instead he taught that there was 'no self' at all. Here is a quote from a recent seer through, who 'got it' a few weeks ago; might the answer to my above question be as simple as this?:

"I know I saw it to some degree very early on in this process (as it is really not very complicated!) Conditions are it. The Buddha didn’t say everything is pratitya samutpada plus a little chap with a clipboard, twiddling knobs in a control box - he said dependent arising is it...full stop! I had never realised this before. I had always found a way to import the ‘I’.... albeit in the guise of an ever changing self, into the Dharma."


Nor did the buddha say everything is pratitya samutpadait plus: "...an energy field in the upper half of your skull..." (Tara33 above)
Yes, there are sensations but where is the 'self' in direct experience?
The Buddha simply taught that there was no self. He did not teach that there was no delusion of self. He knew all about that delusion as he had once taken refuge in it too.
I'd like to now ask you to allow it to become at least provisionally admissable that there is no 'self', there are only the skandhas, in the same way that you acknowledged above that there is no hearer, only the heard.

Get back this to me evening before 10.30 GMT if so inclined.

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Fri May 31, 2013 6:18 pm

OK, this sounds very interesting indeed. I will not be able to respond today. I am leading an all-day retreat tomorrow and need to do some preparation for the rest of the day. And I'm likely to be pretty wiped out tomorrow evening, so who knows about tomorrow. I'll keep you posted.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Fri May 31, 2013 6:41 pm

Ok keep me posted. But just re read all of the above before bed. You will have a lovely day tomorrow, especially if you just re read it all again in the morning after setting yourself up with a bit of kindly breathing first.

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Sat Jun 01, 2013 2:39 pm

Just a really quick reply now as I head out in about 30 minutes.

I have reread your post several times now. For me it's not an issue of doubting whether or not I should try that coat on, it's that I can't figure out HOW to try to on! I feel as though this is one of those mind-bender puzzles where you're supposed to see the solution but the only way to see the solution is to shift your perspective completely. It doesn't involve racking the brain, but just a simple shift. And I can't figure out how to make that shift to even start putting that coat on (to mix metaphors here).

Maybe while on retreat today I'll be in a clear enough mind to be able to let go of whatever it is that's clouding my vision.

I am heading straight to my sister's place after the retreat for dinner and to spend time with family. So it's not likely I'll post again today.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Sat Jun 01, 2013 7:51 pm

OK, that's fine, and is clarifying things for me in terms of procedure. Have a good dinner at your sister's.
More from me later. The Great Gatsby tonight at the Arthouse, bringing earplugs as I am told it is LOUD!

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Sun Jun 02, 2013 1:53 pm

way to see the solution is to shift your perspective completely. It doesn't involve racking the brain, but just a simple shift. And I can't figure out how to make that shift
That's it great! You just reassured me that we are right on the money here. Yes that is all it involves. Just take it easy and savour the ride. No, it cannot be figured out from the theory but at least we are agreed on the theory which not every long term Buddhist is these days.

The 'answer' is not really an 'answer' as such because you know the answer already (It is more like a waking up really) it emerges from just looking, I want to emphasize that because it can so easily be overlooked; JUST LOOKING by concientiously attending to data available in you direct experience right now sitting in front of your screen.

Perceiving might be a better word than looking as sometimes we are apprehending the data via ear or mind. Especially applying perception along the lines of the territories outlined in that Direct Experience document I sent previously by email.

The faculty of 'hearing' is a good Dharma door for you. Touch also sounds like a useful access point for you. On the latter, this short video is a lovely proof of that there is no self, just the skandhas. Take your time over it, leave it till later if necessary, but watch it twice and really take in the implications of it. It gave me goosebumps about what it suggested about our capacity to take this teaching out to a wider audience.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCQbygjG0RU

User avatar
Amanda44
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 2:37 am

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Amanda44 » Sun Jun 02, 2013 2:39 pm

I'm still stuck at square one. Watched the video but it didn't strike me in any particular way.

I read this article that came into my mailbox this morning:
Recognizing the Thinker by Tulku Urgyen Rimpoche
http://buddhismnow.com/2013/05/11/recog ... -rinpoche/

And I'm still feeling like this:
https://www.facebook.com/MindfulPurpose ... tif_t=like

I can't figure out what to try differently. I guess I'll just keep simmering on it.

User avatar
Mad biker
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 11:39 pm

Re: Requesting a guide

Postby Mad biker » Sun Jun 02, 2013 4:24 pm

I read this article that came into my mailbox this morning:
Recognizing the Thinker by Tulku Urgyen Rimpoche
http://buddhismnow.com/2013/05/11/recog ... -rinpoche/

And I'm still feeling like this:
https://www.facebook.com/MindfulPurpose ... tif_t=like
Well that could be an example of why it can be better to leave aside all input from anywhere else (though your usual day to day practise is fine) for the duration of this enquiry. The guy was doing his best but it was not that good really. An Eastern church bloke giving me a long advert about how, the-Buddha-alone-was-right-because-he-was-Enlightened just would not cut it for me. And 'mind essence' WTF? Perhaps the guy knew what he meant but what came across looked like standard memorised doctrine.

OK let's you and me get back to METHOD!
Oh hey, I loved your Facebook cartoon above! I laughed out loud and want to be quick to reassure you that no, we are not there yet! Yes,I know I have said it is very ordinary, but it is not so ordinary that you feel the same as you did! When it happens you know it has happened. When the shift comes, it is not an analog shift it is completely digital!
It is the difference between having a cup in your hand and letting it go for it to smash on the floor.

There is no such thing as some of the cup remaining in your hand and some of it being on the floor. It is a black and white distinction and it is just as black and white to me that you are going to get this.
Yes just stay with the simmering.
More from me later.


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 7 guests