I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby poppyseed » Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:17 pm

Hi Azi,
I realise the label doesn’t add anything to the experience and the sensations are just sensations happening.
Great! You're getting the hang of looking rather than thinking about experience :)
How does it feel to see what actually is?

Now that you know how to LOOK, let’s explore the body where sensations are believed to be happening – like “tension in my jaw”, etc
1. Take something cold from the fridge – like a can of cooldrink. When you touch the can, what does more accurately describe your experience:
a. Your fingers feeling cold because of touching a cold can; or
b. Coldness - sensation labelled “cold”? With eyes closed, WHERE does the cold appear?

Observe the order in which the details appear
2. Sit comfortably on a chair. Close your eyes and relax. Pay attention only to the feeling of your body. Just notice the pure sensations, without relying on thoughts or mental images. Keep your eyes closed and look:
Can it be known how tall the body is?
Does the body have a weight or volume?
In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
Is there a boundary between the body and the chair? At the point where your body contacts the chair, are there two things there, a body and chair, or one, sensation?
Is it "my" body, or is it just a body?
Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
Can the 'body' do things?

Look very carefully, especially with the last question. You can look several times during the day while doing other things (like washing hands, showering, walking, lying down, etc) before replying.

At this point, please use the quote function and answer each question individually. I don't need summaries, I want reports of looking with each question

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
GoodnightAZ
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:38 am

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby GoodnightAZ » Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:58 pm

a. Your fingers feeling cold because of touching a cold can; or
b. Coldness - sensation labelled “cold”? With eyes closed, WHERE does the cold appear?

It feels like the sensation appearing in space. But the label very quickly follows it. Especially as the mental formation of the hand appears. Especially in terms of orientation. While it feels like sensation appearing the orientation is very quickly taken over by my idea of where my hand is in relation to my body.

Can it be known how tall the body is?
There’s the mental image of my body and its different parts but when I remove that it becomes just the sensations of my body touching the seat in space. But I think there’s is also a categorisation of the sensations that is difficult to seperate from the actual experience. The feeling of the air on my neck and the feeling of my butt on the chair and feet on the floor are all appearing in space as sensations but I struggle to separate them from where I recognise these sensations as being.
Does the body have a weight or volume?
Similarly I can feel the sensation of the point of contacts I have with my clothes and the seat but no densit or weight. But with weight and volume it is easier to seperate as there isn’t the same point of references for orientation as height.
In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
In the actual experience the body doesn’t have a shape, but it’s difficult to seperate the mental image of the body from the actual experience. But in the actual experience, with eyes closed it’s more like sensations appearing.
Is there a boundary between the body and the chair?
It feels more like there isn’t a chair and a body but more just the sensation of the contact between them.
At the point where your body contacts the chair, are there two things there, a body and chair, or one, sensation?
There is only one sensation, the body’s contact points with the chair becomes less like separate things (back and chair) and more like just the sensation of contact appearing.

Is it "my" body, or is it just a body?
With eyes closed, in actual experience the sensation felt feel like they are appearing in space rather than in my body. It feels like my body or a body and more like just feeling occurring.
Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
It doesn’t feel like there’s an inside in the actual experience but it’s hard not to form the mental image of the body. But for example the feeling in my stomach which I might call inside the body and the contact with the chair feel both just like sensation appearing in space, neither inside or outside.

What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
Body refers to the point of sensations with stimuli. So while the feelings in actual experience don’t feel internal or external, I can recognise that the feeling regardless relates to a body. I don’t have the sensation of things that are not in direct contact with me. So even with my eyes closed it feels borderless, the extent to which sensations appear can in my understanding only relate to what’s in contact with my body.
Can the 'body' do things?
This question struck me a little. In direct experience the things happen in body like the sensations occur but it’s more like the body feels those things happening. But in terms of movement then the body does do something. If I move my hands with my eyes closed I feel the sensation of the air moving but that sensation appears because my hand is moving.

While practicing this something was confusing was the orientation of my mental image. While it feels like just sensation for some seconds I can feel these sensations out of orientation but then the mental body image comes back.

User avatar
GoodnightAZ
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:38 am

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby GoodnightAZ » Thu Nov 19, 2026 12:00 am

Sorry for the late reply I been moving round a lot today and yesterday.
a. Your fingers feeling cold because of touching a cold can; or
b. Coldness - sensation labelled “cold”? With eyes closed, WHERE does the cold appear?


It feels like the sensation appearing in space. But the label very quickly follows it. Especially as the mental formation of the hand appears. Especially in terms of orientation. While it feels like sensation appearing the orientation is very quickly taken over by my idea of where my hand is in relation to my body.

Can it be known how tall the body is?
There’s the mental image of my body and its different parts but when I remove that it becomes just the sensations of my body touching the seat in space. But I think there’s is also a categorisation of the sensations that is difficult to seperate from the actual experience. The feeling of the air on my neck and the feeling of my butt on the chair and feet on the floor are all appearing in space as sensations but I struggle to separate them from where I recognise these sensations as being.
Does the body have a weight or volume?


Similarly I can feel the sensation of the point of contacts I have with my clothes and the seat but no densit or weight. But with weight and volume it is easier to seperate as there isn’t the same point of references for orientation as height.
In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
In the actual experience the body doesn’t have a shape, but it’s difficult to seperate the mental image of the body from the actual experience. But in the actual experience, with eyes closed it’s more like sensations appearing.
Is there a boundary between the body and the chair?

It feels more like there isn’t a chair and a body but more just the sensation of the contact between them.
At the point where your body contacts the chair, are there two things there, a body and chair, or one, sensation?
There is only one sensation, the body’s contact points with the chair becomes less like separate things (back and chair) and more like just the sensation of contact appearing.

Is it "my" body, or is it just a body?
With eyes closed, in actual experience the sensation felt feel like they are appearing in space rather than in my body. It feels like my body or a body and more like just feeling occurring.
Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
It doesn’t feel like there’s an inside in the actual experience but it’s hard not to form the mental image of the body. But for example the feeling in my stomach which I might call inside the body and the contact with the chair feel both just like sensation appearing in space, neither inside or outside.

What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
Body refers to the point of sensations with stimuli. So while the feelings in actual experience don’t feel internal or external, I can recognise that the feeling regardless relates to a body. I don’t have the sensation of things that are not in direct contact with me. So even with my eyes closed it feels borderless, the extent to which sensations appear can in my understanding only relate to what’s in contact with my body.
Can the 'body' do things?
This question struck me a little. In direct experience the things happen in body like the sensations occur but it’s more like the body feels those things happening. But in terms of movement then the body does do something. If I move my hands with my eyes closed I feel the sensation of the air moving but that sensation appears because my hand is moving.

While practicing this something was confusing was the orientation of my mental image. While it feels like just sensation for some seconds I can feel these sensations out of orientation but then the mental body image comes back.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby poppyseed » Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:00 am

Hi Azi,
Body refers to the point of sensations with stimuli. So while the feelings in actual experience don’t feel internal or external, I can recognise that the feeling regardless relates to a body.
Remember the apple exercise? "Apple" is a label pointing to colours, sensations, smells and tastes. But can an actual "apple" be found as something separate from those experiences?
Now apply the same looking to "body". There are sensations, colours, thoughts and mental images, but can you find a "body" as something additional to these? Or is "body" another label describing them?
The actual experience of the body is thought. Thought points to sensations, colours, smells :) and labels it a ‘body’, but can a body be found as actual experience or only thoughts about a body?
With eyes closed, in actual experience the sensation felt feel like they are appearing in space rather than in my body. It feels like my body or a body and more like just feeling occurring.
Ok let’s agree on something:
Seems like/feels like = thought content
Nothing in DE is feels or seems like – it’s either here clear as a day (e.g. as sensation/colour/etc) or not.

You repeatedly describe sensations as "appearing in space". But can you actually find this space in direct experience, apart from the sensations themselves? Or is space another interpretation/mental image supplied by thought?
Close your eyes and notice a sensation, perhaps the contact with the chair. Now, apart from the sensation itself, can you actually experience the space in which it supposedly appears?
Does the sensation have a location of its own, or is that location supplied by thought and mental imagery?
And is there a sensation AND space containing it, or is there simply sensation? Check… Is space not just another mental image?

While it feels like just sensation for some seconds I can feel these sensations out of orientation but then the mental body image comes back.
There's no need to get rid of it. Mental images are thoughts too. The same way you don't have to get rid of thoughts. We're simply investigating whether what the image/thought (their content) describes can actually be found in direct experience. Let's explore this with a little experiment.
Close your eyes and imagine holding a watermelon in your hands. Imagine it as vividly as possible — its weight, shape, and the texture of its skin. Now open your eyes.
What happened to the watermelon? Was there ever an actual watermelon there, or only a mental image of one?
The image (aka thought) appeared, certainly, but was what it depicted actually present? Could you actually touch it and smell it, or taste it?
Now consider the mental image of your body. Is the image itself the body, or is it a thought ABOUT the body?
When that image appears, does it change anything about the sensations themselves?

This question struck me a little. In direct experience the things happen in body like the sensations occur but it’s more like the body feels those things happening. But in terms of movement then the body does do something. If I move my hands with my eyes closed I feel the sensation of the air moving but that sensation appears because my hand is moving.
Can a mental image do anything? Can a label do anything? Can a sensation do anything? Do you SEE anything doing something on anything else? (think of the apple and cup of coffee exercises)
We’ll have a deeper investigation of this next…
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
GoodnightAZ
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:38 am

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby GoodnightAZ » Fri Nov 20, 2026 1:42 am

Remember the apple exercise? "Apple" is a label pointing to colours, sensations, smells and tastes. But can an actual "apple" be found as something separate from those experiences?
Now apply the same looking to "body".
I get it, before I was still attaching the idea of a body to the direct experience. The sensations appear but I was still assigning those sensations to the label of the body rather than just sensations.

There are sensations, colours, thoughts and mental images, but can you find a "body" as something additional to these? Or is "body" another label describing them?
In direct experience I can’t find a body. There are just these senses occurring. With my eyes closed that idea of a border and body goes away.
The actual experience of the body is thought. Thought points tosensations, colours, smells :) and labels it a ‘body’, but can a body be found as actual experience or only thoughts about a body?
The body is just a label, there is only thoughts about the body in the actual experience.

You repeatedly describe sensations as "appearing in space". But can you actually find this space in direct experience, apart from the sensations themselves? Or is space another interpretation/mental image supplied by thought?
Space appears as another mental imagery similar to the body orientation mental image. The sensations are just occurring rather than being in a specific place or place in general.

Close your eyes and notice a sensation, perhaps the contact with the chair. Now, apart from the sensation itself, can you actually experience the space in which it supposedly appears?
The sensation just appears as sensation.

Does the sensation have a location of its own, or is that location supplied by thought and mental imagery?
The thoughts add the image of a location but in the actual experience there is only the sensations.
And is there a sensation AND space containing it, or is there simply sensation?
It is just the sensation. The space is just an image added on.


Close your eyes and imagine holding a watermelon in your hands. Imagine it as vividly as possible — its weight, shape, and the texture of its skin. Now open your eyes.
What happened to the watermelon?
The watermelon never existed it was just a thought about a watermelon and how it would feel and smell.

Was there ever an actual watermelon there, or only a mental image of one?
The watermelon only existed as a mental image.
The image (aka thought) appeared, certainly, but was what it depicted actually present?
No it was just a thought.
Could you actually touch it and smell it, or taste it?
There were thoughts about how it would smell and feel but they were just thoughts about it and now actual experience.
Now consider the mental image of your body. Is the image itself the body, or is it a thought ABOUT the body?
The mental image of the body is just a thought about the body.

When that image appears, does it change anything about the sensations themselves?
Nothing is added to the sensation through the image, it’s just a label. Like how the feeling of the rain doesn’t get added to by calling it rain.

Can a mental image do anything? Can a label do anything? Can a sensation do anything? Do you SEE anything doing something on anything else?
There is no doing it’s only happening. The “body” feels, like when holding a cold glass there’s only feeling. The sensation happens. The mental image doesn’t portray anything in the actual experience.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby poppyseed » Fri Nov 20, 2026 9:22 am

Hi Azi,
Great looking! :)
You've explored how thoughts and mental images label sensations and create the impression of a body and its location.
Now let's investigate thoughts themselves.
For the next exercise I want you to sit somewhere quiet and observe thoughts. A thought appears.
In that moment is there anyone or anything which recognises the thought or is being aware of it?
Can you see anything that is separate from the thought and does the thinking?
Did you do anything to make a particular thought or thoughts appear? Could you have done anything to make a different thought appear at that exact moment instead? Can you select from a range of thoughts to have only pleasant thoughts?
Can you choose not to have painful, negative or fearful thoughts?
Can you pick and choose any kind of thought?

Is there anything that is responsible for the thoughts like a traffic cop saying which one to go and which one to stay? Can the flow of thoughts be changed?
Where do thoughts appear from? Where are they coming from and going to? Do they appear randomly or in a structured way?

Watch like a hawk.

Write down a sequence of 5 thoughts in the order that they appear. Now check:
Could you predict the order of their appearance?
Did you know which will be the second or the fourth?
Is it possible to prevent a thought from appearing? Can you stop thinking a thought in the middle? How long does that last?
Test it for the fun of exploration.
It seems that thought has some logical ordered appearance, but look carefully and just notice if there is an organised sequence. Or is it just another thought that says ‘these thoughts are in sequence’ or “they take content from previous thought”, or that "one thought follows another thought"?

Are thoughts 100% true?
What are you, when you don't think about what you are?


Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
GoodnightAZ
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:38 am

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby GoodnightAZ » Fri Nov 20, 2026 10:28 pm

In that moment is there anyone or anything which recognises the thought or is being aware of it?
The thoughts just appear as the sensation just thought.
Can you see anything that is separate from the thought and does the thinking?
Initially I was not considering the voice in my head as a thought but rather a me that was directing or making sense of what’s happening but that changed through later questions.

Did you do anything to make a particular thought or thoughts appear?
This is where the realisation of the voice in my head as another thought. I let my mind flow and I thought about what I’d tell you then I thought about this bus I tried to catch earlier and then other things. And in this I recognised that these thoughts were random so I said I’ll direct the thought to something specific so I said Stephen hawking in my head and I started thinking bout him. But then the question about where that voice of direction came from and I realised that was a thought too. And I couldn’t find where that came from. The voice as a thought just appeared the same way the images do. I had been seeing it as seperate from the thoughts like the witness of the thoughts. The thought that was me that I could control but I realised that I didn’t know where that thought came from either.
Could you have done anything to make a different thought appear at that exact moment instead?
No because any choice to change those thoughts was themselves a thought that I couldn’t find where it came from. It was just a thought happening that I had believed to be seperate from the other thoughts happening.
Can you select from a range of thoughts to have only pleasant thoughts?
No the thoughts just appear as thought. Even the idea of directing the thoughts is just another thought. And the idea of pleasant thoughts themselves is just a thought.
Can you choose not to have painful, negative or fearful thoughts?
Similarly no and the idea of a thought being negative or painful or fearful is just another thought like there is a thought and a sensation and then a thought about the sensation appearing.

Can you pick and choose any kind of thought?
No cause the choosing itself comes from a thought that also just appears.
Is there anything that is responsible for the thoughts like a traffic cop saying which one to go and which one to stay?
This is what I thought the voice was, like I’d always considered it my voice of reason or control like the parts of my thoughts that is me and that can argue with other thoughts or change or direct thoughts, not realising that it itself was a thought.
Can the flow of thoughts be changed?
No any attempt to change thoughts is just thoughts.
Where do thoughts appear from?
They just appear.
Where are they coming from and going to?
They just appear and they just go.
Do they appear randomly or in a structured way?
They are random they just appear and they change on their own.

Write down a sequence of 5 thoughts in the order that they appear.
I had thought of me telling you about my thoughts

Then the thought of a boy in china

Then a sunset

Then a red ribbon

Then a nurse

Now check:
Could you predict the order of their appearance?
I couldn’t predict them they changed in a way that was automatic to a degree. Like a generator finding relation between things.

Did you know which will be the second or the fourth?
No
Is it possible to prevent a thought from appearing?
No trying to stop a thought it’s itself a thought
Can you stop thinking a thought in the middle?
The choice to stop a thought is itself a thought
How long does that last? Test it for the fun of exploration.
The thought don’t stop as when the thought to stop another thought appears, I then get more thoughts appearing.
It seems that thought has some logical ordered appearance, but look carefully and just notice if there is an organised sequence. Or is it just another thought that says ‘these thoughts are in sequence’ or “they take content from previous thought”, or that "one thought follows another thought"?
With the sequence I wrote I had a thought that connected the thoughts as being related to the colour red but that thought was itself a label describing these thoughts.

Are thoughts 100% true?
Because they are random idk. The thoughts are real in the sense of simply thought that emerges in my direct experience but the content of the thoughts is random. The thoughts may reflect truth about the direct experience.


What are you, when you don't think about what you are?
When I realised I couldn’t find a me in my thoughts I felt tension. Sensation appearing. I had thought I understood the idea of there not being a self in your thoughts but I hadn’t realised I held the belief still of a me that was in the seat of the thoughts. That voice that was in the thoughts but me. But in realising that voice is just a thought too. I want to say there is no me I can find in these experiences but I don’t know if that is also just a thought and that I’m still holding an idea of me still somewhere else. But even that thought about a me somewhere is just a thought. I’m not sure if I’m describing a genuine realisation or if this is coming from ego.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby poppyseed » Sat Nov 21, 2026 9:54 am

Hi Azi
Wonderful looking!
I had been seeing it as separate from the thoughts like the witness of the thoughts. The thought that was me that I could control but I realised that I didn’t know where that thought came from either.
Yes! The voice in your head is a mental sound / thought. But how would it be known that thoughts have a voice, and that the voice is your voice? Have you ever been able to record thoughts as they spontaneously arise and then play them back in order to hear them, and to hear that they are in your voice? :)
I couldn’t predict them they changed in a way that was automatic to a degree. Like a generator finding relation between things.
Yes! Thoughts are self-organising. They stick to each other like matching puzzle pieces (stories about stories). Language is basically the relationship between concepts – how they are organised. That carries meaning on top of the meaning of the actual concepts. That is why different concepts mean different things to different people and in different situations. One very good analogy of how words and language are just pointers to but not the actual DE, and how meaning is formed, is AI. GPT (Generative pre-trained transformers) are large language models that are based on the semantic relationships between words in sentences (natural language processing). GPT models are trained on a large amount of text. The training consists in predicting the next token (a token being usually a word, sub-word, or punctuation). Throughout this training, GPT models accumulate knowledge about the world, and can then generate “human-like” text by repeatedly predicting the next token. But can a model have any direct experience of what it’s talking about?
This is what I thought the voice was, like I’d always considered it my voice of reason or control like the parts of my thoughts that is me and that can argue with other thoughts or change or direct thoughts, not realising that it itself was a thought.
Yes!! I call these secondary and third thought – thoughts about thoughts about thoughts… First thoughts are descriptions of “what is happening”, and then further thoughts express opinions, judgements, likes and dislikes, etc.
Which leads me to:
The thoughts may reflect truth about the direct experience.
Can they be true? At best they are an approximation of reality. If thoughts were reflecting reality we would get wet just by saying waterfall or we don’t have to eat real chocolate we could just imagine eating one.
I recently tried a new fruit for me which the locals call “sour soap”. If I give you a description – the fruit is fragrant, sweet and sour, fleshy, and soft – did you manage to experience and get an idea what the fruit tastes like? How can you know what I am talking about if you haven’t tasted that fruit? The description of experience is no help when it comes to the actual experiencing. We can talk about tasting the sour soap, but it’s all conceptual: ideas about ideas and not the experience that is happening right now.
Think of the apple exercises or the cup of coffee exercise… Thoughts talk about apples and cups, their sizes, and shapes, furthermore about likes and dislikes, where all that is there are sensations, colours, tastes, smells, and sounds. And even these are labels – DE labels but still labels.
Check…
Close your eyes and allow a thought or a series of thoughts to appear. Continue to pay attention to thoughts as they appear for a few more seconds. With your eyes still closed, listen to whatever sound is present for several moments. Now, go back and forth between thoughts and the sound.
Does the sound appear in a different “place” to thoughts? Can you find an actual line / wall / boundary that divides the thoughts and the sound? Or is the line a mental construct?
Seeing ALL thoughts as empty is where freedom rests. There is no truth worth fighting for :). The freedom lies in seeing that concepts are creations of language that serve the purpose of communicating. They are practical, but empty of inherent existence. First thoughts (the descriptors) are useful for communication. Secondary and third is where the delusion lies.
I suppose the analogy with the icons on your computer desktop comes handy. They are used as a visual representation of what is actually a binary code – 0’s and 1’s - so you can make use of them. But is the icon of email really a box with mail in it? And is it worth talking about the aesthetics of the icons, what we like about them and what we don’t :)
I want to say there is no me I can find in these experiences but I don’t know if that is also just a thought and that I’m still holding an idea of me still somewhere else. But even that thought about a me somewhere is just a thought. I’m not sure if I’m describing a genuine realisation or if this is coming from ego.
Notice that you're now looking for confirmation that you've genuinely realised something.
But what would confirm it? Another thought saying "Yes, I've got it"?
And if that thought appeared, would it prove anything? And to WHOM?

Forget for a moment about whether this is a genuine realisation. When you look right now, can you actually find a thinker separate from the thoughts, or only thoughts appearing, including thoughts about a thinker?

When you say this might be coming from ego, what exactly is this ego? Can you find an entity producing these thoughts, or is "ego" another label for certain patterns of thinking? Can thoughts (so called "ego") think?
The important distinction is that thinking certainly happens. The question is whether an independently existing thinker — called me, mind, or ego — can actually be found doing it.
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
GoodnightAZ
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:38 am

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby GoodnightAZ » Sat Nov 21, 2026 6:19 pm

But how would it be known that thoughts have a voice, and that the voice is your voice? Have you ever been able to record thoughts as they spontaneously arise and then play them back in order to hear them, and to hear that they are in your voice?
When I looked into this I found that the “voice” itself isn’t a voice. It’s more ideas appearing but when I looked into it I realise there isn’t a voice but more so just ideas appearing. Narration appearing, but I don’t grasp the how would it be known. As I look more into it thoughts label those thoughts as a voice. And thoughts recognise it as a voice.
But can a model have any direct experience of what it’s talking about?
No a model does not have any direct experience in general all of its actions come from its training data. It’s funny you used this example as I studied machine learning and learning and making models expanded my ideas about thoughts and how they are like outputs based on training data received during youth. But that’s more like a metaphor not a direct comparison.

If I give you a description – the fruit is fragrant, sweet and sour, fleshy, and soft – did you manage to experience and get an idea what the fruit tastes like? How can you know what I am talking about if you haven’t tasted that fruit?
With your description my mind goes to what i remember of fruits I’ve had that match that description and the thought of the experience of tasting those conjure up. But that is just a thought and I can’t know how it tastes. And this makes me realise something about the question of if thoughts can be true. The thought can only use thoughts about other experiences to make sense of something in direct experience. For example an apple infront of me, and I have the thought that it will be sweet but in my direct experience there is only the apple inftont of me. The thought is based on others thoughts about the direct experience to come to a conclusion about but that truth isn’t 100% true it’s just an assumption. There is only the direct experience of a colour infront of me.
Does the sound appear in a different “place” to thoughts? Can you find an actual line / wall / boundary that divides the thoughts and the sound? Or is the line a mental construct?
Doing this exercise when I listened to the sounds around me it’s like they appeared in thought at the same time. The conversations that I heard even when I tried to remove the label of what they were appeared like thoughts in the same as my thoughts.
But is the icon of email really a box with mail in it? And is it worth talking about the aesthetics of the icons, what we like about them and what we don’t :)
That is just an assumption from thought about the colours seen. It’s like a Rorschach test. When it comes to talking about what we like about the aesthetics it’s just the appearance of sight and sensation and then thought about that sensation. It’s like the exercise about unpleasant thoughts.
But what would confirm it? Another thought saying "Yes, I've got it"?
And if that thought appeared, would it prove anything? And to WHOM?
There is no proving it. Any answer about it would appear from thought.
When you look right now, can you actually find a thinker separate from the thoughts, or only thoughts appearing, including thoughts about a thinker?
There’s only thoughts appearing. At the moment i have the idea of it like cascading thoughts, thoughts on different layers. But that idea is itself a thought and all these thoughts are just appearing.
what exactly is this ego? Can you find an entity producing these thoughts, or is "ego" another label for certain patterns of thinking? Can thoughts (so called "ego") think?
An ego is just another thought. It’s the thoughts labelling thoughts. The thoughts just appear and conversation with other thoughts but they’re all just appearing in thought. These thoughts aren’t produced by anyone they are just appearing. Like how sound just appears. There is no one doing the thinking. But I’m struggling with if there is anyone one hearing the thinking.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: I am looking for a guide through the foundational fetters

Postby poppyseed » Sun Nov 22, 2026 10:26 am

Hi Azi,
You're looking very carefully now! :) Something interesting stands out in your observations.
There is no one doing the thinking. But I’m struggling with if there is anyone one hearing the thinking.
As I look more into it thoughts label those thoughts as a voice. And thoughts recognise it as a voice.
And yet you say you're struggling with whether there's someone hearing the thinking.
Let's look at this carefully.
When an actual sound is heard, such as someone speaking, notice the sound itself. Then notice any thoughts interpreting or describing it.
Is the sound the same as the thought about it? Can you distinguish the two?

Now notice a thought appearing, followed perhaps by another thought describing it.
Is there actually a thought recognising another thought, or simply thoughts appearing one after another?
And apart from these appearances, can you find anything doing the recognising or listening?

Now pay attention to the hearing itself…
Find somewhere quiet and listen to the sounds around you. Perhaps birds chirping, traffic, or voices.
Notice how thoughts label the sounds: "birds", "traffic", "someone talking", perhaps even "I hear that".
Can you find a dividing line between the sound and the hearing of it? Where does one end and the other begin?
And can you find anything separate from the hearing that is doing it? An "I", “Azi”, a body, a pair of ears, or any entity as a listener?
Are there actually three separate things in direct experience — a sound, hearing, and a hearer — or what exactly can be found?

Try it with different sounds and tell me what you notice.
Then look at thoughts appearing. Is there a thought AND something separate hearing or recognising it? OR thoughts just appear as they ARE?
Look at what actually happens, rather than how thought explains it.
Love,
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Semrush [Bot] and 19 guests