Ready or not, enough theory

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Anastacia42
Posts: 12681
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2016 3:04 am
Contact:

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Anastacia42 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 5:57 pm

You must be relaxed to see.

Be patient. With all of this thinking , it could take a long time.

Loving,
~ Stacy

"Thought is a garbage can. If you look into the garbage can, all you will get is garbage."

~ Adyashanti

User avatar
Robshin
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 4:47 am

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Robshin » Tue Nov 17, 2026 7:28 pm

1. No, the body is not real.
Well in the book Elena answered to Charles "There is a body, a mind—all that stuff, but nothing ‘owns’ that."
And that's what I was referring to.
So it seems your answer "No, the body is not real" dodged the question.

2.
just have the senses and thoughts, and nothing moves.
Good!
You say good, but maybe you don't get what I mean. Maybe it's not good. You always say good, when I report any experience, without knowing if, maybe, I have difficult time to articulate my experience, and can't actually give you an accurate account of my experience.
Which would mean, you don't really care to hear about my experience. But if you don't care about my experience the best idea of what's important is then: you probably only want me to experience, but actually telling you the content doesn't matter.


Rant incoming, ignore if you like. Otherwise I hope you understand and don't take offense. It was like I needed some purging and decided to keep it even though it feels uncomfortable.

Ah but there is no me, so I can't experience anyways. And experience is just a label. So, all I can truly state is nothing at all, ever. Which also came from the mind (since it was written in words), which means it's also incorrect, so there is nothing I could say, do or think, nor not say, not do or not think that would make any of this go anywhere whatsoever. So I can rant and write as much as I want, it matters not. If I'm in the forum or not, matters not, having ever talked to you, was neither a waste of time nor a good use of time. Typing these words is just happening because the body feels like doing so. Nothing useful has ever happened and could ever happen, it's all just this garbage, thoughts after thoughts after thoughts, with some hope arriving that this rant may actually change anything just to discover there's nothing, just a feeling and another thought that says "hope". The fingers stopping the typing here and there and then resuming. Now again, since they started moving, more feeling and thought about "hope" saying this might be it, and another round of dissociation, all back and forth, and then ahh yes, the thought of posting this and you saying one of your two lines either "good" or "you're in thought", and me not knowing what the Fuck I'm supposed to do with it, and then again seeing that there is nothing to do that could go anywhere and have any positive impact, because it's always the same answers. Now the trying arises to keep up this odd feeling in my body, as if this is the "gate", but it's just another sensation paired with the thought of hope. The recognition that "hope" seems to come up again and again, as if there's some great thing I could ever reach if only one magic little thing happens, only one magic little step, and the thought that I'm just one millimeter away, even though there is no "there" there, there is just the sounds of typing, the odd sensation, a sore wrist, the light of my screen, and another round of hope since now I explained some DE, you might approve and say "good" again for my next little seeker-dopamine hit, and keep me in the loop. Your "that's thoughts" and "good" are like treats and beatings to a dog that hopes to find out what's right. I'm that little dog woof woof - hah a laughter comes out of me - and people who awakened reported laughing, so THAT was it? No of course not, nothing changed, I just laughed, I laugh every day and I've not been awakened. Don't even get me started on the fuckery of "there is no gate" or "nobody to awaken" when it's obvious that people reported differently before and after the shift. So we are looking for a shift, but nothing changes, yeah sure, go to some logic class. 1 = 0, okay, makes sense for absolutely noone. I'm not going to stop writing until everything has been said. I've looked at someone's forum, with almost 600 entries and months of rambling, what the actual fuck, I certainly don't want to be this guy, imagine running around for years trying to "wake up" and getting absolutely nowhere, what a waste of time. I gotta give props to you, you guys have a lot of patience, although the obvious thoughts of you repeating the same stuff to everyone multiple times, by copy-and-paste, or using AI for your responses is a bit disheartening, I actually don't ever know if someone really takes a good look at anything deeply but just uses "person said a thought, let's tell him it's a thought", or "person formulated something like a DE, let's say good", or "let's copy this exercise from my clipboard, that'll keep him busy for a while". With the anger, there is also a lot of insecurity about posting any of this. Yeah I know insecurity is a sensation and a thought, no need to tell me. No seriously, don't say it. I KNOW. Doesn't change anything. Is of absolutely ZERO help to get told a fact you already know. So please spare it. A lot of shame in the thought of actually sending this reply. I don't even know if I can call this honesty. I'm just ranting and letting my frustration out by typing words in the way that the mind presents them. So those are all thoughts, with some small amount of DE mixed in, which are also just thoughts and labels and not the actual experience. I can't tell you about my true experience, can I? Not because I'm not real, but because my experience is not accessible to you in any way, just like your experience is not accessible to me. And that's the exact reason for my "body" question, but you thought the best thing to do is leave me in the dark. Is frustration such a good catalyst maybe that you don't let me off the hook? That would actually be quite loving. But I have doubt. Speaking of. Doubt. What the fuck was that, the FIRST thing you ever wrote to me is that I'm in doubt, followed by not saying or doing or pointing towards anything related to that, no transparent effort to show anything about doubt due to my doubt-ing. Just exercises, clipboard-copys of answers, and again leaving me in the dark. Is this the method, or are you just not really trying? Could your trying even do anything? Could my trying even do anything? Ah thoughts, thoughts, thoughts. Another thought. Here, another thought. And one more, here's a thought. I want to stop the thoughts but I can't and also wanting is probably not real as well.




Okay let's get back to business.


3. Frustration is a body Sensation plus the label/ thought "Frustration. "
see my rant above and my next answer.
4. You *are* in thought.
I fear you'll probably brush shortly over everything in this post and / or say I'm in thought
--> I was right, again. My brain is too sharp for these shenanigans.
Apparently a sharp brain doesn't help with this process then lol


The Exercise

5. and try this:

Introductory Body Exercise [...]
Can it be known how tall the body is? Does the body have a weight or volume? In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
From direct experience: no. Weight or volume would be a number, how would one experience a number?
Is there a boundary between the body and the clothing? Is there a boundary between the body and the chair?
From direct experience: this has been tricky. I haven't found a boundary between body and clothing, but not because I've sensed clearly that there is none, but because thoughts get in the way of sensing, making the experience almost muddy.
Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
Same, very muddy with thoughts, DE feels difficult here.
What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
The label "body" refers to a bunch of thoughts and sensations. I can't tell you about the experience, because it's impossible to speak about it. Best I can do: i see, and i sense. and some of the patterns and colors and sensations are bodyish. Actually, all sensations are bodyish in that way. Which is why I assume to have a body. It's the same with my "self", and thoughts i guess.

Please go talk to Vince's group.
I don't feel like it


Be patient. With all of this thinking , it could take a long time.
Yup, I know. But I can't stop thinking, so there's really nothing I can do about it.
And I would say I'll try my best but since there's nobody who could try, or change, that's kinda pointless as well.

So I'll just look for the DE based on your questions and try to go with your mantra about setting up the environment.
Which would mean: okay I'll try be patient. :-)
Robin
________________________

I have no idea what I'm doing
:-)

User avatar
Anastacia42
Posts: 12681
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2016 3:04 am
Contact:

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Anastacia42 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 8:45 pm

Yes. A "sharp brain" just gets in the way of looking.

If you "don't feel like" attending Vince's telecoms for help or following suggestions, maybe you need a different guide. I'll see who's available.
~ Stacy

"Thought is a garbage can. If you look into the garbage can, all you will get is garbage."

~ Adyashanti

User avatar
Robshin
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 4:47 am

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Robshin » Tue Nov 17, 2026 10:32 pm

ok
Robin
________________________

I have no idea what I'm doing
:-)

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 794
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Noro » Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:34 pm

Hello Robin, my name is Rowena, and I am happy to take over from Stacy to be your guide, it is often very helpful to have someone else - a different perspective if you like.

I thought it would be good to address the points you brought up about three posts ago to get a starting place from which to continue:

a) I keep reading in the gateless gatecrashers book, the self just as real as batman or santa clause etc., but:
Supposedly, still, the body is real, but it's not "my" body, because "me" is an illusion.
But if my body isn't "my" body, and a different body in this room is also not "my" body, why are there only experiences from "my" bodys perspective? I don't see their sight, don't smell their smelling, etc. So there MUST be a difference between "my" body and all the others.
What conventional thinking says regarding the above is quite logical and correct. When we are in a room with other people, we notice all sorts of differences. In fact, thoughts, when attention is placed on noticing differences, (which is a well ingrained habit pattern developed over many years) more and more differences will arise as thoughts about the situation.

In direct experience, first of all we must relax in order to quiet the mind, and then we can explore what is actually found in direct experience when there is no perceptual overlay. Perceptual overlay includes all thoughts, labels, concepts etc.
See Exploration of the Visual Field below.
b) i can't stop trying to understand
whenever I try to drop "understanding", I just have the senses and thoughts, and nothing moves. Then it goes back to trying to understand. As soon as an inquiry, question or pointer is used, I am not using only senses because they're questions that are processed in mind.
Understanding brings feelings of security. To face the unknown can be extremely unsettling, and so wanting to understand will continue as long as it needs to, there is no need to drop "understanding", dropping the need to understand and to conceptualize will happen when it does.
c) whenever I try to inquire, I don't know what the inquiries mean. "just look". "what is holding you back?". "is there a you?", "allow the thought that there is no self at all in real life. Is it possible? Is this true?" --> nothing comes up, the questions don't land. They could be just as much "brlshasdknb?", there's no difference, when talking from DE.
Even looking at the fact that nothing comes up and that the questions don't land, changes nothing besides me sensing something like frustration (which, i know, is not a sense, so forget I said it).
OK, no worries, we will keep exploring, and you are invited to give feedback whenever you feel the need.
d) Is "seeing that there is no self" the same as "seeing there is no I"? Because I certainly never claim "self is cold" anyways.
How about we turn the exploration 180 degrees around and start looking for a separate self instead.
Would that be ok with you?

e) communication becomes impossible when sticking to 100% DE. I censor myself at every step, because thoughts come up "that's not DE", "that's a story", "that's a thought", "that's a label" etc.; so I either listen to those thoughts and censor myself, or I don't listen to those thoughts and just write, but then your response is "that's a thought, it's not DE".
No more censoring, everything is worth exploring!


EXPLORING THE VISUAL FIELD

Start from a place where you feel calm and relaxed, take a few gentle breaths, and with attention fully on the visual field:

Look to your right.
Then look to your left.
Finally, bring your head back to centre, NOW CLOSE YOUR EYES and look forward.

Okay, so when you look to the right, the view (visual experience) on the right is seen (whatever that is).

When you look to the left, the view on the left is seen (whatever that is).

And then, when you look in front of you with eyes closed, the visual experience in front is seen. Even with eyes closed there is still a direct visual experience if attention is given to the visual field. There maybe an overall redness if the space is well lit or sunny for example.

So, when the visual field on the right appears, is there a ‘choice’ to see or not to see what's appearing?

I’m not asking can you ‘choose’ to see something else like another view, or ‘blank space’ if you close your eyes,
the question is, in direct experience, can you turn seeing off? Yes/No
Can you NOT see what is seen? Yes/No

Same thing when you are facing to the left, can there be a choice to NOT see the view on the left? Yes/No
Same thing when you are facing forward with closed eyes, can you NOT see the what is seen? Yes/No

Can an independent self or 'doer' be found that can choose to turn seeing off or on? Yes/No.
Can a separate, independent doer or seer be found that controls seeing, or is seeing simply happening?

In direct experience we look at the raw data coming from the visual field as a whole, no labels are added at all although we can say that we perceive colors and shapes. Therefore, from this way of experiencing, there are no objects, there is only a vibrant, colorful field of light. Is this clear for you?

Therefore, in direct experience, when looking at the visual field, can you agree that there are no separate objects, including other people? Yes or No



Any feedback or questions are welcome,

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Robshin
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 4:47 am

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Robshin » Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:16 pm

Hello Rowena,

thank you very much for picking this up so quickly!
I really appreciate you are taking the time and respond to so much of what I wrote.

I'll skip the details, but somehow, the way you addressed each of my concerns / points, helped me get quite relaxed about it, even while not understanding it all. An unusual win for me.


How about we turn the exploration 180 degrees around and start looking for a separate self instead.
Would that be ok with you?
Yes, okay.



To the exercise:
So, when the visual field on the right appears, is there a ‘choice’ to see or not to see what's appearing?

I’m not asking can you ‘choose’ to see something else like another view, or ‘blank space’ if you close your eyes,
the question is, in direct experience, can you turn seeing off? Yes/No
Can you NOT see what is seen? Yes/No
I spent a lot of time doing this exercise and looking.

I'd love to say yes or no, but even after your clarification, I'm still not sure what exactly you're asking. So I give you a two answers that are true right now, but answer different questions, depending on what the question meant. And you pick which one you meant (if any), if that's okay?

Answers:
-> No, while seeing is happening, it's not the case that seeing is not happening. So it's impossible to choose not to see when I see. Because it is already seen.
-> No, the "choice" to not see is not in my awareness at any point. It is obvious that "choice" isn't even a thing. It's just a thought that I would attach after not seeing it anymore (after turning the head or something).

Same thing when you are facing to the left, can there be a choice to NOT see the view on the left? Yes/No
Same thing when you are facing forward with closed eyes, can you NOT see the what is seen? Yes/No
Same answers as above.

Can an independent self or 'doer' be found that can choose to turn seeing off or on? Yes/No.
Yes an independent self or doer can be found (it's me, hi), but no, I can't choose.
Can a separate, independent doer or seer be found that controls seeing, or is seeing simply happening?
No, not separate. But yes, independent (hi, I'm here). No, I can't control seeing, seeing is happening and I'm aware of it.
In direct experience we look at the raw data coming from the visual field as a whole, no labels are added at all although we can say that we perceive colors and shapes. Therefore, from this way of experiencing, there are no objects, there is only a vibrant, colorful field of light. Is this clear for you?
Yes I feel like it's clear. If I were to rephrase this, I'd say for example: there is a table, but the object "table" is imaginary, as in, it's just sensing / seeing. So, ordinarily, the label "table" gets put onto some "shape+color+thought"-object which is useful to me and makes it seem more real than it is.

Therefore, in direct experience, when looking at the visual field, can you agree that there are no separate objects, including other people? Yes or No
Yes!



Your last two questions reminded me of a quote from Terence Mckenna:
a child lying in a crib and a hummingbird comes into the room and the child is ecstatic because this shimmering iridescence of movement and sound and attention, it’s just wonderful. I mean, it is an instantaneous miracle when placed against the background of the dull wallpaper of the nursery and so forth. But, then, mother or nanny or someone comes in and says, “It’s a bird, baby. bird. bird!” And, this takes this linguistic piece of mosaic tile, and o- places it over the miracle, and glues it down with the epoxy of syntactical momentum, and, from now on, the miracle is confined within the meaning of the word. And, by the time a child is four or five or six, there- no light shines through. They have tiled over every aspect of reality with a linguistic association that blunts it, limits it, and confines it within cultural expectation.
Robin
________________________

I have no idea what I'm doing
:-)

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 794
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Noro » Wed Nov 18, 2026 9:33 pm

Hi Robin,

I really loved the quote from Terence Mckenna, this is totally in the spirit of where direct experience leads.
So, when the visual field on the right appears, is there a ‘choice’ to see or not to see what's appearing?
I’m not asking can you ‘choose’ to see something else like another view, or ‘blank space’ if you close your eyes,
the question is, in direct experience, can you turn seeing off? Yes/No
Can you NOT see what is seen? Yes/No
-> No, while seeing is happening, it's not the case that seeing is not happening. So it's impossible to choose not to see when I see. Because it is already seen.

-> No, the "choice" to not see is not in my awareness at any point. It is obvious that "choice" isn't even a thing. It's just a thought that I would attach after not seeing it anymore (after turning the head or something).
Sometimes the wording can be a bit confusing, but your first answer is the one that is being looked for as you are referring to the direct experience.

The second answer is not an answer from direct experience, it is a logical answer coming from a conventional point of view.
Can an independent self or 'doer' be found that can choose to turn seeing off or on? Yes/No.
Yes an independent self or doer can be found (it's me, hi), but no, I can't choose.
My bad, I did not specify that the exercise was to be done from direct experience. But never mind, let's look at this closely.
In direct experience you have the raw data from the five senses and you have thinking overlay. Agreed?

In direct experience, where are you going to look to find a separate, independent self or doer (a "me")?

In direct experience, can a "me" be found in the visual field? Please answer only Yes or No.
In direct experience, can a "me" be found in the sound field? Yes or No.
In direct experience, can an actual separate "me" be found in the field of sensation, this includes a "sense of self" ? Yes or No?


Yes I feel like it's clear. If I were to rephrase this, I'd say for example: there is a table, but the object "table" is imaginary, as in, it's just sensing / seeing. So, ordinarily, the label "table" gets put onto some "shape+color+thought"-object which is useful to me and makes it seem more real than it is.
OK, the way you put it, conventionally speaking, yes, there is a table (like there was a hummingbird), but the object "table" is not imaginary, conventionally there is always something there, and direct experience does not mean that actual objects are imagined, they are simply not separated out from the visual field. Is this clear?


INVESTIGATION WITH AN APPLE
Here's an exercise for you to get very clear on what direct experience is. Find an apple (or any other object will do) and place it in front of you on the table.

When looking at the apple in the conventional way, there is looking at something in the visual field, and perceiving of color and shape, then thinking very quickly adds what is being seen, so, if you are looking at an apple, there will be a thought saying "apple" and maybe a thought saying, "I'm looking at an apple."

In direct experience (DE) there is simply seeing, and this simple act of seeing does not include any interpretations or descriptions. In actual fact, nothing is named in direct experience, (think of a baby that is looking around in wonder), all that is seen is a kaleidoscope of light/color. However, for the sake of communicating we can allow a minimum of thought content in order to do this exercise; so we can say that colors and shapes are seen, and thinking is also 'seen' but the content of thought, the thoughts about what is seen, is not included.

Direct experience does not refer to the content of thoughts i.e. (labels, interpretations and descriptions).

Direct experience refers simply to the raw data of the sense fields: simply: hearing sounds, simply: seeing (may include colors and shapes), simply: smelling, simply: tasting, and simply: feeling sensations and simply: thinking, but without including the thought content.

So, in your direct experience, when you look in front of you,

is there really an apple there or only color and shape and thinking about the chosen object?
Can an actual 'apple/object' be found in direct experience?


While thoughts or descriptions are known conventionally, what thoughts talk about (i.e. actual objects) cannot be found in direct experience?

It can be very tempting for arguments to arise regarding the apparent absurdity of saying that an apple is not an apple.
But in direct experience that is the case. (Think of your hummingbird quote)

I hope that this is clear for you. Let me know how you get on.

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Robshin
Posts: 19
Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2026 4:47 am

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Robshin » Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:22 pm

Hello Rowena,

In direct experience you have the raw data from the five senses and you have thinking overlay. Agreed?
Okay
In direct experience, where are you going to look to find a separate, independent self or doer (a "me")?
From now on, I will look from the five senses.
In direct experience, can a "me" be found in the visual field? Please answer only Yes or No.
No.
In direct experience, can a "me" be found in the sound field? Yes or No.
No
In direct experience, can an actual separate "me" be found in the field of sensation, this includes a "sense of self" ? Yes or No?
No

OK, the way you put it, conventionally speaking, yes, there is a table (like there was a hummingbird), but the object "table" is not imaginary, conventionally there is always something there, and direct experience does not mean that actual objects are imagined, they are simply not separated out from the visual field. Is this clear?
Yes

is there really an apple there or only color and shape and thinking about the chosen object?
Can an actual 'apple/object' be found in direct experience?
(for reference I have a blue spiky ball in my hand)
I look at the ball. It feels like a lie if I say "No, I can't find the object in DE". Because THERE IT IS. I SEE it. I see blue, I see shimmering, I see a line, I see spikes. And I can't choose not to label these.
Do I have to stare for longer? I stared for about 20minutes.

Best,
Robin
________________________

I have no idea what I'm doing
:-)

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 794
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Ready or not, enough theory

Postby Noro » Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:11 am

Hello Robin,
is there really an apple there or only color and shape and thinking about the chosen object?
Can an actual 'apple/object' be found in direct experience?
(for reference I have a blue spiky ball in my hand)
I look at the ball. It feels like a lie if I say "No, I can't find the object in DE". Because THERE IT IS. I SEE it. I see blue, I see shimmering, I see a line, I see spikes. And I can't choose not to label these.
Do I have to stare for longer? I stared for about 20minutes.
OK, let’s go back to the hummingbird analogy.
First of all. Yes, conventionally speaking there is a blue spiky ball and a hand, even your hand….. but in direct experience there ball and the hand have not ‘yet’ been rendered into objects. They have not been one separated out from the visual field by thinking and been brought into the conventional world of objects with names.

Secondly, there was no mention for you to stare at the object! Were you trying to make it disappear? That’s not the point at all! Direct experience is really about learning a new way of taking in experience, of looking at the visual field as a baby would, as a field of light, colors and shapes, without labels. Unborn into conventional reality which is relative. (A hand in English is labeled “un main” in French!)

Thirdly, you said you see blue, yes, you see blue, but amongst a whole lot of other colors and shapes. No separation, no background. Like a painting where everything is paint, there are no gaps anywhere.

Finally, you say “it feels like a lie if I say say "No, I can't find the object in DE". Because THERE IT IS. I SEE it.“. The word “feels” is important. It is a lie if you are trying to tell yourself that it’s not there, that it can’t be found. Your body is reacting to the lie!

Please give it another try:
Place the blue spiky ball on a flat surface a little way away from you.

Now, look at the visual field in font of you, but open your gaze fully to take in the whole visual field at once. What do you see in direct experience? Allow thoughts to subside as you take in the whole field of light and color. Relax your mind. Play around with slowly shifting your gaze back and forth and closing your eyes so the vision is a little blurry. You see a blue shape together with a whole lot of other colors and shapes don’t you? Simply seeing happening.

Can you enjoy this direct experience without bringing in thoughts to process what you see into conventional seeing of objects and labels?

Please let me know if this is clearer now? Let me know how it feels to take in the visual field in this way?

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Google [Bot] and 63 guests