realizing selflessness
Re: realizing selflessness
Can’t sleep. Gonna lie here in bed and mentally settle into my theater seat, with my bucket of popcorn, to be the watcher/watching of the movie of what K’s attention does when she’s still and quiet and her mind isn’t engaged in any particular task but she’d prefer not to just get caught up in thoughts but to be aware of the here and now . . .
For about 15 minutes, this felt more or less like watching K do shikantaza. Then I was thinking that if the idea was to shift from being the doer to the watcher, maybe K should be doing something that seemed more like doing, not just perceiving (and thinking), so I tried to be the watcher of K giving herself “This is it”-type pointers. But that didn’t really work.
I don’t understand what the point is of trying to be the watcher/watching of the movements of attention. But maybe I’m falling into the problem of getting too practice-y?
Now what?
For about 15 minutes, this felt more or less like watching K do shikantaza. Then I was thinking that if the idea was to shift from being the doer to the watcher, maybe K should be doing something that seemed more like doing, not just perceiving (and thinking), so I tried to be the watcher of K giving herself “This is it”-type pointers. But that didn’t really work.
I don’t understand what the point is of trying to be the watcher/watching of the movements of attention. But maybe I’m falling into the problem of getting too practice-y?
Now what?
Re: realizing selflessness
P.S. Maybe that’s just another pointer to add to my arsenal for meditation time or whenever: “You’re not the doer; you’re just the watching.”
(OK, really gotta try to sleep . . . )
(OK, really gotta try to sleep . . . )
Re: realizing selflessness
Next morning (on this side of the planet).
Per my last post: Without turning it into a practice, I think I'll just try to remember now and then during the day, including during sitting periods, that I am in fact not the doer but just the watching of what's happening (along with remembering that "This is it").
Interesting how I keep trying to turn pointers into something to DO. The mind really wants a project, even despite being sick of projects.
Thank you thank you, vince, for all the time you've been putting into this guidance!
Per my last post: Without turning it into a practice, I think I'll just try to remember now and then during the day, including during sitting periods, that I am in fact not the doer but just the watching of what's happening (along with remembering that "This is it").
Interesting how I keep trying to turn pointers into something to DO. The mind really wants a project, even despite being sick of projects.
Thank you thank you, vince, for all the time you've been putting into this guidance!
Re: realizing selflessness
(Flooding you with messages again. Thank you for being okay with that. Something I really like about the LU model is that writing is a good way for me to process things, but I have trouble doing it with an audience of only myself.)
Afternoon sit:
I did basically what I’ve mostly been doing the last few days: pointers and reminders to myself, especially “This is it” and “Stay here.”
Had to include a lot of “Don’t take notes,” i.e., stop putting my experience into words for me or you or whoever.
Heard “This is it” not only as “Samsara is nirvana” (i.e., what I’m looking for is and has always been right here) and “Attend carefully to present experience” but also as “This is all there is,” i.e., my experience of life consists of the experiences here and now and nothing else.
(Today, I didn’t hear “This is it” as “This is the home stretch,” as I did the other day. But last night, my husband, who practices Zen and with whom I have not shared any of your suggestions that I’m “close,” said lightheartedly, “If you get enlightened while I’m the shower, you can come in and tell me.”)
Also, a few times during the sit, I took a mental step back to watch what was happening.
Earlier today, I was thinking about being the watcher/watching of what’s happening and how I could imagine that the world I experience is a hyper-realistic virtual reality simulation, and I’ve tuned into the K character, so it’s like watching a really immersive movie of K living her life. And then I thought of the idea in that video you shared of how this all starts to feel less like work and more like play — because that image felt playful.
Afternoon sit:
I did basically what I’ve mostly been doing the last few days: pointers and reminders to myself, especially “This is it” and “Stay here.”
Had to include a lot of “Don’t take notes,” i.e., stop putting my experience into words for me or you or whoever.
Heard “This is it” not only as “Samsara is nirvana” (i.e., what I’m looking for is and has always been right here) and “Attend carefully to present experience” but also as “This is all there is,” i.e., my experience of life consists of the experiences here and now and nothing else.
(Today, I didn’t hear “This is it” as “This is the home stretch,” as I did the other day. But last night, my husband, who practices Zen and with whom I have not shared any of your suggestions that I’m “close,” said lightheartedly, “If you get enlightened while I’m the shower, you can come in and tell me.”)
Also, a few times during the sit, I took a mental step back to watch what was happening.
Earlier today, I was thinking about being the watcher/watching of what’s happening and how I could imagine that the world I experience is a hyper-realistic virtual reality simulation, and I’ve tuned into the K character, so it’s like watching a really immersive movie of K living her life. And then I thought of the idea in that video you shared of how this all starts to feel less like work and more like play — because that image felt playful.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
Good. But be precise.
“This is it” is cleanest when it means:
This exact experience is all that is available.
Not:
This is the home stretch.
This is almost awakening.
This is the state I need to stabilize.
This is the clue that I am close.
Those are add-ons.
The strongest version is the one you saw today:
This is all there is.
Not as a cosmic claim. As immediate fact.
Life, as experienced, is never somewhere else. There is only this: sitting, hearing, thinking, wanting to take notes, not taking notes, remembering, body sensations, “This is it,” thought about husband, thought about enlightenment, playful image, watching, commentary.
Nothing else is available except as thought-image now.
So yes: “Don’t take notes” was useful. Not because words are bad, but because note-taking can become the self quietly preserving its centrality:
“I must capture this.”
“I must report this well.”
“This is important for my process.”
“This may be evidence.”
That is the practitioner rebuilding itself as the recorder.
Then the VR/movie image: useful, but dangerous.
Useful because it loosens the sense that K is the controller. It makes life feel less like a burden and more like an unfolding.
Dangerous because it can smuggle in a subtler watcher:
“I am the consciousness watching the K-character.”
That is still duality. Just a more spacious version.
So test it.
When the image appears — K as character in an immersive movie — look for the one watching the movie.
Where is it?
Behind the eyes?
Above the body?
Outside the simulation?
In the head?
In “awareness”?
What is actually found?
Sensation.
Image.
Thought.
A sense of distance maybe.
Playfulness maybe.
Ease maybe.
But is a watcher found?
No.
So don’t stop at:
K is being watched.
Go one cut deeper:
Watching is happening.
The image of K is happening.
The sense of immersion is happening.
The sense of stepping back is happening.
No watcher is found.
That keeps it clean.
And yes, the shift from work to play is a very good sign — not proof of anything, not a badge, but a softening of the grim seeker machinery. Take real life as “stuff to play with,” not lab work or grim improvement.
So for the next sitting, keep it extremely simple:
This is it.
Stay here.
No notes.
No meditator found.
No watcher behind the watching.
And when playfulness comes, don’t grab that either.
Playfulness is it.
Dullness is it.
Thinking is it.
Wanting to report it is it.
Forgetting is it.
No home stretch.
No special event required.
Just this, without the added owner.
vince
“This is it” is cleanest when it means:
This exact experience is all that is available.
Not:
This is the home stretch.
This is almost awakening.
This is the state I need to stabilize.
This is the clue that I am close.
Those are add-ons.
The strongest version is the one you saw today:
This is all there is.
Not as a cosmic claim. As immediate fact.
Life, as experienced, is never somewhere else. There is only this: sitting, hearing, thinking, wanting to take notes, not taking notes, remembering, body sensations, “This is it,” thought about husband, thought about enlightenment, playful image, watching, commentary.
Nothing else is available except as thought-image now.
So yes: “Don’t take notes” was useful. Not because words are bad, but because note-taking can become the self quietly preserving its centrality:
“I must capture this.”
“I must report this well.”
“This is important for my process.”
“This may be evidence.”
That is the practitioner rebuilding itself as the recorder.
Then the VR/movie image: useful, but dangerous.
Useful because it loosens the sense that K is the controller. It makes life feel less like a burden and more like an unfolding.
Dangerous because it can smuggle in a subtler watcher:
“I am the consciousness watching the K-character.”
That is still duality. Just a more spacious version.
So test it.
When the image appears — K as character in an immersive movie — look for the one watching the movie.
Where is it?
Behind the eyes?
Above the body?
Outside the simulation?
In the head?
In “awareness”?
What is actually found?
Sensation.
Image.
Thought.
A sense of distance maybe.
Playfulness maybe.
Ease maybe.
But is a watcher found?
No.
So don’t stop at:
K is being watched.
Go one cut deeper:
Watching is happening.
The image of K is happening.
The sense of immersion is happening.
The sense of stepping back is happening.
No watcher is found.
That keeps it clean.
And yes, the shift from work to play is a very good sign — not proof of anything, not a badge, but a softening of the grim seeker machinery. Take real life as “stuff to play with,” not lab work or grim improvement.
So for the next sitting, keep it extremely simple:
This is it.
Stay here.
No notes.
No meditator found.
No watcher behind the watching.
And when playfulness comes, don’t grab that either.
Playfulness is it.
Dullness is it.
Thinking is it.
Wanting to report it is it.
Forgetting is it.
No home stretch.
No special event required.
Just this, without the added owner.
vince
Re: realizing selflessness
I put this long quote here because this seems particularly important, and I kind of get it but also find it slippery.When the image appears — K as character in an immersive movie — look for the one watching the movie.
Where is it?
Behind the eyes?
Above the body?
Outside the simulation?
In the head?
In “awareness”?
What is actually found?
Sensation.
Image.
Thought.
A sense of distance maybe.
Playfulness maybe.
Ease maybe.
But is a watcher found?
No.
So don’t stop at:
K is being watched.
Go one cut deeper:
Watching is happening.
The image of K is happening.
The sense of immersion is happening.
The sense of stepping back is happening.
No watcher is found.
That keeps it clean.
I definitely get that a “watcher” can just be a different, perhaps subtler version of a “self” apart from reality. So I understand why you lean toward talking, instead, about “watching” and that “watching is happening,” which doesn’t so strongly suggest a “self” doing the watching.
But then I find myself once again falling into confusion about why, then, we’re even talking about “watching,” if it suggests separation or any sort of watcher, which is precisely the illusion that needs to be seen through.
Hypothesis: Stressing “watching” is about the contrast with being the “doer” of one’s life — that one can’t actually find a doer or controller or chooser. One’s life is just happening, and all there is is the “watching” of experience.
So now I'm going to go back and reread the quote above . . . So if I’m trying to be the “watching” and end up as a “watcher,” I basically do self-inquiry on that watcher to discover that no such thing can be found. Quoting this last part again:
Time for Zoom group. More later.Watching is happening.
The image of K is happening.
The sense of immersion is happening.
The sense of stepping back is happening.
No watcher is found.
Re: realizing selflessness
I dunno. Even after the group meeting, I still feel somewhat befuddled about the watching thing.
I noticed myself wondering if, at this point in these exchanges, we’re mostly just giving my mind some little things to do — slightly different pointers to play with, excuses to do some writing about experience — to keep it occupied while everything percolates through until some sort of shift happens whenever it happens. It’s like my mind needs the pacifier of feeling useful, or maybe just an engaging toy, to keep it from fussing. So I’d be grateful if you’d continue to humor my mind by giving it interesting little things to do and write about.
Of course, I also hope that something you say to me will be like a whack with a stick from a Zen teacher, jolting me into awakening. Or what about hypnotism?
But actually, I imagine that this exchange will mainly continue to offer pointers that help me look in the right direction — y’know, the direction of right here.
Whatever it is we’re doing, I’m grateful to you, vince.
I’ll play with this pointer now:
It occurs to me that maybe the choice of the word “watching” is what I’m struggling with, perhaps because it sounds like a doing, as opposed to, say, “seeing,” which just sounds like perceiving. Is there a reason you’re not using the word “awareness”? Has that been used so much by the Advaita Vedanta folks that now it sounds like a spiritualized “self”?
The thing I said in the meeting about how seeing just happens if my eyes are open, and hearing just happens if my ears aren’t plugged, and maybe watching just happens if I’m conscious? — that would ring truer to me with the word “awareness” than with the word “watching.” Watching seems active, like being on the lookout, focusing attention on things, while awareness seems like it’s just there if I’m alive and conscious.
But now I feel like this is too many words, too much thinking and communicating.
Just this. Stay here. This is it. What's experienced right now is all there is. And that doesn’t include a doer or watcher or owner of any of it.
I noticed myself wondering if, at this point in these exchanges, we’re mostly just giving my mind some little things to do — slightly different pointers to play with, excuses to do some writing about experience — to keep it occupied while everything percolates through until some sort of shift happens whenever it happens. It’s like my mind needs the pacifier of feeling useful, or maybe just an engaging toy, to keep it from fussing. So I’d be grateful if you’d continue to humor my mind by giving it interesting little things to do and write about.
Of course, I also hope that something you say to me will be like a whack with a stick from a Zen teacher, jolting me into awakening. Or what about hypnotism?
But actually, I imagine that this exchange will mainly continue to offer pointers that help me look in the right direction — y’know, the direction of right here.
Whatever it is we’re doing, I’m grateful to you, vince.
I’ll play with this pointer now:
Yeah, OK, I can try that.So for the next sitting, keep it extremely simple:
This is it.
Stay here.
No notes.
No meditator found.
No watcher behind the watching.
It occurs to me that maybe the choice of the word “watching” is what I’m struggling with, perhaps because it sounds like a doing, as opposed to, say, “seeing,” which just sounds like perceiving. Is there a reason you’re not using the word “awareness”? Has that been used so much by the Advaita Vedanta folks that now it sounds like a spiritualized “self”?
The thing I said in the meeting about how seeing just happens if my eyes are open, and hearing just happens if my ears aren’t plugged, and maybe watching just happens if I’m conscious? — that would ring truer to me with the word “awareness” than with the word “watching.” Watching seems active, like being on the lookout, focusing attention on things, while awareness seems like it’s just there if I’m alive and conscious.
But now I feel like this is too many words, too much thinking and communicating.
I think I need to take this to heart. From the relative perspective, I think it makes some sense to talk about the “home stretch” or an “event,” but given that I want to become acquainted with the absolute perspective, I think I need to try to grok how there can’t be a “home stretch” for getting to what’s always been right here. You can’t be closer or farther. And realizing what’s always been right here and is apparently stupidly obvious is a funny thing to call a “special event.” But, yeah, I have the problem of being all too familiar with these ways of thinking and talking, so they might not hit home and challenge my usual perspective as well as I might wish.No home stretch.
No special event required.
Just this, without the added owner.
Just this. Stay here. This is it. What's experienced right now is all there is. And that doesn’t include a doer or watcher or owner of any of it.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
Yes. This is a real language snag.It occurs to me that maybe the choice of the word “watching” is what I’m struggling with, perhaps because it sounds like a doing, as opposed to, say, “seeing,” which just sounds like perceiving. Is there a reason you’re not using the word “awareness”? Has that been used so much by the Advaita Vedanta folks that now it sounds like a spiritualized “self”?
The thing I said in the meeting about how seeing just happens if my eyes are open, and hearing just happens if my ears aren’t plugged, and maybe watching just happens if I’m conscious? — that would ring truer to me with the word “awareness” than with the word “watching.” Watching seems active, like being on the lookout, focusing attention on things, while awareness seems like it’s just there if I’m alive and conscious.
“Watching” can easily imply a watcher.
It can sound like:
someone is on duty
someone is monitoring experience
someone is doing mindfulness correctly
someone is staying alert
So yes, for you, “seeing”, “noticing”, or even “experiencing” may be cleaner.
The reason I’ve mostly avoided “awareness” is exactly what you suspected: it so easily becomes a spiritualized self.
Not always. But often.
The mind can make awareness into:
the real me
the witness
the background
the container of experience
the thing that is awake
Then the old self has simply moved house. It is no longer K the person; now it is awareness watching K.
we need to be careful not to turn awareness into a concrete thing. Awareness is an abstract noun. The more direct move is not to imagine an entity called awareness, but to notice sensory experiencing: sound, sensation, colour, thought, movement.
Your meeting phrase is good:
Seeing happens if eyes are open.
Hearing happens if ears are not blocked.
Maybe aware-ing happens if consciousness is present.
But even there, be careful with “if consciousness is present.” That can turn consciousness into a subtle object.
Cleaner:
Seeing happens.
Hearing happens.
Sensation happens.
Thought happens.
Noticing happens.
No watcher needed.
So maybe replace “watching attention” with:
“Notice attention moving.”
Or even cleaner:
“Attention moves.”
That removes the active watcher.
For meditation, try these:
This is it.
Seeing is happening.
Hearing is happening.
Sensation is happening.
Thought is happening.
Attention moves.
No mover is found.
And when the word awareness appears, don’t reject it. Just test it.
Is awareness found as a thing?
Or is there only seeing, hearing, sensing, thinking, feeling, knowing?
The trap is subtle:
“I am aware” creates an I.
“Awareness is aware” creates a spiritualized I.
“Aware-ing is happening” is closer, but still a little awkward.
Maybe simplest:
This is known.
Then don’t ask by whom? as philosophy - Look.
Known: sound.
Known: sensation.
Known: thought.
Known: visual field.
Known: wanting.
Known: confusion.
Knower: unknown.
Found only in thought.
I was listening to the latest songs when I was walking the dog today and I kept thinking of how appropriate some of these songs are for you. Anyway, here's a link to the playlist on SoundCloud. I can't re-order them so I suggest you start at the bottom of the list where the latest ones are.
https://soundcloud.com/vince-schubert-1 ... al_sharing
Oh, there are no written lyrics on SoundCloud. If you want to read the lyrics, I suggest you go to Substack and find the song.
vince
Re: realizing selflessness
For about two years, Rupert Spira’s videos were one of my main sources of guidance for practice, so I did a lot of “being awareness” and “resting as awareness.” His approach worked well to bring me back into regular practice after decades of failed attempts to reengage. Actually, before that, it was Hubert Benoit’s book The Supreme Doctrine that helped me get over some of what was blocking me.
A big struggle for me has always been trying to juggle the “already” aspect (inherent buddha-nature, or that there’s nowhere to go, nothing to do) with the “not yet” aspect (the value of practice and the sense that awakening is a thing that happens and is important). That is, if what I’m looking for is already here, what’s the point of practice? But if there’s nothing like practice happening, don’t I just stay stuck in my suffering-laden perspective? (Another participant in the Zoom meeting was getting at that last point.)
Rupert’s approach, while very much not oriented toward any sort of awakening event, somehow pulled me gently back into practice and, at the same time, toward settling into the “already” perspective.
Then I discovered Adyashanti and Angelo DiLullo, who are grounded in Zen but with some Advaita influence, and also Henry Shukman, who’s a legit Zen teacher, and I discovered LU, with its “no-self” focus, and I was glad to return to a more Zennie way of framing things.
Before your group, I’d participated a few times in another, similar sort of group, but their predominant way of thinking about all this came from Hinduism and specifically TM — “self-realization” rather than “no-self” — and I could work with that, but it felt kind of foreign.
OK, that was all K playing with this morning’s shiny toy to keep her mind occupied so that it won’t fuss too much about having nothing to DO regarding awakening. I’ll try to keep that to a minimum.
Anyhow, I do get how “awareness” can become a substitute “self” in a way that might not be helpful, at least from the perspective of Zen and whatever LU is up to and whatever you’re up to.
I kind of like “aware-ing” for my purposes. Oh, or the more normal “noticing” also has less of a sense of DOing than “watching” does. Yeah, I can work with this:
A big struggle for me has always been trying to juggle the “already” aspect (inherent buddha-nature, or that there’s nowhere to go, nothing to do) with the “not yet” aspect (the value of practice and the sense that awakening is a thing that happens and is important). That is, if what I’m looking for is already here, what’s the point of practice? But if there’s nothing like practice happening, don’t I just stay stuck in my suffering-laden perspective? (Another participant in the Zoom meeting was getting at that last point.)
Rupert’s approach, while very much not oriented toward any sort of awakening event, somehow pulled me gently back into practice and, at the same time, toward settling into the “already” perspective.
Then I discovered Adyashanti and Angelo DiLullo, who are grounded in Zen but with some Advaita influence, and also Henry Shukman, who’s a legit Zen teacher, and I discovered LU, with its “no-self” focus, and I was glad to return to a more Zennie way of framing things.
Before your group, I’d participated a few times in another, similar sort of group, but their predominant way of thinking about all this came from Hinduism and specifically TM — “self-realization” rather than “no-self” — and I could work with that, but it felt kind of foreign.
OK, that was all K playing with this morning’s shiny toy to keep her mind occupied so that it won’t fuss too much about having nothing to DO regarding awakening. I’ll try to keep that to a minimum.
Anyhow, I do get how “awareness” can become a substitute “self” in a way that might not be helpful, at least from the perspective of Zen and whatever LU is up to and whatever you’re up to.
I kind of like “aware-ing” for my purposes. Oh, or the more normal “noticing” also has less of a sense of DOing than “watching” does. Yeah, I can work with this:
And this:Seeing happens.
Hearing happens.
Sensation happens.
Thought happens.
Noticing happens.
No watcher needed.
Known: sound.
Known: sensation.
Known: thought.
Known: visual field.
Known: wanting.
Known: confusion.
Knower: unknown.
Will check out the songs, starting at the bottom. Thanks.
Re: realizing selflessness
Having a bout of feeling more-than-usually oppressed by dealing with the ordinary tasks of life. Had a mushy and confused afternoon sit, but it did involve some noticing of seeing, hearing, feeling, and thinking and a little bit of noticing of the noticing.
Re: realizing selflessness
I started poking around in your Substack files. A couple of stories I connected with were "When It Let Go" and "Let It Come, Let It Go."
Re: realizing selflessness
Afternoon sit, guided by this:
- Seeing: the carpet in front of me and, more fuzzily at the periphery of vison, other parts of the room and parts of my body; one big insect flying by.
- Hearing: A/C (different sounds from different vents), a few birds outside.
- Feeling: breath in nostrils, sensations of sitting, cool air blowing on skin.
- Thinking: mostly thoughts about meditation and “taking notes” on meditation, also a few thoughts about someone we saw immediately before sitting and about plans for later in the day.
No thinker of thoughts is experienced, no perceiver of sensations, no doer of meditation.
But still a sense of “self,” located especially in head.
What’s actually there?
Tightness across brow (tension? sinus issues?), feel of lips touching together, feel of tongue against teeth, feel of cheeks.
Sense that the point-of-view of the seeing is a “seer” behind the eyes.
Sense of the perceiver being separate from and at a distance from what is seen.
Just an array of colors and shapes. Mind adds overlay of depth perception and labels objects.
Close one eye to turn off a key mechanism of depth perception.
Easier that way to experience the “seen” as being “here,” not at a distance.
What about sound?
Easier to experience sound as being “here” than sight.
What about bodily sensations?
Definitely mapped onto a mental image of the body in space.
Close eyes so that at least I’m not seeing my crossed legs.
Still seems like perceiver is at a distance from legs, in head.
(That could be a whole meditation: trying to just notice the raw physical sensations of the body, without the body map and the “perceiver” in the head, and experience the sensations as “here.”)
This is it. Present experience is all there is:So for the next sitting, keep it extremely simple:
This is it.
Stay here.
No notes.
No meditator found.
No watcher behind the watching.
- Seeing: the carpet in front of me and, more fuzzily at the periphery of vison, other parts of the room and parts of my body; one big insect flying by.
- Hearing: A/C (different sounds from different vents), a few birds outside.
- Feeling: breath in nostrils, sensations of sitting, cool air blowing on skin.
- Thinking: mostly thoughts about meditation and “taking notes” on meditation, also a few thoughts about someone we saw immediately before sitting and about plans for later in the day.
No thinker of thoughts is experienced, no perceiver of sensations, no doer of meditation.
But still a sense of “self,” located especially in head.
What’s actually there?
Tightness across brow (tension? sinus issues?), feel of lips touching together, feel of tongue against teeth, feel of cheeks.
Sense that the point-of-view of the seeing is a “seer” behind the eyes.
Sense of the perceiver being separate from and at a distance from what is seen.
Just an array of colors and shapes. Mind adds overlay of depth perception and labels objects.
Close one eye to turn off a key mechanism of depth perception.
Easier that way to experience the “seen” as being “here,” not at a distance.
What about sound?
Easier to experience sound as being “here” than sight.
What about bodily sensations?
Definitely mapped onto a mental image of the body in space.
Close eyes so that at least I’m not seeing my crossed legs.
Still seems like perceiver is at a distance from legs, in head.
(That could be a whole meditation: trying to just notice the raw physical sensations of the body, without the body map and the “perceiver” in the head, and experience the sensations as “here.”)
Re: realizing selflessness
And yet another post:
Was reading some of your old threads, archived under "Links to all guided conversations where realization happens," and was feeling jealous of those who seemed to "get it" relatively quickly and easily, and was wondering why I'm still not seeing it. Of course, some of them had had glimpses earlier, which I haven't, but even discounting those, a lot of folks seemed to wake up pretty quickly.
Until I ran across LU and Angelo DiLullo, it probably wouldn't've even occurred to me to think that waking up could be so quick and easy as I'm now under the impression it can be, and it's been less than two months now that I've been being guided at LU, but still, at this moment, I'm feeling impatient and frustrated, and I'm wondering if there's something in particular that's standing in the way.
Was reading some of your old threads, archived under "Links to all guided conversations where realization happens," and was feeling jealous of those who seemed to "get it" relatively quickly and easily, and was wondering why I'm still not seeing it. Of course, some of them had had glimpses earlier, which I haven't, but even discounting those, a lot of folks seemed to wake up pretty quickly.
Until I ran across LU and Angelo DiLullo, it probably wouldn't've even occurred to me to think that waking up could be so quick and easy as I'm now under the impression it can be, and it's been less than two months now that I've been being guided at LU, but still, at this moment, I'm feeling impatient and frustrated, and I'm wondering if there's something in particular that's standing in the way.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
Hi K, it doesn't matter which bits I highlight to respond to every one of them contains the same potential.
The demand to know what is standing in the way.
Not as a clever answer. Literally.
Look at the movement:
“They got it quickly.”
“Why not me?”
“Maybe I’m missing something.”
“Maybe there is a block.”
“Maybe Vince can identify it.”
“Then I can remove it.”
That is the seeker-self rebuilding itself out of comparison, time, deficiency, and diagnosis.
Jealousy is not a problem. Impatience is not a problem. Frustration is not a problem.
They are the current doorway.
Do not turn them into evidence that awakening has not happened.
Right now, jealousy means what?
Maybe heat. Tightness. Sinking. Pressure in the face. Thought-images of other people “getting it.” A story of being left behind. A story of being defective. A future-image of finally joining them.
Where is the one who is behind?
Not the story. Not the image. Not the contraction.
The one.
Can it be found?
This is exactly the same knot that appeared in the meeting: while there is seeking, there is dissatisfaction with the status quo; but satisfaction cannot be produced on demand. The move is not to become satisfied, but to see the present construction of dissatisfaction.
The comparison with archived threads is poison only when believed.
They are not ahead.
You are not behind.
There is no line.
There is no spiritual queue.
There is no one who wakes up sooner or later.
There are just stories about people, timelines, awakenings, ease, difficulty, success, failure.
And here, now: jealousy, frustration, thought, sensation, wanting.
That’s it.
You ask whether there is something in particular standing in the way. The most obvious pattern is this:
You keep expecting the seeing to do something for you.
Relieve frustration.
End impatience.
Produce peace.
Stop seeking.
Confirm arrival.
Make ordinary life feel acceptable.
Give you the satisfying moment of “finally.”
So when no self is found, thought says:
“So what?”
That “So what?” is the selfing. It asks, “What benefit do I get from this?”
Look there.
Where is the I that should receive the benefit?
Not found.
So the “block” is not hidden. It is this exact insistence:
“Seeing should feel different from this.”
Say that sentence slowly:
Seeing should feel different from this.
Feel the body.
That contraction is the gate.
Not something to remove. Something to see without obeying.
Right now, what is actually here?
Reading.
Thought.
Comparison.
Impatience.
Maybe tightness.
Maybe ache.
Maybe anger.
Maybe the image of others getting it.
Maybe the sentence “Why not me?”
Where is me?
Don’t answer from memory.
Look again.
..and look at what exists as looking happens. (they looking includes thoughts but not what they are about what they are about is a distraction from the looking.)
much love
vince
Yes. Something is standing in the way.Was reading some of your old threads, archived under "Links to all guided conversations where realization happens," and was feeling jealous of those who seemed to "get it" relatively quickly and easily, and was wondering why I'm still not seeing it. Of course, some of them had had glimpses earlier, which I haven't, but even discounting those, a lot of folks seemed to wake up pretty quickly.
Until I ran across LU and Angelo DiLullo, it probably wouldn't've even occurred to me to think that waking up could be so quick and easy as I'm now under the impression it can be, and it's been less than two months now that I've been being guided at LU, but still, at this moment, I'm feeling impatient and frustrated, and I'm wondering if there's something in particular that's standing in the way.
The demand to know what is standing in the way.
Not as a clever answer. Literally.
Look at the movement:
“They got it quickly.”
“Why not me?”
“Maybe I’m missing something.”
“Maybe there is a block.”
“Maybe Vince can identify it.”
“Then I can remove it.”
That is the seeker-self rebuilding itself out of comparison, time, deficiency, and diagnosis.
Jealousy is not a problem. Impatience is not a problem. Frustration is not a problem.
They are the current doorway.
Do not turn them into evidence that awakening has not happened.
Right now, jealousy means what?
Maybe heat. Tightness. Sinking. Pressure in the face. Thought-images of other people “getting it.” A story of being left behind. A story of being defective. A future-image of finally joining them.
Where is the one who is behind?
Not the story. Not the image. Not the contraction.
The one.
Can it be found?
This is exactly the same knot that appeared in the meeting: while there is seeking, there is dissatisfaction with the status quo; but satisfaction cannot be produced on demand. The move is not to become satisfied, but to see the present construction of dissatisfaction.
The comparison with archived threads is poison only when believed.
They are not ahead.
You are not behind.
There is no line.
There is no spiritual queue.
There is no one who wakes up sooner or later.
There are just stories about people, timelines, awakenings, ease, difficulty, success, failure.
And here, now: jealousy, frustration, thought, sensation, wanting.
That’s it.
You ask whether there is something in particular standing in the way. The most obvious pattern is this:
You keep expecting the seeing to do something for you.
Relieve frustration.
End impatience.
Produce peace.
Stop seeking.
Confirm arrival.
Make ordinary life feel acceptable.
Give you the satisfying moment of “finally.”
So when no self is found, thought says:
“So what?”
That “So what?” is the selfing. It asks, “What benefit do I get from this?”
Look there.
Where is the I that should receive the benefit?
Not found.
So the “block” is not hidden. It is this exact insistence:
“Seeing should feel different from this.”
Say that sentence slowly:
Seeing should feel different from this.
Feel the body.
That contraction is the gate.
Not something to remove. Something to see without obeying.
Right now, what is actually here?
Reading.
Thought.
Comparison.
Impatience.
Maybe tightness.
Maybe ache.
Maybe anger.
Maybe the image of others getting it.
Maybe the sentence “Why not me?”
Where is me?
Don’t answer from memory.
Look again.
..and look at what exists as looking happens. (they looking includes thoughts but not what they are about what they are about is a distraction from the looking.)
much love
vince
Re: realizing selflessness
Lying in bed with lights out (spouse already asleep next to me), doing this on my phone. Want to start processing what you said and sleep on it.
Yes. All of that. I want all of that. I do even probably expect all of that. I feel like I’ve been led to expect all of that. It certainly all sounds very “self”-ish when written out, but there it is.You ask whether there is something in particular standing in the way. The most obvious pattern is this:
You keep expecting the seeing to do something for you.
Relieve frustration.
End impatience.
Produce peace.
Stop seeking.
Confirm arrival.
Make ordinary life feel acceptable.
Give you the satisfying moment of “finally.”
Yep.So when no self is found, thought says:
“So what?”
Of course I know the “right” answer, but I think I need to do more “self”-examination here. Thank you for the pointers that follow. Will pick up there tomorrow.That “So what?” is the selfing. It asks, “What benefit do I get from this?”
Look there.
Where is the I that should receive the benefit?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Google [Bot], opodaniel and 50 guests

