Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Wed May 29, 2024 3:20 am

oooh I didn't post yesterday! had other things on my mind and then remembered too late. so today... I'm doing double!
What reaction do you feel as you've read that responses may be blunt? (That first reaction felt without dressing it up at all)
nothing
To find the truth of "no self" the approach here is to deconstruct the idea of the separate self. It is an unlearning, an undoing and for this reason the best way to approach this is to put aside everything you think you know or expect and just be with this exploration with an openness and a willingness to LOOK directly.
Do you feel anything within you that objects or resists laying aside everything you have learned or think or know or read or have been taught and just depend on your own authentic experience for the duration of this exploration ?
not right now
If I was to ask you what color is the heel of your left sock or shoe, there are at least two ways to answer. One is you could answer from memory or alternatively you could go and LOOK.


What color do you think the heel of your left sock or shoe is?
blue or gray

Can you be 100% sure?
no

When you LOOK DIRECTLY is it what you thought it was?
it was blue. this socket has blue and gray... so not that far haha.
As you are sitting responding to this post describe……
What are you are seeing? (consciously avoiding any labels where at all possible - that is using the most basic descriptive terms possible.)
always seeing color

What are you are hearing? (consciously avoiding any labels where at all possible - that is using the most basic descriptive terms possible.)
always hearing sounds
(activities and DE)
Post several of your own observations of daily activities in a list *exactly* like the one above, please. Same word forms. Same order. EXACTLY.
Activity: playing piano
Seeing keys, simply = color
cold smell, simply = smell
Feeling plastic keys, simply = sensation
Tasting (nothing to report) = taste
Sound of piano playing = sound
Thought (nothing to report) = thought

Activity: drinking inca kola
Seeing metal cup, simply = color
Smells of drink (I can't describe it), simply = smell
Feel of cold, hard cup, simply = sensation
Tasting sweet gum juice = taste
Sound of television playing = sound
Thought of “the bottle is so beautiful!” simply = thought

Activity: washing dishes
Seeing my hands washing, simply = color
Smells of lemon from detergent, simply = smell
Feel of hard glass and soft sponge, simply = sensation
Tasting (nothing to report) = taste
Sound of my hand brushing the cup = sound
Thought of "I can't see well, this room is too dark" = thought

----

observations:

+ right now, just more direct and simpler answers.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Wed May 29, 2024 12:14 pm

Yes, I did miss your post Nicholas. Always happy to see them popping up.😊

Can you be 100% sure?
no
A real contrast to first time through !

+ right now, just more direct and simpler answers.
Yes ! By way of contrast the mind loves complexity.


With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu May 30, 2024 2:21 am

Where am I in the Body?

Please do this very attentively because otherwise you will not have the direct experience. Also for each of the questions tell me your experience as you LOOK to where each question points.

Please look down at your feet right now. Very attentively. And ask yourself the question. Can you find a “me” or an “I” down there in those feet? Do those feet constitute me?. Do it as slowly and as attentively as you can. Do you live there?.
no

And now travel up. To the knees. Look at yourself from the knees down to the toenail. With the same question. Is there a “me” to be found down there. Is this you?
no

And now travel. Up to your waist. We travel up to the neck now, but you'll need to be more thorough and examine that body between the neck and the waist front and back. Are you there?
no

Outside and inside look right down into the inside. And ask yourself. Is this me?
no
And then from the neck right up to the topmost hair of the head. And be sure to LOOK and FEEL around inside the head and notice the brain. The ears and the throat. Look right down. Through the throat. Can you find yourself there?
no

Because now you've encompassed the body. Is this you? Can you find yourself anywhere? Anywhere at all? In all that you have examined inside or outside?
no

Now look behind the eyes, because sometimes we think that we are behind the eyes looking out. This is where you said the watching was happening. Is there actually a watcher there? Can you be 100% sure that you can find yourself even there?
no

And eventually if you do this faithfully IS THERE ANY EVIDENCE AT ALL - not because I say so but because if this has been faithfully done, you have actually come to the conclusion yourself – to prove that you are your body or any specific part of it?
no
If during this experience you have not become fully convinced, if it’s not absolutely clear to you that there is no place at all within your body where you are then please do it again.. And if necessary, a third or fourth time. Until you are no longer taking my word for it. Until you yourself can bear witness to the fact that you have searched yourself thoroughly. And that you know that you are not inside of that frame.

So tell me Nicholas after all this direct LOOKING can you find a “me” or an “I” in the body in any shape or form whatsoever?
no


Is there anywhere that you SEEM to be?
only as a belief, not in the body.


Do you have any lingering doubts about what you have directly experienced here?
no

observations:

+ haha on past answers there's still rambling hahaha!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu May 30, 2024 12:25 pm

Nicholas,

Very clear, succinct responses here.

Are there any doubts arising as you go through this?




If doubts do pop up it would be very useful to mention them as we go along.



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Fri May 31, 2024 4:06 am

mmhm the site seems to be down a lot these last few days, have you noticed? there's no info about this on the forum.
Are there any doubts arising as you go through this?
not at the moment!
Imagine what a baby sees when they first open their eyes.
What would you say they are seeing?
color

Do they have any labels in their mind?
no

If you asked a five year old what they are seeing, would what they describe be any different to what a baby actually is seeing?
yes


If no, why not?
-

If yes, how would it be different?
a 5 year old can communicate, and would tell you labels.
Label-Reality Correlation

There is a belief that labels have a one-to-one correspondence with ‘reality’. But there isn’t. Just like it is a generally accepted belief that labels like ‘good’ and ‘bad’ are inherent characteristics of ‘things’. But actually, they are not.

When you look at the word label ‘GREEN', what is your actual experience?
RED

You are seeing green, right? Or as you look at the word green are you actually seeing red but believing the minds interpretation of the word green?
I'm seeing red

Does the label ‘GREEN’ have a one-to-one correspondence with ‘reality’? Or does the label suggest something else other than what is here now (red colour)?
label suggest red colour

Is 'green' associated in any way with the experience of the colour red; or is green just a label that overlays the actual experience of red?
green is just a label

If the label ‘GREEN’ is replaced with the label ‘GOOD’ or ‘BAD’, is the redness affected in any way as the labels suggests?
no

Does redness become ‘good’ or ‘bad’, or do the labels have no affect whatsoever on ‘reality’?
labels have no effect

Let me know what is SEEN.
just labels, text with different colors.

observations
+ less use of mind now. just more direct straightforward answer without thinking

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri May 31, 2024 12:02 pm

Hello Nicholas,

mmhm the site seems to be down a lot these last few days, have you noticed? there's no info about this on the forum.
Yes it has been very slow and unresponsive. The IT folks are seeing a lot of bot activity and suspect data scraping is going on. It happened a couple of months back too and they were able to get a handle on it then. They are trying to get it sorted again.

Are there any doubts arising as you go through this?
not at the moment!
Let me know if any pop up

+ less use of mind now. just more direct straightforward answer without thinking
Indeed !
How does that FEEL?




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun Jun 02, 2024 3:45 am

Hi. My pc died, that’s why I couldn’t report yesterday. I will get a new one this week I hope... it was time.
+ less use of mind now. just more direct straightforward answer without thinking
Indeed !
How does that FEEL?
Doing a quick look, feels bit good
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If the label ‘GREEN’ is replaced with the label ‘GOOD’ or ‘BAD’, is the redness affected in any way as the labels suggest?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As you LOOK at the sentence above and without any reference to thought, what is actually SEEN? What is your Actual Experience here?
Colors
Now let’s remind ourselves what this exploration is all about. It's to look for the “me.”
So right now can any specific thing that we could label the “me” be found?
belief, habit.

Now, turn your attention to the SEEING itself as you LOOK.
Can you find a specific place from which SEEING arises?
not really. I do have this habit/belief to identify a “me” behind the eyes but I know that’s not true. Again, it’s just habit.
As you continue to look can you find a “me” that is in control of the SEEING?
well, I still believe that I’m in control.
(wait a minute, on second look... ok I'm not totally sure but I sense that no one controls seeing. it was very quick. there's something here.)

Can you choose to stop SEEING?
no

While what we are LOOKING AT is continually changing does the SEEING ITSELF change in any way?
no

So explore the SEEING that is happening with these questions in mind and tell me anything else about your DIRECT EXPERIENCE that you are noticing
just thoughts. Colors. Sounds.

Next time you go for a walk practice looking without labeling.
I’d love to hear. What happened?
(will do this tomorrow, it’s 23:12 right now)

(picture)
When looking at this picture, thought automatically divides colour into colours and then names colour as specific objects.

IGNORE ALL object, image and colour labels or interpretations as you JUST LOOK at this picture:-
Are there many colourS or just colour?
just colour

What tells you there are many different colours?
-

Is there a gap between the ‘objects’ - the cobblestones or the buildings for instance ?
no

Is there a dividing line between ANY object?
no

Where does colour begin and end?
it never ends! Because seeing = color

Does any shape exist without colour or any colour exist without shape?
no

Is SEEING possible without colour?
no

Can anything be found in PURE SEEING other than colour?
no

Is there a seer separate from that which is seen?
there’s still a small belief in a seer but it’s shrinking

Is there any place you can find where a seer ends and the colour starts?
no

In DIRECT EXPERIENCE is there any difference between ”colour” and “seeing”? Are those two labels interchangeable?
Color = seeing

I notice...
+ less tiredness, less fatigue with this work.
+ more understanding of the real questions haha. Some just went over my head.
+ more clear seeing, still a long way to go.
+ less “but what about thisss” (ramble)

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun Jun 02, 2024 1:17 pm

Hi. My pc died, that’s why I couldn’t report yesterday.
Life happens Nicholas !!

(wait a minute, on second look... ok I'm not totally sure but I sense that no one controls seeing. it was very quick. there's something here.)
So good you're catching this "something here" It all happens so quick but as you find the mind "slowing" down you are able to catch things. This slowing down is a natural consequence of repeated and consistent LOOKING

it never ends! Because seeing = color
Beautiful !!

+ less tiredness, less fatigue with this work.
There is so much effort associated with thinking that we come to think is normal. Until the thinking subsides even a little and what you have described here is recognized.

+ more understanding of the real questions haha. Some just went over my head.
+ more clear seeing, still a long way to go.
+ less “but what about thisss” (ramble)
Really good. I feel it in these posts Nicholas


With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Jun 03, 2024 3:08 am

Hello again

Now from DIRECT EXPERIENCE we are going to prove whether or not there is a seer and what is seen as separate entities or separate definable objects.


Soften your gaze and notice your total field of vision. All you see is color. In the AE of seeing there is only colors. Right?

Choose any particular part or shape or "object" in your field of vision and focus on that.

Now move your attention “back” to where you believe you are seeing from. Continue to move your attention to and fro between what you sense as the source of seeing and the chosen object. Please do this a number of times

In moving your attention to and fro does your attention cross any boundary at all?
no (actually, there’s nowhere to move attention to)


SLOW THIS RIGHT DOWN.

Is there ANY division between what is seen and what thought tells you is the seer?
no

Is there anywhere a so called "seer" starts or ends and the object which is seen starts or ends?
no

Can you in any way stop this experiencing of seeing?
no

Sure, the colors in the field of vision change, but does the ACTUAL SEEING itself change in any way?
no


Tell me, without ANY labeling or interpretation of the mind overlaying your experience can you find any DIVISION, ANY GAP, ANY BOUNDARY, ANY SEPARATION IN YOUR ACTUAL SEEING EXPERIENCE at all?
nop

As you move your attention back and forward is there ANYTHING that interrupts that movement?
it’s a trick of the mind, attention is always there. There’s no seer.

Please do this a number of times throughout the day in different situations. What do you find?.
there’s only the seen

Is there anything else you notice in your ACTUAL EXPERIENCE of SEEING that you would like to report?
It helps reinforce the LOOKING at SEEING when I LOOK at SENSATIONS. There’s only sensations. There’s only seeing. And so on.

Notice
+ I see that at this point I was still caught at “feeling” a self
+ I also see that I considered the exercise hard. It was hard because I was doing something or thought I had to do something. Nothing needs to be done.
+ there were a lot of thoughts hahaha

I think I realized something here (right now, while doing the exercise again), but I have no idea what. I got a little bit emotional but again... I have NO IDEA what I have realized. It's another brick though.

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Jun 03, 2024 3:09 am

The "hello again" was from me, I accidentally quoted it ups haha

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon Jun 03, 2024 12:30 pm

Hi Nicholas

Notice
+ I see that at this point I was still caught at “feeling” a self
+ I also see that I considered the exercise hard. It was hard because I was doing something or thought I had to do something. Nothing needs to be done.
+ there were a lot of thoughts hahaha

I think I realized something here (right now, while doing the exercise again), but I have no idea what. I got a little bit emotional but again... I have NO IDEA what I have realized. It's another brick though.
There is nothing that comes to mind to add to what you have described Nicholas. In fact trying to add something could well take from what you say here.


With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue Jun 04, 2024 5:21 am

hellooooo
We'll take this inwards and outwards a little further.......

Choose an object out in your field of vision.

Now while you are holding a soft gaze imagine a bright red watermelon in your mind. Got it.?

Now move your attention between the object just chosen and the imagined watermelon. Continue to move your attention between the two.

Does your attention actually cross ANY BOUNDARY between what is typically considered to be inwards ( the Imagined watermelon) and the object "out there"?
no

Now move your attention between the watermelon, the chosen object in the field of vision AND SEEING ITSELF.


Tell me, without ANY labeling or interpretation of the mind overlaying your experience can you find any DIVISION, ANY GAP, ANY BOUNDARY, ANY SEPARATION IN YOUR ACTUAL SEEING EXPERIENCE at all?
no

As you move your attention back and forward is there ANYTHING that tells you where any notion of a line between inside and outside might be that your attention has to cross?
they are different senses. Isn’t that some kind of a dividing line?


Is there anything else you notice in your ACTUAL EXPERIENCE of SEEING about the phenomenon of imagined watermelon, the field of vision and the reality of SEEING?
we do consider the imagined watermelon and the object out there as different senses right? Out there is seeing and imagination is thought content (visual). Is that right?

Ok, this one... might need some more work right? What do we do? Take notes and move forward and work on it as soon as I finish the rest? Or expand on it now? Your call

Observations
+ huh... I had difficulty concentrating on this. Now I don’t, wonder why
+ only difference is that I know there’s no seer now
+ still some rambling there

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue Jun 04, 2024 12:24 pm

Hi Nicholas

Ok, this one... might need some more work right? What do we do? Take notes and move forward and work on it as soon as I finish the rest? Or expand on it now? Your call
Let's dig in while it is alive for you


As you move your attention back and forward is there ANYTHING that tells you where any notion of a line between inside and outside might be that your attention has to cross?
they are different senses. Isn’t that some kind of a dividing line?
Let's keep this really simple and investigate this only by LOOKING
Look at the question again ........ without drawing any conclusions, concepts or interpretation can you find ANY FORM OF A DIVIDING LINE as your attention moves from "inside" to "outside"?



we do consider the imagined watermelon and the object out there as different senses right? Out there is seeing and imagination is thought content (visual). Is that right?
SEEING is SEEING. Consider this.....
Is SEEING happening when you dream (imagining when you are asleep)?




Do you not SEE colors when you dream?





Of course during a dream the mind creates labels, interprets shapes and creates a story based on its interpretation of the colors. SEEING and COLOR (two words are interchangeable) are what we might call "benign" without mind interpretation just like we experience when we are awake during the day

So when awareness of color is experienced in imagination during waking hours is there a difference in SEEING that is experienced while dreaming?




Remember the tomato exercise. When you placed the tomato in front of you colors were seen. Now close your eyes and imagine a tomato colors arestill seen. The colors seen in imagination are the minds memory thought of the colors of a tomato.

So whether SEEING is "within" or "without" so called, can you see it is the same SEEING sense?





Believing what we SEE in imagination and believing that to be reality is at the heart of illusion. But SEEING is SEEING regardless of whether color is in, or not in, imagination.

+ only difference is that I know there’s no seer now
Is there any doubt about this at all?




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Wed Jun 05, 2024 5:10 am

Code: Select all

As you move your attention back and forward is there ANYTHING that tells you where any notion of a line between inside and outside might be that your attention has to cross?
they are different senses. Isn’t that some kind of a dividing line?
Let's keep this really simple and investigate this only by LOOKING
Look at the question again ........ without drawing any conclusions, concepts or interpretation can you find ANY FORM OF A DIVIDING LINE as your attention moves from "inside" to "outside"?
I don’t know. I don’t even know what a dividing line is in this case. This one I don’t see it yet.
we do consider the imagined watermelon and the object out there as different senses right? Out there is seeing and imagination is thought content (visual). Is that right?
SEEING is SEEING. Consider this.....
Is SEEING happening when you dream (imagining when you are asleep)?
wait a second. Imagination is an entirely different thing from dreaming. Dreaming is closer to hallucinations, they happen right in front of our eyes. In fact, you can imagine stuff even when you are dreaming. My point is: dreaming is closer or equal to seeing but imagining not because it’s a different sense.

Do you not SEE colors when you dream?
yes


Of course during a dream the mind creates labels, interprets shapes and creates a story based on its interpretation of the colors. SEEING and COLOR (two words are interchangeable) are what we might call "benign" without mind interpretation just like we experience when we are awake during the day

So when awareness of color is experienced in imagination during waking hours is there a difference in SEEING that is experienced while dreaming?
they are different. It’s like comparing seeing with hearing.


Remember the tomato exercise. When you placed the tomato in front of you colors were seen. Now close your eyes and imagine a tomato colors arestill seen. The colors seen in imagination are the minds memory thought of the colors of a tomato.

So whether SEEING is "within" or "without" so called, can you see it is the same SEEING sense?
Nop, I can’t see it!

+ only difference is that I know there’s no seer now
Is there any doubt about this at all?
Well, the belief is still strong. I can isolate some of the senses and it's obvious there's only the sensed. BUT, the rest of the story is still happening, the ME is there. so it can't be 100% clear. I don't know if I'm explaining myself correctly.

Well… we found something that really needs work here.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Wed Jun 05, 2024 11:50 am

Hi Nicholas
I don’t know. I don’t even know what a dividing line is in this case. This one I don’t see it yet.
So a dividing line cannot be found?
Could that be because a dividing line does not in fact exist in direct experience?




Just LOOK again ....is there any dividing line actually found?




wait a second. Imagination is an entirely different thing from dreaming. Dreaming is closer to hallucinations, they happen right in front of our eyes. In fact, you can imagine stuff even when you are dreaming. My point is: dreaming is closer or equal to seeing but imagining not because it’s a different sense.
Conceptual thinking is taking hold here Nicholas. But let's break down what you have said and LOOK at this in raw DE terms. Keep it simple.

You say ........
Dreaming is closer to hallucinations, they happen right in front of our eyes.
When you say "right in front of our eyes" are you saying that SEEING depends on our physical eyes?



Now remember you have said that as a result of investigating DE that SEEING = COLOR
In imagination, dreaming, hallucinations there is no denying that color appears. So in these "facets" of experience, color appears and where there is color, there is seeing.

You say that imagination and seeing are different senses. That's true. So there is something here that needs to be acknowledged that might help clarify what is being pointed to. The CONTENT of imagination is FANTASY. Imagination is concepts ABOUT reality - not the direct experience of reality itself. To be aware of a mental image appearing in imagination, that appearance is noticed because of (imagined) color. And color = seeing. The reverse is also true. No color, no seeing, no noticing of mental images.
In your DIRECT experience right now can you find and describe a mental image that is not seen?




Visual mental images appear as imagined color(seeing) and can be so compelling that they hypnotize us.These hypnotic images and thoughts are the fabric of the illusion. That the mental images are imaginary / illusory cannot be denied. But equally that there is seeing of these mental images (color) cannot be denied either.

So much more about SEEING can unfold later but at this stage we need to be clear that SEEING is not confined to physical eyes. Wherever there is color in experience, there is SEEING

And further to this matter of "inside" and "outside", "inside" and "outside" do not exist in reality. There are no boundaries in awareness. Whilst in truth they do not exist, they are "useful" concepts and we use them as they are conventionally used in language to help orient the investigation.

Is this any clearer now?




With love


Alan


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Eileen and 69 guests