Liberation?

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
zenkitties
Posts: 156
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2011 3:46 am
Location: California
Contact:

Re: Liberation?

Postby zenkitties » Thu Aug 16, 2012 9:07 pm

Do you mean ask questions? asking questions is just creating thoughts which allow the self to arise.
no self arises with the question, there is no self, only the question in which is arising and is experienced by nothing. However, I don't mean ask questions, I mean LOOK again, to observe, to see.
I have seen it perhaps I haven't and have been constantly lost in ego...
That might be a knot to be untangled. The ego isn't a thing, the ego is just a thought of a container in which all others thoughts arise within it. Ego is just another thought, it is not there. Just the same as when it is said that a "mind" is something that thinks thoughts. Not so, the mind is empty if observed, it too is just a thought. ego is also a false sense of continuity. Ego when de-constructed is just mutiple thought sensations happening.
so many kitties! so many zen!
http://liberatedself.wordpress.com/

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:43 pm

Incredible, every time I almost jump up to say something to you, or remember to re-read and re-think everything that was said, I find a new message from you, each one as or perhaps more helpful than the previous one.

I'm still pondering the continuity and focussing my breathing meditation, not that I've been having this problem recently (which I attribute to the "more-enlightened" self story), but previously when I really really got focussed on the breathing and an experience would emerge, or what I would call an experience looking back at it as a past idea, a thought, however tiny, would just emerge, about this experience, if just a recognition of someone/something having this experience, I would immediately get distracted and lose "control", or rather concentration and focus, or maybe control over concentration and focus, oh wait thats just another illusion, you know what I mean :P

My question whilst I continue pondering, or what I call more simmering in present moment, is there anything I could try out to stop this automatic thought from distracting me and taking me into a whole loop of distraction?

Thank you for the continuity idea by the way, it really resonates with me, especially since I listened to one of Bashar's talks on youtube about the teleportation idea where the illusion of continuity is created whereas in fact it's equation is just changing and it's just teleporting microscopic distances. Keep messaging, and indeed it does seem as if I'm freefalling as I'm barely able to keep up even with this conversation :P :)

I know gratitude has been expressed towards you over and over from many others, but I'd like to express mine nonetheless :) What may I call you? - can't believe this is the first time I'm asking

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:00 am

Where is there a you in this experiencing?
"I'm here." Either this answer comes up or "I know there isn't a me anywhere", both of these answers seem like a form of escape from seeing. And if no answer comes up it seems my mind almost shuts off and no thoughts are heard, I just feel my stomach slowly rising to my breath, the air going in through my nose, and yet it feels as though somewhere up there a self is still thinking about the experience, yet I'm just not aware of it. But how can I be aware of a separate me? There is only one me... right? But every time a thought or a reflex or impulse to do something arises even as simple as wanting to drink some juice, scratch my arm or shift my focus, I feel great disappointment in myself and it's difficult to pinpoint where it comes from except from my expectation of being able to focus on one thing, and that being the dissolving of the self at the moment.
Can a you be found in this thought? (sort of like can a bell be found in the sound that thought labels a bell)
Not really... but I don't know what this means... Or there is no meaning to it and it's just the self trying to think another thought about a thought about a thought... But it still comes in the form of an I want to do this or that. But it feels mostly subconscious... As if I'm not doing anything the right way and there's constantly a tiny adjustment to be made, like I'm not sitting comfortably, this isn't the proper pose, I'm being lazy and not doing what I should be doing, I'm hungry, thirsty, I'm not breathing properly... an endless dissatisfaction with the present moment, but even when I recognise it for the self trying to distract me, and persist with remaining motionless in the present moment, a little bit later it becomes subconscious and i open my eyes or do something without even thinking about it, or at least thats what it seems like...

I think you're falling into some continuity issues like I was. Fact of there still being a sense of something there. Break it down to its very sensate qualities just like the false sense of self is a number of beliefs, concepts, and ideas which give the false sense that a Matt is there.
I think I understand what you mean by this, but I don't know how to see past it. Slowing things down seems to work to a certain degree, but then I get caught up in the space between two things and a thought occurs that I'm not breathing so I consciously force myself to breathe, whereas I know somewhere that the breath doesn't need me to consciously breathe it, it'll do it automatically, but sometimes it's difficult going into that state of simply observing the breath and the border between control/observation seems to blur, sometimes i no longer know if i'm doing the breathing or the breath is doing itself and i'm just observing. It all does seem continuous if not for any reason than the belief that it all exists simultaneously and always does, instead of my focus moving to one place and perceiving one thing, then to another and perceiving another, but it's all just creating the new perception the moment the focus moves, creating the illusion of continuity right?
So to is the sense of something there, a collection of the five senses (thought, hearing, touching, tasting, seeing). See how these things aren't actually continuitious but rather follow one after the other in fast succession.
Ah, just what I was writing about in answer to the previous section... Not sure I understand the first part: "So to is the sense of something there" is there a typo here? or am I just not following the sentence properly... Could you say it in another way? I think I get the general meaning and that's what I was just saying before, that the consciousness moves from one sense perception to the next in super super fast succession creating the illusion of continuity, but how do I see through this continuity? I read somewhere about someone slowing their thoughts down until they could see the spaces between the words of the thought and between the thoughts themselves and just slowed things down enough to become the space between the thoughts, how do I do this? when a thought occurs its just one quick stream, I'll give it a try throughout the day though.
I liken it to say a car which isn't actually what the name conventionally says it is.... it is made up of a huge amount of parts that when put together a certain way gives a specific function.

Also think of the I as a rubber band ball. Each rubber band being a thought. It gives the illusion of a ball but when the bands are pulled away, you will notice that there is actually no ball in the center. It wasn't a ball at all!
I read some of your blog about the whole rubber band idea, it's a perfect analogy and I'll try pondering it with this in mind, but this whole process I seem to be making more mistakes than successes and I feel like I'm doing something wrong, but the whole time I feel like I know that this is all just part of the process and there is no right or wrong way to do it, this is just my way of doing it and it's wholly unique and only I can do it, no one else can do it for me and all that is left is to just be grateful for whatever comes into my life to be helpful whether negative or positive, but the positive things feel like they reinforce my ego and so do the negative ones as I try to control the result or situation itself...

User avatar
zenkitties
Posts: 156
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2011 3:46 am
Location: California
Contact:

Re: Liberation?

Postby zenkitties » Fri Aug 17, 2012 1:59 pm

"I'm here." Either this answer comes up or "I know there isn't a me anywhere", both of these answers seem like a form of escape from seeing.
Because they are.
There is only one me... right?
Where? Find it.
But every time a thought or a reflex or impulse to do something arises even as simple as wanting to drink some juice, scratch my arm or shift my focus, I feel great disappointment in myself and it's difficult to pinpoint where it comes from except from my expectation of being able to focus on one thing, and that being the dissolving of the self at the moment.
who feels great dissapointment. Watch the sensation in accordance to the thought of dissapointment. They are not connected in any way, they just happen one after the other. Then only after does the mind connect the two saying they are linked in some way. Their continuity is not real, it's a way in which "logical sense" is made to re-establish a sense of self.
But it feels mostly subconscious... As if I'm not doing anything
Mostly, if not all subconscious *hint*. There is no you to do anything, it is just being done.
As if I'm not doing anything the right way and there's constantly a tiny adjustment to be made, like I'm not sitting comfortably, this isn't the proper pose, I'm being lazy and not doing what I should be doing, I'm hungry, thirsty, I'm not breathing properly... an endless dissatisfaction with the present moment
That's story time right there, welcome to matts beliefs, concepts, and ideas.
breath is doing itself and i'm just observing.
The breath is happening regardless of whether there is thought to say its controling it or not. You aren't in control of your breath because there is no you or ego to control it. Ego is a false notion, just a scramble of conditioning (ideas/concepts/beliefs)
It all does seem continuous if not for any reason than the belief that it all exists simultaneously and always does, instead of my focus moving to one place and perceiving one thing, then to another and perceiving another, but it's all just creating the new perception the moment the focus moves, creating the illusion of continuity right?
Yes for you right now it seems continuous because it hasn't been observed yet that it is not. So pay attention to the breath or something you want to see impermanence of and focus on where there are "glitches" in this continuity. For me the kicker was when watching the breath closley in meditation, the breath will begin to make a jerk like motion. This shows that continuity is not there but fast vibrations of senses being detected. Also for the fact that experiencing in some way is a conglomerate of multiple senses going on one after the other really fast. So try and point this out in your own experience and you will see the impermanence of that object which is being focused on.
I read some of your blog about the whole rubber band idea, it's a perfect analogy and I'll try pondering it with this in mind, but this whole process I seem to be making more mistakes than successes and I feel like I'm doing something wrong, but the whole time I feel like I know that this is all just part of the process and there is no right or wrong way to do it, this is just my way of doing it and it's wholly unique and only I can do it, no one else can do it for me and all that is left is to just be grateful for whatever comes into my life to be helpful whether negative or positive, but the positive things feel like they reinforce my ego and so do the negative ones as I try to control the result or situation itself...
That's a good way of looking at it mate, you aren't doing anything wrong and it is very uniquely your own path.

You've got the suffering part down at least, look at it that way haha.

You could even use the unsatisfactoryness as an object, see what sensations and thoughts make up this feeling of "suffering" and that will unlock your door into impermanence. That suffering is the same in that it's a collection of senses going on really fast and then thought locks it up and says, "well this is why." Instead of believing the story, just tread on and keep observing how its just senses, and there is no actual you to be found/seen in the experience itself happening. :)

I'm glad the rubber band ball analogy works!
so many kitties! so many zen!
http://liberatedself.wordpress.com/

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 2:31 pm

I seem to have created this idea that the self is a separate entity from "me" and that all i have to do is to find the self in order to find me, but neither of these exist... i don't know what to do?

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 2:33 pm

and every time I pose a question to myself, or a question arises, the answer seems to be there already before the arising of the question is finished, which creates another question... more looping...

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 2:45 pm

To be honest, I feel as if we've gotten nowhere and all I want is to start again, I feel like it's gotten more complicated rather than simplified, which is how i've seen it, I don't feel I'm able to communicate what I really feel properly to you and therefore you're unable to help me to the fullest extent and I blame myself for it and make it worse.

I also find it often very frustrating that whenever I see you're online I immediately get an answer and questions out so that you can answer, but then you never seem to be here when I need the guidance the most. At the same time before I start writing to you everything I want to say seems so clear and I know where I've gotten lost, but when I start typing everything gets muddled up and I confuse myself and don't know what to say which creates more frustration. Could we perhaps have a time when we just talk everything out in one go?

Also when I do the breathing meditation, I sometimes begin to feel like I'm falling, upwards or more just without a direction to the falling, but I get distracted by something... don't know what it is, it isn't any external sound or anything more maybe by the feeling.

Everyone I know and I myself as well has always considered me an intelligent person, but I just feel stupid when I start writing to you because what I write seems to be no help whatsoever. Is this just another stage or what? Sorry to sound like a pussy or whatnot but I want to be as honest with you as possible, not hide anything, I really want to get through this, i want to see, I'm sick and tired of seeing everything as an illusion, but that's not the right way of describing my feeling either.

Does any of this make any sense? Does this help?

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 4:25 pm

This really doesn't seem to be working for me, I have a day off of work today and have been pondering/working on this the whole day since i woke up and nothing. How am I going to make any progress when I have full time work now, then university and part time work... I feel like I'm going backwards more than forwards and frankly not having any responses or answers or help is driving me crazy especially with how much effort I'm putting into this. I hate that I'm having this reaction, and I feel terrible but I don't have anywhere else to go, no-one else to talk to, everyone that understands what I'm going through is either on the other side of the planet on holiday and aren't even available to talk to (a few friends who are on a similar path to mine, some who have broken through), or I haven't even met them (ie. you) but I've been feeling alone for a long time even before finding LU, been trying everything and something started to work for me - my commitment to the meditation practice etc. The frustration grows very rapidly and subsides once I read a few lines from Gateless Gatecrashers, but it almost takes a hold of me... No it does completely for a little while, and it's very difficult to realise it for what it is and then hopelessness takes over... This really seems to be a lot harder for me than for other people who's stories I've read on the forum...

Please if you could reply more frequently or something... every time you do I feel a little grain of hope that perhaps this can be done, this can be seen... but when I spend a whole day with no response I don't know what to do. I now notice you're in california, could we maybe transfer to a three on one with some guides in time zones closer to mine?

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 6:04 pm

Could it not be possible that the questions you ask allow an idea of a self to arise? When I am alone and just being, thought's pertaining to a self don't arise. I simply am and everything just is observed. By whom? It is just a way of saying that seeing is happening, this is the inadequacy of words and attempting to communicate. In all my research there is not a single person who hasn't retained a sense of self, is the questioning not presenting the idea of a self with more thoughts, doubts and fears to feed on? Perhaps I'm just confusing my self creating more doubts and fears through these thoughts, doubts and fears and because of this NOT allowing myself to just be as came completely naturally before... The more I question everything the more doubts arise about whether or not i'm not in fact seeing everything as it TRULY is, see I can't get anywhere if you don't reply... Nothing is confirmed or denied... Including whether or not I am actually "enlightened". The only time this way of seeing or thinking about it is when I try and put it in words, otherwise everything just is, and it is being experienced, only when I try to explain it does the I come into play. A doubt is created by you, then my self thinks about it and another thought is created, just as I'm writing this I feel very calm, peaceful and quiet just observing my fingers write the words, there is no thought as to what is being written it just is being written... Perhaps this opinion may be correct or not but it just is so and it grants whatever self there is great peace, quiet and calm, do you not have any perception of a self? Perhaps I am wrong, but I'd like to explore this idea as well. Perhaps i deserve a "slap" for regressing, or a pat on the back, but either way the response to either would be determined by how the self sees it... Is this making sense? I await a reply.

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 7:40 pm

Just finished another long being meditaion, I see this continuity issue clearly, there is never multiple things being experienced simultaneously, it just appears so because consciousness flickers between the different vibrations of each thing. There is a dripping pipe outside my window that never ceases and during the meditation I realised that if consciousness remained focussed on just the air going in and out through the nose, or the up and down of the belly, or even the traffic outside would capture it's attention then the drops would not be heard. After the lying meditation I did a much shorter sitting meditation but was overcome with tiredness, the question arose as to who was tired? automatically an answer arose: how can you be tired if there is noone to be tired. The tiredness subsided a little but returned with a renewed vigour and wanting to document the experience I ended the meditation and began writing all this down. Another thought that occurred was that everything is subconscious, it must simply be observed consciously. The mind creates an idea of possession/origin AFTER something occurs... this may have been experienced in little glimpses and afterwards this thought arose as an explanation.

It appears as though a combination of the questions, thoughts etc that arise in this forum with my previous techniques appears to be getting me somewhere in this realisation. I hope this isn't another illusion. Experience is real, just it's justification, judgement and subjectivity is the creation of the mind - the false illusion of self.

User avatar
zenkitties
Posts: 156
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2011 3:46 am
Location: California
Contact:

Re: Liberation?

Postby zenkitties » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:08 pm

First of all, all of that above stuff is rubbish, it's all story stuff. You deserve a zen slap to the face haha.

you are expecting some kind of pat on the back for your efforts? that's just a false sense of self wanting to establish that it is "enlightened". Another thought story. do you see how those reactions are taking place.

"I'll point the finger at me, I blame myself."

or

"I point the finger at you, it's your fault."

do you really want to play this victimizing game with yourself or do you actually want to look at it.

Write down as simply as possible what you have established so far please. Muddle in your own story up until i see this...
The mind creates an idea of possession/origin AFTER something occurs... this may have been experienced in little glimpses and afterwards this thought arose as an explanation.
only after sensation happens, the mind will create a story as to why it is a certain way. tiredness just happens. It happens to no one, it is just being experienced. What sensations make up tiredness; heavieness, fuzzieness, relaxation, lightness, thought sensation, "I am tired"

I'm sure there are more sensations involved.

Watch the reactions happening rather than grappling to the thoughts themselves. The content isn't the important part, focus on the actual experience. You're making progress though! Wearing out sometimes is the best way of surrender. ;)

What wants the comfirmation, the false sense of self no? Why would comfirtmation be necessary from something that doesn't exist?


Maybe you haven't been really honest with yourself of what you're really expecting out of this? What are you expecting to achieve by being "liberation"?

If one little sentence can through up a bunch of reactions, you need to investigate those reactions and see what beliefs are still needing to be untied.

We can start over if you want. Is that what you would like to do? :)
so many kitties! so many zen!
http://liberatedself.wordpress.com/

User avatar
zenkitties
Posts: 156
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2011 3:46 am
Location: California
Contact:

Re: Liberation?

Postby zenkitties » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:09 pm

Also I cannot change my schedule as to the times im on, I'm actually at work right now. :P

Also have my own schedule during the day etc.
so many kitties! so many zen!
http://liberatedself.wordpress.com/

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:20 pm

I realise all this at times. I feel like theres a demon struggling inside of me, feels good to face it, but it's difficult. I'll take notes during work tomorrow and instead of going on every impulse to message you every time one side of the demon takes over, I'll calmly summarise after work tomorrow evening. Thank you for your patience :)

User avatar
zenkitties
Posts: 156
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2011 3:46 am
Location: California
Contact:

Re: Liberation?

Postby zenkitties » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:25 pm

Ha! Demon... :)

Just an unchecked belief is all, try and look at the core of the belief thats causing want for attention and give it the attention it deserves!

That's why everything goes into chaos, because we aren't being attentive to whats going on!

Keep working at it and tell me what comes up. But look honestly, and keep seeing how the you does not fit in anywhere when the story arises, but see the belief instead that is looking for the attention.

Again seeing there is no you for the belief to still be there. There is also nothing controlling the belief, or no one.
so many kitties! so many zen!
http://liberatedself.wordpress.com/

User avatar
matt1313
Posts: 39
Joined: Sat Aug 11, 2012 9:42 pm

Re: Liberation?

Postby matt1313 » Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:36 pm

and no let's not start over, but if you could give me a few basic questions again that I should try to honestly answer, that will give me direction for tomorrow and clarity. a goal to achieve. yes i agree, i haven't been completely honest with myself, but the story ran so far that i wasn't even able to see it.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 127 guests