Hi Lisa,
It's clear what you are saying about thought being the source of fear.
Looking at the thoughts, and giving them no attention, I find they just appear out of nowhere, and disappear into nowhere. And can definitely not be controlled. The idea of controlling a thought would be another thought coming out of nowhere.
There is another thing I noticed, which is that when the information-content of a thought is somehow given more attention, this leads to a feeling in the body. And then a possible chain of thoughts-feelings (a story).
I suppose this could be called identification. There obviously are times when the information of a thought is important but that would be mostly sense related ('I smell something burning - better get up a do something about it').
And another point: a lot of thoughts do seem to appear out of nowhere, but from the information-content it is easy to deduce that they come from memory (storage of 'my' individual experiences). A small baby will not have any memory and hence not really any thoughts. So the idea of being someone may well be connected to memory.
With regards to the fear-thought, it is clear to me that that is one of many passing thoughts that is somehow given more attention thus leading to a feeling in the body, etc etc.
Note: I noticed you responded to what I said in my last post of 10:34pm, I was wondering whether you had also read the 10:22pm one. Anyway not important probably. I trust the next step will come to you spontaneously.
Thanks for working with me,
Josh
My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Excellent Josh! This is clear seeing... thoughts come from nowhere, go back to it, cannot be controlled and attention given to content often causes emotional feelings. Really good work.
I focused on your second posting so that you could get clear about thoughts as the source of the fear. It's key to see that, because if fear is left to percolate without the understanding of what it is, our entire process here could be undermined. Do you now feel clear? Check for that fear, keep checking and let it speak to you when necessary. The same for thought... are you clear how that operates? I am going to assume so for now, and continue. Let me know.
When asked, 'Where is this 'I', this 'you' that fear is trying so hard to protect? Where is it located?' you said:
Look for what is looking. Look for the I, the entity. You say you cannot find a constant and then speak as if that constant actually exists. Prove that it does not. Look. It is not findable. Settle that by being absolutely confident there is nothing to find.
I'm happy to be working with you, Josh... :)
Lisa
I focused on your second posting so that you could get clear about thoughts as the source of the fear. It's key to see that, because if fear is left to percolate without the understanding of what it is, our entire process here could be undermined. Do you now feel clear? Check for that fear, keep checking and let it speak to you when necessary. The same for thought... are you clear how that operates? I am going to assume so for now, and continue. Let me know.
When asked, 'Where is this 'I', this 'you' that fear is trying so hard to protect? Where is it located?' you said:
Nice. And just set it aside, as it is a constant for everyone, noticed with looking. No all look, as you know! This underlying experiencing is not what we are going for. You also said:The only constant thing is that I am aware...Where is this I? If I close my eyes and be quiet, there is a sense of being present that has a kind of energetic feel to it,
Here's where to focus. 'I find...... with myself'... Look here. Sounds like 2, doesn't it? The 'I' is looking at something called 'myself'. Where is this I, where is this myself? You also say 'I am Josh'. Where is this 'Josh'?.I cannot find a constant I. I find thought activity that creates a certain feeling of intimacy with myself. The information that I am Josh living a life.
The I that fear is trying to protect is primarily this sense of being a body, being in a body.
Look for what is looking. Look for the I, the entity. You say you cannot find a constant and then speak as if that constant actually exists. Prove that it does not. Look. It is not findable. Settle that by being absolutely confident there is nothing to find.
I'm happy to be working with you, Josh... :)
Lisa
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Just typed a gigantic pile of words. I was not logged in so the reply could not be posted. Haha. Good riddance probably.
Again, but briefly.
You seem to suggest, as did my previous guide, that it is possible to get positive, undeniable evidence that, once seen, will remain. That is the type of thing I'm after.
I've been to many spiritual gatherings (satsangs) and when asked to look for the I have not been able to find it which resulted in beautiful experiences of bliss, love and so on. But, as you say, I still live my life as if I am somebody with a life (actually not much of a life at the moment, but that us another matter) so the seeing has never been total enough to cut the illusion. Suffice to say that the subject of looking for the I is one with a lot of charge.
If I look now for the I, I cannot find anything of substance. Still, something is looking. If I look for what is looking, I find nothing of substance. Still I am here, or something, some experience is here, and there is awareness of it. This awareness is like nothing but it is still here. See - I've done it, I now feel peace, love, silence.
But I haven't cut the rope of illusion.
I'm a bit stuck at this point.
Again, but briefly.
You seem to suggest, as did my previous guide, that it is possible to get positive, undeniable evidence that, once seen, will remain. That is the type of thing I'm after.
I've been to many spiritual gatherings (satsangs) and when asked to look for the I have not been able to find it which resulted in beautiful experiences of bliss, love and so on. But, as you say, I still live my life as if I am somebody with a life (actually not much of a life at the moment, but that us another matter) so the seeing has never been total enough to cut the illusion. Suffice to say that the subject of looking for the I is one with a lot of charge.
If I look now for the I, I cannot find anything of substance. Still, something is looking. If I look for what is looking, I find nothing of substance. Still I am here, or something, some experience is here, and there is awareness of it. This awareness is like nothing but it is still here. See - I've done it, I now feel peace, love, silence.
But I haven't cut the rope of illusion.
I'm a bit stuck at this point.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
You say:
You can continue to feel that peace, love, silence and yet have the belief in the faux 'I' pop up, and that's not what you want. We know that. So, focus not on those feelings.
Focus on the thought 'I', 'me', 'my', 'mine'. To what do they point? Look for THAT... where is it? Can't find it? You say you cannot find anything of substance when you look at the 'I' thought... what DO you find? Tell me about that. If it's nothing... what does that point to?
Lisa
When I asked you to 'look for what is looking' I actually meant look again for the 'I' that you think sees all, interprets all, directs all. Because before you are absolutely in realization that there is no 'I', that is what you believe: that the 'I' is IT.If I look now for the I, I cannot find anything of substance. Still, something is looking. If I look for what is looking, I find nothing of substance. Still I am here, or something, some experience is here, and there is awareness of it. This awareness is like nothing but it is still here. See - I've done it, I now feel peace, love, silence.
But I haven't cut the rope of illusion.
You can continue to feel that peace, love, silence and yet have the belief in the faux 'I' pop up, and that's not what you want. We know that. So, focus not on those feelings.
Focus on the thought 'I', 'me', 'my', 'mine'. To what do they point? Look for THAT... where is it? Can't find it? You say you cannot find anything of substance when you look at the 'I' thought... what DO you find? Tell me about that. If it's nothing... what does that point to?
Lisa
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
It seems every 'me' or 'mine' points to an ever changing array of feelings and thoughts. Now a thought of being frustrated, then a feeling of sadness: 'I am frustrated', 'I feel sad'. Etc etc.
So the sense of I (am experiencing) pops up with every thought or feeling. This I is not constant but is constantly popping up. It has no substance, perhaps it is the byproduct of experiencing.
So the sense of I (am experiencing) pops up with every thought or feeling. This I is not constant but is constantly popping up. It has no substance, perhaps it is the byproduct of experiencing.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
OK... look at feelings like you looked at thoughts, Josh.
From where do they come? How do they arise... where do they go? Can they be controlled, directed...?
From where do they come? How do they arise... where do they go? Can they be controlled, directed...?
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Feelings just come up and disappear. Thoughts can create feelings and vice versa but they are the same. Coming out of nowhere, going back to nowhere.
But my point was not feelings, but that it seems to me now that experiences, in other words, feelings and thoughts, are changing continuously and each experience brings with it the sense of a me experiencing it. I cannot put my finger on that 'me', it seems to be almost inferred or implied, a ghost that accompanies the experience (or is a parasite on the experience, claiming it). There is no constant thing that I can call I, yet 'I' is being experienced seemingly continuously. At least, that what it looks like looking at it now.
But my point was not feelings, but that it seems to me now that experiences, in other words, feelings and thoughts, are changing continuously and each experience brings with it the sense of a me experiencing it. I cannot put my finger on that 'me', it seems to be almost inferred or implied, a ghost that accompanies the experience (or is a parasite on the experience, claiming it). There is no constant thing that I can call I, yet 'I' is being experienced seemingly continuously. At least, that what it looks like looking at it now.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
You are having genuine experiences here, Josh.... and filtering them through thought. They are simply what they are, and nothing called an 'I' is attached to them. Check this.feelings and thoughts, are changing continuously and each experience brings with it the sense of a me experiencing it. I cannot put my finger on that 'me', it seems to be almost inferred or implied, a ghost that accompanies the experience
While you watch thoughts go through, while feelings arise and dissipate... where is the I, but in what you assume to be watching, assume to be feeling? Look for it... can you find it watching thoughts or feeling feelings?
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
One thing is for sure, it's all thought, thought, thought that creates confusion. Somehow this enquiry seems to activate thinking, because of the effort. Just picked up my smoothie, poured it and had a sip and therein was no thinking, just the smoothie, and attentiveness, no 'I' doing it. But I must say, I do enjoy my smoothie ;)You are having genuine experiences here, Josh.... and filtering them through thought. They are simply what they are, and nothing called an 'I' is attached to them. Check this.
When reading your post, this felt like the right direction, and my immediate observation is, yes, I can find something watching thoughts and feelings. Which is this attentiveness I mentioned. And yes, this is where 'I' am.While you watch thoughts go through, while feelings arise and dissipate... where is the I, but in what you assume to be watching, assume to be feeling? Look for it... can you find it watching thoughts or feeling feelings?
Yet I do not experience being an observer as such. I am watching thoughts and feelings but I cannot pinpoint who is watching. As they say, there is no little man in here watching, that is clear.
So experiences undeniably occur. And the watching of them undeniably occurs. And something else fuzzy occurs that is the sense of me claiming experiences.
I'm sorry, seems like I keep doing the same loops. Trying to find where this false sense of I dwells so I can expose it.
You are telling me to look and be absolutely sure there is none. How to do it?
I am watching thoughts and feelings. And I cannot pinpoint that I.
And that's not the end of the story, I know that. Maybe there is resistance to take that last step. The intellect cannot go there. With what do I look then?
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
I sense your frustration here, Josh. And you noticed that it lifted when having your smoothie. Just the smoothie, the taste, the feel....
You are close, and yet are still identifying 'you' as being 'something':
One way to verify this is to ask: If that were to be gone... if there were no more conscious awareness... would life be experienced here in this body/mind? Of course, the answer is no. Without indwelling consciousness the body dies. It is what is aware of being... and the 'me' is particular thoughts about a particular body/mind human. Consciousness is generic to all. Do you see the difference? Focus on this and let me know.
An exercise that might assist here is to imagine what it would be like to live everyday life in the complete realization that there is no 'I' looking out of the eyes, no 'I' thoughts claiming ownership of everything from the body, to possessions, to friends and family members ('my', 'my, 'my'). To simply let that generic conscious awareness be present without the 'I' as a filter. Practice that, out in nature is good, and see what happens.
You are close, and yet are still identifying 'you' as being 'something':
This is not 'where' you are. This is simply consciousness. This is awareness of being alive, of being conscious... what you are noticing above is this conscious awareness of what IS. It is not 'you', not the 'I', the 'self'.I can find something watching thoughts and feelings. Which is this attentiveness I mentioned. And yes, this is where 'I' am.
Yet I do not experience being an observer as such
One way to verify this is to ask: If that were to be gone... if there were no more conscious awareness... would life be experienced here in this body/mind? Of course, the answer is no. Without indwelling consciousness the body dies. It is what is aware of being... and the 'me' is particular thoughts about a particular body/mind human. Consciousness is generic to all. Do you see the difference? Focus on this and let me know.
An exercise that might assist here is to imagine what it would be like to live everyday life in the complete realization that there is no 'I' looking out of the eyes, no 'I' thoughts claiming ownership of everything from the body, to possessions, to friends and family members ('my', 'my, 'my'). To simply let that generic conscious awareness be present without the 'I' as a filter. Practice that, out in nature is good, and see what happens.
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
I know you are right. The 'where' is a strong factor in the identifying mechanism, though. I find it hard to accept that I am nowhere. This non-locality is another way of saying 'generic to all' as you are pointing out next.This is not 'where' you are. This is simply consciousness. This is awareness of being alive, of being conscious... what you are noticing above is this conscious awareness of what IS. It is not 'you', not the 'I', the 'self'.
I appear to be expecting, or looking for an 'implosion' where the tendency to locate myself ceases completely.
Also, when you say 'what you are noticing is this conscious awareness' there appear to be two. Some I looking at that awareness whilst it is more the other way around? I notice a tendency to project my I in this awareness, and you clearly say: this is not me. I am confused, but then I see I am not actually noticing it, it is simply THERE. I cannot see it, but it SEES.
I see the difference. I notice the fear of death, and I see it relates to those particular thoughts that think they 'have' consciousness whereas consciousness is the precondition for thoughts to be. The fear is that with the death of this bodymind this consciousness will be gone for evermore. Nothing before my birth and nothing after my death. For sure being conscious of these particular bodymind thoughts will be gone for ever but consciousness will be aware of the next thing. Much like a baby is aware of the next thing.One way to verify this is to ask: If that were to be gone... if there were no more conscious awareness... would life be experienced here in this body/mind? Of course, the answer is no. Without indwelling consciousness the body dies. It is what is aware of being... and the 'me' is particular thoughts about a particular body/mind human. Consciousness is generic to all. Do you see the difference? Focus on this and let me know.
I am asking the fear, what are you protecting me from, and the first thing it says is: from love...
Maybe enlightenment is being that consciousness without anyone left to say I am that...
To simply let that generic conscious awareness be present without the 'I' as a filter.An exercise that might assist here is to imagine what it would be like to live everyday life in the complete realization that there is no 'I' looking out of the eyes, no 'I' thoughts claiming ownership of everything from the body, to possessions, to friends and family members ('my', 'my, 'my'). To simply let that generic conscious awareness be present without the 'I' as a filter. Practice that, out in nature is good, and see what happens.
I like that. I will practice it. Fake it till I make it? ;)
Thanks, I sense you sensing where I'm at and that feels good.
If this 'I' is gone, what will be left? I'm starting to feel that nothing will be left, not even that consciousness. And that is not a scary thought.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
This is calling for clarity, Josh:
Yes... look around as if there is no 'I' looking. Just notice the world, the body, the thoughts that pass through. Notice that there is no 'I' to legitimately claim anything, there can only be the thought 'I'. That's all there ever was...
It would have worked better for me to say: 'what is being noticed is this conscious awareness'. Because, yes, your temporary confusion around awareness/consciousness forgets that I am using conventional language. So... noticing of conscious awareness is happening... that's all. How can something nonexistent, how can a thought of 'I', notice or be noticed?Also, when you say 'what you are noticing is this conscious awareness' there appear to be two. Some I looking at that awareness whilst it is more the other way around?
You never were anywhere. The body/mind is right here, right now; the 'I'... nowhere. The 'I' is just a bunch of thoughts; to have it NOT BE is insignificant, and since it was always the case, is nothing new. Ponder that... it's nothing new. There never was a Josh, only a body with that label. So nothing disappears, there will just be noticing that it is not, and never was.I find it hard to accept that I am nowhere...... If this 'I' is gone, what will be left? I'm starting to feel that nothing will be left, not even that consciousness.
Yes... look around as if there is no 'I' looking. Just notice the world, the body, the thoughts that pass through. Notice that there is no 'I' to legitimately claim anything, there can only be the thought 'I'. That's all there ever was...
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
I'm even more confused now. What is being noticed.... by what? In my experience this conscious awareness IS the noticing. I can't see it but I know it because it is always noticing. May sound like semantics but to me it seems to be an existential point. This noticing is the closest I can get to 'who I really am', God, all of existence, source, the void from which all springs, and other such terms that are concepts to me but they do point to a reality. No entity here, but impersonal unconcerned noticing of whatever content appears.It would have worked better for me to say: 'what is being noticed is this conscious awareness'. Because, yes, your temporary confusion around awareness/consciousness forgets that I am using conventional language. So... noticing of conscious awareness is happening... that's all. How can something nonexistent, how can a thought of 'I', notice or be noticed?
Unfortunately I have heard this a hundred times before. I understand it but I don't fully realise it. The pointer is clear: there is not a state of no-I that I have to aspire to - there only has to be clear seeing that there never was an I.You never were anywhere. The body/mind is right here, right now; the 'I'... nowhere. The 'I' is just a bunch of thoughts; to have it NOT BE is insignificant, and since it was always the case, is nothing new. Ponder that... it's nothing new. There never was a Josh, only a body with that label. So nothing disappears, there will just be noticing that it is not, and never was.
There will just be noticing: so that means I am that noticing; not I as bodymind Josh but I as let's say the void. Right? I'm sorry I'm probably not making myself clear.
Let me put it in another way: for something, anything to be, there has to be awareness of it. So awareness is the source. I must be that source. Because that is all there ever is. And there is no personal I in it at all. I'm aware this is the Advaita angle but I'm coming to it by looking, I'm not regurgitating concepts.
Experimented with this today... if there are no problems it seems to go well. But as soon as there are, 'I have to solve this problem for me' becomes very prominent along with the feelings that go with it. Will that go if there is clear seeing or will all of that just continue, the most intense I contraction and survival mechanisms will still occur?Yes... look around as if there is no 'I' looking. Just notice the world, the body, the thoughts that pass through. Notice that there is no 'I' to legitimately claim anything, there can only be the thought 'I'. That's all there ever was...
The question because this type of thing feels so dense and identified and then the sense of I becomes quite strong.
I shall continue with looking, noticing, even though there is a slight effort in it that seems to cloud reality with a conceptual layer and projects a looker, a noticer. I can't undo that effort (as that would be effort again). The effort is actually noticed, so...
Sorry Lisa, to be such a thickheaded and stubborn student but there it is.
I do value the intensity that comes with our dialogue and hopefully it will reach a climax where the bubble simply bursts (or is seen there never was one).
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
I do not see you as a thickhead at all, Josh. You are going through this 'process' just fine. Questions, doubts, confusions are a part of it. We just continue on. :)
Get solid on the fact of no self, no I. That's your primary task because it is the foundational false belief. Set aside ideas about awareness, source, etc etc. as they really throw a wrench in the mix. You can easily and more fruitfully take them up again later. For now continue to focus on the task at hand.
Life is being noticed by awareness. And awareness is not a thing, an entity, and certainly not 'you'. It might be said to simply be a function, like seeing, hearing, etc. So noticing happens, too.No entity here, but impersonal unconcerned noticing of whatever content appears.
You have carts before horses here. You have not seen clearly that there is no personal I in anything (because you still hold to I as real), and that completely clouds things, so that saying you must the the source is untenable. Your vision is not clear.So awareness is the source. I must be that source. Because that is all there ever is. And there is no personal I in it at all.
Get solid on the fact of no self, no I. That's your primary task because it is the foundational false belief. Set aside ideas about awareness, source, etc etc. as they really throw a wrench in the mix. You can easily and more fruitfully take them up again later. For now continue to focus on the task at hand.
Look right there, at 'the sense of I'; at that 'conceptual layer'. What are those, really? Look into those. What do you find? Are these real, or thoughts? Are these the I that you think is real?and then the sense of I becomes quite strong.... there is a slight effort in [looking] that seems to cloud reality with a conceptual layer and projects a looker, a noticer.
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
That's clear. The task at hand it is.You have carts before horses here. You have not seen clearly that there is no personal I in anything (because you still hold to I as real), and that completely clouds things, so that saying you must the the source is untenable. Your vision is not clear.
Get solid on the fact of no self, no I. That's your primary task because it is the foundational false belief. Set aside ideas about awareness, source, etc etc. as they really throw a wrench in the mix. You can easily and more fruitfully take them up again later. For now continue to focus on the task at hand.
That sense of I that arises when there are problems in 'my life' is FELT as real. I appear to 'navigate' through life based primarily on how I feel. I may feel transparent and expanded without not much sense of I at all, and it is at times like that that I (almost) feel everything is clear as the blue sky; or I may feel contracted with a sense that events are happening TO ME and then I feel identified and not clear and anxious because I have to lead this life and solve its problems.Look right there, at 'the sense of I'; at that 'conceptual layer'. What are those, really? Look into those. What do you find? Are these real, or thoughts? Are these the I that you think is real?
If I look at this rationally it is clear that they are both passing states and that the sense of I fluctuates (is even gone completely during sleep) so it cannot be real; but I do not SEE that clearly beyond a shadow of a doubt.
With regards to that conceptual layer, when I try to look for this I, or try to live as if there is none, I notice an effort going on and this effort seems to be exerted by someone, by 'me'. This effort is my intellect attempting to look, and because I have so many concepts about the matter, trying to emulate the 'experience of no-I'.
In the first case I feel I am the experiencer and in the second the doer.
Another matter:
My auntie died this afternoon. I was a long time coming but in the end if was sudden.
We had her body taken to her house and there will be a fair bit of organising and so on over the next week.
I'll try to keep posting once a day but if I miss a day you will know why.
It was strange as always to see the body with the familiar features but devoid of consciousness and life.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 7 guests

