Hey Vince! :)
Let me say this, and then I'll read and work with what you've just written.
I see that when I decide to be mindful I can access any of my 5 senses, my emotions or my thoughts. Naturally, I can only access one experience/perception at a time- EITHER smelling OR hearing OR my emotional state OR my thoughts, etc. Further, I see that each of these is a separate TYPE of experience and like oil and water no two of them mix into a solution.
Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Hey Dan,
How does this decision happen ?
Do the previous post before answering this one...
vince
Yes, What are the implications of this ?I see that when I decide to be mindful I can access any of my 5 senses, my emotions or my thoughts. Naturally, I can only access one experience/perception at a time- EITHER smelling OR hearing OR my emotional state OR my thoughts, etc. Further, I see that each of these is a separate TYPE of experience and like oil and water no two of them mix into a solution.
When a thought (to be mindful) appears...when I decide to be mindful
How does this decision happen ?
Do the previous post before answering this one...
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Hi Vince
I say my thinking was frantic because I’m not sure I know how to have direct experience. The only way I can try to recognize thoughts is by having an intention to recognize thoughts and by remembering what a thought is, and that intention and that memory are thoughts themselves as far as I can tell.
I started doing this. I labeled everything that had a story to it as a thought. Very quickly I was overwhelmed at labeling a thought as such at least every second. This made my thinking at least as frantic as when I tried to acknowledge the content of every thought.just notice the fact that a thought has happened. This is direct experience of the thought.
I say my thinking was frantic because I’m not sure I know how to have direct experience. The only way I can try to recognize thoughts is by having an intention to recognize thoughts and by remembering what a thought is, and that intention and that memory are thoughts themselves as far as I can tell.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good evening Dan,
(rhetorical question) No. The content is the container. How do you notice that you have had a thought without getting caught up in it's content ?
If you notice that a thought has occurred, that noticing is a replay of the thought. It is a memory of the original thought.
If you notice the thought but don't consider what it was about, then you might say that you had a direct experience of it. The moment you consider it, describe it, elaborate on it's content, you are in additional thought streams.
Answer me this; Does any thought have inherent credibility ?
If you think "it's daytime" when it's night time, you would say that that thought has no credibility - right ?
Now is you think "it's daytime" and it is actually daytime, does that thought have inherent credibility, or is it the circumstances (the sun is noticed, etc) that give it credibility ?
Let's say that you feel a sensation on your arm, you look where you felt it and see that an insect is there.
The original sensation is the direct experience. However within milliseconds the mind is looking for explanation. The looking provides credibility to the stories that arise.
So, from the perspective of the organism, what exists except sense input and thought and response to thought ?
Can you think of anything ?
love
vince
Ha, yes. It does get tricky. The medium is the message. Does a thought have a container and a content ?I say my thinking was frantic because I’m not sure I know how to have direct experience.
(rhetorical question) No. The content is the container. How do you notice that you have had a thought without getting caught up in it's content ?
If you notice that a thought has occurred, that noticing is a replay of the thought. It is a memory of the original thought.
If you notice the thought but don't consider what it was about, then you might say that you had a direct experience of it. The moment you consider it, describe it, elaborate on it's content, you are in additional thought streams.
Answer me this; Does any thought have inherent credibility ?
If you think "it's daytime" when it's night time, you would say that that thought has no credibility - right ?
Now is you think "it's daytime" and it is actually daytime, does that thought have inherent credibility, or is it the circumstances (the sun is noticed, etc) that give it credibility ?
Let's say that you feel a sensation on your arm, you look where you felt it and see that an insect is there.
The original sensation is the direct experience. However within milliseconds the mind is looking for explanation. The looking provides credibility to the stories that arise.
So, from the perspective of the organism, what exists except sense input and thought and response to thought ?
Can you think of anything ?
love
vince
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
I'll get to the last pointing instructions in a moment, I just want to say something first.
Depression is painful beyond words. I need this insight so badly for any quality of life. I avoid following your instructions because when I do, and I still don't experience myself as just awareness of phenomena, I get very frustrated and that's uncomfortable. And when I think of following your instructions or replying I just think of how hopeless it is and how I'll never get it. And I know that this is full of "I" statements, and that's just the thinking that's saying this, and that I don't even exist and "I" only loosely applies to the watching that's going on in some peaceful place full of well-being. But I still don't get it.
Also, for the last two and a half weeks I've been able to just focus on my feelings, which eventually just became bodily sensations both inside and out, and that has kept me calm through what would have been at least one breakdown where I am overwhelmed by negativity and fantasize about suicide and maybe scream but mostly just suffer intensely. I just had my first "sort of" breakdown since I've started this focusing on my feelings, I had it today, but I still feel I was able to navigate it through this focusing in a way that didn't leave me completely helpless and hopeless as I've been in the past. So that's something positive that's happening for me.
Depression is painful beyond words. I need this insight so badly for any quality of life. I avoid following your instructions because when I do, and I still don't experience myself as just awareness of phenomena, I get very frustrated and that's uncomfortable. And when I think of following your instructions or replying I just think of how hopeless it is and how I'll never get it. And I know that this is full of "I" statements, and that's just the thinking that's saying this, and that I don't even exist and "I" only loosely applies to the watching that's going on in some peaceful place full of well-being. But I still don't get it.
Also, for the last two and a half weeks I've been able to just focus on my feelings, which eventually just became bodily sensations both inside and out, and that has kept me calm through what would have been at least one breakdown where I am overwhelmed by negativity and fantasize about suicide and maybe scream but mostly just suffer intensely. I just had my first "sort of" breakdown since I've started this focusing on my feelings, I had it today, but I still feel I was able to navigate it through this focusing in a way that didn't leave me completely helpless and hopeless as I've been in the past. So that's something positive that's happening for me.
- whitey1022
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
So I want to notice thoughts and then immediately run away mentally so I don’t elaborate on it? This feels like a silly exercise.If you notice the thought but don't consider what it was about, then you might say that you had a direct experience of it.
I’ll say no, because it seems true that thoughts don’t have inherent credibility but I don’t feel I’ve been exhaustive in verifying this.Does any thought have inherent credibility ?
I could pay attention for a month straight and notice only these 3 phenomena but still, how could I be sure that another phenomenon didn’t escape my attention? I could call on my lifetime of experience and conclude that it was only these 3 phenomena the whole time, but why would I necessarily be right? Maybe my mind is just too distracted or foggy to check the answers to these questions.So, from the perspective of the organism, what exists except sense input and thought and response to thought ?
Can you think of anything ?
OK, so I’m not supposed to answer these questions philosophically but instead from “direct” experience. I don’t know how to have the direct experience still, maybe. There is the sensation itself that I experience only through memory. So should I be okay with that and just focus on the sensation anyway? Not that we're working with sensation. I certainly don't know how to use direct experience to answer the three questions, and in trying to verify the first statement it just feels like nothing, I guess it feels like thinking.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?
Good evening Dan,
My story about this is that the motivation for seeking liberation plays a big (really big) part in success. (or failure)
(language makes it difficult to explain this. 'success' is not the right word, as this (waking up) is not a conclusion to effort)
..anyway, what i'm trying to say is that being motivated to avoid something, heads us in the wrong direction.
We will never get 'there' while looking backwards. (it explains some of the difficulties that you have been having)
Let's come at this from a different direction. (head on)
What we are looking for is discovery. For you to recognize those things that you currently believe, that distort the flow of what is actual.
If i tell you of these things, then they are only words. For them to facilitate a change, they have to be an Aha!
The bottom line is that much of what you believe is rubbish.
The consequence of believing this stuff is the suffering that you experience.
Now the key here is the word "believe".
What do you think a belief is ?
How does it work ?
Let your thoughts have their say (and write them here), then look for an example of a belief that you hold, and describe what it is and how it affects you.
Hang in there Dan,
vince
Not being part of my experience, i cannot imagine the extent of this. i do imagine that thoughts of suicide are evoked by imagining an end to this pain.Depression is painful beyond words.
Hmm, this is tricky (to explain). Do you remember the disclaimer about what LU is not ?I need this insight so badly for any quality of life.
My story about this is that the motivation for seeking liberation plays a big (really big) part in success. (or failure)
(language makes it difficult to explain this. 'success' is not the right word, as this (waking up) is not a conclusion to effort)
..anyway, what i'm trying to say is that being motivated to avoid something, heads us in the wrong direction.
We will never get 'there' while looking backwards. (it explains some of the difficulties that you have been having)
Let's come at this from a different direction. (head on)
What we are looking for is discovery. For you to recognize those things that you currently believe, that distort the flow of what is actual.
If i tell you of these things, then they are only words. For them to facilitate a change, they have to be an Aha!
The bottom line is that much of what you believe is rubbish.
The consequence of believing this stuff is the suffering that you experience.
Now the key here is the word "believe".
What do you think a belief is ?
How does it work ?
Let your thoughts have their say (and write them here), then look for an example of a belief that you hold, and describe what it is and how it affects you.
Hang in there Dan,
vince
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Anastacia42, Robshin and 59 guests

