I'm glad to see that we are discussing the same thing. Since that experience, and especially because I have not been able to duplicate it, I have doubted that it actually was the full experience of the present moment and of no-self. I have imagined that it might just be some wish fulfillment or other coincidentally similar anomalous experience. But I believe through your affirmation and through some internet searching, especially in descriptions of "flow" state, that this is the sought-for experience, the reality- without constant want and lack- that is possible and preferable to what the materialist West would call "ordinary waking consciousness".YES YES YES :)
-Is this because mindfulness, or the consistent effort to "listen to"/experience any input through the five senses, will increase the frequency and length of my selfless experiences? I see that the effort itself is able to calm me, but just light calming is not a sufficient result to inspire me to practice.It is not an unfruitful effort.
Things are just made to be more complicated than they need to be.
-I'm not sure I understand what you mean here. Do you mean that the difficulty of accessing selfless experience is caused by the incessant attention to thoughts that I have as a result of my social conditioning?
-I'm not quite sure what this means either. Is this an offer of a simpler approach you could take with me if I'm willing?I am ALL about simplicity if there is a willingness to stick to the simplicity by you.
The most essential question is always IS THERE or IS THERE NOT a self. It's a yes or no question.
-I understand, and I think for a few moments the other night I accessed selfless experience, and it is an experience of abundance versus the experience of scarcity I am more familiar with. This is as far as I can attest to its "truthfulness" versus the untruth of my typical experience. Clearly it is preferable, and I imagine no survival advantages or other desirable aspects of life are lost when one regularly experiences selflessness.
-When I ask myself that most essential question (IS THERE or IS THERE NOT a self?), it seems to be addressed to the "me" who does the logical thinking, and so I try to answer with thoughts. Therefore I am not using this question and am instead listening to sensations in the hope that the one I'm attending will suddenly occupy the entire field of my awareness, as happened the other night.Thinking is NOT direct experience.
I am confused as to why I would be able to have the selfless experience for a moment or two the other night, despite having done very little mindfulness recently, and I would not be able to repeat it in the two days since then. In my mindfulness (my effort to pay attention to sensation- I use mostly touch and hearing, and sometimes sight), when I am really listening to a particular sensation for a few moments at a time, I am not aware of any thoughts at that moment that are distracting me. But I have assumed that there must be some unconscious thinking still, because what else would be preventing the immersion experience besides thought?
I don't expect you to respond to all of this, I'm just clarifying to help you see where my thoughts and my practice are.

