This reply doesn’t come from looking at AE, it’s a thought interpretation, the content of a thought only.V: What is the AE of space? Is it a sound, image/color, taste, smell, sensation or thought?K: The experience of space seems to be a stillness. It itself has no sound, image , taste, smell or sensation, or thought. Yet those appear as an experience of movement within it.
If a sentence starts with “It seem” or “it feels like” then it a sure sign that what will follow is just an analogy, just the content of thoughts.
Take a cup or any object into your hands. And investigate if the cup can be experience in any other way then with the 5 senses. Can you?
Can anything be experience in any other way than with the 5 senses?
Look carefully. Don’t just think, but really try to experience outside the 5 senses. Can this be done?
This reply didn’t come from looking at AE. This is a thought interpretation.V: How is it known exactly that thoughts are appearing in space?K: The thoughts appear in the same space that sees them. There isnt something that sees an appearance in a space other than itself.
What is the AE of ‘space seeing the thoughts’? – is it a sound, image/color, taste, smell, sensation or thought?
Is this REALLY experienced as such?
Look very carefully. Watch for visual thoughts. Is it possible that there is a visual thought showing a vast empty space?
How is it known that there is something that is seeing thoughts?V: What does generate thoughts?K: They seem to appear in that which sees them, so it feels like it is the same thing in a way, like it must come from here
This is a thought speculation.
Is there a thought + the knowing/seeing of it?
Is there a dividing line between a thought and the knowing of it?
Where does the thought ends and the knowing of it starts?
Is this seer you talk about something separate from all the rest?
Noticing happens - how do you know the seer is what notices?
Does the seer have a shape, a location, a weight? Can you point to this seer?
Is seer something other than, different to, or separate from experience?
Can you find anything at all that is called "seer", or do you just find experience?